EPTdifferent tier. wouldn't be fair to the others to have to be compared to them
Greatest Players of All Time: Part 2 - Page 10
| Forum Index > SC2 General |
Shellshock
United States97276 Posts
different tier. wouldn't be fair to the others to have to be compared to them | ||
|
Sakkreth
Lithuania1096 Posts
| ||
|
Undead1993
Germany17651 Posts
On April 19 2015 04:09 Sakkreth wrote: Haha all those americans with polt making top 5, stop being delusional. do you really want to argue with this? ![[image loading]](http://www.teamliquid.net/staff/Waxangel/GSL/fionn/5Poltimus.jpg) | ||
|
Boucot
France15997 Posts
Because I don't see how one of these players could not be there. | ||
|
i-MajiN
France113 Posts
He just won olimoleague today and these past two years made him one of the most greatest players ;p It's really hard to make this kind of ranking but the writer make a good job. Maybe the top 20 could be satisfy much people with others stars like Parting sOs Bomber and why not soulkey or Stephano | ||
|
Undead1993
Germany17651 Posts
On April 19 2015 04:17 Boucot wrote: My theory is that both Polt and PartinG will be in the list, with MC and TaeJa. And Mvp/Life tied for the first place. So 6 players in the top 5. Because I don't see how one of these players could not be there. i can see easily parting not being there. i think you guys overhype him quite a bit | ||
|
Makro
France16890 Posts
On April 19 2015 04:17 Boucot wrote: My theory is that both Polt and PartinG will be in the list, with MC and TaeJa. And Mvp/Life tied for the first place. So 6 players in the top 5. Because I don't see how one of these players could not be there. considering the reasoning of stuchiu and the fact that taeja won most of his stuff outside korea, it would make sense that taeja is not in the top 5 then again i'm not sure of anything at this point | ||
|
Nirel
Israel1526 Posts
| ||
|
Shellshock
United States97276 Posts
On April 19 2015 04:20 Undead1993 wrote: i can see easily parting not being there. i think you guys overhype him quite a bit I may or may not have seen the final 5 and stephano and/or parting may or may not be in it | ||
Darkhorse
United States23455 Posts
Also dae where the hell is aLive? I guess you are saving him for top 5 stu? So it'll be 5. Polt 4. Taeja 3. Life 2. aLive 1. Mvp ? | ||
|
FueledUpAndReadyToGo
Netherlands30548 Posts
| ||
|
FrostedMiniWheats
United States30730 Posts
As for Rain, I don't think he belongs here at all and certainly not as high as he is. Yes his rapid string of top-tier results after transitioning over to sc2 are impressive and especially since he innovated so quickly. Yet, outside of both of his OSL runs, his premiere results are kind of weak compared to what you'd expect for a top 16 player. WCS Asia was a bunch of foreigners and PvP, where Rain only played one top-tier PvP for that run (PartinG). I'm not even sure the 2013 Hotsix cup should be a tier-1 event considering the format was only a ro8 (where he played a slumping Symbol and Dear to get to the finals) over the span of 4 days.. Then there's the consistency route, where Rain is one of very few reliable Protoss players. Yet, even in that regard, Rain got not one, but TWO charity seeds into code S. Now, I'm not stupid enough to think that Rain wouldn't have eventually made it in to code S, but there's no denying that it greatly accelerated things for him. Back then you couldn't go from code B to champ in one season. Given how closely contested this list is, I think that's a notable blemish on Rain. Especially when he's ahead of the likes of Maru, who's gotten ro8+ in nearly everything since winning his OSL while even up against huge imbalance. | ||
|
Yorkie
United States12612 Posts
On April 19 2015 04:22 Shellshock wrote: I may or may not have seen the final 5 and stephano and/or parting may or may not be in it Good top 5 should be 5. herO 4. Polt 3. Stephano 2. Mvp 1. Life Taeja obviously not in it because he never won anything until he ran away to take money from foreigners. Parting never won GSL so he doesn't deserve top 15 either. | ||
|
Dreamer.T
United States3584 Posts
| ||
|
KingofdaHipHop
United States25602 Posts
| ||
|
Undead1993
Germany17651 Posts
On April 19 2015 04:33 Yorkie wrote: Good top 5 should be 5. herO 4. Polt 3. Stephano 2. Mvp 1. Life Taeja obviously not in it because he never won anything until he ran away to take money from foreigners. Parting never won GSL so he doesn't deserve top 15 either. the salt but what is herO doing there | ||
|
Dodgin
Canada39254 Posts
| ||
|
Frakkofff
Russian Federation66 Posts
I miss you old man. | ||
|
PinheadXXXXXX
United States897 Posts
On April 19 2015 04:21 Makro wrote: considering the reasoning of stuchiu and the fact that taeja won most of his stuff outside korea, it would make sense that taeja is not in the top 5 then again i'm not sure of anything at this point Taeja not in the top 15 would be a travesty though. Maybe he should have been in #6-10, but his accomplishments are far too numerous and impressive to leave him out of the list entirely, and he hasn't been already listed... Edit: Taeja is also on the frontpage picture of the article. I don't know if that means anything. | ||
|
DarkPlasmaBall
United States45221 Posts
On April 19 2015 04:17 Boucot wrote: My theory is that both Polt and PartinG will be in the list, with MC and TaeJa. And Mvp/Life tied for the first place. So 6 players in the top 5. Because I don't see how one of these players could not be there. Yeah, honestly, one of them not being in the top five means they weren't even good enough up be in the top fifteen, which is incredible. | ||
| ||
