EPT
. My votes:
Excellent
Excellent
Average
Good
Good
GSL Casters Survey - Page 22
| Forum Index > SC2 General |
|
Kar98
Australia924 Posts
. My votes: Excellent Excellent Average Good Good | ||
|
Rabbitmaster
1357 Posts
Tasteless: Good. Very close to excellent tbh, but i had to distinguish him from artosis somehow. Solid casting, very funny but could use some more game knowledge. Also "Tastosis" has like the best chemistry of any caster-team ive ever seen. Kelly: Bad. What she said was not actually bad, but i can not help it if i find her dialect incredibly annoying. Sorry Kelly! :< DOA: Average. Haven't seen too much from this guy, but when ive tuned in to GSL code A hes been OK i suppose. Moletrap: Average. Pretty much the same as above (DOA). | ||
|
Deleted User 183001
2939 Posts
I could understand Kelly's accent, but her voice was not too pleasing to the ears, to understate it. Sometimes she casted with some knowledge of the game, and other times not so much. Not particularly great imo. | ||
|
Bunnypanda
United States103 Posts
She is a girl so you hate her She is foreign so you hate her She *insert stupid here* so you hate her This is the main reasons people have issues with Kelly. Please note I say issues because nobody really hates her, that is just a convenient(but terrible) fallback for you to argue with. She has a heavy accent, it is very noticeable She gets excited and her voice goes up in a high shrieking pitch She has very general and average game knowledge She very often speak in absolutes, she is predicting things wrong based on the information she has yet she will carry on this idea until the cows come home Now don't get me wrong, i am not saying this just so i can bash Kelly, I'm merely pointing out the facts here. I think she could be a great addition to casters if she works on her English and game knowledge. And as far as i know from watching her stream, she is trying to improve and she is even taking English speaking lessons, clearly she is trying and that is great. If there is anything this community needs it's more females taking charge and showing that this is not a male only esport. It is just a bit unfortunate that the first girl to get a big break happened to also have some major flaws that the majority(please see the polls) say cannot be discounted simply because she is female and should "catch a break" for it. All in all, i hope that more girls do casting / pro gaming, it will do wonders for the community as a whole. Moletrap looks like a cuddly little mole, he is adorable how can anyone not love him. Artosis is probably the most passionate guy i have ever heard cast a game of starcraft, bar none. Tasteless is funny, has great play by play and his analytical bits are picking up quite well. He is my favorite caster right now. Doa has a lot to learn i think, his analysis is too often wrong, he too often say the wrong things. But he can only improve, and from watching him do Code A the first time with Kelly, he has noticeably improved. | ||
|
Yoshi Kirishima
United States10382 Posts
However... Tasteless is horrible and takes the quality away due to premature GG. Same with Artosis, but he does it to a much smaller, restricted extent. | ||
|
ilmman
364 Posts
| ||
|
Gracksaurusrex
United Kingdom171 Posts
But I guess that he is just showing his love for the game, so I am not going to fault him for that | ||
|
Bobster
Germany3075 Posts
 On May 20 2011 16:30 Kar98 wrote: I thought Doa would get better reviews Yeah, very unhappy with that as well. Oh well, not everyone can have good taste. | ||
|
Bobster
Germany3075 Posts
On May 21 2011 08:04 Bunnypanda wrote: It's pretty funny how people that defend Kelly more often than not take the road of: She is a girl so you hate her She is foreign so you hate her She *insert stupid here* so you hate her This is the main reasons people have issues with Kelly. Please note I say issues because nobody really hates her, that is just a convenient(but terrible) fallback for you to argue with. She has a heavy accent, it is very noticeable She gets excited and her voice goes up in a high shrieking pitch She has very general and average game knowledge She very often speak in absolutes, she is predicting things wrong based on the information she has yet she will carry on this idea until the cows come home Glad to hear someone sticking to the facts and not getting swayed by some laughably emotional sense of subjectivity. On May 21 2011 08:04 Bunnypanda wrote: Moletrap looks like a cuddly little mole, he is adorable how can anyone not love him. ... nevermind. (All joking aside, 3 of the 4 complaints you have about Kelly fit to Moletrap as well. >_>) | ||
nimdil
Poland3772 Posts
 DoA = boring = bad. Moletrap = Excellent. Not that insightful (he sometimes overlooks some things visible on the screen) but extremely entertaining. Plus he is the reason I started reading TeamLiquid this 2 years ago, maybe even more. | ||
|
Bunnypanda
United States103 Posts
On May 22 2011 23:38 Bobster wrote: Glad to hear someone sticking to the facts and not getting swayed by some laughably emotional sense of subjectivity. ... nevermind. (All joking aside, 3 of the 4 complaints you have about Kelly fit to Moletrap as well. >_>) Haha, yeah i was just being funny with moletrap, i don't think hes a great caster at all. The high pitched shriek is what burns my brain. But he does look like a mole, there is no denying that. And i can sorta stand listening to him, because his voice is not horrible. | ||
|
RickOrShay
New Zealand132 Posts
| ||
|
JadedZerg
21 Posts
Kelly was bad or horrible for lack of game knowledge and the voice was terrible DoA I think is average, he doesn't know a lot about the game but enough to be just a caster not a commentator Had to vote horrible for moletrap but maybe he should just be bad. The reason is he often just takes over the cast and his knowledge of the game seems very limited. His voice isn't exactly easy to listen to either, leaving me muting the stream/VoD and playing the terran music and watching for myself. He's not hopeless and can improve, but he seems to be more of a caster rather than a commentator. I'll be looking forward to seeing if Wolf can fill the analytical commentator role that the code a duo lacks. | ||
|
fant0m
964 Posts
Top to bottom: Artosis Tasteless Wolf (already including him here, even though we haven't seen much of him) Moletrap Doa Kelly I'm looking forward to seeing the poll for Wolf after the next season. | ||
|
LuckstYle
Germany181 Posts
| ||
|
leecH
Germany385 Posts
also he is like the guy who knows all the stats. i really like that its like when watching soccer its like "he had a really good season blablabla". i like! | ||
|
cyclone25
Romania3344 Posts
On May 26 2011 21:58 leecH wrote: i hope moletrap will stay to cast GSTL and Code A. he has a really cool and unique voice. he really is up there with my favorite casters. also he is like the guy who knows all the stats. i really like that its like when watching soccer its like "he had a really good season blablabla". i like! You mean: " Moletrap is the guy who reads all the stats." I noticed that his knowledge on players is very poor actually and most of it comes from reading the stats that GSL displays before each match. Calling jookTo a bad player and making fun of him is just one example. People who actually had knowledge on jookTo predicted that he will put up a good fight vs Anypro. | ||
|
karpo
Sweden1998 Posts
Tasteless reiterates the same basic things so many times that it can get annoying. Artosis early GSL casting was very biased (s1/s2 zerg whine), it still shows with his huge hardon for players like Nestea. Kelly has a very thick accent and shrieks when there's action going down. Moletrap talks over other casters, trying to one-up them. Doa is a bit stiff, needs to loosen up a bit. Day9 had the whole "Aha, mm, aha, yeah." deal going whenever the cocaster was talking back in the early tournaments. I mean, people seem to focus on the bad things when all casters have them. Most of the kinks can be worked out with practise and some work i think. Really dislike people that don't give casters a chance before creating a royal shitstorm. | ||
|
Klive5ive
United Kingdom6056 Posts
The "WolfTrap" dynamic was a bit different to what we've seen before and needs time to develop. A great start though, but then that's what you'd expect from a guy who's done a lot of casting before. He's a bit like Tasteless in his style I thought, anyone else think that? | ||
|
WolfStar
United Kingdom155 Posts
That's not to say I think Tastosis should be removed from their spot as you have to give them props for getting out there and waiting patiently for their time. | ||
| ||
