|
On January 22 2010 10:23 Nikoner wrote:At first I hadn't realised that Bill Murray has been posting so much... and most, if not all, of his posts are like this: Show nested quote +On January 22 2010 08:24 Bill Murray wrote:
I vote for a double lynch on day 2 Which doesn't even make sense, since it will most likely lead to us lynching 2 townies, if anything...
Most of his posts has been triple-post confusing one liners yea, but that isn't much of an argument for lynching
|
DoctorHelvetica - your list is chronologically incorrect, it omits some interesting bandwagoning.
|
Yes, re-reading t_co's posts have made me like his arguments less, which is why I have retracted my aim of having him become mayor. Like some have said, he might not use his powers the way the town wants him to.
The core of my aim is that at this point, I would rather leave active participants alive.
We have 34 players and we have to find 7 mafia among them. t_co is a top 6 poster and is revealing a lot of information about him/herself. We have 14 players with 1-5 posts, 2 players with 0 posts. Low-participation mafia members will be a lot harder to identify.
|
correct me please, i may have misplaced some things with my bad memory
|
It's getting down to the wire guys... can everyone please put their choice and perhaps a short blurb describing why?
|
Mystlord
United States10264 Posts
On January 22 2010 09:47 meeple wrote:
If we don't lynch him, then who? nobody seems able to decide on something.
I'm still all for the lynching of t_co. I'm just saying that even if we don't lynch him, it hurts us to let him into office.
Zona: I see your reasoning for wanting to lynch Faronel and not t_co, but you cannot randomly lynch people based off of low activity and a tenuous link at best. We won't get any information at all from Faronel's lynching, which drops him even lower on the priority list.
I still believe that t_co's lynching will give us the most information. Even if he isn't mafia, it will point us in a clear direction. I've already seen evidence of his strange and wild arguments confusing some people, and it hurts us to keep him in if he starts confusing the town, regardless of whether he's a townie or not.
|
It takes a while to read that many pages.
As for the t_co vs Hobbes lynching debate, I think it would be better to lynch t_co. As mentioned by every single other person, t_co is inconsistent and confrontational. Although, it might be interesting to leave him alive and see what happens next. From what I've seen of Mafia games, there always seems to be one townie who is overly aggressive and plays stupidly. That isn't a good reason to keep him alive though.
As for Hobbes, what exactly are the clues pointing to him? The barbaric sounds -> picture of tiger [hobbes] dancing? Is that it or did I miss something important? If that is it, I think that clue matches cookie monster keit better. And I don't think it matches anyone good enough for a lynch.
|
Hobbes has been active in discussing the clues, though.
|
On January 22 2010 10:29 meeple wrote:
It's getting down to the wire guys... can everyone please put their choice and perhaps a short blurb describing why?
Day 1 lynching choices for the mayor?
|
On January 22 2010 10:29 meeple wrote:
It's getting down to the wire guys... can everyone please put their choice and perhaps a short blurb describing why?
t_co - If he is Mafia, then that puts faronel under suspicion, not the other way around. If he isn't mafia, it gives us some new perspective. Regardless, his irrational arguments and accusations have done nothing but divide and hurt the town.
|
On January 22 2010 10:30 Mystlord wrote:Show nested quote +On January 22 2010 09:47 meeple wrote:
If we don't lynch him, then who? nobody seems able to decide on something. I'm still all for the lynching of t_co. I'm just saying that even if we don't lynch him, it hurts us to let him into office. Zona: I see your reasoning for wanting to lynch Faronel and not t_co, but you cannot randomly lynch people based off of low activity and a tenuous link at best. We won't get any information at all from Faronel's lynching, which drops him even lower on the priority list. I still believe that t_co's lynching will give us the most information. Even if he isn't mafia, it will point us in a clear direction. I've already seen evidence of his strange and wild arguments confusing some people, and it hurts us to keep him in if he starts confusing the town, regardless of whether he's a townie or not.
Whats the clear direction if he's green/blue?
|
On January 22 2010 10:31 CynanMachae wrote:Show nested quote +On January 22 2010 10:29 meeple wrote:
It's getting down to the wire guys... can everyone please put their choice and perhaps a short blurb describing why? Day 1 lynching choices for the mayor?
Yes please
|
On January 22 2010 10:23 Nikoner wrote:At first I hadn't realised that Bill Murray has been posting so much... and most, if not all, of his posts are like this: Show nested quote +On January 22 2010 08:24 Bill Murray wrote:
I vote for a double lynch on day 2 Which doesn't even make sense, since it will most likely lead to us lynching 2 townies, if anything...
I don't want this point to get overlooked. A lot of Bill Murray's posts have not been useful. Many one-liners, and other posts asking for medic protection since for whatever reason he thinks he is a high profile target.
|
FREEAGLELAND26780 Posts
I still say we lynch t_co, then move onto Hobbes (by clues) since a disruptive player just adds senseless text to wade through. I'm keeping up with all this whenever I get back to my computer, so it makes it easier on the people like me. Furthermore, if we get the mafia day 1 or 2 it doesn't matter since they are able to have 3 killpower anyway since 7 and 6 are the same.
|
On January 22 2010 10:28 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
correct me please, i may have misplaced some things with my bad memory
Well, it's not that the list is incorrect, the thing is that at the bottom of page 3, after two consecutive votes for t_co, by Ser Aspi and me respectively, 789 was quick to change his vote to t_co, who at that point looked like he might get into office if the bandwagon kept going.
|
Wouldn't they have 3 kp even with 5?
2.5 rounded up is 3
|
On January 22 2010 10:36 Nikoner wrote:Show nested quote +On January 22 2010 10:28 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
correct me please, i may have misplaced some things with my bad memory Well, it's not that the list is incorrect, the thing is that at the bottom of page 3, after two consecutive votes for t_co, by Ser Aspi and me respectively, 789 was quick to change his vote to t_co, who at that point looked like he might get into office if the bandwagon kept going.
ah ^^
|
On January 22 2010 10:25 CynanMachae wrote:Show nested quote +On January 22 2010 10:23 Nikoner wrote:At first I hadn't realised that Bill Murray has been posting so much... and most, if not all, of his posts are like this: On January 22 2010 08:24 Bill Murray wrote:
I vote for a double lynch on day 2 Which doesn't even make sense, since it will most likely lead to us lynching 2 townies, if anything... Most of his posts has been triple-post confusing one liners yea, but that isn't much of an argument for lynching
I never said I wanted to lynch him. Methinks you doth protest too much.
|
We shouldn't lynch Hobbes based on clues. Clues in the first day are designed to be useless, just a buildup for future days. It's really easy to get obsessed on clues; I certainly was trying to clue analyze myself  But we need to remain logical and realize that a clue link is meaningless right now.
Lynching t_co is not useful either. It's basically a wasted lynch at this point. Faronel or any of those low contribution people is totally the right idea me thinks.
We don't learn anything by lynching anyone really besides that person's role. Lynching t_co won't tell us anything useful. Same with hobbes or anyone else.
|
On January 22 2010 10:36 flamewheel91 wrote:
I still say we lynch t_co, then move onto Hobbes (by clues) since a disruptive player just adds senseless text to wade through. I'm keeping up with all this whenever I get back to my computer, so it makes it easier on the people like me. Furthermore, if we get the mafia day 1 or 2 it doesn't matter since they are able to have 3 killpower anyway since 7 and 6 are the same.
Well, you could say that if we get a mafia on day 1 AND day two their kp would be reduced. But anyway, chances are very low of that lol.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
