EPTScariest Starcraft 2 Player [Teamliquid Pick] - Page 2
| Forum Index > SC2 General |
|
FatBat
Germany326 Posts
| ||
|
KalWarkov
Germany4126 Posts
 Foreign Group Bwith Foreign Group Dpretty much shows how bad thought out this is. i like the idea, but it couldve been done so much better. | ||
|
Eee
Sweden2712 Posts
| ||
|
StarGalaxy
Germany744 Posts
The votes are very subjective. Is there any system for the Group Assigning? my subjective opinion: not sure if Bischu deserves his spot, not that he is bad, but i would rate others more highly (maybe axlav, monchi etc. ) i would choose TheStC over fOrGG,GanZi, sC, Ryung,... at any day I would choose any player out of Foreign Zerg Group B and C over all the players from Foreign Zerg Group D And an other group of death: Foreign Protoss Group B | ||
|
FiWiFaKi
Canada9858 Posts
On April 10 2012 08:08 OrbitalPlane wrote: looks like a fun idea^^ The votes are very subjective. Is there any system for the Group Assigning? my subjective opinion: not sure if Bischu deserves his spot, not that he is bad, but i would rate others more highly (maybe axlav, monchi etc. ) i would choose TheStC over fOrGG,GanZi, sC, Ryung,... at any day I would choose any player out of Foreign Zerg Group B and C over all the players from Foreign Zerg Group D And an other group of death: Foreign Protoss Group B I chose 16 players that I felt that qualified and ordered them by their ELO ranking (if I ranked them from strongest to weakest according to me I don't think it'd be fair)... Groups were assigned: 1,8,9,16 2,7,10,15 3,6,11,14 4,5,12,13 And to the other question, the Top 2 Advance. | ||
|
FatBat
Germany326 Posts
| ||
|
StarGalaxy
Germany744 Posts
On April 10 2012 08:13 FatBat wrote: But then the poll system is a bit off because u can only vote on time. For example zerg group A: Noone cant deny stephano is the "scariest" zerg from all of these. So he will have like 95% of the votes. And the other are kinda decided by some fanboys u give the person like 50 votes. Its not really decided then by the community. I have to agree, but i am pretty sure you can't do polls on TL with more than one option. | ||
|
IMNasty
663 Posts
if you want the "scariest player" overall just pick top 5 korean terran/zerg/protoss and have a vote from those | ||
|
Corsica
Ukraine1854 Posts
| ||
|
FiWiFaKi
Canada9858 Posts
On April 10 2012 08:17 IMNasty wrote: are you trying to make a list at the end or just find the best overall? because a list doesn't work because by selecting the same amount of players between foreigner and korean you are under the assumption that foreigner skill and korean skill levels are equal, which is obviously not true. if you are keeping the comparisons separate then it would work well. if you want the "scariest player" overall just pick top 5 korean terran/zerg/protoss and have a vote from those I guess I'd want to kill more than one bird with one stone, so we can see who the best of each race is, foreign or korean. On April 10 2012 08:13 FatBat wrote: But then the poll system is a bit off because u can only vote on time. For example zerg group A: Noone cant deny stephano is the "scariest" zerg from all of these. So he will have like 95% of the votes. And the other are kinda decided by some fanboys u give the person like 50 votes. Its not really decided then by the community. Overall I don't think it's a huge concern, I think the scariest two will find themselves on top, I agree it isn't perfect, but since there can only be one option this method is better than doing a single elimination because really good players can find themselves out very early. The other alternative is have two of each poll and total the votes between the two polls, but that is too complicated. | ||
Shellshock
United States97274 Posts
| ||
|
DamnCats
United States1472 Posts
| ||
|
Striker.superfreunde
Germany1118 Posts
I think a scary player is a realy hard to estimate one. So i would say Naama and GoOdy are two hard to estimate players. Naama because of his unconventional, but well thougt out one-base all-ins and GoOdy because of his realy not so common mech style and his patience. Both are having their weaksnesses, but they are also able to play down a standard (not exemplary, but solid) macro game. I don't know the other terras (or even races) well enough to make a judge about them. so this is only my personal opinion! | ||
|
CeriseCherries
6170 Posts
On April 10 2012 08:05 ZenithM wrote: MMA's less than average TvP is here to remind us that Flash still doesn't play SC2. + Show Spoiler + But honestly, if his TvP and TvT were as strong as his TvZ, he would probably be unbeatable until BW S-class switch or something :D lets not forget Flash's own less than perfect TvP Foreigner zerg group D -_____- snute too strong I honestly don't disagree with any of the current ratings... its just harder to say with foregienrs | ||
|
Fawkes
Canada1935 Posts
On April 10 2012 08:05 ZenithM wrote: MMA's less than average TvP is here to remind us that Flash still doesn't play SC2. + Show Spoiler + But honestly, if his TvP and TvT were as strong as his TvZ, he would probably be unbeatable until BW S-class switch or something :D SC2 TvP is why Flash hasn't switched over obviously! | ||
|
Aunvilgod
2653 Posts
On April 10 2012 08:39 Fawkes wrote: SC2 TvP is why Flash hasn't switched over obviously! Flash would innovate the matchup and go Air-Terran. | ||
|
stichtom
Italy695 Posts
NightEnd > Fraer Bling > Titan Are you kidding me ? | ||
|
dgwow
Canada1024 Posts
KOREAN Terran: MKP Protoss: Genius Zerg: DongRaeGu FOREIGN: Terran: ThorZaiN Protoss: HuK Zerg: Stephano Most of these aren't really debatable, perhaps T & P for Koreans, especially protoss as there isn't really a dominant player right now, with many good consistent protoss but not GSL champion level. | ||
|
HuKPOWA
United States1604 Posts
But it is fun to see who wins <3 | ||
|
00Visor
4337 Posts
![[image loading]](http://i.qkme.me/359ts7.jpg) | ||
| ||
