EPTI'd like to know your reads on cake and mebaby particularly.
A Classy Game of Mafia - Page 183
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
DarthPunk
Australia10857 Posts
I'd like to know your reads on cake and mebaby particularly. | ||
|
Vivax
21972 Posts
On March 07 2024 09:30 DarthPunk wrote: Vivax can you just tell me in dot points why you think jealous is mafia. He cleared JAT for not wanting me mayor He scumread cop although she did the same He applied an universal reason for a townread selectively | ||
|
Koshi
Belgium38799 Posts
MZ Rels Jacob Mebaby TTS Because I hope you are town VE. | ||
|
Vivax
21972 Posts
| ||
|
Alakaslam
United States17336 Posts
On March 07 2024 08:26 Jealous wrote: Understandable. Hoping you engage more directly with the game itself, though; could be a good distraction to really involve yourself in scumhunting instead of (at least in my eyes) being mostly on the outskirts throwing random posts here and there. This was in fact my intent- but I got scum read right out the gate as blue, got bitter, outed the role, and (rightly) lost all respect. That can make direct scumhunting difficult to self- motivate toward. But it is happening, if not publicly yet. | ||
|
DarthPunk
Australia10857 Posts
On March 07 2024 09:33 Vivax wrote: He cleared JAT for not wanting me mayor He scumread cop although she did the same He applied an universal reason for a townread selectively Thanks, sometimes less is more. | ||
|
DarthPunk
Australia10857 Posts
Ironic from me but im trying to tone it down, lest this becomes imperial all over again. | ||
|
DarthPunk
Australia10857 Posts
| ||
|
Jealous
10141 Posts
On March 07 2024 09:08 Vivax wrote: @ Jealous Tsk.Tsk. But you put copcake into your scumreads. You can't sell to anyone in this game that copcake put less effort than JAT into doubting my claim and making me mafia and at the very least it's the same degree of effort. It was my genuine impression. He seemed to be driving that train of thought based on how I read it. Meanwhile... On March 07 2024 09:08 Vivax wrote: Why didn't you use this type of argument on her like you did on JAT if it's all it took to make you favour Trfel over JAT? I believe this makes you caught buddy. Had to dive to see when exactly she jumped on that train because I am pretty certain it wasn't her starting it and I see this: On March 05 2024 02:56 CopCake wrote: I also do not understand the whole vivax is town because he claimed jailkeeper because that is bullshit. Not because the logic of the whole scenario but because I think he is the type of player to be insane enough as mafia to do something like that. So, sure, she agrees with it, but she is just sheeping IMO. I don't think a scum!JAT is dumb enough to put himself under the line of fire for this take. But I can see scum!CopCake sheeping him once he does and hoping to make something out of nothing. On March 07 2024 09:08 Vivax wrote: Not just that: This is a post you wholeheartedly agreed with. But the useless nai trash discussion is also what you used to justify not voting JAT. Mostly referring to the call-out by sandroba itself and her posting being a part of what I found to be mostly trash posting in general up until that point, including the tea party, sharks, townreading the two people she invited to her tea party basically immediately, etc. | ||
|
Jealous
10141 Posts
On March 07 2024 09:29 Oatsmaster wrote: Sure but you didn’t mention this at all when making your vote, going back and saying that’s the case doesn’t mean that you were thinking about it when you made the vote Here are the two posts showing that I basically followed Koshi's logic, which is what I am claiming. Even has a reiteration of my JAT logic to boot: https://tl.net/forum/mafia/621454-a-classy-game-of-mafia?page=128#2551 https://tl.net/forum/mafia/621454-a-classy-game-of-mafia?page=130#2589 | ||
|
Vivax
21972 Posts
On March 07 2024 08:54 Vivax wrote: Looking at the VC three wasted their votes of which two probably could have done so because they got frustrated about lacking thread pull. Either rayn is simply town here and we're dealing with: Palmar, JAT, VE, DMB, Jealous + MZ maybe but can't get a read + Rels maybe but he's just doing less than usual which is offputting. Or he's not and one of those is actually town. Just putting it out there. Okay and if you take yourself out of the equation, what do you think of those that remain in this list ? Which one could you see yourself lynching tomorrow ? | ||
|
Jealous
10141 Posts
On March 07 2024 09:45 Vivax wrote: Okay and if you take yourself out of the equation, what do you think of those that remain in this list ? Which one could you see yourself lynching tomorrow ? Hmm. I guess I'd say that my perception of the following improved overall: Palmar JAT rayn (improved relative to me gut-scum-reading him in my initial reads list, but not too much) My perception of the following did not: VE DMB MZ Rels Between the above I found DMB and VE to be the more erratic and thus unhelpful posters for the most part. Rels and MZ just haven't done much recently in general, though I guess VE can be added to that list too; VE's posts over the last 24 hours are just a big fat nothingburger. MZ at least seems to be trying to catch up after a shitty day so I can be patient there at the moment. Rels, similar story, though I agree with whoever said that they would have "lynched over half the game" over Trfels. So, TLDR, I guess my top contenders from that list would be VE and DMB, followed by probably rayn (though I do want to give them more time to work on things, as I mentioned before, I did like how they approached the CopCake discussion overnight). As for names outside of that list, I think TTS and CopCake both deserve a mention. | ||
|
Jealous
10141 Posts
Rels, similar story, though I agree with whoever said that Rels' post saying they would have "lynched over half the game" over Trfels was bad. | ||
|
DarthPunk
Australia10857 Posts
On March 07 2024 09:55 Jealous wrote: Hmm. I guess I'd say that my perception of the following improved overall: Palmar JAT rayn (improved relative to me gut-scum-reading him in my initial reads list, but not too much) My perception of the following did not: VE DMB MZ Rels Between the above I found DMB and VE to be the more erratic and thus unhelpful posters for the most part. Rels and MZ just haven't done much recently in general, though I guess VE can be added to that list too; VE's posts over the last 24 hours are just a big fat nothingburger. MZ at least seems to be trying to catch up after a shitty day so I can be patient there at the moment. Rels, similar story, though I agree with whoever said that they would have "lynched over half the game" over Trfels. So, TLDR, I guess my top contenders from that list would be VE and DMB, followed by probably rayn (though I do want to give them more time to work on things, as I mentioned before, I did like how they approached the CopCake discussion overnight). As for names outside of that list, I think TTS and CopCake both deserve a mention. This post seems entirely reasonable vivax. | ||
|
Vivax
21972 Posts
On March 07 2024 09:55 Jealous wrote: Hmm. I guess I'd say that my perception of the following improved overall: Palmar JAT rayn (improved relative to me gut-scum-reading him in my initial reads list, but not too much) My perception of the following did not: VE DMB MZ Rels Between the above I found DMB and VE to be the more erratic and thus unhelpful posters for the most part. Rels and MZ just haven't done much recently in general, though I guess VE can be added to that list too; VE's posts over the last 24 hours are just a big fat nothingburger. MZ at least seems to be trying to catch up after a shitty day so I can be patient there at the moment. Rels, similar story, though I agree with whoever said that they would have "lynched over half the game" over Trfels. So, TLDR, I guess my top contenders from that list would be VE and DMB, followed by probably rayn (though I do want to give them more time to work on things, as I mentioned before, I did like how they approached the CopCake discussion overnight). As for names outside of that list, I think TTS and CopCake both deserve a mention. It‘s a bit in contrast to this very recent opinion On March 07 2024 08:57 Jealous wrote: Hmmm. I can see it as potentially scum!Rayn trying to push a lynch on Palmar then backing off of it when they saw it wasn't happening any time soon, and town!Palmar catching onto this and/or having other reasons for scumreading Rayn. However, I'll have to take a look at their filters to see what the actual timing and pacing of what you said is. Would rather see it with my own eyes than take your word for it. | ||
|
Jealous
10141 Posts
On March 06 2024 19:07 Palmar wrote: Don't like this take but it may be just egoposting from Rels. I didn't think Trfel was gonna flip mafia and I didn't vote him. I explained why I didn't think he'd flip mafia. But I'd be lying straight up if I claimed something like this. For someone who has seemingly been so little involved in the game you're claiming an awful deep understanding of the game to object to what is essentially a diet policy lynch. | ||
|
Vivax
21972 Posts
Marv + Sandro surviving or not will clear that up. If they both die I‘m eating that NK wifom. | ||
|
DarthPunk
Australia10857 Posts
| ||
|
Jealous
10141 Posts
On March 07 2024 09:59 Vivax wrote: It‘s a bit in contrast to this very recent opinion Well, I haven't gone through the actual filters yet, so that might change my perception. Again, my perception of rayn improved due to their activity overnight re: CopCake, but as I stated in my long-winded response to rayn in the first place (link for reference) I haven't seen enough to make me think of rayn as now more town than scum at this moment. If anything, I think that keeping him around over would lead to better things for discussion- and analysis-wise than VE, DMB, TTS, and CopCake, which should thus be more favorable for the town. | ||
|
Vivax
21972 Posts
On March 07 2024 10:05 DarthPunk wrote: I think palmar and JAT both look way better Alright. I gather that you prefer cop and dmb? Any other three that come to your mind ? | ||
| ||
