Now how will this work on TL? well tbh we all know with all the effort putting on strategy forum right now (sc2 section ofc), the forum still completely full of shit (no offense to anyone). No pro would even bother reading the forum and trolls are every where. The highlight poster are gods and no one really ever consider correcting them even if they post something wrong(slightly incorrect would be a good term but w/e) (again, no offense to anyone).
suggestion: a special 'battle arena' forum with limited number of poster (suggestion 200). Only these 200 people could post in this forum and everyone else could read it.
there will be qualifier to select 100 people (20 from each sever AM EU SEA KR CN), the other 100 will be community/mod suggestion and decided by voting(poll) Ratio of these 2 could be scale depend on the size of qualifier.
Poster who qualified are force to meet a quota of post per week in that forum, suggesting 50(non-1-liner) People who do not meet the quota will be out of the forum. Replacement will be mod/community suggestion.
Each week, each 'forum poster' will need to submit at least 1 replay of them winning on ladder. If any one who is not a 'forum poster' (challenger) could submit 3(or more) recent replays where you beat a 'forum poster' and the forum poster cant submit his own matching number recent replays of himself winning against the challenger, the 2 will swap place. Notice tide will favor the forum poster and nothing will happen. The definition of 'recent' could be changed by 'moderator' depends on patch/season on BNet.
Any posters could challenge to prove the other not worthy by defeating the enemy in a bo3. Loser will have to go through a trial by winning a 5 games in a row KOTH vs either other random forum posters or community pick people.
Moderating in this forum will also be different: since all of these members are quality posters, the mods will be judges for the matches that played between posters. Every official match should be obs by a judge or have it replay approved by at least 3 judges.
I know the idea is really really rough but the main purposes is creating a really really exclusive forum for pros/semi-pros who wish to contribute for the forum. I know that TL probably not gona install this feature but it would be a great idea if somebody want to create a new community to try and implement.