[M][N] Elementary Mafia - Page 56

On June 01 2018 03:33 LightningStrike wrote:

Can't decide on my second scum yet will try to do filter diving in a little bit.

On May 29 2018 05:43 fuba wrote:

I didn't believe jealous was scum, but was ok with him as a policy lynch. I wasn't gonna vote him, but wasn't really too upset with him as an option. And I had little thought on DF. I definitely wasn't gonna pop in and vote DF with no personal reasoning 20 minutes before EOD. I guess since I was viewing Koshi as town, the smarter thing would have been to switch my vote to someone who was definitely not being lynched, but I didn't consider that at the time.

Shenannies are for people who have had the time and have given a good deal of thought to what they're doing - I didn't have that.

On May 30 2018 11:46 fuba wrote:
It occurs to me that not behaving exactly like HF would in a given scenario might not make you scum :o

On June 01 2018 03:45 GlowingBear wrote:


Just saw this in your filter and shenannies is actually the very opposite.

On June 01 2018 03:48 GlowingBear wrote:


What do you mean with this?

On June 01 2018 03:53 fuba wrote:
My two scum are DF and HF, but mostly from a paranoia POV. I'm not entirely sure of it, and generally from my way of scumhunting it's harder to read high-content posters, but I feel like since the moment Jealous was pretty locked in as the lynch, HF's been playing the long game. If DF is scum, then HF was basically able to pull the trigger on one of his scumbuddies D1 without fear and make himself look better in the process (and also making the alternative lynch candidate look townier because they were the counterwagon). He railed against rayn, he railed against GB, he railed against Koshi - either all high content posters who will oppose him or people that had the potential to read him well. People who can oppose his outspoken personality late game. He hasn't gone after (from what I can remember) me, DF, or byj - not sure about LS or Rels - I think they're kinda in the middle. If scum HF is going to survive with a team of himself, Jealous, and DF, he needs to take out those that can oppose him end game and will pursue it to his lynch. He tried to get the doc to protect himself over you, scum tried to take you out last night instead of him. He's not really trying to get other people to post more than they are - he's settling on high content posters and, if he's town, just kind of assuming the low content posters are town for no reason.

DF is kinda there as an afterthought and somewhat because of what I said yesterday. His spot could be filled by someone else - dunno who though. And I'm kind of locked in the thought of HF choosing between which of his two scum mates to hammer D1.

On June 01 2018 03:57 fuba wrote:

It was mostly a comment on HF's apparent stubbornness, and the fact that Koshi not behaving exactly how HF says he would have might not have been a valid reason to vote him.

On June 01 2018 03:33 GlowingBear wrote:


If you're town, this is the worst thing you can do to help your team.
Accept that in a mafia game you can and will be called mafia for unwanted reasons and carry on.

So let's talk.

On June 01 2018 03:35 GlowingBear wrote:
I mean, it's day3, there is probably a towniest to scummiest list you can do in your mind.

On June 01 2018 04:01 fuba wrote:
HF is a player who posts too much for me to feel comfortable with a read on him based on what he actually says, so I look at his actions in the context of the goings-on of the game, and it doesn't feel like a "town HF looking for scum" agenda - it looks like a "scum HF rooting out his competition so he can make it to endgame" agenda.

It's also likely that if he fights me on the read, I will not engage - I don't have the energy for prolonged discussions.

On June 01 2018 04:07 LightningStrike wrote:
##Vote: LightningStrike
Decided it's time to do this.

On June 01 2018 04:07 GlowingBear wrote:
Why are you so dodgy about your reads, LS?