| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
thrawn2112
United States6918 Posts
##Vote KillingTime seems town is pretty dead set on lynching me (hmmm..... that went down easily didn't it?) so I'm probably not gonna spend too much time in the thread other than to laugh at the crazy association cases you guys are planning. just remember that there's at least 1 scum within the list of debears, kush, dandel, and atreides | ||
|
thrawn2112
United States6918 Posts
| ||
|
kushm4sta
United States8878 Posts
| ||
|
sharky246
1197 Posts
Looking over the past 2 lynches, thrawn's vote has been in both the townies that ended up dead. I sense this is alittle bit more than a coincidence. Also, I find it highly unlikely that none of the mafias had their votes in for the dead of one of these guys that got lynched. Check and mate, thrawn. | ||
|
Keirathi
United States4679 Posts
thrawn2112 (6) - debears, Atreides, Dandel Ion, kushm4sta, KillingTime, Sharky246 kushm4sta (1) - JacobStrangelove KillingTime (1) - Dandel Ion (0) - Atreides (0) - JacobStrangelove (0) - Currently, thrawn2112 is set to be lynched with 6 votes. Deadline in just under 8 hours. | ||
|
thrawn2112
United States6918 Posts
So my emotions are telling me "no don't trust that lying asshole" but logically his boredom claim makes a bunch of sense, and is actually a very town-ish tell. So I guess remove dandel from that list. Which leaves me with kush/debear/atreides. My initial suspicion of atreides started with his post after deadline.... but remedy did that too and he was green so the feeling of guilt about a mislynch could obviously also be a town trait. And if anything he's been consistent with his suspicion of me for pretty much the entire game so his vote for me makes a lot of sense. Now there's kush. Oh kush, where to begin. Kush is the guy with a scummy town meta, I know this from my previous games. He just posts whatever random thought comes into his head as he's lighting dat bowl. I've been getting a town vibe off of him for most of the game. First there is the shit with him trying hard to get people to switch to stutters while remedy was already voted in for the reason that the remedy lynch came about too easily. That's wayyyy more a townish thing for him to do.... rather than a mafia who for some reason decides to stick his neck out and tell everyone to vote switch. Also he has been talking with me about jacob even though I'm set to be lynched which suggests that he is interested in discussing his top scumread. Talking about your top scumread with the guy who is being lynched is just.... sooooo townie. Hrmm now here comes the irony of all ironies..... that only leaves debears. His case against me I originally thought to be genuine but that was just because of the length of it and research he put into it. That could be town or mafia so I'm throwing that out. His case looks like spin city with all the "Thrawn, the mason killer" shit. And when I read that my first thought was "how could anyone come to that conclusion?" I don't think it's something a scumhunting townie would see of as suspicious. So based on all of the above, my mafia pick among the 4 of them would have to go to debears. It's hard to think that because I've been thinking he was town for basically all game, but meh, it happens. So my conclusion is that there are only 2 mafia, or debears is scum. [##Unvote] [##Vote: debears] | ||
|
thrawn2112
United States6918 Posts
| ||
|
thrawn2112
United States6918 Posts
##Unvote ##Vote: debears | ||
|
thrawn2112
United States6918 Posts
| ||
|
thrawn2112
United States6918 Posts
Also can the people that are voting for me tell me what I've done that is scummy rather than something that would be done by a town player [/i]or[/i] a scum player? For far too long people have been making cases based off of pointing out flaws in logic and similar stuff. I've been doing it too but I really think that debears is scum. If there's someone left who thinks I'm town and you agree with my process of elimination post a few posts up then you need to vote for debears. | ||
|
thrawn2112
United States6918 Posts
so thrawn do you think Jacob is scum?[/QUOTE I dunno. why is he scum? I'm willing to consider that his long walls of texts aren't indicative of either town or scum... and he's had a pretty strong town read on me most all game. And since I think there's a mafia roleblocker it'd make sense if he was scum.... for example mafia would roleblock me because they see me as a potential blue threat... which would align perfectly with jacob having such a strong town read on me all game. and he has been pretty wishy washy about his read on me in the last few pages. Do you have an argument other than that he's pissing you off? Cuz to me that's what it looked like when you first began being suspicious of him. | ||
|
thrawn2112
United States6918 Posts
| ||
|
sharky246
1197 Posts
On September 26 2012 01:28 thrawn2112 wrote: sharky: look at where other people have had their votes cast, for example your mason partner sharrant. both of his votes ended up on town players. If that's really the sole basis of your vote on me then you need to try harder than that But the difference is that sharrant was a mason, whereas you are unconfirmed (i don't doubt the possibility that you are townie, but all signs point to scum). | ||
|
thrawn2112
United States6918 Posts
On September 26 2012 02:33 sharky246 wrote: But the difference is that sharrant was a mason, whereas you are unconfirmed (i don't doubt the possibility that you are townie, but all signs point to scum). what I was trying to tell you is that just because somebody has only voted for townies doesn't mean that they're scum. the fact that sharrant was confirmed mason has nothing to do with it... he lynched two townies because he was wrong. being wrong is possible. if being wrong weren't possible or even likely then we wouldn't have had so many damn mislynches in this game. and do you really think that's a strong reason to vote for me? if town mislynches again they are seriously fucked unless some lucky shit happens during the night cycle. if you're gonna vote for at least tell me your reasons other than making such a simplistic argument. sorry to say this and I'm not trying to be rude but this game requires way more thought than you've put into it so far | ||
|
thrawn2112
United States6918 Posts
Sonic, a confirmed town, was suspicious of me. Also, there were a few others who commented on my original "lynch last player" idea and they all were suspicious of it or said it was dumb. And debears comes in and on his very first post of the game, at a time when town players are supposed to be very suspicious of everyone, and he makes a huge post on why he thinks I'm town. How would anyone be able to make such a strong town read at that early phase of the game, especially if they themselves are a townie and are supposed to be suspicious of everything that's said in the game? Well they can make a town read and they can talk about all the town motivations..... because they know who's town. | ||
|
sharky246
1197 Posts
Remember the first lynch, 5 people voted for drazak. Sonic Death Monkey was townie, sharrant was townie, i am townie and that leaves you and kush. KillingTime, Dandel Ion, Sharrant, JacobStrangelove and you voted for another townie on the second lynch. Among kush, you, killing, dandel, and jacobs, i find it hard to believe that none of you would be mafia. I mean the possibility that none of the people who's vote landed on a guy dead being mafia is just near impossible. There are 3~4 mafia out of a possible 7 people (excluding me). If those 5 people aren't mafia, well that doesn't make sense. So at least 1 of you 5 must be the mafia. And because you appeared twice, you seem alittle more suspicious than the other 4. Now i am going to bed. I guess you are going to die, unless something happens like last time were people changed their votes the last hour, and i suspect that might happen again. | ||
|
sharky246
1197 Posts
| ||
|
thrawn2112
United States6918 Posts
On September 26 2012 03:11 sharky246 wrote: Of course i could be wrong. Nobody apart from the mafia knows if the person they vote for is scum or townie. But since the main objective of the scums is to kill all townies, don't you think that someone among those who voted for the townies would be mafia? I'm not saying that you are 100% mafia. But if someone was to be mafia, i'm pretty sure it is someone among those who voted for the guy that ended up dead. And since you were there twice, i think you are the most likely to be mafia. In fact, if you end up mafia, i'm pretty sure i know who the others are. Remember the first lynch, 5 people voted for drazak. Sonic Death Monkey was townie, sharrant was townie, i am townie and that leaves you and kush. KillingTime, Dandel Ion, Sharrant, JacobStrangelove and you voted for another townie on the second lynch. Among kush, you, killing, dandel, and jacobs, i find it hard to believe that none of you would be mafia. I mean the possibility that none of the people who's vote landed on a guy dead being mafia is just near impossible. There are 3~4 mafia out of a possible 7 people (excluding me). If those 5 people aren't mafia, well that doesn't make sense. So at least 1 of you 5 must be the mafia. And because you appeared twice, you seem alittle more suspicious than the other 4. Now i am going to bed. I guess you are going to die, unless something happens like last time were people changed their votes the last hour, and i suspect that might happen again. sharky at this phase in the game you need to be 100% sure. don't just quit out this early. if we mislynch then the game is pretty much over. what do you think about debears? | ||
|
kushm4sta
United States8878 Posts
What I mean is you accuse someone new every hour hoping to get people to jump him. And when they don't you switch to someone else easy as that and try again. The only people.you haven't accused directly are Jacob and me. I forget who called you the boy who cried wolf but it's quite apt. | ||
|
kushm4sta
United States8878 Posts
| ||
| ||
StarCraft 2 StarCraft: Brood War Dota 2 Counter-Strike Heroes of the Storm Other Games summit1g6433 Grubby5600 ScreaM2727 FrodaN1871 Beastyqt1255 shahzam304 B2W.Neo256 elazer253 C9.Mang0155 ZombieGrub51 Trikslyr37 trigger1 |
|
Replay Cast
ReBellioN vs HonMonO
The PondCast
WardiTV Invitational
Replay Cast
OSC
Replay Cast
Replay Cast
CranKy Ducklings
[BSL 2025] Weekly
Replay Cast
[ Show More ] |
|
|
EPT
