Greatest Map of All Time Tournament - Page 11

Andi_Goldberger

Germany1608 Posts

July 20 2020 02:28 GMT

#201

Metalopolis is of course a legendary map, but its also so basic...I think it was only loved because it was a non-catastrophic map at the time.I voted Redshift because I really liked the concept and played a lot of fun games on it (besidesmy losses to 2rax reaper, but Metalopolis seems even worse if that was a category :D). Metalopolis is gonna win for sure anyway^^

I voted Newkirk just for the Innovation - Taeja game while Ephemeron was just fine

Vaani is a great map, but Daybreak is an even greater one

I never really liked Echo and BelShir Vestige gave us some sick TvZs so I voted BelShir.

The WORST maps are kind of unremarkable this time, its pretty much up to personal taste in these ones anyway. The only one that stands out for me is Backwater Gulch with the awkward highground above EVERY SINGLE THIRD BASE. just wtf

necrosexy

451 Posts

July 20 2020 02:35 GMT

#202

daybreak and cloud kingdom

Solar424

United States4001 Posts

July 22 2020 00:12 GMT

#203

Round of 32 matches 9-12 results:
+ Show Spoiler +

Best Map Ro32 Match 13

Poll: Which of these maps do you consider to be the BEST?

Golden Wall (31)

53%

Overgrowth (27)

47%

58 total votes

Your vote: Which of these maps do you consider to be the BEST?

(Vote): Overgrowth
(Vote): Golden Wall

+ Show Spoiler +

Overgrowth
+ Show Spoiler +

Golden Wall
Best Map Ro32 Match 14

Poll: Which of these maps do you consider to be the BEST?

Coda (29)

69%

Iron Fortress (13)

31%

42 total votes

Your vote: Which of these maps do you consider to be the BEST?

(Vote): Iron Fortress
(Vote): Coda

+ Show Spoiler +

Iron Fortress
+ Show Spoiler +

Coda
Best Map Ro32 Match 15

Poll: Which of these maps do you consider to be the BEST?

Abyssal Reef (38)

84%

Polar Night (7)

16%

45 total votes

Your vote: Which of these maps do you consider to be the BEST?

(Vote): Abyssal Reef
(Vote): Polar Night

+ Show Spoiler +

Abyssal Reef
+ Show Spoiler +

Polar Night
Best Map Ro32 Match 16

Poll: Which of these maps do you consider to be the BEST?

Whirlwind (38)

84%

Korhal Floating Island (7)

16%

45 total votes

Your vote: Which of these maps do you consider to be the BEST?

(Vote): Korhal Floating Island
(Vote): Whirlwind

+ Show Spoiler +

Korhal Floating Island
+ Show Spoiler +

Whirlwind

Worst Map Ro32 Match 10

Poll: Which of these maps do you consider to be the WORST?

Sanshorn Mists (18)

56%

Zerus Prime (14)

44%

32 total votes

Your vote: Which of these maps do you consider to be the WORST?

(Vote): Sanshorn Mists
(Vote): Zerus Prime

+ Show Spoiler +

Sanshorn Mists
+ Show Spoiler +

Zerus Prime
Worst Map Ro32 Match 13

Poll: Which of these maps do you consider to be the WORST?

Fractured Glacier (18)

53%

Backwater (16)

47%

34 total votes

Your vote: Which of these maps do you consider to be the WORST?

(Vote): Fractured Glacier
(Vote): Backwater

+ Show Spoiler +

Fractured Glacier
+ Show Spoiler +

Backwater
Worst Map Ro32 Match 14

Poll: Which of these maps do you consider to be the WORST?

Incineration Zone (30)

83%

Stasis (6)

17%

36 total votes

Your vote: Which of these maps do you consider to be the WORST?

(Vote): Incineration Zone
(Vote): Stasis

+ Show Spoiler +

Incineration Zone
+ Show Spoiler +

Stasis
Worst Map Ro32 Match 15

Poll: Which of these maps do you consider to be the WORST?

Anaconda (16)

55%

Blitzkreig (13)

45%

29 total votes

Your vote: Which of these maps do you consider to be the WORST?

(Vote): Blitzkreig
(Vote): Anaconda

+ Show Spoiler +

Blitzkrieg
+ Show Spoiler +

Anaconda
Worst Map Ro32 Match 16

Poll: Which of these maps do you consider to be the WORST?

Invader (23)

68%

Korhal Compound (11)

32%

34 total votes

Your vote: Which of these maps do you consider to be the WORST?

(Vote): Invader
(Vote): Korhal Compound

+ Show Spoiler +

Invader
+ Show Spoiler +

Korhal Compound

ZigguratOfUr

Iraq16955 Posts

July 22 2020 01:01 GMT

#204

For stuff like Backwater vs Fractured Glacier it really depends on how you weight things. Just based on the layout Fractured Glacier is obviously the worse map of the two. However given that it saw no play it's just vacuously bad. Whereas Backwater is aggressively a bad map since it tortured us with awful awful games, which is why I'm voting for it.

Azzur

Australia6267 Posts

July 22 2020 03:08 GMT

#205

M13: Overgrowth easily, although I think Golden Wall is a good map, maybe one day if more and more great games get played on it, it'll become a contender in Greatest Map of All Time II
M14: Coda for me
M15: I love Abyssal Reef so easy choice
M16: Whirlwind easily for me

Nakajin

Canada8991 Posts

July 22 2020 03:48 GMT

#206

Incinaration zone is pulling an impressive paradox of being both stupidly small and also having over half the bases feel totally useless.

[PkF] Wire

France24239 Posts

July 22 2020 08:34 GMT

#207

Overgrowth - Golden Wall is heartbreaking. I'm really fond of Golden Wall and I consider it the best map of recent years. But Overgrowth is too much of a juggernaut in map making history to not vote for it.
Iron Fortress - Coda and Abyssal Reef - Polar Night are close, those maps are all in the "good but not oustanding" category imo. Went for Coda and Polar Night.
On the contrary, Whirlwind is outstanding and KFI is terrible. So Whirlwind by a huge margin.

As usual I don't have much to say about the worst maps contest ; I'll just mention I was surprised to see Korhal Compound vs Invader there, those maps were ok at least and there were faaar worst maps that could have entered. I liked Korhal Compound a bit when it was on ladder so I voted Invader.

Olli

Austria24422 Posts

July 22 2020 08:43 GMT

#208

On July 22 2020 17:34 [PkF] Wire wrote:
Overgrowth - Golden Wall is heartbreaking. I'm really fond of Golden Wall and I consider it the best map of recent years. But Overgrowth is too much of a juggernaut in map making history to not vote for it.
Iron Fortress - Coda and Abyssal Reef - Polar Night are close, those maps are all in the "good but not oustanding" category imo. Went for Coda and Polar Night.
On the contrary, Whirlwind is outstanding and KFI is terrible. So Whirlwind by a huge margin.

As usual I don't have much to say about the worst maps contest ; I'll just mention I was surprised to see Korhal Compound vs Invader there, those maps were ok at least and there were faaar worst maps that could have entered. I liked Korhal Compound a bit when it was on ladder so I voted Invader.

I like how your reasoning is almost identical to mine on each of these votes. Saves me the trouble of writing it up myself!

[PkF] Wire

France24239 Posts

July 22 2020 09:23 GMT

#209

On July 22 2020 17:43 Olli wrote:

Show nested quote +

I like how you reasoning is almost identical to mine on each of these votes. Saves me the trouble of writing it up myself!

you're welcome mate

Superouman

France2195 Posts

July 22 2020 12:10 GMT

#210

Even though Golden Wall is one of the best maps i've ever made, i can't see it beating a titan like Overgrowth. But hey, it will have at least one vote!

Cricketer12

United States14003 Posts

July 22 2020 14:25 GMT

#211

On July 22 2020 21:10 Superouman wrote:
Even though Golden Wall is one of the best maps i've ever made, i can't see it beating a titan like Overgrowth. But hey, it will have at least one vote!

Make that 2. It's important to vote for good maps

BobFossil1

60 Posts

July 23 2020 06:38 GMT

#212

I voted Golden Wall as well. Every time I see it I like it a bit more. It's original and really offers a lot of different viable strategies and game types. IMO it's already begun to live up to its potential. I hope it's a close vote in the end!

ejozl

Denmark3556 Posts

July 23 2020 17:43 GMT

#213

ppl underrate Golden Wall, years from now we will look back at it as the best map. FIGHT ME!