|
If you come in here looking for "anime recommendations" then please refer to this chart before posting: Anime Recommendations (as of may 2014). We also have an IRC channel called #tladt where we all hang out. The channel is on Rizon, not QuakeNet! Feel free to check it out. TLADT discord is Discord.ggFor currently airing anime, please see Anichart.net |
I wish I did this when I read through Umineko the first time. Compiling my thoughts as I went would have helped. I also made a big mistake of pausing to read Little Busters inbetween ep4 and ep5, which resulted in me forgetting a lot of stuff from the first 4 eps. I eventually figured it out in Episode 6, but its possible to do by ep4 if you pay real close attention.
Also, Shana=Shannon?
And this isn't really a spoiler, but the only servants allowed to wear the family crest are servants who work under Kinzo, the family head. So a servant hired by one of the other family members wouldn't be permitted to wear it.
As an aside, are you reading the original version, or the PS3 patched version?
|
On August 12 2014 01:54 Ryuhou)aS( wrote:YESSSS how could i forget Magi!!!!!! thats a good one. I only had one problem with it + Show Spoiler + in the end of the 1st season it felt like it got really bogged down in the whole "trying to save my childhood friend/city" thing. I get why they did it, and it's importance to the storyline(at the time). It's just, they make it feel like it's a huge deal saving this country then they immediately completely forget about the country and never go back (sure they make mention of it at times...like when morgana ran into ali`baba's older brothers). I donno, i feel like they spent way to much time on a mediocre storyline and it pulled the rest of the show down a bit.
Agree to some extent, but that's why S2 > S1. + Show Spoiler +I also really liked how they conveyed how the head of the magic school became the way he did.
On August 12 2014 05:54 Tabbris wrote:Show nested quote +On August 12 2014 03:31 ragz_gt wrote:
magi manga is infinitely worse than FMA... To be fair FMA is hard to beat. I considered it my favorite completed manga(opinion). I didn't mean to say magi was near that good but its enjoyable and think its similar in style to FMA.
Agree FMA is my favourite as well & think it is the best over all. Think it should be literally the first anime/manga anyone recommends to anyone skeptical of anime/manga as it can be appreciated by everyone.
But from reading Magi the story, characters, and world is done in a much more convincing manner than most other manga I've read. + Show Spoiler +I wasn't remotely bored listening to the history of it all and am actually genuinely interested to see where it goes from here. To the point where I think it could be one of the best mangas of all time if it continues down this path. However with the massive inflation of power levels where people are starting to throw nukes around it may go down a path of shit instead. But I have some faith in the author! Hmm this isn't really a spoiler. ;o
|
On August 12 2014 06:26 Sentenal wrote:I wish I did this when I read through Umineko the first time. Compiling my thoughts as I went would have helped. I also made a big mistake of pausing to read Little Busters inbetween ep4 and ep5, which resulted in me forgetting a lot of stuff from the first 4 eps. I eventually figured it out in Episode 6, but its possible to do by ep4 if you pay real close attention. Also, Shana=Shannon? And this isn't really a spoiler, but the only servants allowed to wear the family crest are servants who work under Kinzo, the family head. So a servant hired by one of the other family members wouldn't be permitted to wear it. As an aside, are you reading the original version, or the PS3 patched version?
I'm playing the ps3 patched version. Is there a difference that I should know about? The game is confusing so far and I'm not sure whats real and what is fake. I'm guessing that things I'm reading isn't completely true because+ Show Spoiler + I read the first manga of Higurashi and came to the conclusion that the MC maybe wasn't seeing what was actually happening on my own which someone told me was correct the faces of the victims missing for some reason
Also I just got to the rule of red. Is this something in general that I can reliably count on?
|
On August 12 2014 06:39 SK.Testie wrote:Show nested quote +On August 12 2014 01:54 Ryuhou)aS( wrote:YESSSS how could i forget Magi!!!!!! thats a good one. I only had one problem with it + Show Spoiler + in the end of the 1st season it felt like it got really bogged down in the whole "trying to save my childhood friend/city" thing. I get why they did it, and it's importance to the storyline(at the time). It's just, they make it feel like it's a huge deal saving this country then they immediately completely forget about the country and never go back (sure they make mention of it at times...like when morgana ran into ali`baba's older brothers). I donno, i feel like they spent way to much time on a mediocre storyline and it pulled the rest of the show down a bit. Agree to some extent, but that's why S2 > S1. + Show Spoiler +I also really liked how they conveyed how the head of the magic school became the way he did. Show nested quote +On August 12 2014 05:54 Tabbris wrote:On August 12 2014 03:31 ragz_gt wrote:
magi manga is infinitely worse than FMA... To be fair FMA is hard to beat. I considered it my favorite completed manga(opinion). I didn't mean to say magi was near that good but its enjoyable and think its similar in style to FMA. Agree FMA is my favourite as well & think it is the best over all. Think it should be literally the first anime/manga anyone recommends to anyone skeptical of anime/manga as it can be appreciated by everyone. But from reading Magi the story, characters, and world is done in a much more convincing manner than most other manga I've read. + Show Spoiler +I wasn't remotely bored listening to the history of it all and am actually genuinely interested to see where it goes from here. To the point where I think it could be one of the best mangas of all time if it continues down this path. However with the massive inflation of power levels where people are starting to throw nukes around it may go down a path of shit instead. But I have some faith in the author! Hmm this isn't really a spoiler. ;o .
The thing about magi which I reallly like about it is the characters. They feel interesting and complex which stands out from alot of similar mangas of the genre. The characters have thier own agenda and act in the grey at times. But I agreed the power ups are getting a bit worrisome but we will see.
|
On August 12 2014 07:16 Tabbris wrote:Show nested quote +On August 12 2014 06:26 Sentenal wrote:I wish I did this when I read through Umineko the first time. Compiling my thoughts as I went would have helped. I also made a big mistake of pausing to read Little Busters inbetween ep4 and ep5, which resulted in me forgetting a lot of stuff from the first 4 eps. I eventually figured it out in Episode 6, but its possible to do by ep4 if you pay real close attention. Also, Shana=Shannon? And this isn't really a spoiler, but the only servants allowed to wear the family crest are servants who work under Kinzo, the family head. So a servant hired by one of the other family members wouldn't be permitted to wear it. As an aside, are you reading the original version, or the PS3 patched version? I'm playing the ps3 patched version. Is there a difference that I should know about? The game is confusing so far and I'm not sure whats real and what is fake. I'm guessing that things I'm reading isn't completely true because + Show Spoiler + I read the first manga of Higurashi and came to the conclusion that the MC maybe wasn't seeing what was actually happening on my own which someone told me was correct . I only read the first 3 volumes of Higurashi so I never finished it but Im a little familiar with the authors style from that. I'm having little luck however with Umineko. Whenever I think i got something figured out it just fucks with you like + Show Spoiler +the faces of the victims missing for some reason . although reading this vn gives me a headache its honestly pretty awesome that a vn is making me actively think lol. Also I just got to the rule of red. Is this something in general that I can reliably count on?
Other than art/voices, no actual differences. Ecael and I are somewhat purist in that we liked the original version more, so was just curious as to which you are reading.
As opposed to Higurashi, Umineko actually attempts to follow the rules of mysteries. If you are on episode 2, thats the chapter were the author just lays you down and fucks you. Come episode 3 and 4, you get a better idea of how to approach it. There are some more things I could say about how to approach the mystery, but I think a lot of the fun is to figure it out yourself, so I won't comment on much more.
As far as the Red Truth goes, it is pretty much the only thing you can trust as 100% true. huehue I'm so clever.
|
Netherlands45349 Posts
Next season looking p good so far
GBF 2
PP2(moe police hanakana)
FSN with my favourite route
Log Horizon 2
Dat weird ass Sunrise Mecha show with Nana Mizuki
looking p nice.
|
|
|
On August 12 2014 09:44 Kipsate wrote:
Next season looking p good so far
GBF 2
PP2(moe police hanakana)
FSN with my favourite route
Log Horizon 2
Dat weird ass Sunrise Mecha show with Nana Mizuki
looking p nice.
There are a lot of shows, like 7 I am interested in watching during the fall season.
So Working!! S3 was announced what about SxS? Do they have enough material for another season?
|
|
|
On August 12 2014 09:44 Kipsate wrote:
Next season looking p good so far
GBF 2
PP2(moe police hanakana)
FSN with my favourite route
Log Horizon 2
Dat weird ass Sunrise Mecha show with Nana Mizuki
looking p nice.
i think i have like 9 shows already and the full list for fall isn't even out yet. : (
|
On August 12 2014 10:53 Emnjay808 wrote:
Log Horizon S2
AOTY
Fall is going to be stackeddddddddddddddddd
Hoping for FSN or PP2 for AOTY 
|
On August 12 2014 05:48 Miscellany wrote:
Why did I think it was a good idea to open those akame spoilers T.T
well the ones i opened i was thinking they were discussion of the previous episode and not talking about the future of the anime based on having read the manga. Oh well, I'll just have to be more careful
On August 12 2014 06:39 SK.Testie wrote:But from reading Magi the story, characters, and world is done in a much more convincing manner than most other manga I've read. + Show Spoiler +I wasn't remotely bored listening to the history of it all and am actually genuinely interested to see where it goes from here. To the point where I think it could be one of the best mangas of all time if it continues down this path. However with the massive inflation of power levels where people are starting to throw nukes around it may go down a path of shit instead. But I have some faith in the author! Hmm this isn't really a spoiler. ;o .
Well I'm not into reading manga, so i donno where it's at now...but to be honest at the end of S2 the powerups were already ridiculous. So of course it's gonna get real bad...they really had nowhere to go from where. I also enjoy the characters though, they have great personalities that mix and mash really well. To be frank, the best part is the setting/world it's in. I freaking love it. I just wish there was a lot more dungeons and shit like that...they really made me think that was the focus of it, but then they only show like 1 or 2 dungeons
|
Canada8036 Posts
Aldnoah - It's ok. The MC is pretty boring. I don't really care for any of the cast, in fact. While the show itself is not particularly bad, I don't look forward to it at all. Also, why is the entire Martian side composed of idiots? They can't even prevent some random guy from stealing a ship. It also seems a bit odd how impractical all the Martian mechs are.
Argevollen - The main duo are still annoying. Would it kill them to focus more on the side characters?
Nozaki - Pretty decent. Depends on the skit though.
Barakamon - See above.
Rokujouma - As expected, the drama is awful.
Yama no Susume s2 - I maintain that 10 minute eps is too long.
Zankyou - For such a pretty show, it's almost criminal how boring the plot has been thus far. Hopefully this new character will mix it up a bit. Also, Lisa a shit.
Fate/Kaleid - Still waiting on based shota. Kuro's doing a great job carrying though.
|
Girls und Panzer was everything I could have hoped for in a cute girls in tanks anime
|
Seirei Tsukai no Blade Dance is like this season's dragonar academy but with a bit less ecchi, better girls, better mc, and better setting/plot. Probably the anime that is the biggest surprise because my expectations were so low for it.
|
On August 12 2014 15:45 Slaughter wrote:
Seirei Tsukai no Blade Dance is like this season's dragonar academy but with a bit less ecchi, better girls, better mc, and better setting/plot. Probably the anime that is the biggest surprise because my expectations were so low for it.
i think it's going alright. i have trouble liking any of the girls though so it's hard + Show Spoiler +
I'm really interested in seeing how OP the MC can get, and his connection with this Ashbell (thats the name right?) character.
|
Just read the Tsukihime manga while waiting for Paradox Spiral to finish downloading.
Nasu pls Biblethump. My feels gland weren't ready for this after finishing Anohana
|
oh Kara no Kyōkai, garden of sinners, hows the anime??? i heard that it is pretty bloody/brutal which is what i like, but the torr*nt seeding can be daunting (which is why i didnt get to watch it).
|
On August 12 2014 17:01 BurningSera wrote:
oh Kara no Kyōkai, garden of sinners, hows the anime??? i heard that it is pretty bloody/brutal which is what i like, but the torr*nt seeding can be daunting (which is why i didnt get to watch it).
All of the movies are pretty good (some less than others but yeah). Worth watching just for the animation/music alone and some of the fights are pretty epic.
|
Like most of Type-Moon's other works (IMO so far). If you generally like the pacing and writing style of Nasu (Fate/Zero doesn't count. Urobutcher wrote it), you'll like KnK. The series is fucking massive though, 720p is 26gb for 8 movies.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
