|
On July 03 2018 05:06 Calix wrote:Did anyone ever comment on this post by the way? I don't think they did. Now that you know there's a mafia between Slenderman and CopCake (or me if you think I'm lying), thoughts? Show nested quote +On July 01 2018 09:04 TheSlenderMan wrote:
I thought the Day would end tomorrow, not today :/
I see going by the last few pages that my inactivity warrants an apology. I don't know yet what has happened in the Thread, but I see a LOT of Modkills so something nasty must've happened.
I only had time to read a measly ten pages. If I do get retroactively modkilled for inactivity (as some people seem to be demanding), there's probably only one useful thing I can say at this point: I feel VERY strongly that Cake is Town. Cake isn't this fortright and confident as Mafia -- she "beats up around the bush" (if that's the correct English idiom) and focuses on manipulating people but doesn't do that here. I've played with her a lot and feel VERY strongly about this read.
If I had voted based on what I had read, my Vote would've gone to Calix. I really, really dislike the early Vote on Cake. Not because I disagree with the read, but because it felt really lazy, identifying Cake as a possible "low-hanging fruit" in the Thread. It didn't seem to have legitimate content-analysis to back the Vote up. Other than that his thread-presence has so far merely warranted the comment "okay-ish" in my notes, and such meek thread-presence (I've noticed) often ends up pointing to Scum.
rayn has started the game pointing out the exact things I would've expected him to, in the exact tone. So I feel pretty confident in saying he's also Town here, FWIW.
Of the non-modkilled early posters that leaves only Conversion and HF -- HF's start seems different compared to the last game, but not in a suspicion-raising way. "Undecided", in other words.
Conversion has been relaxed slash borderline troll-y, but based on small things like #133 I'd say they are slightly more likely to be Town. Ultimately also "undecided", though.
FWIW Mocsta seemed very different compared to the last game so my read of him was Town.
TicTock I felt more iffy about -- the tone of the early pages Townread to me, but #105 was really bad and #108 seemed self-aware in a Mafia-like way.
Regfan seemed very Town to me. Played with him a lot but that was many many years ago. As Mafia he starts painting himself in a corner very early in the game (tries to "overproduce content" in other words). There was no sight of that here, and the whole hydra-dynamic seemed not forced.
Wait, slenderman posted?
I believed he only posted the thanks rayn for telling me the game was here lol
|
United Kingdom30775 Posts
If we want to believe calix then it is objectively the best play to lynch copcake until slender posts once and then vote him.
If he is mafia he is modkilled and if he is town we kill mafia copcake.
|
On July 03 2018 05:06 Calix wrote:Did anyone ever comment on this post by the way? I don't think they did. Now that you know there's a mafia between Slenderman and CopCake (or me if you think I'm lying), thoughts? Show nested quote +On July 01 2018 09:04 TheSlenderMan wrote:
I thought the Day would end tomorrow, not today :/
I see going by the last few pages that my inactivity warrants an apology. I don't know yet what has happened in the Thread, but I see a LOT of Modkills so something nasty must've happened.
I only had time to read a measly ten pages. If I do get retroactively modkilled for inactivity (as some people seem to be demanding), there's probably only one useful thing I can say at this point: I feel VERY strongly that Cake is Town. Cake isn't this fortright and confident as Mafia -- she "beats up around the bush" (if that's the correct English idiom) and focuses on manipulating people but doesn't do that here. I've played with her a lot and feel VERY strongly about this read.
If I had voted based on what I had read, my Vote would've gone to Calix. I really, really dislike the early Vote on Cake. Not because I disagree with the read, but because it felt really lazy, identifying Cake as a possible "low-hanging fruit" in the Thread. It didn't seem to have legitimate content-analysis to back the Vote up. Other than that his thread-presence has so far merely warranted the comment "okay-ish" in my notes, and such meek thread-presence (I've noticed) often ends up pointing to Scum.
rayn has started the game pointing out the exact things I would've expected him to, in the exact tone. So I feel pretty confident in saying he's also Town here, FWIW.
Of the non-modkilled early posters that leaves only Conversion and HF -- HF's start seems different compared to the last game, but not in a suspicion-raising way. "Undecided", in other words.
Conversion has been relaxed slash borderline troll-y, but based on small things like #133 I'd say they are slightly more likely to be Town. Ultimately also "undecided", though.
FWIW Mocsta seemed very different compared to the last game so my read of him was Town.
TicTock I felt more iffy about -- the tone of the early pages Townread to me, but #105 was really bad and #108 seemed self-aware in a Mafia-like way.
Regfan seemed very Town to me. Played with him a lot but that was many many years ago. As Mafia he starts painting himself in a corner very early in the game (tries to "overproduce content" in other words). There was no sight of that here, and the whole hydra-dynamic seemed not forced.
I love you slenderman T-T
After this post I claim that Slenderman is NOT Mafia.
|
United Kingdom30775 Posts
If Calix then becomes confirmed parity cop then koshi heals her. If calix gets off a check or dies koshi is mafia. If calix is rb koshi will die.
|
Slenderman could post at the last minute though and thus avoid mod-kill. I'm staying on that guy.
#ritoky #ninjavoting
|
On July 03 2018 05:10 CopCake wrote:Show nested quote +On July 03 2018 05:06 Calix wrote:Did anyone ever comment on this post by the way? I don't think they did. Now that you know there's a mafia between Slenderman and CopCake (or me if you think I'm lying), thoughts? On July 01 2018 09:04 TheSlenderMan wrote:
I thought the Day would end tomorrow, not today :/
I see going by the last few pages that my inactivity warrants an apology. I don't know yet what has happened in the Thread, but I see a LOT of Modkills so something nasty must've happened.
I only had time to read a measly ten pages. If I do get retroactively modkilled for inactivity (as some people seem to be demanding), there's probably only one useful thing I can say at this point: I feel VERY strongly that Cake is Town. Cake isn't this fortright and confident as Mafia -- she "beats up around the bush" (if that's the correct English idiom) and focuses on manipulating people but doesn't do that here. I've played with her a lot and feel VERY strongly about this read.
If I had voted based on what I had read, my Vote would've gone to Calix. I really, really dislike the early Vote on Cake. Not because I disagree with the read, but because it felt really lazy, identifying Cake as a possible "low-hanging fruit" in the Thread. It didn't seem to have legitimate content-analysis to back the Vote up. Other than that his thread-presence has so far merely warranted the comment "okay-ish" in my notes, and such meek thread-presence (I've noticed) often ends up pointing to Scum.
rayn has started the game pointing out the exact things I would've expected him to, in the exact tone. So I feel pretty confident in saying he's also Town here, FWIW.
Of the non-modkilled early posters that leaves only Conversion and HF -- HF's start seems different compared to the last game, but not in a suspicion-raising way. "Undecided", in other words.
Conversion has been relaxed slash borderline troll-y, but based on small things like #133 I'd say they are slightly more likely to be Town. Ultimately also "undecided", though.
FWIW Mocsta seemed very different compared to the last game so my read of him was Town.
TicTock I felt more iffy about -- the tone of the early pages Townread to me, but #105 was really bad and #108 seemed self-aware in a Mafia-like way.
Regfan seemed very Town to me. Played with him a lot but that was many many years ago. As Mafia he starts painting himself in a corner very early in the game (tries to "overproduce content" in other words). There was no sight of that here, and the whole hydra-dynamic seemed not forced. I love you slenderman T-T After this post I claim that Slenderman is NOT Mafia.
Do you think I'm town, CopCake? ^^
|
There is no need for a mafia slenderman to say that I am a manipulative bitch when I roll mafia.
He could have just said “Oh I have played games with her” need to consider if he was pocketing but still ToT <3
|
On July 03 2018 05:08 Holyflare wrote:
If we want to believe calix then it is objectively the best play to lynch copcake until slender posts once and then vote him.
If he is mafia he is modkilled and if he is town we kill mafia copcake.
He wasnt modkilled before
Why would he be modkilled here?
|
Trying to use mod-kills to decide who to lynch is extremely terrible so let's not do that.
|
On July 03 2018 05:11 Calix wrote:Show nested quote +On July 03 2018 05:10 CopCake wrote:On July 03 2018 05:06 Calix wrote:Did anyone ever comment on this post by the way? I don't think they did. Now that you know there's a mafia between Slenderman and CopCake (or me if you think I'm lying), thoughts? On July 01 2018 09:04 TheSlenderMan wrote:
I thought the Day would end tomorrow, not today :/
I see going by the last few pages that my inactivity warrants an apology. I don't know yet what has happened in the Thread, but I see a LOT of Modkills so something nasty must've happened.
I only had time to read a measly ten pages. If I do get retroactively modkilled for inactivity (as some people seem to be demanding), there's probably only one useful thing I can say at this point: I feel VERY strongly that Cake is Town. Cake isn't this fortright and confident as Mafia -- she "beats up around the bush" (if that's the correct English idiom) and focuses on manipulating people but doesn't do that here. I've played with her a lot and feel VERY strongly about this read.
If I had voted based on what I had read, my Vote would've gone to Calix. I really, really dislike the early Vote on Cake. Not because I disagree with the read, but because it felt really lazy, identifying Cake as a possible "low-hanging fruit" in the Thread. It didn't seem to have legitimate content-analysis to back the Vote up. Other than that his thread-presence has so far merely warranted the comment "okay-ish" in my notes, and such meek thread-presence (I've noticed) often ends up pointing to Scum.
rayn has started the game pointing out the exact things I would've expected him to, in the exact tone. So I feel pretty confident in saying he's also Town here, FWIW.
Of the non-modkilled early posters that leaves only Conversion and HF -- HF's start seems different compared to the last game, but not in a suspicion-raising way. "Undecided", in other words.
Conversion has been relaxed slash borderline troll-y, but based on small things like #133 I'd say they are slightly more likely to be Town. Ultimately also "undecided", though.
FWIW Mocsta seemed very different compared to the last game so my read of him was Town.
TicTock I felt more iffy about -- the tone of the early pages Townread to me, but #105 was really bad and #108 seemed self-aware in a Mafia-like way.
Regfan seemed very Town to me. Played with him a lot but that was many many years ago. As Mafia he starts painting himself in a corner very early in the game (tries to "overproduce content" in other words). There was no sight of that here, and the whole hydra-dynamic seemed not forced. I love you slenderman T-T After this post I claim that Slenderman is NOT Mafia. Do you think I'm town, CopCake? ^^
I am thinking!!!!!
It is the first time I am facing a mafia slenderman and i have to think, it is a fiasco if he was mafia and I never got the opportunity to fight him.
|
United Kingdom30775 Posts
On July 03 2018 05:11 Calix wrote:
Slenderman could post at the last minute though and thus avoid mod-kill. I'm staying on that guy.
#ritoky #ninjavoting
If he posts at the last minute then I will boycott any future game with this voting mechanic and post count of 1 requirement. I will also lose all respect for slenderman.
Why is self voting even a thing? Just don't count their vote and modkill them.
|
No
The best thing is to wait for rayn.
He has played with mafiaslendy! Before.
And I am confident rayn is 100% town after the doct thing with koshi.
Like I said, there is no way mafia would lose the opportunity to win the game.
|
On July 03 2018 05:15 Holyflare wrote:Show nested quote +On July 03 2018 05:11 Calix wrote:
Slenderman could post at the last minute though and thus avoid mod-kill. I'm staying on that guy.
#ritoky #ninjavoting If he posts at the last minute then I will boycott any future game with this voting mechanic and post count of 1 requirement. I will also lose all respect for slenderman. Why is self voting even a thing? Just don't count their vote and modkill them.
If you're mafia who keeps talking about mod-kills and other bullshit instead of playing the game then I will lose all respect for you ^^
It's a mechanic I used in the last game because I didn't want to mod-kill for no-votes and Kelsier copied me.
You already know this since you were in that game where I introduced this mechanic.
I don't recall you bitching about it this much then, if at all.
|
Also “no killing” is a very cake thing to do and rayn hasnt said anything about it. So he believes in doctor Koshi.
|
United Kingdom30775 Posts
On July 03 2018 05:18 Calix wrote:Show nested quote +On July 03 2018 05:15 Holyflare wrote:On July 03 2018 05:11 Calix wrote:
Slenderman could post at the last minute though and thus avoid mod-kill. I'm staying on that guy.
#ritoky #ninjavoting If he posts at the last minute then I will boycott any future game with this voting mechanic and post count of 1 requirement. I will also lose all respect for slenderman. Why is self voting even a thing? Just don't count their vote and modkill them. If you're mafia who keeps talking about mod-kills and other bullshit instead of playing the game then I will lose all respect for you ^^ It's a mechanic I used in the last game because I didn't want to mod-kill for no-votes and Kelsier copied me. You already know this since you were in that game where I introduced this mechanic. I don't recall you bitching about it this much then, if at all.
Yes but nobody abused it and it was still shit. Why would you not modkill for no votes when that is the entire point of this game that gives information.
|
United Kingdom30775 Posts
I advocate for no kill and see what happens tonight.
|
United Kingdom30775 Posts
I will not shake the mafia mylo claim plays.
|
On July 03 2018 05:20 Holyflare wrote:Show nested quote +On July 03 2018 05:18 Calix wrote:On July 03 2018 05:15 Holyflare wrote:On July 03 2018 05:11 Calix wrote:
Slenderman could post at the last minute though and thus avoid mod-kill. I'm staying on that guy.
#ritoky #ninjavoting If he posts at the last minute then I will boycott any future game with this voting mechanic and post count of 1 requirement. I will also lose all respect for slenderman. Why is self voting even a thing? Just don't count their vote and modkill them. If you're mafia who keeps talking about mod-kills and other bullshit instead of playing the game then I will lose all respect for you ^^ It's a mechanic I used in the last game because I didn't want to mod-kill for no-votes and Kelsier copied me. You already know this since you were in that game where I introduced this mechanic. I don't recall you bitching about it this much then, if at all. Yes but nobody abused it and it was still shit. Why would you not modkill for no votes when that is the entire point of this game that gives information.
While I'd love to continue this discussion about hosting, I'd rather you do some game-solving, sweetheart.
|
United Kingdom30775 Posts
I refuse to game solve until tomorrow when we have more perfect information.
|
On July 03 2018 05:23 Holyflare wrote:
I refuse to game solve until tomorrow when we have more perfect information.
The perfect information being Koshi flipping doctor?
There's zero point in no lynching when the only scenario that can come of it is one of the blue roles dying tonight. You're not even advocating for using the extra time to discuss anything!
You're probably pushing for a no lynch so we don't get the chance to kill the roleblocker. Because if we lynch the roleblocker then Koshi can heal me and I get another cop check.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
