[M][N] Generic Mini Mafia II - Page 11

On May 18 2017 20:45 Holyflare wrote:


It changes the question because pb isn't saying sl looks townier. But whatever floats your boat.

Palmar not even trying to figure me out at this point. Waiting to shit fight with me tomorrow i presume.

On May 15 2017 04:31 Tumblewood wrote:
hf and sl are probable town. palmar and fuba are probable scum. skynx and vivax are somewhere in between. and i am absolutely not ok with lynching outside of those 6 names. not really ok with going after hf or sl but clearly that's not stopping anyone

On May 18 2017 23:56 Palmar wrote:
this is, literally, quite the towniest game on content I've played, but whatever.

On May 19 2017 02:07 sicklucker wrote:
lets just say if im mafia with tumble +1 i would never let those morons kill df who town reads me over others

On May 19 2017 01:53 Prison Break wrote:
I've nailed it down to this

town: LS, Palmar, HF

scum: Grack or Vivax
scum: sicklurker

but vivax pushed sicklurker, so grack is more likely. vivax did have a weird post where he'd question why people would lynch sicklurker though, which can be interpreted as softdefending. I really don't like vivax "if my townread on TW is anything like my townread on PB then he must be mafia", that sounded insincere and it's complete bullshit. what's holding me back is that vivax pushes sicklurker now

as for grackeroni, he mentioned my post seemed scummy (where I went from scumreading HF to townreading him based on his posting), then when called out on it he basically retracted it pretty fast. seemed like he was trying to see if others would catch on, and when they didn't he kind of dropped it. Very scummy. If HF is town, and I went from scumreading to townreading him, then I can imagine scum being frustrated by that because they obviously want town to kill other town, so I can see this play having a scum motive. Don't see how it makes sense from town though

I think 2 scum is between these 3, LS palmar have been townie all game. no way HF is scum and being that paranoid yesterday, that seemed very real and townlike. so yeah I want to lynch between these 3, and I think both scum are between them

On May 19 2017 02:57 sicklucker wrote:
anyway this game is more about mechanics right now. will the mafia kill one of palmar or skynx? or will they be pussies and go after an unconfirmed not risking the 50/50 save. fun times the doctor is a true hero

On May 19 2017 03:47 sicklucker wrote:
hes talking about my master plans for night actions. its just wifmo bro

On May 11 2017 08:44 Tumblewood wrote:
okay, I might as well get all my reads out at once:
grack is my rock for now. and ls, but I always read him town. (don't get confused, he still is town. I'm always right.)
for now I'm gonna just ignore Palmar and Hf, because Palmar is obstinate and not crusading yet Hf is kinda just yelling and picking fights. plus one of them or rayn will probably die n1
Damdred is a little good in my book
prison break seems like most players I see from other sites. he seems to at least believe what he's saying
skynx has disappointed me so far. he reminds me of myself which is usually a bad sign
fuba had one post I thought sucked but other than that I've been ignoring him
rayn is town I think? I like rayn, he's doin good stuff
anyone else I just forgot was playing

On May 18 2017 22:59 Palmar wrote:
As for the current gamestate, and some very short reservations:

Grack: the fact that TW was willing to townread him so hard that he offered to build a towncase (I can't remember if he actually did, but I remember asking him for one) throws a wrench in that read of mine. Grack has still played a very underwhelming game if he's town and he's not really helping figure anything out, but still... It's making me pause.

sicklucker: I have a gut feeling he's town. There's literally no justification for it, I just think he is. I might be completely and utterly wrong. He's not done anything and when he's in the thread his posts are completely worthless... idk... I guess I'm gonna wait until tomorrow to read him in more detail.

Vivax: Still hedging on town. Still have the same nagging suspicions, but still gonna ignore them based purely on effort and content. I dislike how he intends to follow up on the scumlynch but whatever.

HF: The big question to me. I should probably be fairly sure he's mafia but I'm just not. The way he responded to my taunting and to skynx's reveal actually sounded rather townie. I also vaguely recall him making some case or push on TW at some point, but it may be me misremembering. I'm going to go back and see if, how and why that happened.

LS: Super underwhelming this game. I actually think it's not unlikely he's mafia. If you gave me a gun and told me to shoot someone I'd shoot, HF, but only because killing him would be fun. If I was shooting for the most likely to flip mafia I think I'd shoot LS.

PB: I've written him off as town throughout the game, because he sounds like one. Depending on what happens tomorrow he's a good candidate to just review and see if I wrote it off too quickly. He's a low content poster, but whenever he does post it feels like he has a townie mindset.

Skynx: 100% cop, confirmed.

______________________________

So in summary, I would probably kill LS right now. But I have very little faith in that being the correct call. It's mostly based on how I feel about the game at the moment. He's a guy that generally isn't afraid to post but he has somehow avoided almost all the big shitfights this game, just like TW did, really.

So yeah.... more tomorrow, maybe today.

On May 19 2017 05:15 Holyflare wrote:
SL
Grack
Palmar (if alive another cycle after)
LS (can really be anywhere above)
Vivax
Pb

probably a good lynch order

On May 19 2017 05:19 Holyflare wrote:


I re-read his list post and it actually wasn't too bad

but SL is because of everything he's done this cycle and he 100% should be the lynch, he's afkd but been here, he's said sketchy things and hedging on alignments so he fits in with the moment and he's refusing to interact properly with anything

Failing that;

Grack is because of his vote at the deadline and the lack of absolutely anything, if Grack is mafia then he effectively saved Palmar and Palmar is almost definitely mafia. Then you don't have to see if he dies or not because he's mafia.