Hogwarts Mafia

On October 17 2013 05:09 Grackaroni wrote:
##Propose Alliance: Slytherin
##Declare War: Ravenclaw
##Send Warning: Gryffindor - "you're next"

Hufflepuff!

On October 17 2013 06:22 raynpelikonoshi wrote:
##vote: Skanjab1s

Bring it on slytherin scum

On October 17 2013 06:24 Grackaroni wrote:

You forget yourself, Hufflepuff is home to the greatest witches and wizards around.

On October 17 2013 06:41 I-be-Pro wrote:
Okay I'm done with the contest. Just won it. So let's talk mafia.

Anything interesting happening in your QT supersoft? This skanjab guy asked in mine wether mafia has 1 member per house.
Rather scummy question to me. There's really not much to get out of that. Obviously everyone assumes so at this point but what do you expect the hosts to answer to that? Up until this point it's just a no-brainer question that might have not been a no-brainer for him. I ask that kind of questions all the time but this particular one really makes it sound like he's trying to "just post something" and look like he's participating imo.

On October 17 2013 06:52 supersoft wrote:


can you give me the exact quote of his question? I tend to trust these noob-"slips"... ^_^

I'll tell you about my houseQT later, i wanna give my proposal from above (houseclaims etc.) some time.
Maybe someone points out a flaw in my idea. There is no need to rush things...

On October 17 2013 06:54 supersoft wrote:
OKAY WAIT

I want you guys to post all the posts from your house QTs regarding this 1mafia per house theory.

On October 17 2013 06:48 Grackaroni wrote:

1) the voting thread wasn't even created when I posted.
2) It's not a real vote
3) Watching for players being afraid to put votes in the voting thread at the start of the game is a silly and ineffective method of scumhunting.

On October 17 2013 06:56 supersoft wrote:


yes you are? you didnt read the rules before you started this game? how newbie is that? Very newbie!
How do you even plan on playing this game? are you just here to chat with us a little bit?

On October 17 2013 06:56 I-be-Pro wrote:


The point I'm making is that it's a hosts job to answer that with no no matter what, even if that answer actually is yes. There never was a chance to get a yes out of that answer.

On October 17 2013 07:01 raynpelikonoshi wrote:
Skanjab1s



"guis I am town because I don't know yet the compositions of each House'

On October 17 2013 07:06 I-be-Pro wrote:

I actually agree with the bottom one and it's one of the things that came up in my head as well.

I get that he didn't catch the no copy&paste rule. But I assume if he rolled town he at least would check on the number of mafias in the game if it's so plainly in the OP. AT LEAST when he's having ideas like that himself (his theory). When he posted it in the QT and I checked the number instantly because I was pretty sure I saw 6 mafia and wanted to confirm.
I've seen this particular one happening from mafia at least once, might have been even me no idea.

On October 17 2013 07:07 raynpelikonoshi wrote:

1) Do you think scumteam already knows who is in each House?
2) Do you understand why I am saying you are scum?

On October 17 2013 07:10 raynpelikonoshi wrote:

Twice the right answer. New question:

1) Why are you twisting my words and pretending that I just scumslipped when you knew the purpose behind my post?

On October 17 2013 07:17 Zaragon wrote:
Guess we'll let the Houses trickle out to fuel discussion. There is the off-chance that scum has no one in two whole Houses, too. After my last game, I'm going to be more careful about dismissing something very unlikely prematurely.

I realized something is going to be very confusing: bits of rayn's scum play looks similar to Koshi's town, and their hydra is not particularly stating who is talking (unless I missed them setting up times or something in the pregame). For an early read, them using that ambiguity I'll put down as leaning slightly scum.

skanjab1s is just odd so far, somewhat scummy and/or new; any meta on him?

On October 17 2013 07:28 raynpelikonoshi wrote:
hahahaha

plz tell the thread why you are certain I am scum.

On October 17 2013 07:39 I-be-Pro wrote:


Why do you put so much emphasis on how that's not a reason to think someone's scum instead of putting emphasis on him doing it? It's a valid point you make but the basic idea behind it is completly wrong. I'm pretty sure a lot of people have seen that and yet noone is defending him because you usually don't want to defend other people in their stead; you want to see them defend themselves unless you already know their alignment.

You ARE kind of attacking Zaragon but you're making a bigger deal out of defending here. Why?

On October 17 2013 07:52 I-be-Pro wrote:



The first one downplays his accusation, the 2nd one downplays his accusation again, the 3rd one is defending.

What I'm saying is I usually like people a lot more when they have a somewhat agressive tone to them. Mafias have a hard time picking sides and accusing people because they have to make shit up. You're lacking the balls to call him out clearly for what he does. I don't mind you pointing out the flaws if you'd use it to attack him but you're just happy stating his flaws.

On October 17 2013 08:01 I-be-Pro wrote:
Anyways, that's it for me, have to wake up in 7 hours again. Something that might be interesting from my QT or might just be plainly nothing:

Skanjab1s asked if I am I-be-Pro (I called myself Toad in the QT... sry) - nothing wrong with this one at all, despite my recent attacks against him.
snowman answered that question with a positive (trying to rephrase here...)

Think he has been reading the thread and is actively lurking atm. Make of that what you want. I don't have the time to type any more tonight, sry.