EPTalso i don't know if you believe me at that point, but i caught an amazing amount of references in lucky star for a westerner, but i still liked, say, azumanga's style of comedy better. hell, haruhi-chan was at least twice as strong for a 4koma adaptation.
Anime Discussion Thread - Page 4
| Forum Index > Media & Entertainment |
If you come in here looking for "anime recommendations" then please refer to this chart before posting: Anime Recommendations (as of may 2014). We also have an IRC channel called #tladt where we all hang out. The channel is on Rizon, not QuakeNet! Feel free to check it out. TLADT discord is Discord.gg For currently airing anime, please see Anichart.net | ||
|
SpiritoftheTunA
United States20903 Posts
also i don't know if you believe me at that point, but i caught an amazing amount of references in lucky star for a westerner, but i still liked, say, azumanga's style of comedy better. hell, haruhi-chan was at least twice as strong for a 4koma adaptation. | ||
|
konadora
Singapore66161 Posts
Luckily, K-ON! doesn't require any :3 | ||
|
King K. Rool
Canada4408 Posts
JC Staff is okay, though I think they butchered HnG's character designs. | ||
|
SpiritoftheTunA
United States20903 Posts
On May 30 2009 03:58 King K. Rool wrote: Other than Haruhi nothing else from KyoAni really interests me. Lucky Star was really popular (and still is), but I don't think K-ON is/will be. I think it's only a passing fad, since there's really nothing explosive this season (personally Cross Game is my favourite anime of the season, but I'm an Adachi fan), and it involves lots of moe, music, and basic humor so people like it. I don't find it that funny, and the cute was only good for the first 5 minutes before the main character's retardation starting pissing me off. JC Staff is okay, though I think they butchered HnG's character designs. no love for key/visualarts? edit: | ||
|
errol1001
454 Posts
On May 30 2009 03:17 MYM.Testie wrote: I'm a bit surprised you made a thread about a silly and shallow fluff anime like this. Yeah. I have no idea why this series is so popular. | ||
|
Ziph
Netherlands970 Posts
I don't why people like AIR so much tho I watched it twice and I think it was just plain boring (maybe i didn't get it ugh) >.< | ||
|
Ecael
United States6703 Posts
On May 30 2009 03:46 SpiritoftheTunA wrote: i read the book after the anime and the book honestly wasn't that much stronger to me? meh also i don't know if you believe me at that point, but i caught an amazing amount of references in lucky star for a westerner, but i still liked, say, azumanga's style of comedy better. hell, haruhi-chan was at least twice as strong for a 4koma adaptation. Probably just a matter of personal taste? I really enjoyed the FMP series as a light novel, to the point of everything else other than Fumoffu feeling subpar, heh. As for Lucky Star, you could've caught a ton of references and still not enjoyed it as much I suppose? The reaction I saw from Asians and Westerners in terms of reaction to Haruhi-chan and Lucky Star is quite different, the latter seems to be geared more towards Asians. On May 30 2009 03:57 konadora wrote: lucky star required so much additional background knowledge, even I had some trouble understand a few =.=" Luckily, K-ON! doesn't require any :3 I know, at some point I practically gave up watching raws, hoping for translator notes >< | ||
|
konadora
Singapore66161 Posts
| ||
|
King K. Rool
Canada4408 Posts
Not as much into drama TBH, and key/visualarts stuff is all pretty drama/romance heavy and had little humour (from at least what I watched). School Days was probably the only drama-heavy anime I watched, if only for the WTF ending. edit: I think renaming the thread is a good idea. It's nice to have anime discussion without trolls for once. | ||
|
Ecael
United States6703 Posts
On May 30 2009 04:11 konadora wrote: Any suggest that we rename this thread to KyoAni thread so that we can get more discussions going without the possibility of this thread being closed due to being off-topic? I'm not complaining or anything, I'm happy to be discussing something like this so nicely :D That'd be way too vague wouldn't it? The only saving grace would be that Haruhi and k-on are separated atm, but even then we risk having way too much here at once. Just from this season we'll be like talking about Munto, Haruhi, Haruhi-chan, and k-on. On May 30 2009 04:11 King K. Rool wrote: Not as much into drama TBH, and key/visualarts stuff is all pretty drama/romance heavy and had little humour (from at least what I watched). School Days was probably the only drama-heavy anime I watched, if only for the WTF ending. edit: I think renaming the thread is a good idea. It's nice to have anime discussion without trolls for once. They kicked up on the comedy significantly with Clannad and Little Busters, Kanon is still closer to Air, unfortunately I still haven't heard of anything about LB being animated. On the other hand, the is Rewrite and that other one (gah I can't think it as anything else other than Haruhi ripoff character design), plenty of things to look forward to visual novel wise. | ||
|
Ziph
Netherlands970 Posts
On May 30 2009 04:11 King K. Rool wrote: Not as much into drama TBH, and key/visualarts stuff is all pretty drama/romance heavy and had little humour (or at least what I watched). School Days was probably the only drama-heavy anime I watched, if only for the WTF ending. WUT?! School Day's ............................. Seriously if you watched that then pretty much any anime should meet your minimum requirements holy shit School Days was so fucking ()facepalm() bad. BTW: I really liked Munto TV from last season really much I hope someday it gets continued does anyone know whats going on with this series ? | ||
|
King K. Rool
Canada4408 Posts
edit: WUT?! School Day's ............................. Seriously if you watched that then pretty much any anime should meet your minimum requirements holy shit School Days was so fucking ()facepalm() bad. Hahaha. I "watched" most of the first 10 or so episodes while playing on my PS2. I didn't enjoy it at all other than the ending, which was one of the most spectacular things I've seen. | ||
|
Syxygy
558 Posts
 I said it in the other thread but BECK (the manga, at least) is way better~ | ||
|
konadora
Singapore66161 Posts
On May 30 2009 04:13 Ecael wrote: That'd be way too vague wouldn't it? The only saving grace would be that Haruhi and k-on are separated atm, but even then we risk having way too much here at once. Just from this season we'll be like talking about Munto, Haruhi, Haruhi-chan, and k-on. I'm pretty sure nobody will derail any on-going discussion that badly. If we're talking about KyoAni then it'll last for a few pages, then slowly maybe another, like Key or something. | ||
|
da_head
Canada3350 Posts
| ||
|
Ecael
United States6703 Posts
On May 30 2009 04:14 Ziph wrote: WUT?! School Day's ............................. Seriously if you watched that then pretty much any anime should meet your minimum requirements holy shit School Days was so fucking ()facepalm() bad. BTW: I really liked Munto TV from last season really much I hope someday it gets continued does anyone know whats going on with this series ? Theatrical version just showed I think, I keep on seeing character songs popping around. On May 30 2009 04:14 King K. Rool wrote: Is Haruhi-chan worth watching? I saw one with cooking and it was meh-tacular. Only Nagato+porn was funny. edit: Hahaha. I "watched" most of the first 10 or so episodes while playing on my PS2. I didn't enjoy it at all other than the ending, which was one of the most spectacular things I've seen. I loved it, but as you saw with the exchange between me and Tuna, my tastes might be skewed. The 4koma was excellent, and I can't wait till they start doing disappearance in haruhi-chan style. School Days lol, that was some ending. I didn't watch it at all (though I know what has happened) and somehow got some friends to watch it without question. Lovely responses. | ||
|
konadora
Singapore66161 Posts
On May 30 2009 04:14 Ziph wrote: WUT?! School Day's ............................. Seriously if you watched that then pretty much any anime should meet your minimum requirements holy shit School Days was so fucking ()facepalm() bad. BTW: I really liked Munto TV from last season really much I hope someday it gets continued does anyone know whats going on with this series ? School Days was kind of okay since it was rather refreshing (with the main character dying, the female protagonists going totally different directions, rage against Makoto, etc) | ||
|
konadora
Singapore66161 Posts
Poll: What should this thread be renamed into? (Vote): The anime discussion thread (Vote): KyoAni thread (Vote): Non-shounen anime discussion thread (Vote): Still K-ON! thread (Vote): Others (suggest in post) | ||
|
fusionsdf
Canada15390 Posts
| ||
|
Malongo
Chile3472 Posts
| ||
| ||
