Nice list! I always like seeing what other people rate as their favorite games ever.

And guys saying, "OMG add this!", "you should put this on", etc - we've got at least nine years of fantastic Starcraft and that's something like 10,000 games. There have to be at least 200-300 of those that could plausibly go on a Top 50 list. So thanks for sharing your thoughts, but let this guy's list alone. Make your own.

(For instance, I was disappointed not to see (T)

Light <Colosseum II> (T)

fantasy + Show Spoiler +

on the list, because imo it's the second best modern-style TvT to date (behind only Flash vs Leta with the nukes). But that's *my* taste.)

Apex

United States7227 Posts

May 26 2010 03:26 GMT

#86

Nice list, but in my opinion, for that Bisu v. Stork game that's listed at #15, if it's going to be any Bisu vs. Stork game, I would have to say that Bisu vs Stork Game 5 of the MSL Finals (forgot the map) should be the one listed. One of the greatest PvPs I've ever seen.

Other people have made other awesome suggestions so I'm just going to leave it there.

yeti

United States259 Posts

May 26 2010 03:46 GMT

#87

I love

Stork and

Jaedong, and I love the #1 Game.
But why was it #1? It Really wasn't as epic as even (P)

Stork vs

GoRush the Last Pro-league #1 that Jon747 put up ~6 months ago. Not to mention various other games.

GHOSTCLAW

United States17042 Posts

May 26 2010 03:49 GMT

#88

gorush vs nada is amazing, and I can't believe that it didn't make it on. Really new games on this list, and I can't agree with all of them. They were good...just not amazing ^^

GHOSTCLAW

United States17042 Posts

May 26 2010 03:52 GMT

#89

On May 26 2010 05:12 thunk wrote:
A 5 pool on Troy made the top 10? You must be a July fan.

Taken into context inside of the game, it wasn't bad, all things considered. I would hafta place Jaedong vs fantasy 4 pool as a much stronger mindgame play though (don't remember what year even, game 1 of the series was on HBR, game with the 4 pool was on a blue tileset).

Gann1

United States1575 Posts

May 26 2010 03:59 GMT

#90

2009 Bacchus semis, game 3 on Holy World

at least i think that's the one you're talking about

ghrur

United States3786 Posts

May 26 2010 04:25 GMT

#91

On May 26 2010 12:46 yeti wrote:
I love (P)

Stork and

Jaedong, and I love the #1 Game.
But why was it #1? It Really wasn't as epic as even (P)

Stork vs

GoRush the Last Pro-league #1 that Jon747 put up ~6 months ago. Not to mention various other games.

Yeah, I agree with this because I loved Iris vs GGPlay more being a GGplay fan. ^_^
I also can't believe Action vs Flash didn't make it anywhere despite the INSANE defiler usage, but hey, that's cuz BW's just so awesome top 50 ain't enough.

unionbank

Australia666 Posts

May 26 2010 04:52 GMT

#92

Bisu vs Iris best game I've ever witnessed..... i still can't get over the fact that Iris won in that situation.. classic example of never say die 10/5 stars

BisuDagger

Bisutopia19363 Posts

May 26 2010 04:58 GMT

#93

GGPlay vs Stork just made me miss a date with my gf! GRAWGH! I wish I could use mind control like stork did so I wont get in trouble. Or at least plague her so when her health is low I can go in for the killz.

QuoC

United States724 Posts

May 26 2010 04:59 GMT

#94

none of these matches are rigged right? <_>

ohN

United States1075 Posts

May 26 2010 05:15 GMT

#95

July vs Best Ever OSL 2008 Set2 was just awesome. I saw it again after seeing the list. :D

canucks12

Canada812 Posts

May 26 2010 05:43 GMT

#96

No Casy vs July? That was a pretty awesome game.

ZenDeX

Philippines2916 Posts

May 26 2010 05:45 GMT

#97

On May 26 2010 13:59 QuoC wrote:
none of these matches are rigged right? <_>

A rigged match wouldn't be a good match to watch anyway with one player just playing badly.

Emon_

3925 Posts

May 26 2010 06:24 GMT

#98

Congrats on the list. Games are a lot of fun to watch. I think #47 Leta vs. Pure on HBR needs to be higher up, but you have a lot of good games on the list and in the right places!