|
On March 26 2017 05:45 raynpelikoneet wrote:
Who was like "scum or cop" on DF?
On March 23 2017 20:26 Koshi wrote:
Last pages of darthfoley is setup talk and then Eden is mafia talk. Nothing else. If he isn't the cop he is mafia. He completely stopped playing the game after and during getting the Eden bus cred.
And I still didn't forget about that lie he told to put me under suspicion.
Far out the best bet on mafia. Far far.
##vote darthfoley
|
|
|
this was short before the claim, when a lot of ppl had df in their poe.
or were like "scum or cop"
|
I genuinely thought he was mafia which is why i jailed him last night, he was only my #2 cop read after Koshi. 
|
On March 26 2017 05:40 disformation wrote:Show nested quote +On March 26 2017 05:31 Damdred wrote:On March 26 2017 05:28 Damdred wrote:
I'm last what was thread consensus at the time on f2f then? And what was tumbles rread on him based off of?
Town points for whoever answers besides rayn F2f should be df rip autocorrect not sure when you mean? tw had df as scum early and then flipped for: outside of that he has like no explanation? think thread consent on df was fairly middle ground for the most part. town leanish for tone in some cases. some ppl had him in like poe, but not at the bottom usually. thats more from memory though.
On March 26 2017 05:42 disformation wrote:this was short before the claim, when a lot of ppl had df in their poe. or were like "scum or cop" Show nested quote +On March 22 2017 14:09 Tumblewood wrote:thoughts on all some players with reasoning: disformation - has these huge walls of text. in some places he seems to show real conviction, but it's fleeting. i am conflicted because it seems like a lot of work for a scummer to put it but mostly he writes long posts that don't seem to have the intention of ever being read. leaning scum + Show Spoiler +i know you're going to ask what that means and i ask you figure it out yourself damdred - leaning back towards town because i remember (though i could not find it in his filter) the part where he sees eden's post and he's like "this is bad but i don't have time to explain why yet" which is something scum rarely does, usually preferring to just wait until they have the case (or at least, i think so). then again he has not impressed me in any respect this game so he is not off the hook yet. onegu - objectively bad, but that is to be expected. there are some things i have seen in his filter which are either so out of left field or so 'little' (like, "i expect this player to be yelling at me more") that i don't think scum1gu could come up with it in multiple instances. darthfoley - this quote & associated posts + Show Spoiler +Sorry for thinking that tumblewood's paranoia and generally EoD play isnt purely mafia indicative when I've done the same thing myself? make me real nice n happy inside and it warms my heart to think a player might play with such a townie agenda. (this really is the reason i townread df so hard during n1 and early d2) other than that i might describe him as indignant, which i consider a townie trait. but when he is not being indignant he is quite floaty and "this is weird" (vs "this makes X scum"). still, df is probably town. xatalos - when not antagonizing someone or another he does not post any quality analysis. fortunately for him i think shitfighting is quite a townie thing to do so he is ??? help me i have too many townreads bye
what are you trying to say in these posts? I don't understand a single bit how anything here has to do with anything.
|
well. my point wasnt phrased very well, but still stands.
that was to say: tw had a town read, when a bunch of ppl didnt.
not 100% of the majority of the thread had him as scum. maybe half?
|
On March 26 2017 05:51 raynpelikoneet wrote:Show nested quote +On March 26 2017 05:40 disformation wrote:On March 26 2017 05:31 Damdred wrote:On March 26 2017 05:28 Damdred wrote:
I'm last what was thread consensus at the time on f2f then? And what was tumbles rread on him based off of?
Town points for whoever answers besides rayn F2f should be df rip autocorrect not sure when you mean? tw had df as scum early and then flipped for: On March 19 2017 06:31 Tumblewood wrote:
I'll town df. he has passion (tm) outside of that he has like no explanation? think thread consent on df was fairly middle ground for the most part. town leanish for tone in some cases. some ppl had him in like poe, but not at the bottom usually. thats more from memory though. Show nested quote +On March 26 2017 05:42 disformation wrote:this was short before the claim, when a lot of ppl had df in their poe. or were like "scum or cop" On March 22 2017 14:09 Tumblewood wrote:thoughts on all some players with reasoning: disformation - has these huge walls of text. in some places he seems to show real conviction, but it's fleeting. i am conflicted because it seems like a lot of work for a scummer to put it but mostly he writes long posts that don't seem to have the intention of ever being read. leaning scum + Show Spoiler +i know you're going to ask what that means and i ask you figure it out yourself damdred - leaning back towards town because i remember (though i could not find it in his filter) the part where he sees eden's post and he's like "this is bad but i don't have time to explain why yet" which is something scum rarely does, usually preferring to just wait until they have the case (or at least, i think so). then again he has not impressed me in any respect this game so he is not off the hook yet. onegu - objectively bad, but that is to be expected. there are some things i have seen in his filter which are either so out of left field or so 'little' (like, "i expect this player to be yelling at me more") that i don't think scum1gu could come up with it in multiple instances. darthfoley - this quote & associated posts + Show Spoiler +Sorry for thinking that tumblewood's paranoia and generally EoD play isnt purely mafia indicative when I've done the same thing myself? make me real nice n happy inside and it warms my heart to think a player might play with such a townie agenda. (this really is the reason i townread df so hard during n1 and early d2) other than that i might describe him as indignant, which i consider a townie trait. but when he is not being indignant he is quite floaty and "this is weird" (vs "this makes X scum"). still, df is probably town. xatalos - when not antagonizing someone or another he does not post any quality analysis. fortunately for him i think shitfighting is quite a townie thing to do so he is ??? help me i have too many townreads bye what are you trying to say in these posts? I don't understand a single bit how anything here has to do with anything.
I was hoping damdred would tell me. you know since he was asking about it.
|
On March 26 2017 05:52 disformation wrote:
well. my point wasnt phrased very well, but still stands.
that was to say: tw had a town read, when a bunch of ppl didnt.
not 100% of the majority of the thread had him as scum. maybe half?
Yes and that is only repeating what reads in his filter and not answering Damdred's actual question.
|
On March 26 2017 05:28 Damdred wrote:
I'm last what was thread consensus at the time on f2f then? And what was tumbles rread on him based off of?
Town points for whoever answers besides rayn
Like fucking come on he is obviously telling you to answer "what does it mean?"
|
On March 26 2017 05:54 raynpelikoneet wrote:Show nested quote +On March 26 2017 05:52 disformation wrote:
well. my point wasnt phrased very well, but still stands.
that was to say: tw had a town read, when a bunch of ppl didnt.
not 100% of the majority of the thread had him as scum. maybe half? Yes and that is only repeating what reads in his filter and not answering Damdred's actual question.
He asked what the thread consensus on df was and what tumbles read on df was?
|
curious to see what happens tonight. i'm gonna try and look over the D2 stuff right now and see if i find anything before i might die
|
On March 26 2017 05:56 darthfoley wrote:
curious to see what happens tonight. i'm gonna try and look over the D2 stuff right now and see if i find anything before i might die
You don't btw need to claim anything about your check before the day hits.
It literally doesn't help because the result doesn't get out in case you die.
|
On March 26 2017 05:57 raynpelikoneet wrote:Show nested quote +On March 26 2017 05:56 darthfoley wrote:
curious to see what happens tonight. i'm gonna try and look over the D2 stuff right now and see if i find anything before i might die You don't btw need to claim anything about your check before the day hits. It literally doesn't help because the result doesn't get out in case you die.
yea i won't. i hope you go god mod. in rayn i trust
|
On March 26 2017 05:55 raynpelikoneet wrote:Show nested quote +On March 26 2017 05:28 Damdred wrote:
I'm last what was thread consensus at the time on f2f then? And what was tumbles rread on him based off of?
Town points for whoever answers besides rayn Like fucking come on he is obviously telling you to answer "what does it mean?"
tw not giving a fuck about thread consent making him more likely to be town?
|
could also be:
tw's read on df being very static, despite tw looking at df multiple times, more likely scum?
or something about tw knowing the setup and there being a cop and stuff?
|
daaaaaaaaamdy. i really want to know the answer now!
|
I jailed disformation.
Xatalos is not mafia.
If there is a kill disformation is not town for certain.
I don't think Koshi is mafia. I don't think Damdred is mafia. I don't think Tumblewood is mafia.
I think it's disformation + AMG. If one of them is town then probably Damdred. I really can't see either of AMG / Tumble do what they have as scum.
gl
|
I actually jailed Tumblewood.
Xatalos is not mafia.
If there is a kill Tumblewood is not town for certain.
If there is a kill and cop was roleblocked Tumblewood is 90% town.
I don't think Koshi is mafia. I don't think AMG is mafia. I don't think Damdred is mafia.
I think it's disformation + Tumblewood. If one of them is town then probably Damdred. I really can't see either of AMG / Koshi do what they have as scum.
gl
|
I still really don't like Koshi's play around the Eden lynch. At least Koshi and Xatalos are almost surely not on the same team.
On March 20 2017 05:49 Koshi wrote:Show nested quote +On March 20 2017 03:30 darthfoley wrote:
PSA that I hate Rels. That is all.
Anyways, I must say that I've been thoroughly unimpressed by Koshi's effort levels so far. Like I understand D1 being a crap shoot and all, but the D1 play looks super passive. Even know there are plenty of arguments going on between Xata, Calix, rayn, Damdred, Eden etc but Koshi only pops in with a few one liners.
Would like to hear what he makes of all of this stuff This is a fucking lie. I was only here the first 24h and I did way fucking more than that. Like.. You are taking my 24h filter and then pretend it is all I did for 96 hours. mafia.
Posts like this are objectively bad imo. He did a good job of misconstruing shit I said earlier in the game.
On March 20 2017 07:45 Koshi wrote:
The real problem I have with DF his fake ass accusation on me is that it is just so blatantly wrong and not committal. I told everybody I was going to have a busy 96 hours but had a 4 page filter in the first 24. In which I drove the game forward. Then I was afk for 48 hours and people started mumbling, and then DF comes in and says that... Like.. Why?
On March 20 2017 08:29 Koshi wrote:Show nested quote +On March 20 2017 08:28 raynpelikoneet wrote:On March 20 2017 05:41 Koshi wrote:On March 20 2017 02:40 raynpelikoneet wrote:
And i am having fun with that, because people cannot be convinced with any sort of logic anymore in this game so i don't really see what else should i be happy about when playing mafia anymore. What the fuck are you talking about? We fucking followed your lynch. We hit town. Now you are mad that we are not listening to logic? Also you and Xatalos want to explain this because literally noone did call Malongo mafia for the reasons i did, people argued he is mafia for different reasons but somehow both of you and Xatalos want to paint it as "rayn lead the lynch on Malongo" which is by default wrong. No I am not doing that there at all. I am calling out your bullshit that we don't want to listen to logic while we lynched who you wanted. You can't say 'this time sucks and don't want to listen to logic" while we fucking lynched who you wanted.
All of these posts just scream fake anger to me. Like why the hell would these posts trigger you so hard lol. We've already discussed how rayn wasn't the only person to case Malongo D1, etc. But I just find the way Koshi has framed stuff this game to be either half right or outright wrong many times.
I find his reasons to switch off Eden onto Xata to be relatively poor, then it's even weirder that he switches back on to Eden late for no explanation.
On March 22 2017 06:05 Koshi wrote:
Hmm the Eden lynch is set in stone. TW/rayn/Damdred/Calix are lock town then. If 1 is mafia this is over. I can live with that.
Weird wording... why does it matter if the lynch is set in stone if you truly believe Xata is mafia? He even says he made 3 posts about Xata being mafia. Yet...
On March 22 2017 06:18 Koshi wrote:
I'll explain myself better. I take a risk on Damdred and TW but I cba to fucking even doubts to reads anymore if Eden flips town. It is your own fucking fault they become untouchable.
On March 22 2017 06:27 Koshi wrote:
##unvote
##vote Eden1892
We pray to jeebus.
I just find his filter thoroughly unimpressive. Everything is either other people's fault, "cba to explain to you plebs," or reads that flip on a whim without explanation and he gets away with it because he's Koshi
. He also called Calix lock town forever and then she died over one blue. Calix was also one of the few players besides me to put any pressure on him.
Really hate the argument that "Koshi wouldn't do X night action!" considering 1) i dont think anyone left would do these night actions 2) he's been afk for large chunks of time, including perhaps the mafia night actions so that's something to think about. He could still be mafia and just not have sent in the actions.
|
Canada11355 Posts
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
