EPTHarry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Mafia
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Jayme
United States5866 Posts
| ||
|
Jayme
United States5866 Posts
On June 22 2010 04:39 ~OpZ~ wrote: Because I'm terribly defensive!? -_- At any rate, you asked me how the benefit, and I was in a list of three people with Radfield....And I don't have a good feeling about Radfield this game yet...just a hunch so far... To be quite fair with concerning Radfield last game...that was just about the first time in 3 or 4 games he wasn't outright killed in the first night. Him being a little bit overzealous in such a circumstance while not necessarily justified is at least understandable. That being said I have no idea whether he is town or not at this point because frankly it's just that early. | ||
|
Jayme
United States5866 Posts
On June 22 2010 11:07 Thegilaboy wrote: Might cause the Mafia to slip us as they would have to make up different identities that are good people in Harry Potter. Any inconsistencies or doubles would point towards suspicion. Here's the problem I have with the mass roleclaiming. The HP universe is a fairly large one. This added to the fact that the list name at the beginning has been removed makes the whole "making some name up" a great deal easier than it was before. There were a few pro dumbledore characters that were major but weren't necessarily mentioned in that list and unless someone copy and pasted the exact list...and how we would know this list is accurate or not...we're kind of in a bit of a bind in that regard. It might work though because the blue roles in this game seem a bit flimsy if what I've read so far is correct. I just don't think the mass claim is as beneficial as it was before that list was taken down. | ||
|
Jayme
United States5866 Posts
On June 22 2010 23:42 DCLXVI wrote: Do we have a detective? The role list says Detective: See Legilimency and Occlumency. Legilimency is listed as a mafia spell. From the way medic is defined (see episky, a blue spell) it seems that there is no actual detective that can role check. Also, can people have multiple spells? Occlumency seems kind of useless unless people can have multiple spells. I am not sure why the mafia would want to try to find out everyone's character. Obviously they would like to know who harry is so they don't kill him, but other than that it only seems to help them guess at blue roles, maybe. (this is assuming that the mafia already have a safe name list) So is it true that only mafia get the red spells and only townies get the blue spells? It would make no sense if the town didn't have at least some of the "red" spells. I think the only actual difference between the blue spell and the red spells is only the "moral compass" aspect of it. The town would be extraordinarily weak without a legilimancer at all. Someone with occlumency can block that obviously but if this game is themed based on actual book events the number of people that should have occlumency is very very small. I don't see why people wouldn't have multiple spells. I'm voting for Amber[Light] for now. He's really the only candidate that has any plan what so ever that we can follow through so at least we have some sort of direction to go once twilight/night hits. Anything is better than running around without heads on straight. | ||
|
Jayme
United States5866 Posts
On June 23 2010 04:35 AcrossFiveJulys wrote: You could always try your luck this game -_^ if we keep playing together, eventually you'll be right! To be fair, for a few hours I was fairly convinced you were red last game when you turned out green. Anyway, unless the rest of the town wakes up and starts voting a lot differently, it looks like we'll have amber/radfield as our town leaders. Both of them seem rather pro town at this point, but of course, as always, don't overreact and start PM'ing your roles to them or put complete trust in them. You aren't supposed to PM at all unless you have a role that allows it in the first place... | ||
|
Jayme
United States5866 Posts
I also noticed in the voting thread that Yellowink very nearly blitzed himself into an elected position. If the last two YI votes had gone through and Gilaboy's had been counted he would have been the Pardoner over Radfield in the span of 2 some hours...again with no real explanation except from Opz as to why they even did so. The only reason he wasn't made Pardoner is because the inactive people were late voting. | ||
|
Jayme
United States5866 Posts
On June 26 2010 04:31 YellowInk wrote: Considering there is only 4 scum, if you found someone that was a death eater, even Voldemort (whom we can't kill yet), you should definitely come forward. Consider that if you get killed and revealed as a DT (assuming we don't have a second medic that decided to cover), we'll know for sure that that person was Voldemort. Coming forward will probably just get you roleblocked into oblivion, though. I suspect the death eaters have a great deal of magic at their disposal. Oh, and consider me half-asking for medic protection again. Though now you can give me just 50% likely protection (if you think I'm town) since there's probably only one medic out there. I advise using an RNG for your final decision on this sort of thing. If a DT shows up, that would obviously be an awesome target for protection too. Lets keep the mafia guessing. Even if the DT gets roleblocked into oblivion killing just one of the DE's is more than enough trade off for that, especially considering we have more than one DT most likely and I can't see DE's having more than one roleblocker...especially if a DT gets a response back that points toward Nagini or something to that end. Killing a horcrux is nothing short of invaluable. YI you have been considerably less aggressive this time around than before. If this is just because you're switching it up and would prefer to just lay a bit lower then okay...you haven't done anything I find particularly scummy in this game. In fact one of the only things I've found very very odd this game is your odd surge of votes you got right before the deadline and be honest...you would have been in the elected position if the voters had been a little bit more cognizant of the time. I'm not a huge fan of lynching inactives anymore. That style of play used to work back when people were a bit hesitant when they were read...now you don't see that at all anymore. The likely hood that an inactive will flip town is pretty how and we gain pretty much nothing for it. I'd also like to say that 24 hours passes much quicker than you'd think when you work nights O.o | ||
|
Jayme
United States5866 Posts
On June 26 2010 04:47 Jayme wrote: Even if the DT gets roleblocked into oblivion killing just one of the DE's is more than enough trade off for that, especially considering we have more than one DT most likely and I can't see DE's having more than one roleblocker...especially if a DT gets a response back that points toward Nagini or something to that end. Killing a horcrux is nothing short of invaluable. YI you have been considerably less aggressive this time around than before. If this is just because you're switching it up and would prefer to just lay a bit lower then okay...you haven't done anything I find particularly scummy in this game. In fact one of the only things I've found very very odd this game is your odd surge of votes you got right before the deadline and be honest...you would have been in the elected position if the voters had been a little bit more cognizant of the time. I'm not a huge fan of lynching inactives anymore. That style of play used to work back when people were a bit hesitant when they were read...now you don't see that at all anymore. The likely hood that an inactive will flip town is pretty how and we gain pretty much nothing for it. I'd also like to say that 24 hours passes much quicker than you'd think when you work nights O.o PBWOE Forgive me for the edit, was merely the last sentence and I just woke up. My bad my bad. | ||
|
Jayme
United States5866 Posts
Also the day lengths absolutely confuse me. Some nights we can talk, some nights we can't talk. I don't even know what to follow anymore. The bandwagon from yesterday just got switched until today. Probably moved because it was known that it's pretty easy to push Larkis when the time is needed. Still have no clue what real alignment people have because even with the posts there is very little in the way of tells because of the HUGE bandwagons. Really let's see if this next night actually brings something because I can barely get a read on anything with the way things have been going at all. I expected a little more time before we reached twilight but the majority was reached extremely quickly.. | ||
|
Jayme
United States5866 Posts
On June 29 2010 09:12 Roffles wrote: Felt like I was reading a really bad fanfiction right there. Lol that was what I would call mediocre. Bad fanfiction is really really bad. | ||
|
Jayme
United States5866 Posts
On June 29 2010 09:16 AcrossFiveJulys wrote: so YI did not die? This means one of four possibilities: 1) abenson lied 2) YI was protected by a town doctor 3) YI is voldemort 4) YI was protected by a death eater after abenson announced his kill (assuming they have episky) I was under the impression that Medics could protect themselves.... | ||
|
Jayme
United States5866 Posts
On June 29 2010 09:24 Amber[LighT] wrote: I roleblocked him last night, so he couldn't possibly protect himself Oh.... OH well then. That's an interesting turn of events there though I'm not quite sure what it means. YI has been fishy but Abenson could be straight lying. | ||
|
Jayme
United States5866 Posts
On June 29 2010 09:42 JeeJee wrote: bm can you confirm whether or not we can lynch voldy? it says he cannot die until the horcruxes are gone, so i assume this means lynch won't work -- will the lynch be wasted and we go into twilight with nothing happening or what? If you're going completely into the book thing what should happen is that his Horcrux should take his place acting as his "life" Or he could just straight die I like that better -.- Voldemort was never unkillable, it was just that he was able to resurrect himself upon death...but he used up a Horcrux doing so. | ||
|
Jayme
United States5866 Posts
If he doesn't die he's voldy, that's pretty much the only plausible explanation of living through two of them. | ||
|
Jayme
United States5866 Posts
On June 29 2010 21:42 Amber[LighT] wrote: Seriously casting the AK on me was stupid. You're going to seriously regret that when we NEED those spells. The fact that they used one on you doesn't bother me. The fact that you got double tapped...THAT bothers me. Either one of them is full of shit or you just got double tapped with 2 day vig spell that are most certainly a one shot only deal. | ||
|
Jayme
United States5866 Posts
On June 29 2010 22:44 ~OpZ~ wrote: WAIT NEW DEVELOPMENT AMBER IS POTTER!!! HAHAHAHAHA everyone vote YellowInk for death. That is all. HAHAHAHAHAHA Amber claiming potter has got to be legit? Why? UH Hello, DUH Harry's in game. So, if Harry = horcrux, I hope my attack hits. Then we can lynch Voldy and gg it. Worth a shot I suppose. | ||
|
Jayme
United States5866 Posts
| ||
|
Jayme
United States5866 Posts
On June 30 2010 05:03 YellowInk wrote: Why? If Amber[Light] really is Harry Potter and I really am town aligned and Harry really did get Imperious Cursed (or BM posts that protego somehow protects against role blocks as AL suggested might be possible), what is wrong with this picture? What is a jack and how does this protect you? Because Harry should be completely immune to the imperious curse. If this game is anything at all like the books Harry should have immunity to imperious. I don't like you YI. You bring up a gambit that states that using it will be a significant cost to the town and I can't think of anything that would hurt the town so badly as to "cost" us unless this is a stall tactic as to not get lynched. As for name claiming? I'm the brunette bookworm. | ||
|
Jayme
United States5866 Posts
| ||
|
Jayme
United States5866 Posts
On June 30 2010 05:50 Amber[LighT] wrote: Abstain. Whoever of the two we think could be VM I can attempt a daykill on. If the kill is successful, then we lynch the other, If the kill is unsuccessful, then the other might be VM. Or the person you attempted to kill is VM...he still has a hidden horcrux around. | ||
| ||
