If you come in here looking for "anime recommendations" then please refer to this chart before posting: Anime Recommendations (as of may 2014). We also have an IRC channel called #tladt where we all hang out. The channel is on Rizon, not QuakeNet! Feel free to check it out. TLADT discord is Discord.gg

For currently airing anime, please see Anichart.net

Ecael

United States6703 Posts

May 29 2009 19:29 GMT

#81

On May 30 2009 04:27 fusionsdf wrote:
maybe it should cover this season's anime? If its all anime ever, it will be too big

Might as well as bump babo or Shauni's blog at that point then, those at least have reviews for new viewers to work with.

konadora

Singapore66356 Posts

May 29 2009 19:31 GMT

#82

It looks like the discussion can cover a wider field.. not just this season's animes. And definitely no bleach/naruto here.

King K. Rool

Canada4408 Posts

May 29 2009 19:34 GMT

#83

They kicked up on the comedy significantly with Clannad and Little Busters, Kanon is still closer to Air, unfortunately I still haven't heard of anything about LB being animated. On the other hand, the is Rewrite and that other one (gah I can't think it as anything else other than Haruhi ripoff character design), plenty of things to look forward to visual novel wise.

Was Clannad funny? I think I watched 1 or 2 eps and dropped it.

I loved it, but as you saw with the exchange between me and Tuna, my tastes might be skewed. The 4koma was excellent, and I can't wait till they start doing disappearance in haruhi-chan style.

School Days lol, that was some ending. I didn't watch it at all (though I know what has happened) and somehow got some friends to watch it without question. Lovely responses.

Didn't even know Haruhi-chan was a 4koma also. Just assumed they were trying to milk the franchise for money.

Got my friend to watch School Days too. I was like "Don't worry man, it gets so awesome", and the entire time he was watching he kept complaining how crap it was (he's not into that stuff either, and we share pretty similar tastes), but he appreciated the ending right after swearing at me haha.

Ziph

Netherlands970 Posts

May 29 2009 19:34 GMT

#84

On May 30 2009 04:31 konadora wrote:
It looks like the discussion can cover a wider field.. not just this season's animes. And definitely no bleach/naruto here.

Agreed, No One Piece either Please >.<

Chau

Canada408 Posts

May 29 2009 19:35 GMT

#85

So...discussion of all anime that doesn't have another thread for it, then? o.o

On a related note. Mio <3

-orb-

United States5770 Posts

May 29 2009 19:35 GMT

#86

That guitarist is amazing

Ziph

Netherlands970 Posts

May 29 2009 19:36 GMT

#87

On May 30 2009 04:34 King K. Rool wrote:

Show nested quote +

Was Clannad funny? I think I watched 1 or 2 eps and dropped it.

Clanned and Clannad~AS~ Are really Funny sometimes, also really baww ;_; be prepared lol you shouldn't watch it for the comedy I guess hehe.

Onii-Chan~ What should Mei do?

konadora

Singapore66356 Posts

May 29 2009 19:36 GMT

#88

Clannad was funny, Clannad After Story was more baaw than lulz.

Also, should we rename the thread to 'Anime Discussion Thread', where I specify in the OP 'no Bleach, One Piece or Naruto'?

MeriaDoKk

Chile1726 Posts

May 29 2009 19:38 GMT

#89

Oh god why =[, I really tried to watch this but after the frst episode I couldn't, Eden of the East and FMA:B are FOR ME the best show's this season

Even Sengoku Basara is better

konadora

Singapore66356 Posts

May 29 2009 19:39 GMT

#90

On May 30 2009 04:38 MeriaDoKk wrote:
Oh god why =[, I really tried to watch this but after the frst episode I couldn't, Eden of the East and FMA:B are FOR ME the best show's this season.

Eden of the East is good (yet to catch up on it though

) So is Phantom. FMA:B doesn't really interest me, maybe it's because I've read the manga already =.="

Ecael

United States6703 Posts

May 29 2009 19:39 GMT

#91

On May 30 2009 04:31 konadora wrote:
It looks like the discussion can cover a wider field.. not just this season's animes. And definitely no bleach/naruto here.

lol, yes, please, I don't really mind Bleach, but Naruto hurts.

On May 30 2009 04:34 King K. Rool wrote:

Show nested quote +

Was Clannad funny? I think I watched 1 or 2 eps and dropped it.

Show nested quote +

Yeah, Clannad tossed in way more comedic elements, watch on and see. It is closer to like 6:4 drama:comedy ratio. Little Buster might as well as have been 5:5 heh.

I don't know how Haruhi-chan got started (Churuya-san was doujin in origin, actually, excellent artist), but it probably was just another way to milk the franchise, albeit one that turned out to be excellent.

About the school days thing, I remember some very similar event happening with me and my friend, largely complaints about boredom for like the first 7 episode and streams of curses from then on. I need to toss more people Higurashi too, and Umineko when it airs, just to see reactions :p

EDIT - Ziph, no, don't link that, don't link that, I am going to have to rewatch and reread that portion of Clannad at this rate.

konadora

Singapore66356 Posts

May 29 2009 19:41 GMT

#92

I'm going to request for a thread name change to 'Anime Discussion Thread' with the 'No Naruto/Bleach/One Piece' rule. All okay with that?

Ecael

United States6703 Posts

May 29 2009 19:42 GMT

#93

On May 30 2009 04:41 konadora wrote:
I'm going to request for a thread name change to 'Anime Discussion Thread' with the 'No Naruto/Bleach/One Piece' rule. All okay with that?

I still think it is a bit too vague, but the general consensus seems to be heading that direction, so I have no complaints.

Ziph

Netherlands970 Posts

May 29 2009 19:43 GMT

#94

On May 30 2009 04:39 konadora wrote:

Show nested quote +

Eden of the East is good (yet to catch up on it though

) So is Phantom. FMA:B doesn't really interest me, maybe it's because I've read the manga already =.="

I Dropped -Eden of the East- after 2 episodes I might pick it up again, I really loved the OP meh~. -Phantom- is really good tho starts becoming better and better I guess I also really like -Sengoku BASARA-

I think FMA Is way worse then the original although the ED is Reallly good.

Chau

Canada408 Posts

May 29 2009 19:45 GMT

#95

So much hate for School Days...I actually loved it for being different than the usual harem anime... ^^

King K. Rool

Canada4408 Posts

May 29 2009 19:45 GMT

#96

On May 30 2009 04:41 konadora wrote:
I'm going to request for a thread name change to 'Anime Discussion Thread' with the 'No Naruto/Bleach/One Piece' rule. All okay with that?

I think its fine. I read the big 3 (and really enjoy OP), but each one either has too much trolling, or has been discussed to death everywhere else already.

As for Clannad, maybe I'll pick it up. Not really a fan of drama as you can see, but maybe I'll watch it for humor when I have time.

FMA:B is fine... I don't mind the comedic parts which breaks up the grimdark. I think its rushed, but it has to be since the first parts are exactly the same. I'm going to wait until more of it is out before really deciding if I want to drop it.

Anybody else watch Cross Game? I think it's the best anime of the season, first ep actually made me tear up slightly even though I've read the manga.

roronoe

Canada1527 Posts

May 29 2009 19:46 GMT

#97

azu-nyan deserves more votes