EPTReally difficult game for the referee.
2014 - 2015 Football Thread - Page 260
| Forum Index > Sports |
|
bObaZ
Portugal864 Posts
Really difficult game for the referee. | ||
|
NuclearJudas
6546 Posts
On October 05 2014 23:01 Larkin wrote: I didn't say we SHOULD judge everything on intent. But maliciousness is a factor - it's in the rules - for determining whether something is a red card or not. It isn't a clear red because it very obviously looks like a mistimed tackle, missing the ball, rather than a deliberate attempt to do Alexis in. What Cahill meant only he knows - but to the referee, in a split second decision, it doesn't look malicious enough to warrant a red card. I did say that I can see why Cahill's not been given a red. I even bolded the first part of that statement to make it clear. | ||
|
Larkin
United Kingdom7161 Posts
On October 05 2014 23:07 NuclearJudas wrote: I did say that I can see why Cahill's not been given a red. I even bolded the first part of that statement to make it clear. Yes. You also said 'it's a clear red.' | ||
|
malcram
2752 Posts
Really tough game for the ref for sure | ||
|
zeo
Serbia6336 Posts
On October 05 2014 23:08 malcram wrote: Wenger's pretty mad lol... Really tough game for the ref for sure Its gonna be fun watching the press conference after the match | ||
|
Mensol
14536 Posts
![[image loading]](http://i.hizliresim.com/nGR8aB.jpg) He is the special one  | ||
|
ZeroChrome
Canada1001 Posts
| ||
Olli
Austria24422 Posts
| ||
|
Larkin
United Kingdom7161 Posts
On October 05 2014 23:11 DarkLordOlli wrote: I love how even the half time and after-match show is something to look forward to when you've got someone like Gary Neville breaking down a game. I wish Austrian channels would start learning from that. When I can't watch sky I watch US TV streams and they're so hilariously bad | ||
|
Larkin
United Kingdom7161 Posts
| ||
|
zeo
Serbia6336 Posts
On October 05 2014 23:16 Larkin wrote: Jeez, Courtois being treated by paramedics, and is at hospital, hope he's okay. Looked like bad concussion but with bleeding from the ears could be a lot of bad things. Chelsea keepers and head injuries  Hope he is ok | ||
|
NuclearJudas
6546 Posts
On October 05 2014 23:16 Larkin wrote: Jeez, Courtois being treated by paramedics, and is at hospital, hope he's okay. Looked like bad concussion but with bleeding from the ears could be a lot of bad things. Pretty sure that's for precaution, and I hope he's fine. | ||
|
Larkin
United Kingdom7161 Posts
On October 05 2014 23:17 zeo wrote: Chelsea keepers and head injuries Hope he is ok It's a weird compulsion not to treat players with head injuries and it can be life threatening. Courtois should have been subbed immediately. It is just for precaution to take him to hospital, but still. | ||
|
Freaky[x]
Canada995 Posts
| ||
|
Olli
Austria24422 Posts
| ||
|
Mensol
14536 Posts
"The game changed after that. It came alive and became a lot more difficult for Martin Atkinson to referee after that and he is finding it difficult."" | ||
|
Freaky[x]
Canada995 Posts
| ||
|
Larkin
United Kingdom7161 Posts
On October 05 2014 23:21 DarkLordOlli wrote: Courtois looked like he was completely blacked out for a few moments. I almost feel like, in scenarios like that, it should be possible to change players without it counting as a change. Because that's dangerous, life threatening at times. The team shouldn't be punished for it by having to make a change, and they'll always be opting to keep the player on if possible at all because otherwise they're "wasting" a change. That shouldn't be the case. I'm inclined to agree. I would like a system of one 'free' injury sub. Players' wellbeing shouldn't be second to tactics. You could have a retrospective punishment if they fake it to grant another sub or something. Like a 3 game ban. | ||
|
Olli
Austria24422 Posts
On October 05 2014 23:22 Freaky[x] wrote: Darklord... that's too easy to fake I'm sorry, people dive and cheat all over the place and you expect them not to cheat on this ? Please let's not be naive. There are medical staff on the pitch, they should be able to deduce if someone is injured. And I'm only talking about obvious injuries. Like, if someone's bleeding or passed out or something like that. | ||
|
zeo
Serbia6336 Posts
On October 05 2014 23:23 Larkin wrote: I'm inclined to agree. I would like a system of one 'free' injury sub. Players' wellbeing shouldn't be second to tactics. You could have a retrospective punishment if they fake it to grant another sub or something. Like a 3 game ban. How long before every game you have players faking head injuries? My money is on 2nd game  edit: Nobody is going to care about retrospective punishment, like they don't care about it now. | ||
| ||
