| Forum Index > Closed |
|
pyogenes
Brazil1401 Posts
On May 30 2004 22:11 BroOd wrote: Far from simple. To say something is "no-rules" adds far too many variables. how is this then? they magically warp into a street that has nothing nearby (cars trashcans etc) ?? thats what "no rules" means. | ||
BroOd
Austin10831 Posts
On May 30 2004 22:12 Mydnyte wrote: He was helping you understand the point you missed. Actually, he made an inflamatory statement about an exchange he had nothing to do with, much like yourself. So how about you let Mommy and Daddy talk, and keep on posting yawn faces like a good little boy? | ||
Hot_Bid
Braavos36379 Posts
On May 30 2004 21:06 BroOd wrote: So basically you would choose the rules of the fight to cater to one of the fighters? that's the point--there are no rules... | ||
|
BroOd
Austin10831 Posts
On May 30 2004 22:14 intotherei wrote: how is this then? they magically warp into a street that has nothing nearby (cars trashcans etc) ?? thats what "no rules" means. Because now you're stretching this imaginary fight into borderline ridiculous. If you're trying to objectively decide who would win the fight, why create settings that heavily favor one fighting style over the other? As Tien put it, it would be the fight Lee had been training all his life for. A bit unfair, don't you think? Even hypothetically, "warping" into a street or alleyway or another random location simply adds too many variables. | ||
|
Mydnyte
3306 Posts
On May 30 2004 22:16 BroOd wrote: Actually, he made an inflamatory statement about an exchange he had nothing to do with, much like yourself. So how about you let Mommy and Daddy talk, and keep on posting yawn faces like a good little boy? Ok idiot.  | ||
FakeSteve[TPR]
Valhalla18444 Posts
On May 30 2004 22:16 BroOd wrote: Actually, he made an inflamatory statement about an exchange he had nothing to do with, much like yourself. So how about you let Mommy and Daddy talk, and keep on posting yawn faces like a good little boy? Badum ching | ||
|
pyogenes
Brazil1401 Posts
----------------------- no its not imaginary or borderline ridiculous. i wrote "warp" so you wouldnt nitpick. would you like this better? they both walked into the street with nothing nearby. If you're trying to objectively decide who would win the fight, why create settings that heavily favor one fighting style over the other? -------------------- because the outcome is dependant on the setting, no setting was specified thus my answer is dependant on the setting. there is no "objective" answer because, well.... rewind a line  As Tien put it, it would be the fight Lee had been training all his life for. A bit unfair, don't you think? ----------- just like if you put lee in the ring, its the fight ali has been training his whole life for Even hypothetically, "warping" into a street or alleyway or another random location simply adds too many variables. ----------- lol no it doesnt. specify how? | ||
|
Mydnyte
3306 Posts
  | ||
|
FakeSteve[TPR]
Valhalla18444 Posts
| ||
|
Mydnyte
3306 Posts
On May 30 2004 22:29 Rt-S.FakeSteve wrote: Hush  | ||
|
BroOd
Austin10831 Posts
I wasn't nitpicking warp at all, and yes, it is imaginary. And let's take a step back here. The whole "street-fight" idea is ridiculous. If the two were fighting, it would most certainly be a professional one. It's not pick-up basketball we're talking about. One could argue that one offended another on the street, and they decided to fight, but that adds an emotional variable, not to mention who gets the first strike of the fight. "because the outcome is dependant on the setting, no setting was specified thus my answer is dependant on the setting." We're discussing a fight between two legends, and your result is based on a setting? What's the point? "just like if you put lee in the ring, its the fight ali has been training his whole life for" You're re-iterating my point exactly. I never said put them in a ring, because that would be hypocritical, wouldn't it? "lol no it doesnt. specify how?" Because this fight isn't taking place in a vacuum. "The best-laid plans of mice and men often go astry." | ||
|
pyogenes
Brazil1401 Posts
there is no real answer unless the questoin is more defined. i defined the questoin and i gave answers based upon those definitions | ||
|
Zerius[TPR]
Canada1633 Posts
Oh and Im pretty sure i saw one guy is argueing for Lee because "asians are mysterious and scary". No Comment on that mental debacle. | ||
|
BroOd
Austin10831 Posts
| ||
|
pyogenes
Brazil1401 Posts
its like saying "would boxer beat yellow" when?! when boxer is t and yellow is z and lt? or on gaema gowun or what!! the questoin merely needs definition | ||
|
pyogenes
Brazil1401 Posts
On May 30 2004 22:51 Zerius wrote: there have been many good argumenst for both though! Close this topic, its just a waste of time. Ali supporters will continue to use the "twice as big, just as fast, way stronger, and infinitely more experienced" arguement, and the Lee supporters will use examples from his movies, and "credible" quotes from other movie stars about how he was basically invincible. Oh and Im pretty sure i saw one guy is argueing for Lee because "asians are mysterious and scary". No Comment on that mental debacle. | ||
|
BroOd
Austin10831 Posts
| ||
|
pyogenes
Brazil1401 Posts
On May 30 2004 22:56 BroOd wrote: i'm not trying to be an ass, but, shit really? i didnt know that. NO WONDER I FAILED ENGLISH 8 TEIMES??I'm not trying to be an ass, but just so you know, it's "question". edit: maybe u dont get my sarcasm, so ill lay it out for u ppl are sleeping and i awnna be quiet so i make alot of typos when im typing ok?? question just happened to have many typos in a row ._. | ||
|
BroOd
Austin10831 Posts
On May 30 2004 22:54 intotherei wrote: unanswerable when undefined just as many other questoins would be its like saying "would boxer beat yellow" when?! when boxer is t and yellow is z and lt? or on gaema gowun or what!! the questoin merely needs definition Well, I think you're wrong. No matter how many paramaters you add, as long as they remain moderately balanced, either one could win on any given day. The same also applies to Ali/Lee. | ||
|
pyogenes
Brazil1401 Posts
On May 30 2004 22:59 BroOd wrote: really? what if one of them was trapped in an unbreakable box and the other one could push a button filling the box with water and theres absolutely no way the box would break or open. what then? haha going out on a tangent just to be sillyWell, I think you're wrong. No matter how many paramaters you add, as long as they remain moderately balanced, either one could win on any given day. The same also applies to Ali/Lee. | ||
| ||
[ Submit Event ] |
|
|
|
BSL Team Wars
Team Bonyth vs Team Dewalt
Dewalt vs kogeT
JDConan vs Tarson
RaNgeD vs DragOn
StRyKeR vs Bonyth
Aeternum vs Hejek
IPSL
DragOn vs Fear
Radley vs eOnzErG
Replay Cast
Map Test Tournament
PiGosaur Monday
Map Test Tournament
Tenacious Turtle Tussle
The PondCast
Map Test Tournament
Map Test Tournament
[ Show More ] |
|
|
EPT
