|
Patience and Golden instead of XlorD and HaNfy who have more results??
Your Korean bias showing again.
Edit. Oh crap, didn't see Hanfy at first (kinda ashamed of that).
I guess one could argue Patience there instead of Goody for example.
|
On March 18 2018 21:52 D-light wrote:Patience and Golden instead of XlorD and Hanfy who have more results?? Your Korean bias showing again. Hanfy is #7 tho
|
|
I would have appreciated if you would have asked, but it's not a huge deal either way. Not sure if a goat community ranking is the best idea, we will see what happens. Happy that i don't have to do this one though
|
|
|
|
|
United Kingdom31935 Posts
Mvp is #1 obviously who cares about the rest? Being the 2nd goat is literally meaningless as you ain't the greatest then.
|
|
Pandemona
Charlie Sheens House51448 Posts
|
|
United States33069 Posts
Why do you demand TLPD? It hasn't updated games since 2016.
|
|
On March 18 2018 22:20 Leviance wrote:1.-10.: ActionJesuz
cmon, let Lucifron have #10
|
1. Life 2. INnoVation 3. Mvp 4. sOs 5. soO 6. TaeJa 7. MC 8. MMA 9. PartinG 10. Bomber
Its really hard to put some of the guys on the list because thwy played at different periods of the game for different amounts of time.
I think that players who stayed relevant for more years should be ranked high here, while on the other hand we can just guess what would have happened if players started earlier or did not retuere so early in there career ( Jaedong, Mvp)
Others who have not made the list would be:
Zest
Polt
Jaedong
Could not put Polt in the Top 10 because his results were a little inflated in my opinion. I love him but i could not haha
For Jaedong, just think about how he entered the game, completly dominated it for one year (2013) and then had decent results 2014, while still not overcomming a mentale barrier to win the tournaments he played in. Would have loved to see how he would have played skill wise if he played SC2 for a longer period.
|
Austria24417 Posts
|
(Here is my edited list. The original is below the edited list for posterity.)
Edited list (actual submission):
1. INnoVation 2. Mvp 3. Life 4. Maru 5. soO 6. sOs 7. TaeJa 8. MC 9. PartinG 10. Polt
After thinking about it more, although Zest at his peak was the epitome of clean, well-rounded play, I'm not sure he really makes the cut. Similarly, Dark is great, but I'm not sure he has much more of a definitive place than Rogue (whose peak play level may be even higher than Dark's), for example. I put in PartinG because his overall results give him an arguable claim, and I like him. Simple as that.
I wanted to put NesTea on the list, I really did. I also wasn't sure if maybe MMA belongs in that last spot more than Polt. I went with Polt because I felt like he remained relevant longer, even though I was a big MMA fan in the early days especially.
For me, the players who I would guess might rise on this list in the next couple years are Maru (if he can stay in form -- PLEAAASSE stay in form, Maru!) and Rogue (come hell or high water). Also, give it a few years and I hope we'll see Reynor on this list. He looks to me like the new Life.
Lastly, I think it would be interesting to make a community list of "scariest players at their peak", where we might see more of a case for players like Dear, for example, and where I think Rogue and Maru would be much higher on the list.
#####
Original post:
1. INnoVation 2. Mvp 3. Life 4. soO 5. Maru 6. sOs 7. Dark 8. TaeJa 9. MC 10. Zest
This gets tricky and a bit arbitrary after the First 3... Actually, my Judgement is a lot more subjective after #4. And I really only feel totally 100% sure about #1.
|
|
|
|
|
|