|
Durr, the town wins instantly and the mafia die. From their perspective THEY CANNOT WIN if they start killing each other. That means they WON'T. You, however, have assumed that mafia will not trade information because that will automatically lead to such killing and I've said that's not the case because its not a smart move from either mafia team to start shit with the other.
Not exactly. Obviously if the mafia kill each other its bad. Lets suppose we have mafia family A and mafia family B. Now lets say they exchange information or somehow know each other. Sure they can say "lets not kill each other and lets work to kill the town." Fine. But that's idealistic. It sure isnt in the best interest of mafia A and B to kill each other, but it also isn't in mafia A's best interest to ALLOW mafia B the OPPORTUNITY to take free shots at mafia A. Or vice versa. Just because its in their best interest not to kill each other doesnt mean they wont do it. Its a dilemma for them because they can't know for sure the other mafia won't backstab them. In other words, mafia knowing each other is bad and doesnt work for them because they can't trust each other. It is in mafia A's best interest to kill mafia B if they can avoid being killed off first. Obviously, they'll take that opportunity. So will mafia B if they get the chance. Which means that yes, the mafia cannot win if they kill each other. But that is not a fate they can control. It is the side effect of knowing each other. Unfortunately knowing who each other is doesn't foster a nice relationship like you described. It is in mafia A's interest to kill off mafia B before B kills A. How do you stop that when mafia A and B somehow know each other? You can't. If they cooperate, at some point one is going to turn on the other. If I was mafia I wouldn't want to take the chance of being stabbed first. Nobody does. And honestly mafia A would do fine against the town by itself without cooperation from mafia B. The only way the mafia can work together is if they don't know who each other are. I hope this is clear now.
|
I'll be rather honest, you're rambling and I've already addressed all your points.
I'm going to sleep.
|
I'm not even going to bother anymore with you guys.
|
For clarification, this is BC's game, not chuius. He does his clue styles different and gets his clues slightly differently.
I tried finding actual clues, not linking someone i think is guilty off behavior to shitty clues then saying lynch him. You just watch when lordweird turns up green, or the end of the game he isn't the swaying guy.
Also the list of being protected is just power hungry people... I won't bother writing 4000 word documents anymore, realising some links are bad, and spending another hour + getting 3 better clues.
|
Canada7170 Posts
Whoa whoa whoa how is Cam NOT on that list. That's absurd that I'm on there, I haven't even done anything.
|
yeah, all i did was kill ace
lol
|
|
|
On May 05 2009 20:56 motbob wrote:I was 99% inactive before voting on Day 3 and I read something like 10 pages of this thread and I immediately knew Qatol was mafia... come on guys. The sad thing is that it's too late. With the combined voting power of the mayor and the rest of the Mafia, I don't know if we can actually lynch Qatol at all  I feel like last mafia game was the Club Day MSL, this game is Carthage and Tears of the Moon, and the mafia is the Zerg.
YES WE CAN.
|
lol Fuck Camlito I forgot who wrote that essay, chill brah.
|
This is a list of medic protection candidates.- Caller
- RebirthOfLeGenD (yeah, self promotion, deal with it.)
- Malongo
- Ver
- MikeyMoo (edited from Malongo's list)
- Camlito
I was tired when I wrote the first one, sorry cam.
|
|
|
yeah spread the love in the town. well need it before the day comes 
|
Also, that "essay" i writ was 4,074 words in word at first. Then editing came in lol.
|
4492 Posts
On May 05 2009 13:19 RebirthOfLeGenD wrote:Also I think Malongo's protection list needs to be lengthened and updated. This is a list of medic protection candidates.- Caller
- RebirthOfLeGenD (yeah, self promotion, deal with it.)
- Malongo
- Ver
- MikeyMoo (edited from Malongo's list)
From what I can remember, these are the only people who have been useful active and seemingly town aligned recently. If anyone else comes to mind I will quote and edit the list.
Don't anybody go protecting Ver u guys.
|
ya dun protect ver, it will prevent mynocks hit from going through.
stupid town.
|
On May 05 2009 22:07 Camlito wrote:
Also, that "essay" i writ was 4,074 words in word at first. Then editing came in lol.
QUOTE YOUR ESSAY TO THIS PAGE. I don't feel like searching. Spoiler tag it~~
|
4492 Posts
On May 06 2009 01:34 RebirthOfLeGenD wrote:
ya dun protect ver, it will prevent mynocks hit from going through.
stupid town.
Like, duh!
|
On May 06 2009 02:15 Mynock wrote:Show nested quote +On May 06 2009 01:34 RebirthOfLeGenD wrote:
ya dun protect ver, it will prevent mynocks hit from going through.
stupid town. Like, duh!
PSSST.....
VIGI HIT THIS MOTHER FUCKER!
|
4492 Posts
On May 06 2009 02:42 RebirthOfLeGenD wrote:Show nested quote +On May 06 2009 02:15 Mynock wrote:On May 06 2009 01:34 RebirthOfLeGenD wrote:
ya dun protect ver, it will prevent mynocks hit from going through.
stupid town. Like, duh! PSSST..... VIGI HIT THIS MOTHER FUCKER!
Isn't it enough that I'll die tonight by a Mafia hit?
|
Again I'd like to reiterate that we should lynch Qatol and Chuiu at this point.
Chuiu won't be helping our town much until later this week, at which point we'll probably all be dead. So there's not much to lose if we kill him. However, if he flips red, we'll have taken out one of the mafia's strongest players.
Qatol we all know is mafia and we should autolynch him tomorrow.
If I get hit tonight just wanted to say it's been fun playing and pulling the double-cross on Qatol. GG ALT Q Q
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
