Newbie Student Mafia XXVI - Page 10

beentheredonethat

2934 Posts

June 08 2017 19:44 GMT

#1951

ritoky can very well be scum and I'd like to retract my initial townread. my d1 townread on him was super yolo anyways, actually it's super easy to push D1 btdt.

His appearance around D2 flip time was super bad, he's not really contributing etc.

but I also don't wantto give PB a town pass because all he did was come in, defend himself in a weird way, piss off again. he's super low volume. same for conversion. I think in my filter, there's somewhere a list of people (5-6) that I don't have as locked towns.

we should work on that list, it's good.

beentheredonethat

2934 Posts

June 08 2017 19:45 GMT

#1952

On June 08 2017 09:36 beentheredonethat wrote:
So, my town list:

Tubesock (voting Fidei #2)
Tumblewood (blue claim, un-cc'ed, voting Fidei #3)
Grackaroni (had the exact same thoughts about Vivax pre-claim as me, voting Fidei #4 - hammer?)
Holyflare (#1774)

Leaves:
ritoky
LightningStrike (But I think I townread him for some reason earlier already, didn't I?)
Blazinghand
Conversion (who disappeared)
Prison Break (cased)

Is it so easy that a) both newbies are scum together AND both voted outside the scum wagon D1?

This one. This is a good list.

beentheredonethat

2934 Posts

June 08 2017 19:57 GMT

#1956

On June 09 2017 04:54 Prison Break wrote:
I think the most suspicious thing is here who even believes beentheredonethat scumreads me despite me playing differently from last game?

Like he's just tunneling me at this point. I want to believe he's town but I don't think he is. It also doesn't help that I have many townreads as well, I should look into them again in case I'm wrong on BTDT/conversion

I like how me mentioning you always summons you into the thread.

HF if you can seriously shoot, then shoot PB.

beentheredonethat

2934 Posts

June 08 2017 19:58 GMT

#1957

On June 09 2017 04:56 Prison Break wrote:
like I'm not saying scum would always town or scumread me, but the reason has to be genuine, and it seems like btdt is kind of pissed off that I actually came in here to defend myself etc. and people are starting to townread me now. like he doesn't want to let go but he doesn't feel comfortable continuing his push either. but he never really reconsiders. I don't even know what he scumreads me for anymore

Okay. Okay. Can you please do one thing for me: list every single player in the game that is alive and kicking. Next to the name, put in one word what your read on them is. Scum/Town/Null. Please do that. Please.

beentheredonethat

2934 Posts

June 08 2017 20:07 GMT

#1958

No really I cannot get over this shitty shit of a post.

"like I'm not saying scum would always town or scumread me"
What the actual fuck do you mean with that?

"but the reason has to be genuine, and it seems like btdt is kind of pissed off that I actually came in here to defend myself etc. and people are starting to townread me now"

The reason for someone to read you town or scum has to be genuine. Okay, I understand that. I have several reasons for why I scumread you. You say I'm pissed off that you came in here to defend yourself? No! I think that's great! But your defense is in no way making me town read you. On the contrary, the way you are making up things in your defense (such as "I pushed Fidei pretty hard" which is an outright exaggeration and can very well be seen as a lie) are making me feel better on my scumread.
People are starting to townread you now? No! HF does so. For whatever, unstated, super weird reasons, he does so. I guess it's a tone thing or whatever. That is one. And am I mad about this? No, I am not.

You need to realize that not everything I say or do is related to you, PB. Of course I'm wondering why HF is townreading you. Because HF said just 24 hours ago that my case on you is solid! So I'm wondering what made HF change his mind. Because I want to understand not only you, but also HF better.

"like he doesn't want to let go but he doesn't feel comfortable continuing his push either. but he never really reconsiders"

Why would I feel uncomfortable pushing you? Because HF townreads you? Would you please remember that I stated multiple times that I did believe Vivax claim (when everyone(!!!!!) was against Vivax) and that I even hard defended him once he rescineded his flip? Like if I was scum, why would I feel uncomfortable about pushing you if that's the thing people agree with? If that's the thing people townread me for? No, I do not feel uncomfortable! The hell?!

Do I look like I reconsider you being scum here? If so, SORRY! It's just me not knowing everything and considering that I might be wrong. Right now, to me, my points have not been disapproved or something so I'm perfectly fine seeing you flip. Holy.

" I don't even know what he scumreads me for anymor"
How about you check my filter? There you have it multiple times even, partially in conversations, partially in a case. Holy moly.

beentheredonethat

2934 Posts

June 08 2017 20:09 GMT

#1960

On June 09 2017 04:54 Prison Break wrote:
I think the most suspicious thing is here who even believes beentheredonethat scumreads me despite me playing differently from last game?

Like he's just tunneling me at this point. I want to believe he's town but I don't think he is. It also doesn't help that I have many townreads as well, I should look into them again in case I'm wrong on BTDT/conversion

Are you saying my scumread on you is fake? What makes you think that? Can you please point towards observations that are obviously (or not so obviously) made up? Can you please show the flaws in the logic I used to deduct that your behaviour makes you scum? Can you PLEASE do that instead of just saying "who even believes that" because you sound like Trump talking about climate change, holy shit

beentheredonethat

2934 Posts

June 08 2017 20:09 GMT

#1961

and hint, climate change is real

beentheredonethat

2934 Posts

June 08 2017 20:10 GMT

#1962

On June 09 2017 04:51 ritoky wrote:
[image loading]

don't, just don't. instead, be constructive.

beentheredonethat

2934 Posts

June 08 2017 20:11 GMT

#1963

On June 09 2017 04:33 Prison Break wrote:

Show nested quote +

Grack said that, to which I said "Grack+btdt aren't a team"

Show nested quote +

I love that post. It shows that you're actually reading the thread. The majority of your "reads" and posts does make the impression you're not reading the game. However, although not actively posting very much, you pick that very post from HF, because it suits your current "oh, btdt is scum" pattern. You don't even care if the fake rage I put up as scum in Host Revenge is similar to what I'm doing here. You're just bringing it up because hell, you need something to paint btdt red.

beentheredonethat

2934 Posts

June 08 2017 20:12 GMT

#1964

Prison Break is scum. I'm super sure about that.

beentheredonethat

2934 Posts

June 08 2017 20:12 GMT

#1965

HF you townread him. Why? For what?

beentheredonethat

2934 Posts

June 08 2017 20:13 GMT

#1966

BH now that Vivax is dead, who are your scumreads?
Same questions for Grack/LS

beentheredonethat

2934 Posts

June 08 2017 20:36 GMT

#1971

On June 09 2017 05:22 Blazinghand wrote:

Show nested quote +

---->

Show nested quote +

Cool! Two posts where I wasn't, but the rest of my participation of the last 60 minutes was decent.

Yours wasn't.

beentheredonethat

2934 Posts

June 08 2017 20:41 GMT

#1974

On June 09 2017 05:37 Blazinghand wrote:

Show nested quote +

I ain't being all high and mighty about it. I own it. Legit. Be more like me.

I just realized now that this was BH and not ritoky. I thought ritoky quoted these two posts.

beentheredonethat

2934 Posts

June 08 2017 20:42 GMT

#1975

On June 09 2017 05:38 Blazinghand wrote:

Show nested quote +

Though like to be fair, I really thought about not making that post cause I didn't want to upset you, but it needed to be said. If you're gonna shit up the thread, own it. If you're gonna whine about people shitting up the thread within like 10 posts of you shitting up the thread, expect to get called out.

Yeah it's fine. I thought ritoky was the one calling me out for it because he'd then be called out for being here but not here.

beentheredonethat

2934 Posts

June 08 2017 21:52 GMT

#2004

grack hammered fidei though and you scumread him for something you townread me for. I also defended Vivax during and after his claim

beentheredonethat

2934 Posts

June 08 2017 22:00 GMT

#2014

On June 09 2017 06:53 ritoky wrote:
btdt i townread you ENTIRELY based on your emotional play to me. if you did that as mafia i am willing to lose to it, but i will not be happy with you post-game.

I did that as mafia

but to be perfectly honest even the rage that I do as mafia is most of the time genuine. I just take things super personally and I hate being called bad