EPT Theon logic is very similar to Baratheon logic, presumably because you can’t spell the latter without the former.
brilliant
[TV] HBO Game of Thrones - Page 1423
| Forum Index > Media & Entertainment |
All book discussion in this thread is now allowed. | ||
|
Cambium
United States16368 Posts
brilliant | ||
|
Garuga
49 Posts
Also, once the other members realized that the undead army wasn't to be fucked with, wouldn't they have realized Jon was right about needing every single body to fend them off (after what happened in episode 8), thus justifying the actions that Jon took? If Jon had deserted to Jon Stannis or something (an offense actually punishable by death) then it would make sense for him to be a 'traitor," but he was voted Lord Commander, used his discretion within his power, had support for his decisions, and a complete rational basis for having the wildlings south of the wall (to fend off the ice fuckers). Will every Lord Commander of the watch now be killed because some cry-baby kid doesn't like a hard decision that had to be made? What happens if Jon lets the wildlings die and they get overrun by zombies due to lack of troops: does this justify killing him for "betraying" the watch by not protecting them properly? The show just did not justify this death in my opinion; the only justification I see is that they didn't like his decision, yet they went along with it, helped him, and I think episode 8 really showed he was right all along, and his death just felt like it was an attempt to bring about emotion that wasn't really warranted. | ||
|
Shock710
Australia6097 Posts
| ||
|
shin_toss
Philippines2589 Posts
On June 16 2015 10:13 FiWiFaKi wrote: ![[image loading]](http://i.imgur.com/Sr30ote.png) LOL, 10-20 foot wall my ass. In that picture, it's not even the bottom, it's at least 40 feet... Maybe as high as 60. 45-50 feet is my best estimate... In most situations, you'd seriously injure yourself. That snow really has to be quite perfect, and you need to land quite well to get up unscathed. If the snow is right, they should survive though. There you go. 255m.. so it doesnt really matter if its 40 or 41 ft. | ||
|
FiWiFaKi
Canada9859 Posts
On June 16 2015 11:43 shin_toss wrote: There you go. 255m.. so it doesnt really matter if its 40 or 41 ft. 255ft not meters... But anyway, I hope you can recognize the difference. This video is the most ideal conditions possible, and it's a WORLD RECORD. People have survived air plane crashes, but it's not likely. And if you'd like some math: At a fall from 20 meters, so a little bit over 60 feet... If you neglect air resistance, since it's a relatively slow height, you'll hit the ground at 71km/h Meanwhile, if you fall from an airplane, you'll hit the ground at roughly 200km/h... So as you can see, even though the height gets a lot higher, the speed does not increase, and therefore the impulse is not that much higher, hence the G's experienced are only a fraction higher for a speed that's significantly higher. More important is that the snow has the perfect characteristics and perfect depth. Yes, if you scouted it before to make sure the snow is deep enough, right density, and you knew how to fall, then there's a good chance you would sustain minimal injury. However, if we're talking real world, with the conditions shown, it's very likely you'd suffer serious injuries. We all know that she and reek will be fine though. | ||
|
GreenHorizons
United States24142 Posts
On June 16 2015 13:50 FiWiFaKi wrote: 255ft not meters... But anyway, I hope you can recognize the difference. This video is the most ideal conditions possible, and it's a WORLD RECORD. People have survived air plane crashes, but it's not likely. And if you'd like some math: At a fall from 20 meters, so a little bit over 60 feet... If you neglect air resistance, since it's a relatively slow height, you'll hit the ground at 71km/h Meanwhile, if you fall from an airplane, you'll hit the ground at roughly 200km/h... So as you can see, even though the height gets a lot higher, the speed does not increase, and therefore the impulse is not that much higher, hence the G's experienced are only a fraction higher for a speed that's significantly higher. More important is that the snow has the perfect characteristics and perfect depth. Yes, if you scouted it before to make sure the snow is deep enough, right density, and you knew how to fall, then there's a good chance you would sustain minimal injury. However, if we're talking real world, with the conditions shown, it's very likely you'd suffer serious injuries. We all know that she and reek will be fine though. My guess is reek knows they've been pushing the loose snow from the battlements outside the wall. Should be deeper there than anywhere else though the recent thawing would probably make it have a hard ice crust. A bunch of pow pow would be better but they shouldn't end up with much more than a limp. | ||
|
Necro)Phagist(
Canada6660 Posts
On June 16 2015 10:13 FiWiFaKi wrote: LOL, 10-20 foot wall my ass. In that picture, it's not even the bottom, it's at least 40 feet... Maybe as high as 60. 45-50 feet is my best estimate... In most situations, you'd seriously injure yourself. That snow really has to be quite perfect, and you need to land quite well to get up unscathed. If the snow is right, they should survive though. On June 16 2015 13:57 GreenHorizons wrote: Snow is perfect: [X] Landed quite well: [X] Getting up unscathed: [✓] Fall 4x the height [✓] Sansa and Theon are fine. I'd be surprised if either of them sustained any serious injury. | ||
|
Shock710
Australia6097 Posts
I also came across some random dudes questions, regarding the loose ends theres no book talk. First is botherhood of banners like everyone already is talking about but then he goes on to mention a couple of ends i completely forgot about like rickon and the tonks lady and then "Mysterious Qarth Woman in a Mask" - "Maybe this is just a pet curiosity of mine, but who is this mysterious woman, and why does she seem to know so much about Jorah? Just a red herring or what?" ![[image loading]](http://i.imgur.com/sHRd4Ih.jpg) i cant even remember who this is O_o who the hell is this | ||
|
Hyperbola
United States2554 Posts
On June 16 2015 14:03 Necro)Phagist( wrote: Snow is perfect: [X] Landed quite well: [X] Getting up unscathed: [✓] Fall 4x the height [✓] Sansa and Theon are fine. I'd be surprised if either of them sustained any serious injury. Try jumping out of a four story building and see how you end up. Skiing has a transfer of momentum into going fast when you land on an incline, Sansa and Theon jumped onto level ground. Might have been a bit grassy and maybe muddy or some snow but that's not going to slow your deceleration much. Besides, literally five seconds before that scene, Theon pushed that crazy girl off of the same height. She died. So will they. Edit: They have a fucking ladder right there. Why didn't they just use it? + Show Spoiler + ![[image loading]](http://i.imgur.com/SPSAE87.jpg) | ||
|
Zooper31
United States5713 Posts
On June 16 2015 14:33 Hyperbola wrote: Try jumping out of a four story building and see how you end up. Skiing has a transfer of momentum into going fast when you land on an incline, Sansa and Theon jumped onto level ground. Might have been a bit grassy and maybe muddy or some snow but that's not going to slow your deceleration much. Besides, literally five seconds before that scene, Theon pushed that crazy girl off of the same height. She died. So will they. Edit: They have a fucking ladder right there. Why didn't they just use it? + Show Spoiler + Because said ladder obviously isn't long enough. Also think he has time to haul that ladder up to them without being seen? Heck he probably couldn't even do it himself, seems like a heavy solid wood ladder. Also how are you going to compare jumping onto hard concrete to landing in a snow pile. Also said woman landed on rock, on her head, without bracing for the fall at all. | ||
|
Shock710
Australia6097 Posts
I wasnt convinced at first and thought they would at the least have broken legs or feet or something but that video definitely shows the snow could left them unharmed from that fall. Comparing concrete/stone with the snow seems unfair. Not saying that i would try what that guy did in the video because that was pretty crazy even with knowing the snow could brace the fall but i think the fear of some rocks under the snow would put me off. | ||
|
Laurens
Belgium4557 Posts
Guys pls xD | ||
|
GreenHorizons
United States24142 Posts
On June 16 2015 15:04 Laurens wrote: In a fantasy series filled with dragons and magic, the most important question is of course if this fall is possible or not. Guys pls xD Seriously there is a zombie mountain, I fail to see how anything else matters lol. Also on unresolved stories,anyone else curious what this baby's deal is? | ||
|
shin_toss
Philippines2589 Posts
| ||
|
FiWiFaKi
Canada9859 Posts
| ||
|
GreenHorizons
United States24142 Posts
On June 16 2015 15:35 shin_toss wrote: it just shows how White Walkers makes another White Walkers But do they age? And at what rate? | ||
|
d00p
711 Posts
On June 16 2015 08:47 Zooper31 wrote: I suppose. But he talks about how he didn't get like a sword for his last scene and how he might cut his hair. How he's thinking of going into some movies and taking a break to read the books and stuff. He goes into too much detail to think he's actually just bullshitting and is lying about the next season. I always find it baffling when the actors/actresses who are in GoT say stuff like "I hope I don't die, haven't read the books". Why on earth would you not read the books? I would be just a bit curious to find out but I guess people really don't read anymore. | ||
|
shin_toss
Philippines2589 Posts
Why on earth would you not read the books? I would be just a bit curious to find out but I guess people really don't read anymore. bec they said. it might affect their acting | ||
|
d00p
711 Posts
| ||
|
d00p
711 Posts
On June 16 2015 16:23 shin_toss wrote: Probably they age.. its weird to see baby white walkers fighting tho haha bec they said. it might affect their acting Yeah, that's what they would say. Obviously, had they read the books, they still wouldn't be allowed to spoil anything. So I guess it makes sense in some way. | ||
| ||
