|
On March 06 2013 14:37 thrawn2112 wrote:Show nested quote +On March 06 2013 14:07 Hapahauli wrote:
The point I'm trying to make is that there's good reason to have reasonable doubt about Jay's alignment right now, and I want to take the extra time. Is this because of how you view him as being lynch bait, or is there something specifically about this game that gives you reason to doubt? Can you comment on this post: Show nested quote +On March 06 2013 12:14 thrawn2112 wrote:On March 06 2013 10:22 jaybrundage wrote:
Vivax last posts seem geniune. Also i respect Hapa's opinion alot.
##Unvote
##Vote Thrawn
Thrawn's scum meta is lurking HARD. So far he has fit the bill perfectly. As i can recall he said at the beginning that he didn't look at his role pm. And when he does look at it he starting his lurking marathon. If you look at Normal Mini IV Iamp called out thrawn on it. And lo and behold thrawn was scum. just look at that post is that a justifiable reasoning for a vote? and yet, he's acting so sure about it. the best part about his line of reasoning is that it doesn't present anything to argue about... it's not an opinion on my overall play so far, it neither quotes or references anything from my filter that he is suspicious of. it's such an easy justification for him to give because there's actually no room for someone to really disagree with him about it We're finally at a point in the game where we should be held accountable for our votes and this vote from jay is just lazy as all hell. There are NO opinion about any of my reads, NO opinion about how I've acted thus far, NO actual discussion about the differences (other than activity) between my scum/town meta, etc. As I said in the above quote, the stance he's taken is basically a non-stance. It doesn't leave room for argument and contains none of his own opinions concerning my scumminess. His vote is something he can justify as "well in general thrawn is lurky as scum" and there is nothing at all confrontational about that statement.
It's the lynch-bait view. I really like to be patient with those types of players.
It's never bad to take extra time. We'll either confirm our read, or give himself the opportunity to prove that he's town. Both are great outcomes.
|
Vote Count
jaybrundage (4) - Mr. Cheesecake, thrawn2112, DoctorHelvetica, Promethelax
Vivax (1) - Artanis[Xp]
thrawn2112 (1) - jaybrundage
Not Voting (3) - Hapahauli, Dandel Ion, Vivax
With 9 alive it takes 5 to lynch.
On March 06 2013 10:11 Vivax wrote:
Thrawn is someone I didn't consider yet I wouldn't be in grief for lynching him given he's playing trollish casual unreadable etc.
##Unvote
##thrawn2112
A little vote to wake him up.
This has not been counted as a vote.
|
Yeah but at some point we have to hammer somebody and I see no reason to go past a 72 hour mark. Eventually we'll reach a time when discussions keep revolving around in the same circles and tbh I'm inclined to think anybody who wants to extend the lynches forever is scum buying time.
|
anyone got something they wanna talk about? kinda bored atm
scum are probably:
jay, vivax, maybe dandel lon, and a very small chance of mr CC
|
##unvote
don't want anyone to hammer
|
Jay is my lynch you nubcakes I take credit for it and no one else here. His reaction is scummy he fights back lynches as town I know the disheartened feeling you get as scum when people find suspicious that's what I see on him.
Let's see who has the balls to hammer him.
Also, Prom is probably bussing. His switch to jay doesn't make any sense.
##Unvote
##Vote jaybrundage
|
Also it's morning so I'm writing like I have the spastics. Thrawn is unlurky enough to have some slack for now, but his read on me is terrible, too much 420 I believe.
|
On March 06 2013 16:50 Vivax wrote:
Also it's morning so I'm writing like I have the spastics. Thrawn is unlurky enough to have some slack for now, but his read on me is terrible, too much 420 I believe.
what does this mean?
you say "but his read is terrible" and "too much 420"... those are opposing statements. one suggests i'm town and one suggests i'm scum
and fuck i really wanna hammer jay lol
|
HELLO
who is STRONGLY opposed to not lynching jay? how long do we wait?
|
wat
ebwop:
who is strongly opposed to lynching jay?
|
@jay
you mentioned that you don't mind being lynched if it leads to town seeing who the scum are
there are like 6-7 people so far who have voted or might vote for you, which of them do you think is scum? what info can you give us about this lynch?
can you give an answer to this post:
On March 06 2013 11:57 thrawn2112 wrote:Show nested quote +On March 06 2013 11:55 jaybrundage wrote:
Sigh whatever if you town needs to lynch me to see who the scum that lead my lynch im fine with that.
jay, are you really that confident about your read on me, which was ENTIRELY based on meta, that you are already resigning to "go ahead and lynch me, you'll see thrawn is scum then" ?? please tell me more about this vote you've got on me
and also please explain your current thoughts on me, my meta, my vote for you, etc
|
Morning.
Jay looks awful. It makes little sense that he'd resign this easily while contributing absolutely nothing. Since there's no vigi possible in any of the setups and we can be pretty sure scum won't shoot him when he isn't scum we'd have this question roaming around town until we decide to lynch him. I want to give Jay one last chance to come up with his own reads before anyone hammers him though. The lynch is going very easily, but it could be a bus so eh.
Regarding Vivax:
I still think the post I made on him regarding the FoS thing is strong, and it's still a cause for concern. However, his posting as of late has been good and that can't be overlooked. I'm not willing to lynch him right now after the interactions he's had with Promethelax especially, in which I'd say the latter didn't look as good. He seems suspicious of everyone, is throwing his votes around and commenting on a lot of things. If he's scum, I should be able to find something other than the nugget I had. I haven't yet. Prome's case on him feels weak.
Regarding his case on me:
He keeps stressing the point about me calling out Hapa on his town reads and calling it buddying. I found it suspicious that he was happy to call people townie for such little reason, which presumed me to believe he was trying to gain favour from people. Furthermore, I hadn't even read my role yet so there was little reason for me to pursue scum agenda there. I didn't even make reads on the guys he called green yet, I just saw that post, had read the posts before and thought "what, how can you say that after this little content" after which I posted the comment I did.
Regarding Helvetica's post:
His vote post is so wishy washy that it's obviously just a pressure vote rather than actually suspecting me. His main argument is that I'm noncommital; I'm always noncommital. I'm an honest person in character and find it difficult to overexaggerate things or try to mislead people, so I don't do those things. I push people as strong as my case is, and my case on Vivax rested on the meta argument I provided before. I don't pretend to be more confident then I am. As for the argument that Prome is playing different from his meta: I haven't digged into it yet. You can't expect me to meta read every single player in the game before making statements about them.
Tl;dr I'm not willing to lynch Vivax anymore until I get more evidence that he is scum and I'm good with a jay lynch unless he suddenly improves strongly. I still want to give him a chance to reply though.
## Unvote
|
Oh and I'm going to look into Prome and his meta later.
|
jay if I wake up tomorrow and you've not responded i'm hammering you.
that's enough from me for now, tired of talking to myself. you guys are so boring........... as soon as I start posting everyone leaves TT.
|
|
|
hullo
I couldn't get a feel for who you're actually wanting to lynch... looks like it's jay? Except your stance is more of a "wait and see" instead of a "I want to lynch this guy" approach.
|
I want to lynch Jay if he doesn't strongly up his game. Prome is my second suspect but I still need to do more research for that which I'm too lazy to do right now but will get to later.
|
|
|
Great, now we're not allowed to post and hosts are probably sleeping 
|
Blazinghand
United States25558 Posts
Vote Count
jaybrundage (5) - Mr. Cheesecake, DoctorHelvetica, Promethelax, Vivax, thrawn2112
thrawn2112 (1) - jaybrundage
Not Voting (3) - Hapahauli, Dandel Ion, Artanis[Xp]
With 9 alive it takes 5 to lynch.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
