|
As promised, the medic list:
Ace - VERY strong player. Has seriously influenced basically every game he has played.
Ver - Probably the best behavioral analyst the town has.
semioldguy - I was quite impressed with the way he managed the town last game. Strong player.
camlito - One of the better players in the town.
showtime! - He is active and smart. Very dangerous for the mafia to leave alive.
LTT - I have worked with him closely in several games. He was my biggest help for setting up the mass hatter bombings.
Medics, please do not protect anyone other than those people unless you are SURE you are protecting a townie who is DEFINITELY going to take a hit in your mind. In other words, protect people on that list.
The reasoning behind this list is pretty simple. The mafia can choose to hit players not on this list. That is fine. If they do, the town keeps their strongest players alive. If the mafia wants to kill our strongest players, they will have to worry about medics protecting them and will likely stack hits or risk a medic protection.
|
Ok I will reiterate because there appears to be some confusion on the subject.
If you take a hit: Report it in the thread. It doesn't matter if you were saved by a medic or are a veteran. Do NOT say which event happened. The mafia do not know this. Just inform the thread that you took a hit.
If you are a medic and you make a save: During night 1, the contract killer and vigilantes cannot be active. Therefore, the person you saved MUST be innocent. PM them. You cannot be confirmed to the town as a whole, but you can trust that player and work with them for the rest of the game.
|
United States7488 Posts
I think a few more people should be added to that list if you ask me.
|
ok
my exams are over
reading thread now
|
On April 24 2009 04:43 semioldguy wrote:
I think a few more people should be added to that list if you ask me.
Who do you recommend? This is obviously a balancing act between nabbing all the best players and spreading out the medics. I doubt BC has more than 3 medics this game because it is smaller than last game and there are veterans.
|
ok done. mods are slackin' on editing the title imo!
people that stood out to me in one way or another
t_co
dreamflower
pyrr
goodwill
i'll be contacting u guys by pm :-)
|
On April 24 2009 04:30 Qatol wrote:
Ok I will reiterate because there appears to be some confusion on the subject.
If you take a hit: Report it in the thread. It doesn't matter if you were saved by a medic or are a veteran. Do NOT say which event happened. The mafia do not know this. Just inform the thread that you took a hit.
If you are a medic and you make a save: During night 1, the contract killer and vigilantes cannot be active. Therefore, the person you saved MUST be innocent. PM them. You cannot be confirmed to the town as a whole, but you can trust that player and work with them for the rest of the game.
I have a few points:
1. If someone waits to claim they were medic protected in the thread until the medic claims to them through PM it lowers the ability for mafia to make some sort of fake claim, although a fake claim might be kind of stupid it could out a medic if handled incorrectly or cause more damage perhaps.
2. A veteran calling out they lost a life has at least one disadvantage. A mafia hitting someone and having them not die might think they are medic protected and just move on and leave them alone (mafia moved on from me last game after trying once and seeing i was medic protected). If a vet role calls after a hit, medics still have little reason to trust that and switch their protection so that vet would lose potential deterrence. Maybe there's some advantage(s) that outweigh(s) that but I don't know that we should be giving clues to mafia on whether they are dealing with medics or vets now that vets are back in the equation (they weren't in the last game).
|
On April 24 2009 05:44 Pyrrhuloxia wrote:Show nested quote +On April 24 2009 04:30 Qatol wrote:
Ok I will reiterate because there appears to be some confusion on the subject.
If you take a hit: Report it in the thread. It doesn't matter if you were saved by a medic or are a veteran. Do NOT say which event happened. The mafia do not know this. Just inform the thread that you took a hit.
If you are a medic and you make a save: During night 1, the contract killer and vigilantes cannot be active. Therefore, the person you saved MUST be innocent. PM them. You cannot be confirmed to the town as a whole, but you can trust that player and work with them for the rest of the game. I have a few points: 1. If someone waits to claim they were medic protected in the thread until the medic claims to them through PM it lowers the ability for mafia to make some sort of fake claim, although a fake claim might be kind of stupid it could out a medic if handled incorrectly or cause more damage perhaps. 2. A veteran calling out they lost a life has at least one disadvantage. A mafia hitting someone and having them not die might think they are medic protected and just move on and leave them alone (mafia moved on from me last game after trying once and seeing i was medic protected). If a vet role calls after a hit, medics still have little reason to trust that and switch their protection so that vet would lose potential deterrence. Maybe there's some advantage(s) that outweigh(s) that but I don't know that we should be giving clues to mafia on whether they are dealing with medics or vets now that vets are back in the equation (they weren't in the last game).
Do NOT say which event happened. The mafia do not know this. Just inform the thread that you took a hit. Nobody should be claiming they were medic protected. Nobody should claim they are a veteran who took a hit. All they are doing is informing the thread that they survived a hit. The mafia already knows this happened (because they sent the hit in the first place). The town does not.
|
On April 24 2009 01:00 Mynock wrote:Show nested quote +On April 24 2009 00:12 Showtime! wrote:
Told you he was clean.
Mynock considering I never played with you. Arrogance is bliss. I have nothing to prove to anyone and I don't feel like posting every PM; action; and thought process I made on each decision. Everything I do is well mapped out in my head.
With that said, I didn't randomly pick players to be checked.
1. There is a reason why I ran for Mayor.
2. There is a reason why I believe it is in the Town's best interest that I be checked sooner rather than later.
ALL of this would be VOID if and ONLY if I'm the Godfather, which is fairly low.
I am more than capable of organizing a core, but you guys have to do your part as well. You Never played with me? I don't have the time to check up all the games we've played in, but it's a few (Mafia 2 comes to mind, where we had like exactly the same situation with you vs me, lol). Every Mafia game u behave pretty erratically and in a confusing fashion, and this time it's no different.
Once again you missed it. lol
It's okay man, I <3 you anyway. What I meant was you and I never worked together. We just have different approaches to things.
There are some things I don't plan on changing soon, for example, telling you everything I know.
Qatol PM me about assignments please.
|
On April 24 2009 05:50 Qatol wrote:Show nested quote +On April 24 2009 05:44 Pyrrhuloxia wrote:On April 24 2009 04:30 Qatol wrote:
Ok I will reiterate because there appears to be some confusion on the subject.
If you take a hit: Report it in the thread. It doesn't matter if you were saved by a medic or are a veteran. Do NOT say which event happened. The mafia do not know this. Just inform the thread that you took a hit.
If you are a medic and you make a save: During night 1, the contract killer and vigilantes cannot be active. Therefore, the person you saved MUST be innocent. PM them. You cannot be confirmed to the town as a whole, but you can trust that player and work with them for the rest of the game. I have a few points: 1. If someone waits to claim they were medic protected in the thread until the medic claims to them through PM it lowers the ability for mafia to make some sort of fake claim, although a fake claim might be kind of stupid it could out a medic if handled incorrectly or cause more damage perhaps. 2. A veteran calling out they lost a life has at least one disadvantage. A mafia hitting someone and having them not die might think they are medic protected and just move on and leave them alone (mafia moved on from me last game after trying once and seeing i was medic protected). If a vet role calls after a hit, medics still have little reason to trust that and switch their protection so that vet would lose potential deterrence. Maybe there's some advantage(s) that outweigh(s) that but I don't know that we should be giving clues to mafia on whether they are dealing with medics or vets now that vets are back in the equation (they weren't in the last game). Do NOT say which event happened. The mafia do not know this. Just inform the thread that you took a hit. Nobody should be claiming they were medic protected. Nobody should claim they are a veteran who took a hit. All they are doing is informing the thread that they survived a hit. The mafia already knows this happened (because they sent the hit in the first place). The town does not.
yeah thats what you were saying *facepalm* sorry
|
Apparently not posting much is a good way to get yourself killed by the town (eventually) and then have them not care very much if you end up not being a mafia. So it seems like a good idea to make sure people know I'm actually here.
The trouble for me is that all the good players posting in this thread are actually very intimidating and aren't shy about calling out posts they find suspicious. The conversation also goes pretty fast and I don't like quoting people and saying "this" or "fail" or whatever.
But there was one question QuickStriker asked a while back that I know I can answer.
I was basically a bandwagon vote for Qatol, pretty much voting without explaining myself. The logic behind electing a mayor is simple: You don't want a mafia there. You also want a strong and active player there so that if he isn't mafia he'll be a huge asset and if he is mafia he'll be easier to sniff out. The two reasons I voted for Qatol are that he fits the "strong and active player" bill and the fact that he started his campaign before any roles were released. While it's true that he may have been assigned a mafia role the odds of that are slim compared to the odds of him not getting a mafia role. Considering you can't really trust anyone I decided I liked those odds.
|
Detectives should look at the list of players that voted for Qatol as their primary suspect list.
Also I'd be very wary of L, he's just as dangerous as everyone else that has influence in this game.
|
United States7488 Posts
I'd add Bockit and probably Pyrrhuloxia to that list.
|
|
|
Hello my fellow townies. Just letting y'all know that I am active I've just been rather busy lately.
|
On April 24 2009 10:35 BloodyC0bbler wrote:
bumpity bump
Hush you, or I'll kill you.
|
On April 24 2009 10:38 Tricode wrote:Hush you, or I'll kill you.
I believe he is already dead straight off the bat in day one...
Speaking of which, I thought the dead cannot talk unless.... ZOMBIES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
*edit* And also I am back after spending a whole day working and being out... in case someone here decides to question me why I was so quiet after my very long posts I made last night.... so yes people, I'm alive and will post here everyday.... if you excuse me, I will now read all the events that occurred in a single day of this supposely peaceful town of mafias...
|
Way too quiet in here 
|
People with night roles send them in (if useable)
The inactivity is killing me
|
I just hope our meds aren't inactive, they should try to decide who to protect from Qatol's list especially if they don't think they will be on for a bit, we don't want morning to come and finding out a med didn't do their job cause they waited to the last minute.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
