Doctor Who Mafia 2

On March 31 2014 12:27 Alakaslam wrote:

Well this disappeared quickly

On March 31 2014 12:51 thrawn2112 wrote:
ok.

1. hopeless is heavly implying that he is intentionally playing in a way so that people find him scummy. last game he claimed to do this as some sort of strategy. or as he noted in this game (although jokingly) he is doing it for the sake of his 'always scummy as either alignment" meta. so is he town and doing either of those two things or is he scum and taking advantage of people's expectations of his play?

2. did you have a read on slam before you sent him on a mission?

On March 31 2014 12:56 Alakaslam wrote:
Anyone aware of how George Lucas was inspired for the shape of the Millenium Falcon?

On March 31 2014 18:44 Tehpoofter wrote:
@Jar Jar and Austin since you too didn't post much at the start of the day and ended up thinking I was scummy. IF you guys think I'm actually scum do you think its better for town to vote for me today or for Slam and his claimed survivor role? Essentially is it worth it going after a scummy read vs a 3rd party claim by Slam?

On March 31 2014 19:19 Djodref wrote:


Regarding austin, I would like him to interact with more people than Slam and thrawn. I like the fact that he doesn't believe the survivor claim. I don't have problems with him questioning your alignment. But I need more posts from him. I would say slightly town for Austin.
@austin
What were your motivations to interact with Slam ?

I believe myself Slam is 3P, but not such thing as simple as a survivor. Again, I would like him to claim his exact wincon. But that's not the topic.

Regarding Hopeless, he looks disgruntled by the direction this game is taking for this first day (i.e. a lynch on Slam) and he is openly not putting much effort into the game for now. I could see town Hopeless doing that for various reasons. But it's also easy to do this as scum. So null for the moment on Hopeless, and I hope he can step up a little in the future. I don't mind him playing like this at the moment.

On March 31 2014 22:12 JarJarDrinks wrote:
I thought I did:If you want a percentage I'll say 35-40% chance of being scum. But I'll lynch 100% not town almost every time unless there's really obvious scum.

On April 01 2014 00:26 Alakaslam wrote:
Austinmcc, I will at least honor you with this.

You sent me to the hinterlands to see what I found.

Well, go thou to the thither lands of Rayn's filter.

If tehpoofter is scum for the reasons you had me dig up, so find that Rayn also is. For he has called me confirmed town.

See that you do find it! And find why.

Most anti town player on record- FTW.

On March 31 2014 03:16 Tehpoofter wrote:
Actual read on slam is I don't like him he might be mafia claiming the role and rayn brought that up earlier I believe and if he was pushing him for that I wouldn't be suspicious of him but I don't like you want to vote him because you think he is survivor.

If he is survivor I think there is a good way to deal with him in that case.

On April 01 2014 01:13 raynpelikoneet wrote:
Austin you need to use your brain powers with thrawn and Vivax on N1. One of you gets shot and another one get yakked. It will be beneficial to see whose thought process changes after night phase and i wouldn't bank on anyone else to lynch kita just because they can't. They can't even make a case on him. Trust me. That's is the truth, noone in this game will get kita lynched other than you three and most likely one of you gets shot and another one gets yakked.

On April 01 2014 01:16 kitaman27 wrote:


Haven't spent a lot of time on him and he won't be a priority for the remainder of the day due to other individuals I can use my time better on.

Avoiding a town vs town is my biggest worry at the moment because those put you back way too much early on. At work currently so time is limited but I still hope to be able to comment on others more in depth other than rayn.

On March 31 2014 18:14 Tehpoofter wrote:
Which posts are you referring to here where I ask questions and don't follow up after an answer?

On March 31 2014 03:36 Tehpoofter wrote:
@Djo once you're done catching up how do you feel about rayn's this game in comparison to last game we all played (titanic) or previous games?

This question also is good for Vivax/hopeless/thrawn but I don't think tehy're around atm.

On April 01 2014 01:20 raynpelikoneet wrote:

Anything other than D2 is too late.

On March 31 2014 03:02 Tehpoofter wrote:
@ massclaiming Amiko summed up some of the different ways it could go and the reasonings seem good for not doing it helped me think through it. I like Amiko as town for that.


I don't think rayn is town he is playing completely different to the game I play with him before. He was aggressive but I feel like his push on Slam is an easy low hanging fruit type push. Survivor might not be town but its not mafia finding mafia > lynching the survivor. Rayn also should know that we need to look outside of just Slam either way we have to deduce how people are acting today because in an alignment swapping type setup the way you act day to day flip flopping on reads and stuff can give town good information.

I think that rayn is trying to deprive town of information by pushing a slam lynch, he also as I recalled as the super town hero he was last game I played posted a list of his reads as early as he did here.

Rayn is there a reason you chose to do so early? (positing a reads list)


My vote is here because of his push on Slam mainly and he just seems like he has a different town this game.

## unvote

## Vote: Rayn

On March 31 2014 03:23 Tehpoofter wrote:


Okay I misread this the first time and thought it was you saying you want to always lynch the survivor... not the survivor claim.


So Rayn would you say that in a game with possible alignment changes lynching a mafia is crucial in case they can add to their team in some fashion or possibly hit a 3rd party role that can recruit for their own alignment as well?

I feel like even if Slam was still confirmed Survivor in this setup I wouldn't want to lynch him day 1 I'd much rather want to lynch someone I found scummy that could be mafia or an anti-town third party converting type role that seems likely given the setup.

On March 31 2014 06:19 Tehpoofter wrote:


I'll put it this way I don't think hes mafia here more than maybe 5% of the time. I think that he claimed way too passively and without care to be mafia. Mafia I feel like would use this claim in a situation where they're taking lots of pressure and he really wasn't under much I was one of the people voting him at the time and we were far from end of day.

So to me its like 85% survivor/ 5% mafia 5% mafia 5% other. I am of the attitude that to me a successful day for town in this type of game is to hit a mafia. Like if we go to lynch a mafia I'll be 100% happy if we kill Slam and hes survivor I would be like 40% happy if we hit a town I would be 0% happy. So for me I feel like Slam is a safe lynch if we don't have a clear mafia at the end of the day but I don't want to default lynch him from right now when we might catch a scum slipping up and start this game off right. I want an ez game for town not one where we play struggling. Survivor is a super uninformative lynch imo. I mean there is also the chance hes like Fool or something and claims survivor knowing people like rayn would push on him as any alignment (no clue if fool is possible or w.e. but still)

On March 31 2014 06:27 Tehpoofter wrote:



See thats a bad attitude Imo Rayn is only one person and he might be scum this game. Hes not the town hero he was in titanic this is a new game boys and you shouldn't just sheep rayn. The only way rayn gets what he wants is if you act like its a forgone conclusion.

On March 31 2014 18:24 Tehpoofter wrote:



I would love to hear your bigger case rayn. This is what I mean that is different from last game... your heart is either not as into this game or you're a different alignment than last time. The rayn from the game I played was more than happy to bring up a whole case on someone even if it was a massive wall of texts and then scream at the town for not realizing they're scum. This isn't what you're doing this game... its different and its the only meta I know for you. The Way I play mafia is assessing how people play different alignments and roles and compare them between games along with the information in the thread to attempt to make a read. Thus far you are different than last game where you were basically the whole town. IF I have a read you do X as town and then you do Y instead should I draw a different conclusion?