EPTI will just once again plead innocence, since there's still nothing new.
Incognito's TL Mafia XVI - Page 61
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
flamewheel
FREEAGLELAND26780 Posts
I will just once again plead innocence, since there's still nothing new. | ||
|
flamewheel
FREEAGLELAND26780 Posts
| ||
keit
1584 Posts
On January 25 2010 07:47 Mystlord wrote: I honestly don't find any of the connections convincing now. There's just always something that doesn't seem right... I really don't see where the keit connection is coming from :/ Maybe my lack of Sesame Street knowledge makes the apple clue not all that convincing. Haha, trust me, this is about something else. My vote for DoctorH made him react just as I'd thought. | ||
|
keit
1584 Posts
| ||
|
Moloch
Canada222 Posts
Also, I voted for double lynch since if we don't get a Mafia today, we'll have to get at least one tomorrow in order to not be massively behind. Even randomly guessing, two lynches give us a much better chance of pegging a mafia. | ||
|
DoctorHelvetica
United States15034 Posts
On January 25 2010 08:35 keit wrote: Haha, trust me, this is about something else. My vote for DoctorH made him react just as I'd thought. uh, is it wrong to defend myself? The clues connect to you as well and your behavior is well into the realm of suspiciousness. | ||
|
DoctorHelvetica
United States15034 Posts
| ||
|
citi.zen
2509 Posts
I am not claiming this incriminates you beyond any reasonable doubt, it does not. But it does make your argument about willingly sharing your connection with Bill a very weak one. | ||
|
citi.zen
2509 Posts
| ||
|
Zona
40426 Posts
Unfortunately, this is the minority. The majority of past games had mods create a "persona" or "character" based on an amalgam of a player's profile, then create clues from that persona. (So one degree removed.) And there were some crazy connections that I don't think anyone would have guessed correctly. For example, if I wasn't reading too quickly and missing things, one game had a player with a lion in their profile, and the mod decided "Lion = Hunter" to create the "persona" for the player. But then the mod went further and made this a Hunter class from WoW, which made all the clues unguessable from my point of view, impossible to connect to the lion in the profile. I really don't know what to do with clues for now. Thin knife = scalpel seems to be a FAIR clue. If the olympic thing really was a clue and not a red herring, it seems like it would be too obvious? I hope we somehow hit at least one mafia sometime in the future so we can try to see which clues are related and get a sense of how the mods are creating these clues. As others have mentioned, reading people by their interactions and votes is probably BETTER right now. As for Bill the detective dying, it might have been someone he talked to, but it could have been luck too - the other game lost the detective to the day 1 lynch! To me it looks like the mafia decided that many of the active players would be protected and went for targets they thought likely had no protection. I disagree that the bodyguard is a large loss. A bodyguard is a loss ONLY if we're sure the elected officials are town members. If we aren't sure I'd actually prefer that the elected officials lose all of their protection. Don't take comfort in the relatively large numbers of town members alive - we likely lose members at a rate of 3 a night, at least for now, each day only have a CHANCE of getting rid of 1 mafia (with the exception of the 2 double lynches). So our buffer is not that large. I am in favor of double lynching, as this increases the proportion of deaths that are not caused solely by mafia, and might (or might not) bring the day of lower mafia KP closer. I'm really concerned about the high mafia KP right now. I still haven't decided who to vote on - but since I don't have any solid ideas as to who might be mafia based on interaction, I'll choose between the three sorta-solid clue connections. | ||
|
Zona
40426 Posts
| ||
|
Zona
40426 Posts
Since 789 asked for the postcounts, here they are. I stopped them because I didn't want people posting crap for the sake of getting a higher postcount to look more active in these. But yeah, some players still have virtually no posts. DoctorHelvetica: 217 meeple: 169 789: 129 citi.zen: 81 Bill Murray: 79 Zona: 59 Abenson: 48 flamewheel91: 43 t_co: 41 Jugan: 33 StimiLant: 32 ghote: 24 [NyC]HoBbes: 23 Ng5: 21 blue_arrow: 20 CynanMachae: 19 Nikoner: 19 Ser Aspi: 18 Mystlord: 17 The_Master: 12 JohannesH: 8 Phrujbaz: 7 keit: 7 Hyperbola: 6 Faronel: 5 Jayme: 5 tredmasta: 4 magicbullet: 3 dinmsab: 3 derfboy: 1 Fallen_arK: 1 kane]deth[: 1 skronch: 1 ohN: 0 | ||
|
Incognito
United States2071 Posts
Night 2 The nervous town huddled together at the town meeting to decide who they were going to dispatch while a violent storm raged outside. Suddenly, the power went off. Confused, the town scrambled to get the generator on. A gunshot went off, followed by a scream. When the town leaders could finally get the power back on, they noticed kane]deth[ pointing a gun up at the ceiling. The town was immediately repulsed by the sight of kane's gun, and quickly proceeded to lynch him, thinking that his gun was a sign of his guilt. Unfortunately, kane]deth['s blood spilled green on the floor as the town gasped again in amazement. Too bad the town forgot that Liquidia also had a version of the 2nd amendment...maybe they should get rid of that... *** Night roles, please send in your actions to either me or dreamflower as soon as possible. You have until 9:00 PM EST on Monday January 25 to turn them in. Vigilantes may now use their hits. | ||
|
789
United States959 Posts
Anyway I just read Zona's post and I think he may be on to something. For instance the second killer from 2 day 2 clues ... with the bucket looking helmet. Say Incognito is writing in the second style Zona proposed. He could have made Ser Aspi a knight persona (Ser is used as a substitute for Sir in some writings ... and sir is a common way to address a knight.) Bucket like helmet could fit a knight. I'm just throwing this out as an example, not suggesting we should lynch Ser Aspi next. | ||
|
dreamflower
United States312 Posts
On January 25 2010 11:08 Nikoner wrote: I abstain from voting for a lynch today. I vote against a double lynch tomorrow. For the most part, this hasn't been a problem, but for future reference: There's no need to vote against a double lynch. As long as you're voting but don't vote in favor of a double lynch, it's assumed that you're voting against the double lynch. So, there's no need to mention it explicitly. | ||
|
citi.zen
2509 Posts
| ||
|
Nikon
Bulgaria5710 Posts
On January 25 2010 09:50 DoctorHelvetica wrote: Additionally, in my defense, if anyone is accusing me based on my connection to Bill Murray; it would be highly illogical for me, as mafia, to let anyone know I was talking to him or that I knew he was a detective if I was planning to kill him all along. Let the mindgames commence. The first thing that jumped out to me was the bucket-on-head thing - could it be possible that's it's related to Buckethead? | ||
|
Zona
40426 Posts
On January 25 2010 11:18 dreamflower wrote: For the most part, this hasn't been a problem, but for future reference: There's no need to vote against a double lynch. As long as you're voting but don't vote in favor of a double lynch, it's assumed that you're voting against the double lynch. So, there's no need to mention it explicitly. I hope you set more explicit rules. While DrH clearly retracted his vote in favor double lynching, citi.zen's retraction is debatable, his post could also be interpreted as abstaining from voting for a person, and not retracting both his vote on a person and on double-lynching. | ||
|
Incognito
United States2071 Posts
On January 25 2010 11:27 Zona wrote: I hope you set more explicit rules. While DrH clearly retracted his vote in favor double lynching, citi.zen's retraction is debatable, his post could also be interpreted as abstaining from voting for a person, and not retracting both his vote on a person and on double-lynching. You mean this? On January 24 2010 12:39 citi.zen wrote: I take back my double lynch vote. Don't have enough time to be active over the weekend and now am not so sure about the clues. Sounds pretty clear to me. | ||
|
Zona
40426 Posts
| ||
| ||
