So I went to PoisonTVde to watch IEM - Katowice Asia and Oceania Qualifier. Some mediocre music greeted me, and then suddenly "a user joined your channel".

'Is my TS on? Am I talking to someone now?' I thought. But no, it turns out that it was the PoisonTVde commentary to this event. "A user left your channel". And "A user joined you channel". And some static from a mic.

So I typed to chat:
more USER JOINED YOUR CHANNEL commentary please
so unprofessional

And this is how it ended:
[image loading]

Not only did they delete these messages, I got a permaban.

Wasn't I fucking right?

Torte de Lini

Germany38463 Posts

February 06 2014 09:35 GMT

You want to change things, but call him unprofessional.
Do you want to be right or do you want more professionalism.

Sounds like you wanted to be right, so he did the unprofessional thing and banned you.

sctstarcraft

Poland22 Posts

February 06 2014 09:53 GMT

... Well, I hope next time they pay more attention to whatever they're broadcasting.

I stayed on that channel for a while: these guys keep swearing, they have little control over their brodcast - keep forgetting to switch to overlay and we can read all their conversations. It all makes for a pretty low user experience. I'm not really suprised they have so few viewers.

Mstring

Australia510 Posts

February 06 2014 10:12 GMT

People are generally far more open to criticism that is delivered tactfully.

YouthSC

United Kingdom355 Posts

February 06 2014 10:46 GMT

Those channels have <500 viewers for a reason... Just saying'

Torte de Lini

Germany38463 Posts

February 06 2014 10:52 GMT

On February 06 2014 18:53 sctstarcraft wrote:
... Well, I hope next time they pay more attention to whatever they're broadcasting.

I stayed on that channel for a while: these guys keep swearing, they have little control over their brodcast - keep forgetting to switch to overlay and we can read all their conversations. It all makes for a pretty low user experience. I'm not really suprised they have so few viewers.

I would just report it to IEM/ESL guys.

FFW_Rude

France10201 Posts

February 06 2014 11:41 GMT

Well.. You could have say something like :

- "Hello moderators. We can hear the TeamSpeak sounds : "user join your channel" and whatnot. Could you inform the casters ?"

And report it to the persons not on twitch chat where it's garbage that no one read.

And you can still inform people at IEM/ESL

sctstarcraft

Poland22 Posts

February 06 2014 12:05 GMT

On February 06 2014 20:41 FFW_Rude wrote:
Well.. You could have say something like :

- "Hello moderators. We can hear the TeamSpeak sounds : "user join your channel" and whatnot. Could you inform the casters ?"

Pretty interesting suggestion from someone with such nickname

Whatson

United States5356 Posts

February 06 2014 12:14 GMT

Nvm

Scarecrow

Korea (South)9172 Posts

February 06 2014 12:15 GMT

#10

On February 06 2014 21:14 Whatson wrote:

Show nested quote +

Because your nickname on the interenet has soooooooo much to do with how you behave on it.

You should look at the emoticon used before lecturing someone on the internet

Whatson

United States5356 Posts

February 06 2014 12:21 GMT

#11

You know what, you're probably right, and even if you're wrong I'm still detracting from this thread

c0ldfusion

United States8293 Posts

February 06 2014 13:13 GMT

#12

5/5 would read again

FFW_Rude

France10201 Posts

February 06 2014 13:24 GMT

#13

On February 06 2014 21:05 sctstarcraft wrote:

Show nested quote +

Pretty interesting suggestion from someone with such nickname

Well. Apparences are not always true

Fuchsteufelswild

Australia2028 Posts

February 06 2014 13:53 GMT

#14

Even if sctstarcraft didn't go about it in the most tactful way, I agree that banning him was a very immature way of dealing with him...based on what we see.
Possibly you had actually typed a lot more beforehand, in which case it's possible you had deserved it (I'm only pointing out the possibility though, not assuming that was the case).
Either way, if the stream the provide is very unprofessional, letting IEM/ESL know so that they make a decision for themselves is definitely worthwhile, I agree.

On February 06 2014 22:24 FFW_Rude wrote:

Show nested quote +

Well. Appearances are not always true

I couldn't agree more with FFW_Rude, especially assuming we're still talking about forum nicknames.

Yorbon

Netherlands4272 Posts

February 06 2014 14:00 GMT

#15

I'm appalled by such injustice.

Daswollvieh

5553 Posts

February 06 2014 15:37 GMT

#16

I would have banned you, too, because that´s no way to speak to people.

Targe

United Kingdom14103 Posts

February 06 2014 17:28 GMT

#17

On February 07 2014 00:37 Daswollvieh wrote:
I would have banned you, too, because that´s no way to speak to people.

yeah if someone spoke to me like that on my channel i would have banned them too

sctstarcraft

Poland22 Posts

February 06 2014 20:02 GMT

#18

I acknowledge that my way of saying what I wanted to say was not too pleasant. I might have done it in a more helpful and positive fashion. I didn't. Still, note that I did not swear or call them names, I only used irony and called them "unprofessional". No "moron, you forgot to turn off your mic" or anything.

Glad to see people agree such broadcasting "style" is not appropriate. Hope the guys pay more attention in the future. I also, somehow, doubt it.

On February 06 2014 22:53 Fuchsteufelswild wrote:
Possibly you had actually typed a lot more beforehand, in which case it's possible you had deserved it (I'm only pointing out the possibility though, not assuming that was the case).

I agree that it seems plausible and often happens on the internet;) but I think it's actually not possible in this case! You can see the "joined chat" message, you can see the two lines for which I was banned (it was <message deleted>, but when I clicked on the text it appeared again) and you can see the third message which was never posted because of the permaban. Ahh, but of course I could've made the whole picture in paint or sth... Well, I didn't.