Newbie Student Mafia XXVI - Page 125

On June 10 2017 11:40 LightningStrike wrote:

To be fair on ritoky he did check Grack night 2 who he was tunneled on. But ya I would think he would of checked me night 1 as well.

On June 10 2017 11:41 Holyflare wrote:


If you're making a cop play of course you're going to say you checked the guy you're tunneled on? He leaves you as a mislynch because you're very lynchable.

On June 10 2017 11:48 Tumblewood wrote:
mostly semi-recent stuff like titanic 7, ffl. he tryharded in kinda vanilla but also there was yuma, you only shoot once, where he was p lazy. but i also picked out some random ones from the middle of his filter. i don't remember which ones those were but, say, mario mini mafia is an example i found clicking randomly again

On June 05 2017 06:06 Holyflare wrote:


You state BH is clearly town because as mafia he does WAY less:





I'll make it easy:

[N] You Only Shoot Once Mafia Mafia Recruiting-Mason//Traitor Lynched Day 3 - 4 pages
[M][N] Yuma Mini Mafia Mafia Vanilla Lynched Day 2 - 3 pages
[M][N] Noir Mini Mafia: Chapter 2 Town Veteran Lynched Day 1 - 7 pages
[M][T] Cell (Mini?) Mafia III Mafia Vanilla Survived Day 5 - 6 pages
[M][N] Fantasy Football (FFL) Mini Town Vanilla Killed Night 2 - 11 pages
[T] Hearthstone Mafia Town Thrall Killed Night 1 - 4 pages
[N] VII Titanic Mini Mafia: I Have a Cunning Plan... Town Jailkeeper Survived Night 4 - 19 pages
[T] Aperture Mafia 4: This Time it's Personal Mafia Inspector G. Lestrade Survived Night 4 - 13 pages
[M][N] Noir Mini Mafia: Chapter 3 Town Vanilla Lynched Day 1 - 2 pages
[N] Assassination Mafia! Town Anti-Nuker Lynched Day 2 - 7 pages
[M][N] Mini Mafia: The kinda Vanilla Experience Mafia Vanilla Survived Day 6 - 20 pages

Now that's going back realllyyy far which I don't think you would have done, you should be (and most likely would be) looking at his latest games. All of his last mafia games have had his highest page filter counts and basically content counts in the previous few games of his. So, when you say he has more content, more filter length I think that's incredibly disingenuous because that's just not true at all.

So, which games of his did you read exactly? This read looks really fabricated to me.

On June 10 2017 11:56 Conversion wrote:
why are we lynching HF first when lynching TW gives just as much information. if TW flips doctor insta lynch HF tbh. if TW is mafia, we're in a winning position.

if we lynch HF and he flips vig, we instalynch TW, but then we lose HF as a member of town and he doesn't get a chance to use his shot.

if HF + ritoky are both town, mafia has to make a decision to leave one alive. most likely will kill ritoky and RB HF so he doesn't get his shot off.

I really don't like lynching HF over TW if we're lynching inside of blues

On June 10 2017 12:00 Holyflare wrote:




So you looked through his most recent scum games of 20 pages + etc you looked through his town games as well as a town game from 5 YEARS ago and concluded that he does way more as town than mafia. Even though that is false when you look at this list?

You also made that meta read when he had lile 1-2 pages of just pointless spam. What made you town read him?


Furthermore you posted that post just now within 10 minutes and it's a tiny non committal throwaway but somehow you'd much rather claim cop day 1 and call us all bad instead of spending 30 seconds writing thr same thing then. Why?

On June 05 2017 06:05 Tumblewood wrote:
ls, who would you say is "winning" the argument between vivax and Hf?

On June 10 2017 12:06 Tumblewood wrote:
the exact reason i didn't answer your meta question was because i knew that if i tried to explain you would keep arguing his meta and the last thing i wanna do is go down a rabbit hole arguing someone else's meta. so no i won't oblige any more about that
i'm both very annoyed and very vindicated