TL Mafia 2 [GG] - Page 212

On April 11 2008 17:30 Bockit wrote:


While I agree with pretty much all your methodology I don't think you can make the claim "because the juxtaposition doesn't exist then it increases his chance of not being mafia" and for proof I bring quesadilla, whose *only* connection to the clues was his signature, his name wasn't relevant but it was still him. Fair enough it turned out TranceStorm was townie, and the rest of his stuff doesn't match up as well as it seems people were thinking, as you've pointed out. I'm just trying to avoid us falling into the trap of saying "This clue fits X but Y doesn't fit therefore it can't be him" when we've seen that this can be the case.

But yeah I agree with pretty much everything else you've been saying. Let's see some red by nightfall.

On April 11 2008 17:33 Plexa wrote:
fair enough, i would argue that the juxtaposition isn't a central argument but is something which increases the chance of him being innocent. But the clue should match pretty seamlessly to one particular profile trait of the mafia

On April 11 2008 22:09 Unforgiven_ve wrote:
nice nice, the game is alive again! nice analysis by plexa...sorry for not posting much but i've been very busy whit RL stuff, but im always checking the thread and reading the las 2-3 pages. i dont know if you rolechecked ninja...but he's still my 1st suspect :p

On April 11 2008 22:13 Camlito wrote:


Considering how much work ive put into finding california mountain snake, i've come up with shit all...


all i found besides ninja4ever was infundibilum who has a hat and a spinny thing (which was used to cut off the head of someone), but he seems scandinavian, and california mountain snake bowed. So our best bet is ninja4ever. (How ever obvious that seems).

On April 11 2008 22:21 HeRoS)Pink wrote:

I just did a quick research and I remember having seen gent in a profile
I would put amber[light] as a suspect to california mountain snake before ninja4ever

Important words : bowed / peered

On April 11 2008 12:20 Plexa wrote:
People, fuck the lists.

They are a great aid but we shouldn't be pushing them any further.

Rather than take a guess and go "OH EASY 1/3 CHANCE = INSTA WIN" sit back, check the players, and see what the clues spell out.

Rational arguments based on clues are hard to deny, argue or even counter.

On that note L is mafioso. Yes Cottonmouth threw 15 knives, but the important thing how the clues are worded. Why say that he threw 3 knives into each of his legs and 3 into his back? Why is it worded so? Summing the numbers stated you get 12 and given the lack of evidence pertaining to L this is a damming clue against him. This clue is very much alike to Queasy and Sidewinder and should not be lightly dismissed simply.

On April 11 2008 17:00 Plexa wrote:
Lysithea you profile picture is so cool where did you get it from

oh wow you stole my 5200th post haha

On April 11 2008 23:58 fusionsdf wrote:
Its extraneous words, so I consider it a clue, not sure if plexa does

havent been able to relate it to anything though

On April 12 2008 00:03 ~OpZ~ wrote:




I dunno....Has Camlito ever posted in the thread yet comes back to defend iMderek and alventine....Honestly I suspect Alventine some what...for being like the hero of last game. A martyr. Being in a trusted position but against the town...But if thats based on that, then it could be Ace or our Pardoner, but I believe Ace to be innocent....

Oh...Clues are hard to make on people who have no information in their profile...Like Alventine...

Personally I think Chuiu should only allow people with a pic, and sig, to play in the game...