Please use spoilers when quoting a post with pictures and/or videos.
When posting large quantities of media (pictures or videos), please begin spoilering after the first piece. Grouping related videos in the same spoilers & labeling is recommended.
No reposting of old material unless justified
Posting any material with little or no relevent discussion accompanying it
No passion-induced flaming of each other because 'x said y sucked' etc.
Keep the expression hate of music individuals/groups to a minimal level
No 'pagetopping' in any form whatsoever, as it constitutes spam equal to posts similar to 'first'.
No vulgar fan fics or wet dream stories. It is creepy, weird, and it dehumanizes the people who you are here to celebrate/discuss.
Normal posting standards that you find throughout the rest of the site still apply and will be enforced more strictly from here forward (2012/03/11)

Due to the poor nature of this thread in the past, temporary two-day bans will occur more than often if people slip up.

Ym1r

United States1164 Posts

January 01 2013 09:09 GMT

#89081

Not too bad better than the boys imo, but thats not saying much, I'll listen to it here and there otherwise back to Noel and Urban Zakapa.

Seeker

Where dat snitch at?37108 Posts

January 01 2013 09:12 GMT

#89082

On January 01 2013 18:08 Kaiwa wrote:
Seeker is new to KMD? Polls are trollbait 100% of the time

Lol, I'm not new to KMD. I just messed up the title of the poll.

Portvilla

United States42 Posts

January 01 2013 09:13 GMT

#89083

Ugh so hard being a SONE right now...

So much build up and hype for their Korean comeback; then you are left at the end of the MV not knowing what to think T_T

As far as the album goes, plain and generic songs. V nice to listen to, but it won't go down in history any time soon. I think they just want to appeal to a wide of an audience as they can, so simple is the way to go.

At the end of the day I always realize that no matter what I think of what they are doing, the CEO's and producers gathering around that table at SM have a better idea on this than me, so w/e.

3/5 ~ barely

Seeker

Where dat snitch at?37108 Posts

January 01 2013 09:13 GMT

#89084

Alright, nvm. Polls = nono

NicksonReyes

Philippines4431 Posts

January 01 2013 09:14 GMT

#89085

On January 01 2013 18:12 Seeker wrote:

Show nested quote +

Lol, I'm not new to KMD. I just messed up the title of the poll.

Not just the title of the poll, but its very existence is trollbait. Stop making polls.

Hall0wed

United States8486 Posts

January 01 2013 09:15 GMT

#89086

On January 01 2013 18:13 Seeker wrote:
Alright here is the new poll. Feel free to point out if this has errors as well:

+ Show Spoiler +

Poll: SNSD's I Got A Boy?

I don't like it (12)

55%

I like it (5)

23%

Middle ground (5)

23%

22 total votes

Your vote: SNSD's I Got A Boy?

(Vote): I like it
(Vote): I don't like it
(Vote): Middle ground

Lol fail again, both the song in the MV and the album itself are named "I Got A Boy". Dunno which one this is for.

Also the song is much better when you listen to it without the MV.

On January 01 2013 18:14 NicksonReyes wrote:

Show nested quote +

Not just the title of the poll, but its very existence is trollbait.

Yeah we just do not do polls here Seeker, keep them to LR threads please.

xBillehx

United States1289 Posts

January 01 2013 09:16 GMT

#89087

I like Baby Maybe, Promise, 유리아이, Romantic Street and Talk Talk/Boomerang (probably shouldn't count since it leaked ages ago) in no specific order. IGAB is still a mess and Express 999 has the same problem as IGAB, mixing of what should have been different songs. I like the parts that go with the first part though. The rest I haven't decided yet. Pretty much what I expected considering their latest stuff. Whoever sat down to listen to the album and picked the title track is an idiot.

firehand101

Australia3152 Posts

January 01 2013 09:17 GMT

#89088

On January 01 2013 18:15 Hall0wed wrote:

Show nested quote +

Lol fail again, both the song in the MV and the album itself are named "I Got A Boy". Dunno which one this is for.

Also the song is much better when you listen to it without the MV.

lol how is that possible...sigh might as well give it a try , can't get any worse i think

seiferoth10

3362 Posts

January 01 2013 09:22 GMT

#89089

1. Express 999 is 100% making it to my playlist.
2. Promise very high tier.
3. Lost in Love quite good as well.

gap

4. Baby Maybe is high tier.
5. Romantic Street is above average.

gap

6. Dancing Queen is alright.
7. Boomerang is okay.

Grand Canyon

8. IGAB is, admittedly, not very good.

gap

9. XYZ is very low tier.
10. I only made it 0:56 into Look At Me before moving on.

6.5/10. 0.5 deduction for picking a bad title song.

firehand101

Australia3152 Posts

January 01 2013 09:33 GMT

#89090

Listened to the song for the 5th time now, starting to grow on me...but does not come close to deserving an all kill on the K music charts....

which it just did *facepalm*

bLecK

Australia625 Posts

January 01 2013 09:35 GMT

#89091

On January 01 2013 18:22 seiferoth10 wrote:
1. Express 999 is 100% making it to my playlist.
2. Promise very high tier.
3. Lost in Love quite good as well.

gap

4. Baby Maybe is high tier.
5. Romantic Street is above average.

gap

6. Dancing Queen is alright.
7. Boomerang is okay.

Grand Canyon

8. IGAB is, admittedly, not very good.

gap

9. XYZ is very low tier.
10. I only made it 0:56 into Look At Me before moving on.

6.5/10. 0.5 deduction for picking a bad title song.

I found Look at Me quite decent once I got passed the crappy rap sequence at the start of the song.

Traceback

United States469 Posts

January 01 2013 09:37 GMT

#89092

5.86/10 overall including deduction for picking the wrong title.

giesecke

Germany361 Posts

January 01 2013 09:39 GMT

#89093

On January 01 2013 02:42 klogg wrote:
Meanwhile, at SBS..

+ Show Spoiler +

that look, yuri is just too good

PolskaGora

United States547 Posts

January 01 2013 09:46 GMT

#89094

Mmmmm I hate to be part of the bandwagon, and it hurts to admit as a huge SNSD fan, but I did not like I Got a Boy. I will go as far as to admit that when I read everyone's negative opinion I thought that everyone else were haters and that I would surely like it. The dress was completely confusing, though if I think of it that way it kinda makes sense, since the song itself was confusing as hell. All I really heard was that annoying morse code beep in the back and them singing (rapping?). The song didn't seem to have any sort of normal progression whatsoever, as in verses, choruses, bridges, etc. It all ended randomly. Hopefully the rest of the album is good though!

seiferoth10

3362 Posts

January 01 2013 09:53 GMT

#89095

IGAB will be a good performance song, but bad song song. Kinda like 2pm's Hands Up or GD's Crayon.

Aerisky

United States12129 Posts

January 01 2013 09:56 GMT

#89096

Clearly the song's intended purpose is to harbor some subliminal message that will take only the divine elect to a greater plane of existence. Evidently none of us can grasp the true good news behind the track.

Canucklehead

Canada5074 Posts

January 01 2013 10:17 GMT

#89097

This thread needs more psy.

Shankapotamus

United States428 Posts

January 01 2013 10:23 GMT

#89098

So like, that song was a HUGE wtf... kept on switching beats and stuff and to be honest, it didn't really even feel like a song. But DAYUM that video carried hard

sc2superfan101

3583 Posts

January 01 2013 10:25 GMT

#89099

I actually thought the song was pretty tight. really creative for a pop-song. it's definitely busy though.

hyoyeon looks hot as hell too.

Mastermyth

Netherlands207 Posts

January 01 2013 10:49 GMT

#89100

I kinda like it, I've never had trouble with rapidly switching beats. May have helped that I was listening to that DJ Shadow set before this. The post 2 minute part is definitely the better part for me though.