EPT+ Show Spoiler [Madoka] +
The scenery after Madoka becomes a witch looks exactly like some parts of Japan right now. 
I think we know the real cause of this earthquake...
I think we know the real cause of this earthquake...Anime Discussion Thread - Page 847
| Forum Index > Media & Entertainment |
If you come in here looking for "anime recommendations" then please refer to this chart before posting: Anime Recommendations (as of may 2014). We also have an IRC channel called #tladt where we all hang out. The channel is on Rizon, not QuakeNet! Feel free to check it out. TLADT discord is Discord.gg For currently airing anime, please see Anichart.net | ||
|
KazeHydra
Japan2788 Posts
+ Show Spoiler [Madoka] + | ||
|
TimeOut
Germany1277 Posts
On March 11 2011 17:30 Spazer wrote: + Show Spoiler + Oh yeah, that's true. I was mistakenly thinking of her as a normal person. =/ One more thing: in the initial loops, Homura entered a timeframe where Madoka was already a magical girl before she first shows up at the school. However, on subsequent visits, she somehow prevents Madoka from making that crucial first contact with Kyubey. So either she's capable of controlling her "landing point", or there are a few days between her arrival time and when Madoka first contracts, giving her the time she needs to hunt down Kyubey and warn Madoka. I'm leaning towards the latter. However, if this is the case, what on earth was she doing in that time period in the first few time loops? + Show Spoiler [Madoka] + Well, she didn't know everything about her body and how magical girls work in the first iterations. So I guess she spent her days in the hospital, like in the first / real iteration where she arrived far too late. After that failed and after she learned more about her magical girl condition, she basically jumped out of her hospital bed immediately and managed to prevent at least some Kyuubey contact points. | ||
|
Gao Xi
Hong Kong5178 Posts
On March 11 2011 17:34 TimeOut wrote: + Show Spoiler [Madoka] + Well, she didn't know everything about her body and how magical girls work in the first iterations. So I guess she spent her days in the hospital, like in the first / real iteration where she arrived far too late. After that failed and after she learned more about her magical girl condition, she basically jumped out of her hospital bed immediately and managed to prevent at least some Kyuubey contact points. + Show Spoiler + That makes sense, I remember in the scene where everyone was killing each other, someone said that kyubey tricked them, so i think thats where she realized the truth, then it was followed by Madoka dying and said that she didn't want to become a witch and didn't want to be a mahou shoujo, then Homura kills her. | ||
Spazer
Canada8036 Posts
I just realized that despite all the different loops we were shown, we were never told what Madoka's wish was. I imagine it was something trivial when she contracted before Homura arrived, but what about that time at Walpurgis? I guess this is going to be a major plot point in the last two episodes. Perhaps this is the way out? | ||
|
Southlight
United States11768 Posts
![[image loading]](http://img864.imageshack.us/img864/9967/mercurius.png) The main character that really, really should have been the main character. | ||
|
Wala.Revolution
7584 Posts
| ||
|
Southlight
United States11768 Posts
| ||
|
TimeOut
Germany1277 Posts
| ||
|
Wala.Revolution
7584 Posts
| ||
|
Spazer
Canada8036 Posts
On March 11 2011 18:24 Wala.Revolution wrote: I want to hear you scream live. New fetish? :3 | ||
|
Southlight
United States11768 Posts
| ||
|
Yoshi Kirishima
United States10382 Posts
Only 8 episodes out of 11 so far, you can find legally uploaded subs by Funimation on youtube under "Season 1" (omg more than 11 episodes then?) Closest anime I can compare it with (all aspects considered) is Denno Coil, but this is even better. This is not your Code Geass but is still a beautiful anime and has its own share of action/thriller with good pacing and well implemented humor/romance/drama etc. and all. Great animation too. Music is nothing notable so far, I can't really remember any BGM, but it doesn't detract from the show or make the anime seem too "quiet" or silent. | ||
|
Wala.Revolution
7584 Posts
Meh, I'm sorry(?) but I'll be going to sleep... too late. + Show Spoiler + UWAAAAAAAAAAAAA pant pant pant | ||
|
TimeOut
Germany1277 Posts
On March 11 2011 18:28 Southlight wrote: lol, doubt I'd be screaming. I can stream a playthrough of Ayakashibito, as I'd been planning on reading that, but it'd be for the long-haul as it's a full-fledge VN... I guess? As long as it is not too much for you to translate on the fly? I don't want to force you to stream for us, if you want to do something on your own. | ||
|
Southlight
United States11768 Posts
![[image loading]](http://imgur.com/rXUPP.png) You might recognize him. Or you probably won't. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reinhard_Heydrich Edit: On March 11 2011 18:32 TimeOut wrote: As long as it is not too much for you to translate on the fly? I don't want to force you to stream for us, if you want to do something on your own. I'll give it a go, ~00:00 GMT (+00:00) again. We'll see how it goes, if it doesn't work out I can always think of something else for next week. | ||
|
TimeOut
Germany1277 Posts
On March 11 2011 18:32 Southlight wrote: I'll give it a go, ~00:00 GMT (+00:00) again. We'll see how it goes, if it doesn't work out I can always think of something else for next week. Yay, awesome. :D | ||
|
Spazer
Canada8036 Posts
On March 11 2011 18:29 Yoshi Kirishima wrote: I'm just going to drop in again, finally found a[nother] great anime. It's called Fractale. It might not seem your cup of tea at the beginning, but I don't want to say anything else so you can experience and enjoy it to the fullest. Only 8 episodes out of 11 so far, you can find legally uploaded subs by Funimation on youtube under "Season 1" (omg more than 11 episodes then?) Closest anime I can compare it with (all aspects considered) is Denno Coil, but this is even better. This is not your Code Geass but is still a beautiful anime and has its own share of action/thriller with good pacing and well implemented humor/romance etc. and all. Great animation too. I didn't particularly like what they were doing with the story, and dropped the show after episode 3. The idea is interesting and has some merit, but the execution I felt was really lacking. + Show Spoiler [For instance, episode 3] + The gunfight thing came out of nowhere, and although I understand it was supposed to be a dramatic way of stating that things aren't as nice as they seem, it was done in such a way that it was almost unintentionally hilarious. Random mook A dies and characters get all emotional because of that, but he had hardly any characterization, so why should I care? I have been keeping up with the episode summaries though, but overall, I'm still not impressed. + Show Spoiler [Fractale] + In episode 6, we meet Clain's father. What for? Meeting him did not advance the plot - it was basically just a side note. In episode 5, nothing happens. Instead of getting more discussion about the Fractale system, the ethics of using it, the changes to society, etc., we get laundry day. I mean, what the hell. If you're going to make an anime about technology and how it's helping/destroying society, maybe you should focus on that instead of giving us tons of slice of life and some random subplots? I dunno. I feel like this show is Angel Beats all over again. All this potential and they just blew it. | ||
|
Latham
9590 Posts
On March 11 2011 18:47 Spazer wrote: I didn't particularly like what they were doing with the story, and dropped the show after episode 3. The idea is interesting and has some merit, but the execution I felt was really lacking. + Show Spoiler [For instance, episode 3] + The gunfight thing came out of nowhere, and although I understand it was supposed to be a dramatic way of stating that things aren't as nice as they seem, it was done in such a way that it was almost unintentionally hilarious. Random mook A dies and characters get all emotional because of that, but he had hardly any characterization, so why should I care? I have been keeping up with the episode summaries though, but overall, I'm still not impressed. + Show Spoiler [Fractale] + In episode 6, we meet Clain's father. What for? Meeting him did not advance the plot - it was basically just a side note. In episode 5, nothing happens. Instead of getting more discussion about the Fractale system, the ethics of using it, the changes to society, etc., we get laundry day. I mean, what the hell. If you're going to make an anime about technology and how it's helping/destroying society, maybe you should focus on that instead of giving us tons of slice of life and some random subplots? I dunno. I feel like this show is Angel Beats all over again. All this potential and they just blew it. Actually thats a good comparison. Fractale is weird. The MC is well fleshed out and unique, the setting wasn't bad but the plot leaves a lot to be desired. Feels like they're beating around the bush too much. The previews suggested it would be a chase after Phryne all show long, but as it is now, she's been with them for the majority of the episodes. Also you don't feel the drama and the epicness of fighting the fractale system. What is the point of this show? What is the plot? Is it Phryne or the fractale system? Is it a chase or is it a struggle? You can't possibly fit all of it into 11 measly episodes. While they travel around the world, they learn the truth about the fractale system. But it's all they do. It's boring. They mope around and explain the setting. No action, no drama, no significant moments. The art is eye-candy, but that's all there is to this show. + Show Spoiler [IS#10] + Tanabe is like a hamster or coffee (or crack). I still don't see why the Houki hate is so strong. She's got a nice personality. She doesn't gloat about having a superior IS, or anything. She's mostly silent and it's just now her time to shine. Sure Tanabe is hax, but it's not really Houki's fault. I still don't see how she's the only love interest now. She's got an IS now and is given the chance to use it and make an impression. Compared to the Ichika hogging the other heroines did, I consider it justice. Don't blame Houki for crap writing in the future episodes/LNs, blame the author for killing off the chances of the other heroines. It's not like it was impossible for him to limit Tanabe just to delivering the IS and explaining it. If what I read was true, blame him for making Tanabe plot hax instead of just a 1-time boost for Houki. + Show Spoiler [Madoka] + LOL, Tanami going berserk and Homura's story. A nice episode overall. Wonder what Madoka's wish was, though. | ||
|
Ferrose
United States11378 Posts
On March 11 2011 17:14 Spazer wrote: Nice revelation about the OP. But man... + Show Spoiler [Madoka] + Regarding Homura's time travel: why does it only activate after Walpurgis? Does she not have full control over it, or does she only activate the time travel part after Madoka dies? Or is fine control past time stoppage difficult? Theoretically, if her control is absolute, she could replay a section of the past any number of times until the criteria required to activate an event are met. The way her time travel works is interesting. In Haruhi, the SOS brigade is caught in a time loop in which their bodies and minds revert to a predetermined state when the end of the cycle is reached. Nagato is the sole exception since the data integration thought entity is a concept that doesn't exist (presumably) in normal space-time. In Homura's case, every time she goes back, she seems to travel through both time AND space, as she always ends up in the hospital bed. This is kinda odd, since time machines usually act only on either one or the other, but whatever, it's fictional/magical technology. Obviously her physical state does not revert, as she's incredibly athletic as proved by episode 1. She doesn't seem to have aged though, suggesting that either there haven't been that many loops, the time loop itself spans a short amount of time, or her body doesn't age (though that seems unlikely). tl;dr - Worst end: Homura dies of old age and Madoka becomes a witch because nobody stopped her lol + Show Spoiler + The only way for the cycle to stop is for Homura to die, right? So they should just kill Walpurgisnacht, then Homura can go Mami on Madoka and herself. That's the good end. Edit: I also don't get why Homura doesn't go back in time sooner. You'd think that she'd realize that she already planted the flag for the bad end + Show Spoiler [Madoka gifs] + DOCTOR ![[image loading]](http://img684.imageshack.us/img684/5888/46aeac8c897408909ad89a5.gif) ![[image loading]](http://img854.imageshack.us/img854/8049/b8afd82c8a96fc92f33eb73.gif) I could watch this all day: ![[image loading]](http://img864.imageshack.us/img864/5720/8a991818814702fd8d2fd42c.gif) | ||
|
Zergneedsfood
United States10671 Posts
+ Show Spoiler [madoka] + And TimeOut, you blew my mind with the way that Homura wish works. Because since Homura's wish hasn't been granted, she can go back in time as many times as possible to fulfill that wish at the time of the Walpurgis Night. I think that also means that she can "violate" the contract by not fighting Witches. Since her wish hasn't been granted, she isn't bound to fighting them, which explains why she didn't fight Madoka in the.....4th loop that we saw. | ||
| ||
