inactivity has made me stop wanting to run the game. Honestly, the town doesn't have enough active participants to even stand 1/10th of a chance.

I'm up for just ending the game

SpiralArchitect

United States2116 Posts

December 04 2008 05:39 GMT

#1743

88 Pages later? Sounds like your just lazy to me >.<

Camlito

Australia4040 Posts

December 04 2008 05:46 GMT

#1744

Yeh agreed with spiral -_-.

edit: Seems the inactive townies are more active than ace t.t.

Ace

United States16096 Posts

December 04 2008 05:47 GMT

#1745

I am ^_^

but its only since this morning I thought about doing this. The game doesn't have enough discussion going on to be worth it. Especially since I don't think the clues are impossible to figure out.

Camlito

Australia4040 Posts

December 04 2008 05:48 GMT

#1746

There's no discussion because you've milked it all with your (well your delays you couldnt help, but the town can only talk so much without a new post)

Waiting a week between posts wont = activity. It isn't the towns fault, but it isn't yours either as you've been busy.

Ace

United States16096 Posts

December 04 2008 05:49 GMT

#1747

Cam do you think the town really dug deep into that last post?

be honest.

^_^

TruthBringer

United States578 Posts

December 04 2008 05:52 GMT

#1748

Ace keep the game going.

Camlito

Australia4040 Posts

December 04 2008 05:54 GMT

#1749

You may have drove people inactive with that wait aswell t.t

Just keep the game going for atleast 1 more day ace. I have checked the thread 1/16th as much since i've never seen it, so maybe them aswell :D.

BloodyC0bbler

Canada7876 Posts

December 04 2008 05:57 GMT

#1750

On December 04 2008 14:49 Ace wrote:
Cam do you think the town really dug deep into that last post?

be honest.

^_^

:p your clues aren't that hard to figure out fully. I was analyzing them as I went till i saw i died, then was kinda happy as you write way to much

Ace

United States16096 Posts

December 04 2008 05:58 GMT

#1751

lol indeed I do.

RebirthOfLeGenD

USA5860 Posts

December 04 2008 06:00 GMT

#1752

I check the thread for new updates a lot actually. But with a week in between each day and night post it makes me stop posting. Honestly with everything going on behind the scenes with caller there is less discussion because anyone who really talks will get owned by the mafia. So I'm guessing a lot of people speak to caller? I dunno how the other games with mayors worked though.

Just start posting faster and put it on more of a schedule. Oh and to be honest, your clues and bullet form give me a headache, so I can't read them that much. I read all the analysis's though.

Ver

United States2186 Posts

December 04 2008 06:00 GMT

#1753

A big problem with this is the inherent problem of the dual mafia format. We've had to be extremely quiet about saying anything because in order to win the town needs to deflect a significant number of hits of the mafia onto each other, and thus the amount of information that we can reveal publically is very limited. Thus there is very little discussion and mostly robotic orders being followed. This could have been partially alleviated had more people been active in private, but that's been a limited success as well as few apparently wanted to contribute anything.

But yeah general town inactivity has screwed us big time and ruined several nice plans we had. In addition to this, we couldn't tell who was an imposter or what because no matter how suspicious they acted, we wouldn't have enough people even claiming that role until days later or whatever. You'd think that with 4 DTs you'd be able to get even 1 single votelist ever but apparently not.

And mafia have been the most active anyway. It's frustrating knowing the identities of so many but not being able to do much about it.

I don't know. I'd be happy playing the game out but I don't see how the town can win anymore unless key ppl suddenly become active to let certain plans happen. When the modkill comes the town is basically screwed as only a small percentage of mafia have been very silent.

I think next time you should keep a 1 mafia format, because then there can be a lot more said in public rather than being super cryptic about everything and giving the bare minimum in public -> no discussion -> no activity.

Fishball

Canada4788 Posts

December 04 2008 06:04 GMT

#1754

I personally won't be playing anymore if the game really ends right here.

CynanMachae

Canada1459 Posts

December 04 2008 06:29 GMT

#1755

I've been following since the beginning, but I have to agree that when waits got longer it kinda killed the activity.

Vivi57

United States6599 Posts

December 04 2008 06:33 GMT

#1756

If you end it, atleast tell us caller and mtf's roles.

I've been waiting for day so I can find out if caller is mafia.

Ver

United States2186 Posts

December 04 2008 06:36 GMT

#1757

Haha even if he ends it here there are some VERY hilarious stories and information that needs to be published. I dont' know exactly how some happened either so I am anxious too for the juice

SpiralArchitect

United States2116 Posts

December 04 2008 06:38 GMT

#1758

On December 04 2008 14:49 Ace wrote:
Cam do you think the town really dug deep into that last post?

be honest.

^_^

No we didnt and that could be because Caller was guiding our votes, or we all wanted to wait till the next series of clues. That doesnt mean you should end the game, not only that but what about the Mafia? They are winning right now. Its like getting to half time and just calling the game early.

ShadowDrgn

United States2497 Posts

December 04 2008 06:39 GMT

#1759

Ace just doesn't want to make more clues.

Ver

United States2186 Posts

December 04 2008 06:46 GMT

#1760

Anyway I do think that we should continue and just play it out. I do think it's mostly a foregone conclusion but things could happen easily. I,e everyone turns up active again or Lucchese get raped by Yamaguchi to even things out.

There's simply been way too much put in so far to end without even trying.

The key is that the updates must be regular and frequent. I understand how you feel Ace when you get very few PMs from Blues (I assume this is happening at least) and so you wait longer to get them to give town a chance, but that in turn causes everyone else to be inactive. TBH I'm not really sure of an easy way out. I almost want to say plug the dead active townies back in to the inactives, but you'd have to be very restrictive about this and it could potentially be a really bad idea (for example Showtime couldn't be put in as he knows and does way too much)

Oh and yeah you people are stupid (or mafia as several/many are) for wanting to lynch Caller. If he was mafia I guarantee he'd be playing his cards way differently to not arouse suspicion so soon. Those were my guesses and suggestions anyway so you should lynch me if you want to go about mob wars.