I am going to open this game playing as if I know Marv is town. WUT WHY?!

I don't believe I can discern Marv's scum from town early in the game and he is typically very open to discussion and explainations of his thought process (unlike a sandroba type player).

thats all for now

Mattchew

United States5684 Posts

February 14 2013 13:29 GMT

#184

I picked Marv because he is extremely talented and willing to openly discuss his ideas and reads at length. In the games I have played with Sandroba or Syllo, they are both also extremely talented but often short and directly to the point and sometimes I dont see things the way they do, and they are tough to get further explanation from.

Risk, I don't see anyone as town until proven otherwise.

Artanis what do you think of Vivax's scumreads post

Vivax how many games of mafia would you say you've played

Mattchew

United States5684 Posts

February 14 2013 13:46 GMT

#191

I wanna know if your playing nervous and new or nervous or nervous and forced

Mattchew

United States5684 Posts

February 14 2013 15:28 GMT

#206

Vivax what gave supersoft away to you

Mattchew

United States5684 Posts

February 14 2013 15:43 GMT

#218

You forced out reads that seemed like you wanted to answer his question more than you actually cared about the content of your reads

Mattchew

United States5684 Posts

February 14 2013 15:49 GMT

#219

Hey Marv, have you played with vivax and is he perceptive enough to pick up on supersoft being a smurf, also how do you feel about syllos and sandrobas mini conversation in the thread...

Mattchew

United States5684 Posts

February 14 2013 19:22 GMT

#310

I'm back Marv I like your vote on hiropro... That post reeks of fake confidence

Vivax I think I underestimated your actual abilities and underestimated your confidence... These lead to a misguided read on you... I don't necessarily agree with how you've started this game but I'm leaning a little more null on you... Revealing supersoft is pretty towny IMO too.

I don't like Zess so far but I am on my phone and can't really read his filter enough right now

Mattchew

United States5684 Posts

February 15 2013 16:17 GMT

#508

i think that artanis is asking a lot of questions without drawing a ton of actual conclusions. He is also commenting a lot on the general play of individuals and the overal game instead of focusing on what I would consider scum hunting. He is blending in really well IMO.

Marv, syllo and Sandroba what do you think of this?

Mattchew

United States5684 Posts

February 15 2013 16:24 GMT

#513

@marv

OK i just read your case on hopeless. He is using weak language and I agree with the facts you presented to draw your conclusions. I would like you to expand on why your ok with artanis

@vivax

Currently toad and zess are sitting neutral to me, neither are more lynchworthy than hopeless (marv's case), artanis (my thoughts), or grush (just cause, grush.)

Oo I havent read

Mattchew

United States5684 Posts

February 15 2013 16:26 GMT

#515

On February 16 2013 01:22 Artanis[Xp] wrote:

Show nested quote +

How am I asking a lot of questions? I asked one to Sandro, for the rest I've analyzed a bunch of cases. I just don't think any of them are that strong. Strongest being on Toad so far for posting a bunch of fluff, but I've only seen Toad in scum games so I don't know if he does it as Town. My conclusion from analyzing the filters is that Toad is scummiest so far, so I voted for him.

As for yourself, why haven't you been contributing? You've been asking more questions then I have and drawing even less conclusions, plus literally no scumhunting, unless you count questions which you just accused me of as trying to blend in.

I haven't been contributing because I have had nothing insightful, new, or postworthy to post and I only get pockets of time to post so it is hard for me to be conversational with people when I am posting from a phone and only can look every so often

Mattchew

United States5684 Posts

February 15 2013 23:36 GMT

#868

Did we lynch yet my phone died

Mattchew

United States5684 Posts

February 15 2013 23:39 GMT

#872

Fuck sorry... I meant to vote and to be honest I would have voted artanis grush or hopeless.

Congrats guys I have to go read why that lynch happened and worked now

Mattchew

United States5684 Posts

February 16 2013 00:28 GMT

#899

Marv the best part about your 4 quotes up there is there's no way vivax could have known about those other 3 posts... He was legit pushing a nolynch / zess lynch not knowing that Yamato was actually going to get lynched...

Mattchew

United States5684 Posts

February 16 2013 14:37 GMT

#969

I'm pretty sure I'm alive sandro... I apologized to bugs, and I might be taking a ban after this game for missing the vote, but that's not important (unless I'm dead)

The odds mafia was actually playing for a no lynch by bussing zess and splitting the votes to create a No lynch seems unreasonable.

Mattchew

United States5684 Posts

February 16 2013 14:48 GMT

#971

Marv risk and artanis all strike me as town from the way that went down, all of them jumped to someone they were voting with, to someone who was getting voted by who they were originally on... That doesn't read as paranoid to me.

I believe zess is also town.

Vivax is probably scum and that fits my typical MO of finding scum super early with flimsy reasoning and losing confidence in my read early

I just can't reason with myself why any mafia would be on the Yamato wagon with so much time and easy reason to switch can someone tell me why I'm wrong here