On June 05 2013 22:54 Indolent wrote: I'm also confused, but I have to say - damn nice Kubo! This is 2nd time I was really surprised in this manga in this year (1st time was Unohana Kenpachi) - Zangetsu is the form of young Bach? I don't really see the implications of it, but still, I like the feeling of some deeper thinking in here.
I like bleach, but "deeper thinking" and bleach?? Cmon lol
There are a lot of hints about this and about Hollow Ichigo being his real Zanpakutou, not fake-Zangetsu. Also, check this out. Remember Tensa and Hichigo fusing? And Opie using Sklaverei? They're so oddly simillar. And all of the Hollow's claims of being Zangetsu repeatedly to Ichigo, who didn't believe it... Even if it was shoehorned in, it was done nicely.
Bleach in my opinion is good cause of the well done action, and some epic characters. Hints or foreshadowing is probably the weakest point bleach has. While you seem to be right with the hints about zangetsu, one or two not so creative hints really doesnt make bleach "deep" at all.
Take Zaraki for example, one of the most badass characters, looked like a complete plothax stomped, unexplainable power up bob for most of the series, till it gets finally explained why he can loose vs trash and win vs strong people. No foreshadowing, no hints, it straight up looked like plothax of doom. The actual explanation makes only half sense as well and isnt good either, cause it makes his eyepatch completly obsolete. Story really isnt deep in any way in bleach. Its still enjoyable tho, just not deep.
Okay, so i think i somewhat understand whats going on. -Zangestu is the white hollow, that is its true form -Ichigo perceives Zangestu as Bach from 1000 years ago unknowingly because of his subconscious quincy powers So in essence, the old man never really existed, it had always been whitey. If we were to carefully go back and reread alot of this stuff, it actually makes sense (e.g. + Show Spoiler +
Guys stop bashing the manga without even trying to figure out whats happening and calling BS. There's a thin line between the obligation for the author to explain whats going on, and for the reader to figure out whats going on.
There is also a fine line between subtle plot crafting and complete trolling of your readers ;D And we all know on which side of this line Kubo generally is. If I wanted to exaggerate a bit, I would claim that he writes so randomly that sometimes it happens to make sense and seem like good plot design. But I still want to believe, this "Old man Zangetsu = Bach" seems like it actually could have been planned from the beginning indeed.
If so that would means that Ichigo essentially fights without zanpakuto from the beginning right? Would he keep the same bankai after discovering his true zanpakuto? If the true zanpakuto's powers are completely different, it could mean that Ichigo becomes like 10 times stronger. Which is what we want, obviously ;D
On June 06 2013 01:52 ZenithM wrote: But I still want to believe, this "Old man Zangetsu = Bach" seems like it actually could have been planned from the beginning indeed.
If so that would means that Ichigo essentially fights without zanpakuto from the beginning right? Would he keep the same bankai after discovering his true zanpakuto? If the true zanpakuto's powers are completely different, it could mean that Ichigo becomes like 10 times stronger. Which is what we want, obviously ;D
This seemed to makes sense to me at first too, especially considering the Sword smith dude said he makes all swords, and after redoing Ichigos it wouldnt be same. So that would add up with this theory.
What doesnt add up is that Ichigos only sword move ever is the same as his dads, which wouldnt make any sense unless his Sword came from his Shinigami powers. That however would eliminate both Bach and the Hollow as the potential old swords power source. Kubo for ya :D
On June 06 2013 01:39 Icysoul wrote: Okay, so i think i somewhat understand whats going on. -Zangestu is the white hollow, that is its true form -Ichigo perceives Zangestu as Bach from 1000 years ago unknowingly because of his subconscious quincy powers So in essence, the old man never really existed, it had always been whitey. If we were to carefully go back and reread alot of this stuff, it actually makes sense (e.g. + Show Spoiler +
Guys stop bashing the manga without even trying to figure out whats happening and calling BS. There's a thin line between the obligation for the author to explain whats going on, and for the reader to figure out whats going on.
except at that point he was only saying he was Zangetsu because he had gotten so strong at that point he had completely consumed Zangetsu
the kid introduced himself as Tensa Zangetsu then pulls the Hollow out from inside Ichigo its obvious that Zangetsu is his real Zanpaktou and the Hollow is also in there next to him but seperate
also if Zangetsu is not the old man, then why did the old man apear when Ichigo was training to learn Bankai?
On June 06 2013 01:52 ZenithM wrote: But I still want to believe, this "Old man Zangetsu = Bach" seems like it actually could have been planned from the beginning indeed.
If so that would means that Ichigo essentially fights without zanpakuto from the beginning right? Would he keep the same bankai after discovering his true zanpakuto? If the true zanpakuto's powers are completely different, it could mean that Ichigo becomes like 10 times stronger. Which is what we want, obviously ;D
This seemed to makes sense to me at first too, especially considering the Sword smith dude said he makes all swords, and after redoing Ichigos it wouldnt be same. So that would add up with this theory.
What doesnt add up is that Ichigos only sword move ever is the same as his dads, which wouldnt make any sense unless his Sword came from his Shinigami powers. That however would eliminate both Bach and the Hollow as the potential old swords power source. Kubo for ya :D
Not exactly. We still don't know Bach's influence on his powers. Maybe it was only repressing his shinigami/hollow side but still replicating them. This actually fits in quite nicely, allowing him to use the powers he has.
On June 05 2013 21:20 PVJ wrote: I am not sure if I understood this right. Maybe it's just the translation but I've read it 2 times to try and get it.
- Zangetsu is a timewarped Bach - Zangetsu(=timewarped Bach) is his Zanpakuto - his inner devil is a hollow - his inner devil(=hollow) is his new(?) Zanpakuto
?
From how I understood it, this is what's going on:
- What Ichigo percieves as Zangetsu are his quincy powers masquerading as his Zanpakuto (i.e. his "fake Zanpakuto"), in the form of what Bach looked like 1000 years ago. - That which is his inner hollow is actually his true Zanpakuto, which is explained away with "seems Aizen oddly made that hollow kinda the same way that I myself make my swords". Such a lucky coincidence!
I like this explanation best, from the last 3 pages.
On June 05 2013 21:20 PVJ wrote: I am not sure if I understood this right. Maybe it's just the translation but I've read it 2 times to try and get it.
- Zangetsu is a timewarped Bach - Zangetsu(=timewarped Bach) is his Zanpakuto - his inner devil is a hollow - his inner devil(=hollow) is his new(?) Zanpakuto
?
From how I understood it, this is what's going on:
- What Ichigo percieves as Zangetsu are his quincy powers masquerading as his Zanpakuto (i.e. his "fake Zanpakuto"), in the form of what Bach looked like 1000 years ago. - That which is his inner hollow is actually his true Zanpakuto, which is explained away with "seems Aizen oddly made that hollow kinda the same way that I myself make my swords". Such a lucky coincidence!
I like this explanation best, from the last 3 pages.
That doesnt explain how his Swords powers are nearly identical with his dads, who is 100% Shinigami. And if it would be true, and his Hollow powers are his sword, it doesnt explain why he can go different hollow modes on top of the sword.
On June 06 2013 01:52 ZenithM wrote: But I still want to believe, this "Old man Zangetsu = Bach" seems like it actually could have been planned from the beginning indeed.
If so that would means that Ichigo essentially fights without zanpakuto from the beginning right? Would he keep the same bankai after discovering his true zanpakuto? If the true zanpakuto's powers are completely different, it could mean that Ichigo becomes like 10 times stronger. Which is what we want, obviously ;D
This seemed to makes sense to me at first too, especially considering the Sword smith dude said he makes all swords, and after redoing Ichigos it wouldnt be same. So that would add up with this theory.
What doesnt add up is that Ichigos only sword move ever is the same as his dads, which wouldnt make any sense unless his Sword came from his Shinigami powers. That however would eliminate both Bach and the Hollow as the potential old swords power source. Kubo for ya :D
Not exactly. We still don't know Bach's influence on his powers. Maybe it was only repressing his shinigami/hollow side but still replicating them. This actually fits in quite nicely, allowing him to use the powers he has.
Thats really far fetched man. Quincies cant use Shinigami Powers, so according to your theory, his Quincy part, that he doesnt know about replicated his Shinigami powers, which he doesnt even know about either? Also coincidently its the same as his dads, which we dont even know if Bachs previously saw? Also Isshin has an actual zanpak...(who can spell that), so if your theory would be correct then in Ichigos case his "Sword" would just be a replica of his Shinigami powers, not an actual Sword. Isshin however has a real sword, which has the same abilities. 2 different things with the exact same ability and Isshin being able to teach it ? Naaah. And on top of that, shikai, bankai and final getsuga have all been taught to him by shinigamis. And why would it opress his powers to replicate them? Thats just the same thing as using the powers? Only more effort.
That doesnt explain how his Swords powers are nearly identical with his dads, who is 100% Shinigami. And if it would be true, and his Hollow powers are his sword, it doesnt explain why he can go different hollow modes on top of the sword.
his ability would be similar to his dads regardless since the ability is based on the person
its pretty obvious that Kubo made all this up this arc though theres too many inconsistancies for it to be real
That doesnt explain how his Swords powers are nearly identical with his dads, who is 100% Shinigami. And if it would be true, and his Hollow powers are his sword, it doesnt explain why he can go different hollow modes on top of the sword.
his ability would be similar to his dads regardless since the ability is based on the person
its pretty obvious that Kubo made all this up this arc though theres too many inconsistancies for it to be real
Yeh i think so too, both the Quincy and the arc with those other weird dudes seem like a different manga tbh.
The sword smith however said his sword would definetly be different when reforged, so that wouldnt add up with being based on the person.
Thats the thing with Bleach, you always think of a new way how it could make sense, but then you find another hole
On April 18 2012 23:11 Latham wrote: Yay invasion plans. Anyone else think that the leader of Nazi quincies looks a bit like Zangetsu?
From last year
I am a God. Hail me.
On June 05 2013 21:35 sumsaR wrote:
On June 05 2013 21:20 PVJ wrote: I am not sure if I understood this right. Maybe it's just the translation but I've read it 2 times to try and get it.
- Zangetsu is a timewarped Bach - Zangetsu(=timewarped Bach) is his Zanpakuto - his inner devil is a hollow - his inner devil(=hollow) is his new(?) Zanpakuto
?
From how I understood it, this is what's going on:
- What Ichigo percieves as Zangetsu are his quincy powers masquerading as his Zanpakuto (i.e. his "fake Zanpakuto"), in the form of what Bach looked like 1000 years ago. - That which is his inner hollow is actually his true Zanpakuto, which is explained away with "seems Aizen oddly made that hollow kinda the same way that I myself make my swords". Such a lucky coincidence!
I like this explanation best, from the last 3 pages.
That doesnt explain how his Swords powers are nearly identical with his dads, who is 100% Shinigami. And if it would be true, and his Hollow powers are his sword, it doesnt explain why he can go different hollow modes on top of the sword.
Having thought about this more, while it seems like a nice twist it actually completely shits on everything that we have ever learnt about Shinigami and Zanpaktou. It really makes no sense how Zangetsu can be his quincy powers (or whatever) and allow him to use the same techniques as his father yet his actually Zanpaktou is a crazy hollow that likes to take control and rape shit whenever Ichigo should die. Even more I know that the whole rareity of Bankai has been shit on hard but doesnt this make it even more sketchy that he could acquire bankai without having a true Zanpaktou? I confused....
On June 06 2013 01:39 Icysoul wrote: Okay, so i think i somewhat understand whats going on. -Zangestu is the white hollow, that is its true form -Ichigo perceives Zangestu as Bach from 1000 years ago unknowingly because of his subconscious quincy powers So in essence, the old man never really existed, it had always been whitey. If we were to carefully go back and reread alot of this stuff, it actually makes sense (e.g. + Show Spoiler +
Guys stop bashing the manga without even trying to figure out whats happening and calling BS. There's a thin line between the obligation for the author to explain whats going on, and for the reader to figure out whats going on.
except at that point he was only saying he was Zangetsu because he had gotten so strong at that point he had completely consumed Zangetsu
the kid introduced himself as Tensa Zangetsu then pulls the Hollow out from inside Ichigo its obvious that Zangetsu is his real Zanpaktou and the Hollow is also in there next to him but seperate
also if Zangetsu is not the old man, then why did the old man apear when Ichigo was training to learn Bankai?
If we take a very literal look at his zanpakutou now and what we've seen so far, then any representation of the hollow side of Ichigo has been a farce as well. The mask doesn't have any of the same markings or even the same shape. I would guess that all of his powers have been some level of deceit, hiding his true power from him through misdirection.
On June 06 2013 03:14 shark. wrote: Having thought about this more, while it seems like a nice twist it actually completely shits on everything that we have ever learnt about Shinigami and Zanpaktou. It really makes no sense how Zangetsu can be his quincy powers (or whatever) and allow him to use the same techniques as his father yet his actually Zanpaktou is a crazy hollow that likes to take control and rape shit whenever Ichigo should die. Even more I know that the whole rareity of Bankai has been shit on hard but doesnt this make it even more sketchy that he could acquire bankai without having a true Zanpaktou? I confused....
We actually know quite a bit about zanpakutou from other shinigami and their explanations/training. A lot of people complained about Ichigos being incredibly shallow in comparison to everybody else's, so his not being a "real" one would add up, in some sense.
I may be reading this wrong, but it looks like zanpakutou actually come from the souls of hollows (or maybe just souls in general?). They are forged, and then their master's soul is imprinted on them.
The whole concept of an individual misdirecting and deceiving himself about his own powers again and again is beyond stupid lol :D
On June 06 2013 03:17 aksfjh wrote: We actually know quite a bit about zanpakutou from other shinigami and their explanations/training. A lot of people complained about Ichigos being incredibly shallow in comparison to everybody else's, so his not being a "real" one would add up, in some sense.
That would make his Dads sword, which is real, just as shallow, so that doesnt seem likely.
On June 06 2013 03:37 freewareplayer wrote: The whole concept of an individual misdirecting and deceiving himself about his own powers again and again is beyond stupid lol :D
On June 06 2013 03:17 aksfjh wrote: We actually know quite a bit about zanpakutou from other shinigami and their explanations/training. A lot of people complained about Ichigos being incredibly shallow in comparison to everybody else's, so his not being a "real" one would add up, in some sense.
That would make his Dads sword, which is real, just as shallow, so that doesnt seem likely.
By all means, list Isshin's sword abilities and when we've seen him in earnest combat (like the other captains and lieutenants). I must have missed those chapters... -_-