|
Match 5: Think both maps are solid, voted Catallena because of the music video Match 6: Have a soft spot for old WoL maps, but voted King's Cove as it's too solid Match 7: Cloud Kingdom easily, potential winner Match 8: Tight contest, so voted Frost as I liked it better
Didn't vote for worst maps as I'm more interested in the best
|
Really surprised Neo Planet S lost, to Bel'shir Beach of all maps. A bit disappointed even to be honest.
Amazed that Daedalus Point is already out of the worst maps. Some strange decisions to say the least !
Those best maps matches are no-brainers.+ Show Spoiler +(for me at least  ) Terraform, King's Cove, Cloud Kingdom, Frost.
As for the worst maps, I went with Tristram, Atlas, Bifrost and Secret Spring. I think Secret Spring will be a contender for the title, then again I thought Daedalus Point would be considered amazingly bad, so I don't know anymore !
|
On July 16 2020 22:53 [PkF] Wire wrote:
Those best maps matches are no-brainers. Terraform, King's Cove, Cloud Kingdom, Frost.
No brainers for which I have exactly the opposite votes.
|
On July 17 2020 03:07 Charoisaur wrote:Show nested quote +On July 16 2020 22:53 [PkF] Wire wrote:
Those best maps matches are no-brainers. Terraform, King's Cove, Cloud Kingdom, Frost.
No brainers for which I have exactly the opposite votes.
Catallena was a bad map with a bunch of symmetry issues, Steppes is obviously terrible and Acid Plant was profoundly mediocre. Blackpink and Frost is a bit closer.
|
Neo Planet S being eliminated is a proof that humanity does not deserve happiness.
|
On July 16 2020 22:53 [PkF] Wire wrote:Really surprised Neo Planet S lost, to Bel'shir Beach of all maps. A bit disappointed even to be honest. Amazed that Daedalus Point is already out of the worst maps. Some strange decisions to say the least ! Those best maps matches are no-brainers. + Show Spoiler +(for me at least  ) Terraform, King's Cove, Cloud Kingdom, Frost. As for the worst maps, I went with Tristram, Atlas, Bifrost and Secret Spring. I think Secret Spring will be a contender for the title, then again I thought Daedalus Point would be considered amazingly bad, so I don't know anymore ! Don't underestimate how terrible Dash & Terminal was. It's venerable competition for Secret Spring tbh.
|
Canada8988 Posts
On July 16 2020 22:53 [PkF] Wire wrote:Really surprised Neo Planet S lost, to Bel'shir Beach of all maps. A bit disappointed even to be honest. Amazed that Daedalus Point is already out of the worst maps. Some strange decisions to say the least ! Those best maps matches are no-brainers. + Show Spoiler +(for me at least  ) Terraform, King's Cove, Cloud Kingdom, Frost. As for the worst maps, I went with Tristram, Atlas, Bifrost and Secret Spring. I think Secret Spring will be a contender for the title, then again I thought Daedalus Point would be considered amazingly bad, so I don't know anymore !
The thing with worst maps is that we're split between maps that led to famously terrible games and maps that are so clearly nonsensical that they barely got any playtime.
|
Can we not switch to which do you consider the WORST halfway through? It broke my vote flow
|
On July 17 2020 03:56 ZigguratOfUr wrote:Show nested quote +On July 17 2020 03:07 Charoisaur wrote:On July 16 2020 22:53 [PkF] Wire wrote:
Those best maps matches are no-brainers. Terraform, King's Cove, Cloud Kingdom, Frost.
No brainers for which I have exactly the opposite votes. Catallena was a bad map with a bunch of symmetry issues, Steppes is obviously terrible and Acid Plant was profoundly mediocre. Blackpink and Frost is a bit closer. Terraform was turtle mech heaven and Kings Cove was a boring ass turtle map. Frost is a 4 player map with spawn imbalances. Acid Plant and Cloud Kingdom is close but personally I liked Acid Plant a bit more.
|
Frost was proper fun, it gave us the cleanest TvZ game.
|
Bot edit.
User was banned for this post.
|
On July 18 2020 04:03 blackiytos wrote: Weak groups TBH, waiting for the final 4 of WW, KSS Neo Planet S and Overgrowth.
I have some bad news for you.
|
On July 17 2020 17:35 Charoisaur wrote:Show nested quote +On July 17 2020 03:56 ZigguratOfUr wrote:On July 17 2020 03:07 Charoisaur wrote:On July 16 2020 22:53 [PkF] Wire wrote:
Those best maps matches are no-brainers. Terraform, King's Cove, Cloud Kingdom, Frost.
No brainers for which I have exactly the opposite votes. Catallena was a bad map with a bunch of symmetry issues, Steppes is obviously terrible and Acid Plant was profoundly mediocre. Blackpink and Frost is a bit closer. Terraform was turtle mech heaven and Kings Cove was a boring ass turtle map. Frost is a 4 player map with spawn imbalances. Acid Plant and Cloud Kingdom is close but personally I liked Acid Plant a bit more.
I mean I don't disagree about King's Cove, but that still leaves it miles ahead of Steppes.
|
On July 18 2020 10:57 Phredxor wrote:Show nested quote +On July 18 2020 04:03 blackiytos wrote: Weak groups TBH, waiting for the final 4 of WW, KSS Neo Planet S and Overgrowth. I have some bad news for you. I'm actually having an internal debate on whether this is a bot or not because they literally copied a part of Ej's comment from the first page.
|
On July 18 2020 18:28 Elentos wrote:Show nested quote +On July 18 2020 10:57 Phredxor wrote:On July 18 2020 04:03 blackiytos wrote: Weak groups TBH, waiting for the final 4 of WW, KSS Neo Planet S and Overgrowth. I have some bad news for you. I'm actually having an internal debate on whether this is a bot or not because they literally copied a part of Ej's comment from the first page. And the other post they made is "nice " on the wardi team league
|
|
Sad for Terraform, but Catallena wasn't bad either.
New matches : - Redshift sucks imo, so Metalopolis. I remember it was actually rather fun to play on it again when it entered the Dreampool. - I don't care too much for Ephemeron which was probably played when I was not following sc2 anymore, so Newkirk gets my vote. It actually had quite a lot of excellent games. - I love Vaani, but Daybreak without hesitation. - Echo is an ok map, but I already said how much I love Bel'shir Vestige which is a real favorite of mine, I'm so fond of that map. So Bel'shir Vestige. Honestly I'll be pissed if Bel'shir Beach is in the ro16 and not Bel'shir Vestige ! ^^
All the worst maps suck rather equally imo. I didn't remember Sanshorn Mists and I'm actually amazed I didn't vote for Zerus Prime, but that map looked even worse.
Edit : is it just me or there's something strange with the huge number of votes last week ? Probably some bot, right ?
Edit 2 : oh ok, that makes sense. Nice !
|
On July 19 2020 21:16 [PkF] Wire wrote: Sad for Terraform, but Catallena wasn't bad either.
New matches : - Redshift sucks imo, so Metalopolis. I remember it was actually rather fun to play on it again when it entered the Dreampool. - I don't care too much for Ephemeron which was probably played when I was not following sc2 anymore, so Newkirk gets my vote. It actually had quite a lot of excellent games. - I love Vaani, but Daybreak without hesitation. - Echo is an ok map, but I already said how much I love Bel'shir Vestige which is a real favorite of mine, I'm so fond of that map. So Bel'shir Vestige. Honestly I'll be pissed if Bel'shir Beach is in the ro16 and not Bel'shir Vestige ! ^^
All the worst maps suck rather equally imo. I didn't remember Sanshorn Mists and I'm actually amazed I didn't vote for Zerus Prime, but that map looked even worse.
Edit : is it just me or there's something strange with the huge number of votes last week ? Probably some bot, right ? Someone made a thread on r/Starcraft about this, so a lot of people voted that hadn’t before.
|
M9: Metaopolis very easily M10: Newkirk handily M11: Daybreak (I consider it a strong contender for the title) M12: Bel'shir Vestige handily
|
On July 19 2020 21:16 [PkF] Wire wrote: Sad for Terraform, but Catallena wasn't bad either.
New matches : - Redshift sucks imo, so Metalopolis. I remember it was actually rather fun to play on it again when it entered the Dreampool. - I don't care too much for Ephemeron which was probably played when I was not following sc2 anymore, so Newkirk gets my vote. It actually had quite a lot of excellent games. - I love Vaani, but Daybreak without hesitation. - Echo is an ok map, but I already said how much I love Bel'shir Vestige which is a real favorite of mine, I'm so fond of that map. So Bel'shir Vestige. Honestly I'll be pissed if Bel'shir Beach is in the ro16 and not Bel'shir Vestige ! ^^
All the worst maps suck rather equally imo. I didn't remember Sanshorn Mists and I'm actually amazed I didn't vote for Zerus Prime, but that map looked even worse.
Edit : is it just me or there's something strange with the huge number of votes last week ? Probably some bot, right ?
Edit 2 : oh ok, that makes sense. Nice !
New matches : -Metalopolis wins. The game AND meta was fresh, consistent, but still demanding progress to keep up for an incredible stretch of time. Redshift was a fun one-off experiment to practice odd wall-ins before getting shamed by a roach all-in almost every game.
- Ephemeron had great PvZ potential despite a tilted meta. Stats showed amazing defensive games on Ephemeron.
- I remember my daybreak games way better than my Vaani games. My Vaani games were kind of - Oh this is what an army looks like going in a straight line for a long time.
- Echo is an ok map, Bel'shir Visage much better.
|
|
|
|