|
On May 18 2011 21:49 KaRath_ wrote:
I see a lot of hate going towards Kelly.... maybe because she's actually shoutcasting in the GSL and some people aren't?
I do not understand why anyone would have to rate shoutcasters, because you can't compare one shoutcaster to another. Yes, you'll have "bad" shoutcasters, but none of the above are bad shoutcasters, they are all excellent.
You ever heard the term White Knight? People rag on Kelly because they find her hard to listen to. To me she's worse than all TSL casters (D9, Husky, Wheat, Chill etc), all GSL casters, the Dreamhack Invitational casters (Apollo & DeMuslim) and some youtube casters so i personally wouldn't call her excellent.
|
My Rating's:
Artosis: Excellent, Nerd god amongst men!
Tastless: Excellent, LadderSlayer!!
Kelly: Good, Got better as she became more comfortable
Doa: Good, Hope he can hang around really enjoy his casts
Moletrap: Good, Love his research/knowledge of the players, good caster aswell
just my 2cents 
|
I don't think this is all that relevant. Regardless of fan reaction, the casters will keep casting because as of now there's no one better willing to do it. Additionally, haters gonna hate.
|
United States1383 Posts
Tastosis definately reigns over everyone else. Im so excited for Columbus just for the fact of seeing them. Their analysis is great and their banter is so hilarious. They are miles above everyone else.
I love Doa/Moletrap. I think they are both around good or the C to B range. They just haven't been together as long and dont have the connection that tastosis does.
and Kelly is just....well im with the majority
|
On May 18 2011 21:52 karpo wrote:Show nested quote +On May 18 2011 21:49 KaRath_ wrote:
I see a lot of hate going towards Kelly.... maybe because she's actually shoutcasting in the GSL and some people aren't?
I do not understand why anyone would have to rate shoutcasters, because you can't compare one shoutcaster to another. Yes, you'll have "bad" shoutcasters, but none of the above are bad shoutcasters, they are all excellent. You ever heard the term White Knight? People rag on Kelly because they find her hard to listen to. To me she's worse than all TSL casters (D9, Husky, Wheat, Chill etc), all GSL casters, the Dreamhack Invitational casters (Apollo & DeMuslim) and some youtube casters so i personally wouldn't call her excellent.
There is no godamn excuse she's fucking bad, her voice and pronunciation is fucking horrendous: The two godamn keypoints on being a godamn caster.
Get over it, seriously.
What is wrong with all her fans? Yes she loves games and YES that's great and yeah she wants to work in esports but NO she is not cut out to be a fucking caster. Point.
There is no argument, the majority of people agree and I don't get why anyone would take this as a personal assult on her as a person? Jesus fuck we hardly know anything about her unless you've looked it up, I haven't looked up shit on Moletrap/Doa and I don't care, I care about their CASTING and they're atleast bearable, Kelly is NOT. Not for the majority of people and THAT makes her a bad caster.
Sorry for swearing but there's so much blind zealos fanboyism about this and sometimes these arguments will actually be taken seriously and I dread the day we have Kelly casting a IPL/NASL/GSL because her fans think she's a great person. She might be, she is not a good caster.
|
Rating casters as "Horrible" are people that have serious issues or are just spoiled by too much Tastosis. Moletrap is an excellent caster and they both make a great team. This poll is a bit inconsequential anyway as most people know that Tastosis will get mostly positive votes.
|
On May 18 2011 22:03 Krehlmar wrote:
There is no godamn excuse she's fucking bad, her voice and pronunciation is fucking horrendous: The two godamn keypoints on being a godamn caster.
I'm betting 8/10 that the majority of people who are thinking above are native english speakings... Pretty sure most of us non native speakings understood her perfectly... and lets be honest, if to get better a language thats not your native, want to know whats the only solution? Practice it...
Tbh, there are more native english casters who annoy the crap out of me and make me want to go off streams then kelly... Yet those casters are seen as great casters by the native one's! Now explain that to me....
Greetings
Drakey
|
Just look at moletrap and doa failing today at gstl nuff said, i think they dont work well as a team.
|
Voted Good for artosis by mistake.
Meant
Excellent
Good
Horrible
Average
Average
|
On May 18 2011 22:12 Drakey wrote:Show nested quote +On May 18 2011 22:03 Krehlmar wrote:
There is no godamn excuse she's fucking bad, her voice and pronunciation is fucking horrendous: The two godamn keypoints on being a godamn caster.
I'm betting 8/10 that the majority of people who are thinking above are native english speakings... Pretty sure most of us non native speakings understood her perfectly... and lets be honest, if to get better a language thats not your native, want to know whats the only solution? Practice it...
I have been speaking English my entire life, and I had very little problem understanding her. My theory is that people were so used to the voices of Artosis and Tasteless that a female voice threw them off.
|
I dont like Doa and Moletrap very much  maybe because tastosis is soooo much better.
|
On May 18 2011 22:12 Drakey wrote:Show nested quote +On May 18 2011 22:03 Krehlmar wrote:
There is no godamn excuse she's fucking bad, her voice and pronunciation is fucking horrendous: The two godamn keypoints on being a godamn caster.
I'm betting 8/10 that the majority of people who are thinking above are native english speakings... Pretty sure most of us non native speakings understood her perfectly... and lets be honest, if to get better a language thats not your native, want to know whats the only solution? Practice it... Tbh, there are more native english casters who annoy the crap out of me and make me want to go off streams then kelly... Yet those casters are seen as great casters by the native one's! Now explain that to me.... Greetings Drakey
Most singaporean listeners don't like her either. She's now trying to cater to the Chinese casting community instead.
|
Moletrap and Tastosis make sooo many puns, which i love, but they take them too far.
|
Excellent
Excellent
Average
Good
Average
|
Excellent
Excellent
Bad
Horrible
Horrible
|
Does anyone else think Doa and Moletraps voiced should be swapped with their bodies? It just seems like they would fit better that way,,,
|
Kelly knowledge wise was fine, she is a master of many languages, however when it came to casting in English I found it very hard to understand her and some of her phrases made no sense. I am sure if she was casting in her native language and I was native at that language, then she would be good. Sadly as an English caster there are many I would prefer to listen to
|
Artosis's love for this game make him the best. Moletrap need to improve his teamwork.
|
Artosis > Tasteless > DOA > Moletrap > Kelly.
Artosis wins by far IMO. He's smart, loves the game, has great enthusiasm and bountiful knowledge. Only improvement he could make is to switch back to Zerg but I guess I'm biased lol.
Keep up the good work Artosis. The GSL wouldn't be the same without you.
|
Well of course I love Tastosis,who doesn't, so excellent 4 them.
Voted good on Kelly and Doa,they're both very enthousiastic and u can tell by watching their casts that they love e-sports. Plus I don't have a hard time understanding her,so her accent is not an issue for me.
Not a huge fan of Moletrap though, I just find his voice kind of annoying and he interrupts his co-caster way too often . Maybe he's doing a better job in his solo casts, but I've never watched any of that stuff.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
