I think both are great, but ATB being offline is a big advantage. The shots of the other players watching and the presence of a crowd add more than I realized from watching Proleague. ATB also has more variety because there are many small teams instead of three big ones. On the other hand, ACL has a lot more drama in the entries and IMO has produced more quality games.

I'd like to see a version of ACL that adds another team by padding rosters with some promising Fish amateurs like Purpose and is played offline.

Vivi57

United States6599 Posts

June 01 2017 05:01 GMT

#27

In a short league, ATB is more interesting that ACL. For ACL to become interesting, there really needs to be a mentoring storyline where clans are rewarded for nurturing new talent. I think that's mostly what I'm looking for - any team league which feature rookies as well as seasoned players will be more interesting than a league which features the same guys we have been watching for the last 10 years.

Lebesgue

4542 Posts

June 01 2017 05:05 GMT

#28

I agree that there is a need for some mentoring system so new talent can emerge. Otherwise the game will die in the long run, or at the very least the skill level will deteriorate.

CobaltBlu

United States919 Posts

June 01 2017 05:30 GMT

#29

ATB is more interesting to me but I think there needs to be larger teams. Give fresh faces a chance to make a name for themselves by sniping a well known player. Like other people are saying give established players an incentive to mentor new talent.

ShloobeR

Korea (South)3828 Posts

June 01 2017 05:41 GMT

#30

I personally prefer fewer, larger teams, the way ACL does it
but obviously ATB has the advantage of being offline and in the studio.

if teams in ATB each had one lesser known/rookie player that would be great.

BLinD-RawR

ALLEYCAT BLUES51078 Posts

June 01 2017 06:05 GMT

#31

On June 01 2017 13:43 K.H.J wrote:
I want to know your opinion, guys.

Which one is more interesting?

ATB or ACL ?

ACL.

ATB's only advantage is that its offline ACL is like proleague, ATB is like random 3:3s

DarkNetHunter

1224 Posts

June 01 2017 06:07 GMT

#32

ATB and ACL both have a lack of rookies, otherwise they'd be great.

I prefer ATB though because of the team diversity and because it is offline.

sc19980331

China1609 Posts

June 01 2017 06:09 GMT

#33

I also like Ajae League 2, party for old boys :-)
http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/brood-war/523304-ajae-league-season-2

Liquidpedia should be updated:
http://wiki.teamliquid.net/starcraft/Ajae_League_Season_1

sc19980331

China1609 Posts

June 01 2017 06:18 GMT

#34

Plus Larva's league
Final today:
Team SKT : Best Rain sSak S2
Team STX : Last Hero Shuttle Mini
6/1. 21:00 KST. Final

Qikz

United Kingdom12041 Posts

June 01 2017 06:43 GMT

#35

On June 01 2017 15:18 sc19980331 wrote:
Plus Larva's league
Final today:
Team SKT : Best Rain sSak S2
Team STX : Last Hero Shuttle Mini
6/1. 21:00 KST. Final

S K T FIGHTING! :D

K.H.J

Korea (South)769 Posts

June 01 2017 07:40 GMT

#36

Thank you guys

BLinD-RawR

ALLEYCAT BLUES51078 Posts

June 01 2017 09:42 GMT

#37

On June 01 2017 16:40 K.H.J wrote:
Thank you guys

calling it now KHJ is actually a huge sponsor and hes going to create the next proleague

kogeT

Poland2042 Posts

June 01 2017 09:47 GMT

#38

KHJ has been doing some amazing coverage work. Thank you for all that.

L1ghtning

Sweden353 Posts

June 01 2017 20:26 GMT

#39

On May 29 2017 00:19 K.H.J wrote:
Team list

Flash, Sea, Terror

Bisu, JD, Mind

Best , Rain, Briteney

Last, Shuttle, Larva

sSak, Hero, Horang2

Shine, Skyhigh, Movie

Mong, Effort, Snow

Soulkey, Organ, Guemchi

It is not fixed.

Team Bisu and Last are the strongest.

K.H.J

Korea (South)769 Posts

June 04 2017 14:58 GMT

#40

AfreecaTV CEO officially announced ATB S2 in ASL3 Final.