|
If you come in here looking for "anime recommendations" then please refer to this chart before posting: Anime Recommendations (as of may 2014). We also have an IRC channel called #tladt where we all hang out. The channel is on Rizon, not QuakeNet! Feel free to check it out. TLADT discord is Discord.ggFor currently airing anime, please see Anichart.net |
On February 01 2016 04:50 Sentenal wrote:Show nested quote +On January 31 2016 22:38 OsaX Nymloth wrote:On January 31 2016 17:12 Sentenal wrote:On January 31 2016 10:16 OsaX Nymloth wrote: And now I just saw Ga-Rei: Zero and I have deja vu with Mirai Nikki. Altho GRZ ain't so bad and full of plot holes that makes zero sense, it was still terribly mediocre at best. What I can't comprehend is all the '9/10' and '10/10', 'best anime evah' reviews/opinions. ~~ I liked Ga Rei Zero quite a bit. No idea how it is like Mirai Nikki in the least. They're totally different, but share lots of similarities: highly overrated, shallow characters without any real development, poor writing/pacing, plot holes (in Mirai Nikki they were bigger than whatever iceberg hit Titanic) and both have tons of superpositive reviews at places like MAL. I know, I'm grumpy  Its kind of hard to discuss it when your reasons for not liking it are just "overrated" and "I thought it was shit". Ofc people who liked it don't agree with those "reasons", not to mention that two of them aren't even reasons and are irrelevant.
Of course we can discuss it in the details. As for Ga-Rei: Zero: + Show Spoiler +there wasn't really any real character development. Kagura basically for whole series was only saying "Yomi/sorry" or crying, Yomi didn't really seem that interesting, rest of characters are forgettable.
Plot. So we have the specters. Nothing much explained, but ok. So we have like two ministries fighting evil and let's just say, they have like no real methodology, tactics, strategy, nothing. Which you can clearly see in few episodes where they just charge randomly during battle. But that's isn't that important. Their 'spiritual team' sense some weirdness that appeared twice, none bothers to check it out, director is busy with doing nothing. Ugh. Also, that fight of her vs Yomi almost made me burst in laughs. :D
Story progression: well, you could say what's going to happen waaaay before it actually happened. You knew Kagura won't die in first two episodes (if I remember correctly, they even changed the 'slice' animation from 'first' part of the show and the latter one). You could tell from miles away how Kagura and Yomi became close and that Yomi will die in final epic clash with Kagura. That wouldn't be bad if the story was actually told in interesting manner, which wasn't the case. There was problem with pacing as well, but I guess we can blame that on the fact G-R: Z had only 12 episodes.
Also about that "epic final fight". When Kagura's mother died, her father went through a not-so-short ritual to bind the beast and his soul together. Ok. He dies then and... Kagura inherits the beast without any actual rituals, sealings, nothing. A beast that was clearly trying to escape and was supposedly really powerful. So...yeah. Makes sense.
Characters acting without logic, no actual strategy or thought in actions of a ministry (like, not even having anybody watching their 'watcher teams'. Know that wouldn't change the fact Yomi could kill'em without a problem, but still. And the main antagonist, simply boring. Another 'evil kid who will never fight but laugh and watch the outcome of whatever'. Boooooring.
Maybe manga explains this more, but I'm rating anime only. As as a whole, it's utterly mediocre.
As for Mirai Nikki, oh man, don't even get me started on this one :D
Here. A bit of chaotic long post, hope you don't mind.
|
On February 01 2016 05:20 Miragee wrote:lol, I think you made your point clear. I will probably start watching it later this evening. //ok forget it. I forgot that Dragon Arena in Guild Wars is starting today, so I probably won't...
I just wanted an excuse to look up more pics, shouldn't be talking about this stuff after exercising. Certain body parts have stronger control over brain at that time.
Haikyuu was pretty solid this week.
|
Haikyuu is always solid if you like it. 
edit: I just realized I forgot to watch Ajin... It's rather painful to watch, but I guess I'll do it anyway cuz the plot looks like it'll be interesting.
|
+ Show Spoiler [Grimgar 04] +I really liked how they showed goblins as more than just ordinary mobs. They showed the really buff goblin and the crossbow sniper goblin too, that was pretty sick honestly.
Such a death flag raised when he gave his speech to the entire group then skipped over Haruhiro, who obviously is gonna be next in line to lead the group. His death was done right imo. Executed properly and didn't sell it too hard. When the priest master offered to pay for his cremation and Haruhiro denied it, I think that alone shows how much his character has grown and has to grow to be the leader of the group.
Also rip mahou grill. She finally started talking to Manato, lol, get rekt.
Blue-haired side pony tail girl next ep. *rubs hands together* New healer maybe???
|
Schwaresmarken#4, really enjoy it, not quite sure what they said in the end about nobody likes socialism (?), japanese tend to have some weird views on other culture/ideals. This Lise girl something is not right with her, selling herself too hard in this episode.
my grimgar post get edited for spoiler, thanks based mod
|
+ Show Spoiler [Shokugeki 152] +Welp, they do know how to set up the hype. Also, fucking hilarious that Hishoko drew the short straw and ended up with the Steves.
|
Btw miragee if you're going to watching yozakura quartet then this will probably help you a ton: + Show Spoiler [Watching order] + Otherwise i can imagine you'll be fairly confused
|
On February 01 2016 07:35 BurningSera wrote: Schwaresmarken#4, really enjoy it, not quite sure what they said in the end about nobody likes socialism (?), japanese tend to have some weird views on other culture/ideals. This Lise girl something is not right with her, selling herself too hard in this episode.
my grimgar post get edited for spoiler, thanks based mod If you're referring to what I think you are, they meant that the rest of the world doesn't like socialist countries. I guess Communist would make for a better translation in this instance, but the terms at the time are pretty interchangable. And considering the anime is set within the Cold War, its true. The Capitalist West and the Communist East didn't get along.
On February 01 2016 05:42 OsaX Nymloth wrote:Show nested quote +On February 01 2016 04:50 Sentenal wrote:On January 31 2016 22:38 OsaX Nymloth wrote:On January 31 2016 17:12 Sentenal wrote:On January 31 2016 10:16 OsaX Nymloth wrote: And now I just saw Ga-Rei: Zero and I have deja vu with Mirai Nikki. Altho GRZ ain't so bad and full of plot holes that makes zero sense, it was still terribly mediocre at best. What I can't comprehend is all the '9/10' and '10/10', 'best anime evah' reviews/opinions. ~~ I liked Ga Rei Zero quite a bit. No idea how it is like Mirai Nikki in the least. They're totally different, but share lots of similarities: highly overrated, shallow characters without any real development, poor writing/pacing, plot holes (in Mirai Nikki they were bigger than whatever iceberg hit Titanic) and both have tons of superpositive reviews at places like MAL. I know, I'm grumpy  Its kind of hard to discuss it when your reasons for not liking it are just "overrated" and "I thought it was shit". Ofc people who liked it don't agree with those "reasons", not to mention that two of them aren't even reasons and are irrelevant. Of course we can discuss it in the details. As for Ga-Rei: Zero: + Show Spoiler +there wasn't really any real character development. Kagura basically for whole series was only saying "Yomi/sorry" or crying, Yomi didn't really seem that interesting, rest of characters are forgettable.
Plot. So we have the specters. Nothing much explained, but ok. So we have like two ministries fighting evil and let's just say, they have like no real methodology, tactics, strategy, nothing. Which you can clearly see in few episodes where they just charge randomly during battle. But that's isn't that important. Their 'spiritual team' sense some weirdness that appeared twice, none bothers to check it out, director is busy with doing nothing. Ugh. Also, that fight of her vs Yomi almost made me burst in laughs. :D
Story progression: well, you could say what's going to happen waaaay before it actually happened. You knew Kagura won't die in first two episodes (if I remember correctly, they even changed the 'slice' animation from 'first' part of the show and the latter one). You could tell from miles away how Kagura and Yomi became close and that Yomi will die in final epic clash with Kagura. That wouldn't be bad if the story was actually told in interesting manner, which wasn't the case. There was problem with pacing as well, but I guess we can blame that on the fact G-R: Z had only 12 episodes.
Also about that "epic final fight". When Kagura's mother died, her father went through a not-so-short ritual to bind the beast and his soul together. Ok. He dies then and... Kagura inherits the beast without any actual rituals, sealings, nothing. A beast that was clearly trying to escape and was supposedly really powerful. So...yeah. Makes sense.
Characters acting without logic, no actual strategy or thought in actions of a ministry (like, not even having anybody watching their 'watcher teams'. Know that wouldn't change the fact Yomi could kill'em without a problem, but still. And the main antagonist, simply boring. Another 'evil kid who will never fight but laugh and watch the outcome of whatever'. Boooooring.
Maybe manga explains this more, but I'm rating anime only. As as a whole, it's utterly mediocre.
As for Mirai Nikki, oh man, don't even get me started on this one :D Here. A bit of chaotic long post, hope you don't mind. + Show Spoiler +Character Development: I could get that one could not like the character development in the anime, but saying that there simply wasn't any is just false. Is a 'character' different from the beginning of the series compared to the end? No matter what way you look at it, the answer is yes. Kagura did go through many major changes in terms of her outlook and how she thought, over the course of the show. The same can be said for characters such as Yomi and Noriyuki. So rather than not having any character development, its just that they didn't have character development that you liked. Which is fine, since that simply comes down to personal preference. You obviously didn't like how they developed the characters, while others did.
Plot: I'm... Honestly not sure what you are even talking about with a lot of this stuff. The job for exterminators is to go in and kill the target. I'm not sure if you were expecting Tom Clancy out of this or not. For predictability, its not like anime in unpredictably by nature, and when it does try to be unpredictable, it turns out as shit. But Ga Rei Zero did have a bit of unpredictability to it, especially considering its first episode. All of the preview material for the anime exclusively advertised the cast we saw in the first episode. And then the whole cast was killed to a man. And then the second episode seemingly repeated it. IMO the only way you could see through that is if you had prior experience with the manga, to know how it would turn out.
As for Byakuei getting passed to Kagura easily, reading between the lines can explain it pretty easily. Kagura has been being trained and prepared for getting Byakuei for her whole life. Kagura's father wasn't "meant" to have gotten Byakuei, given that he married into the family, was forced to take it due to Kagura being too young at the time to inherit it, not to mention age probably factored in (as it was remarked that everyone who takes Byakuei dies young.), which could all culminate into it being a trail to merge an unrelated/unprepared soul with the beast, compared to a young person who was groomed for it. Finally, there is Byakuei himself, maybe hes just into young girls. Ofc, this is all reading between the lines, so if you only accept things that get spelt out for you as fact, well... To each his own, I suppose.
I don't get what you are referring to with characters acting without logic. I'm not sure why you assume that they had no one protecting the Watcher Teams (unless we are going back wanting everything to be explicit). The main antagonist was boring, I'll agree about that. He's there just because he is in the manga, but he was hardly the antagonist that got focused on anyway, so w/e.
What liking/disliking Ga Rei Zero comes down to is how well much you like the Kagura/Yomi relationship, and if the tragedy involved gave you any FEEEELLLS or not. Its pretty clear that you didn't care for it, but surely you can see how other people might, right? Mirai Nikki is shit, but its not even comparable to Ga Rei Zero IMO. Its about a Yandere stalker girl and keikakus keikakuing kaikakus. Ga Rei Zero is about fighting ghosts and crying.
|
Handa-kun anime announced!
|
Canada8033 Posts
Handa-kun was kinda mediocre. It's pretty different from Barakamon.
|
Dropped this week Luck and Logic Phantasy Star
Total Dropped this season: Active Raid Ajin Divine Gate Luck And Logic Phantasy Star Online 2
Watching Boku dake Bubuki (close to being dropped?) Dimension W Gate Grimgar Schwarzesmarken
Still a VERY solid anime season. Two shows I am very eager to watch every week (Boku and Dimension W). The others are good filler.
I was curious : did any of you ever happened to have NOTHING to watch in a season because none of the series were to your liking?
|
Yea Luck and Logic and Bubuki are pretty close to getting the axe.
|
TLADT24920 Posts
man, I was expecting this latest development in Grimgar at all. + Show Spoiler +I mean, I guess its reasonable considering that Haruhiro will end up leading the group but would've liked Manato to stick around which wouldn't have worked. Quite the emotional episode but was needed.
|
Am I the only one that, based solely upon the opening, am waiting for Kyoma to get involved in some kind of epic dance battle in Dimension W?
Just wondering.
|
On February 01 2016 05:45 Numy wrote:Show nested quote +On February 01 2016 05:20 Miragee wrote:lol, I think you made your point clear. I will probably start watching it later this evening. //ok forget it. I forgot that Dragon Arena in Guild Wars is starting today, so I probably won't... I just wanted an excuse to look up more pics, shouldn't be talking about this stuff after exercising. Certain body parts have stronger control over brain at that time.
What excersises? lol
On February 01 2016 10:32 Unleashing wrote:Btw miragee if you're going to watching yozakura quartet then this will probably help you a ton: + Show Spoiler [Watching order] +Otherwise i can imagine you'll be fairly confused
Oh ok. I would have watched it in order without OVAs, good to know, thanks!
On February 01 2016 13:16 Spazer wrote: Handa-kun was kinda mediocre. It's pretty different from Barakamon.
Yeah, I started reading Handa-kun after finishing Barakamon (anime) because people here suggested it and I didn't like it. It was very different indeed.
On February 01 2016 14:48 XenOmega wrote: I was curious : did any of you ever happened to have NOTHING to watch in a season because none of the series were to your liking?
Nope. The closest one for me was probably spring last year. I watched a handful of shows and the best show for me that season was Kekkai Sensen that barely passed the "ok" mark. But about a year ago I was of the opinion that I wouldn't drop anything I started so this might be the reason.
|
I do Jim Wendlers 5/3/1 then cardio on off days most of the time. So yesterday was a cardio day.
At least this way I'll be a dirty weeb that's fit :<
|
On February 01 2016 14:48 XenOmega wrote: Dropped this week Luck and Logic Phantasy Star
Total Dropped this season: Active Raid Ajin Divine Gate Luck And Logic Phantasy Star Online 2
Watching Boku dake Bubuki (close to being dropped?) Dimension W Gate Grimgar Schwarzesmarken
Still a VERY solid anime season. Two shows I am very eager to watch every week (Boku and Dimension W). The others are good filler.
I was curious : did any of you ever happened to have NOTHING to watch in a season because none of the series were to your liking? yes, last season if we ignore the ones that were carry-overs from the season before that or just s2 to something else.
|
On February 01 2016 19:45 Toadesstern wrote:Show nested quote +On February 01 2016 14:48 XenOmega wrote: Dropped this week Luck and Logic Phantasy Star
Total Dropped this season: Active Raid Ajin Divine Gate Luck And Logic Phantasy Star Online 2
Watching Boku dake Bubuki (close to being dropped?) Dimension W Gate Grimgar Schwarzesmarken
Still a VERY solid anime season. Two shows I am very eager to watch every week (Boku and Dimension W). The others are good filler.
I was curious : did any of you ever happened to have NOTHING to watch in a season because none of the series were to your liking? yes, last season if we ignore the ones that were carry-overs from the season before that or just s2 to something else.
But OPM
|
actually yeah, it had OPM and Owarimonogatari. So I retract, since that was the worst season ever for me, no it never happened
|
On February 01 2016 19:45 Toadesstern wrote:Show nested quote +On February 01 2016 14:48 XenOmega wrote: Dropped this week Luck and Logic Phantasy Star
Total Dropped this season: Active Raid Ajin Divine Gate Luck And Logic Phantasy Star Online 2
Watching Boku dake Bubuki (close to being dropped?) Dimension W Gate Grimgar Schwarzesmarken
Still a VERY solid anime season. Two shows I am very eager to watch every week (Boku and Dimension W). The others are good filler.
I was curious : did any of you ever happened to have NOTHING to watch in a season because none of the series were to your liking? yes, last season if we ignore the ones that were carry-overs from the season before that or just s2 to something else.
One Punch Man Owarimonogatari
and to a lesser extent Subete F
?
I thought most people appreciated at least one of those!
|
|
|
|
|
|