|
tbh it is an ass read, but I dont think scum would propose a game like:
On December 28 2016 04:39 Superbia wrote:Let's spice this up. I have a proposition mods.  Flip your almighty coin: Heads—Kill a person of my choice. Tails—Kill me.
to the hosts. :p
also made me laugh
|
On December 29 2016 05:23 Grackaroni wrote:Show nested quote +On December 29 2016 05:12 GlowingBear wrote:On December 29 2016 05:06 ExO_ wrote:On December 29 2016 04:59 GlowingBear wrote:On December 29 2016 01:58 ExO_ wrote:On December 29 2016 01:40 GlowingBear wrote:On December 28 2016 23:38 Koshi wrote:
So I didn't see there was a voting thread. I even went looking for it yesterday. But I voted today.
Nothing much changed. TT entered the thread and did absolutely nothing but buddy me up and waffle a bit. The most interesting thing was his role suggestion, read it three times, I don't understand it, I doubt he does. lol.
Grack dismissing my case against him like a mafia would. Taking my points super literal and then weazle himself out of them using silly argumentation. Still mafia.
Really liked the reaction from GB on disformation his post. Super townie.
@GB: Do not get tunneled on ExO based on his opening and a reasoning you haven't even explained to the thread fully. He is not yet lock town, but for now he is not a correct lynch, his posting pushed the game forward by a lot, people who try to push the game forwardlook bad by default because they have to create something from nothing, most of the time you do that by posting reply bait comments, I really doubt mafia!ExO opened like he did here. You better go look for the prominent posters that are blending in doing completely nothing as town, or the afkers that are hiding their alignment. Kill those first.
Grack
Slam
Chez
TiTr
Disfo
TT
Superbia
darth
LS
GB
ExO
Slam and Chez are high on the lynchlist because both refuse to work with town. Easy lynches. Easy vig shots. Get rid of them.
Grack is mafia.
TiTr could already have pushed mafia agenda, has complained about things he shouldn't complain about, hasn't pushed the game further, has only 1 strong read which he adopted from thread sentiment.
@TiTr, try to do things other than pretending to be one of those complaining muppets from the muppet show. You do not participate at the game unless forced.
Koshi, I was usually the player that starts thread discussion, I know where you're coming from, but I don't think it looked like he was getting behind real suspicions. It actually looked like to me that he was just trying to look contributive without actually being committed to what he was pushing If we are not lynching him we should lynch disformation GB do you believe that load of bullshit you just spouted? You think I was trying to look contributive without being committed to who I was pushing. It's day 1, the thread was dead and I did everything in my power to get people talking and I think it largely worked. Did you want me to pick 1 player and tunnel them into oblivion? Do you not want me to consider the possibility that other players might be mafia? And where were you? You didn't do anything to get the thread going. Anything you are saying about me could be applied to you twice as hard. Really wanna vote GB now I did exactly the opposite of pushing everywhere, how come you can say that everything I say can be said against me twice as hard? Lol This kind of logic that makes me think you're mafia. You take a post, exaggerate it and use it to call anyone Mafia. You know, it's really easy to call anyone mafia. Sometimes I do that as Mafia because it's very easy and people will call me town for the same bullshit for why they are calling you town. Yes, I am considering other people being Mafia. I've already told the thread I would lynch Disformation. You're misrepresenting what I said (or are too stupid to comprehend it). I never said you were pushing everywhere, I implied the opposite. You accused me of trying to look contributive without contributing. I've contributed at least twice the amount you have. I got in and drove up a dead thread, while you sat around and did nothing. That's not the heart of the things I'm accusing you. You've pushed silly things, like, for example, forcing time traveler to reveal himself if he is a smurf. This is a thing that doesn't matter in any way. When he said he wasn't a smurf but a new player you kept pushing him saying you don't believe him lol. This kind of push is just apparently contributive, but it actually does nothing because him being s smurf or not being a smurf tells nothing about his alignment. And that's what I saw you doing. Most of ExO's posts were from the early game. It's not really a fair comparison.
Then answer me: if he was someone really interested to get the game going, why having a burst of pressure early game but then not being pushy by the end of the day?
|
or to actually add something to my slam thing:
we have like 5 ??? players. And with him I 100% know he can play very town. So I want to pressure him into being more town. not too hard to understand right?
|
On December 29 2016 05:25 disformation wrote:tbh it is an ass read, but I dont think scum would propose a game like: Show nested quote +On December 28 2016 04:39 Superbia wrote:Let's spice this up. I have a proposition mods. Flip your almighty coin: Heads—Kill a person of my choice. Tails—Kill me. to the hosts. :p also made me laugh
Scum would, but that's not the reason why I'm unsure about lynching him, brb
|
On December 29 2016 05:26 GlowingBear wrote:Show nested quote +On December 29 2016 05:23 Grackaroni wrote:On December 29 2016 05:12 GlowingBear wrote:On December 29 2016 05:06 ExO_ wrote:On December 29 2016 04:59 GlowingBear wrote:On December 29 2016 01:58 ExO_ wrote:On December 29 2016 01:40 GlowingBear wrote:On December 28 2016 23:38 Koshi wrote:
So I didn't see there was a voting thread. I even went looking for it yesterday. But I voted today.
Nothing much changed. TT entered the thread and did absolutely nothing but buddy me up and waffle a bit. The most interesting thing was his role suggestion, read it three times, I don't understand it, I doubt he does. lol.
Grack dismissing my case against him like a mafia would. Taking my points super literal and then weazle himself out of them using silly argumentation. Still mafia.
Really liked the reaction from GB on disformation his post. Super townie.
@GB: Do not get tunneled on ExO based on his opening and a reasoning you haven't even explained to the thread fully. He is not yet lock town, but for now he is not a correct lynch, his posting pushed the game forward by a lot, people who try to push the game forwardlook bad by default because they have to create something from nothing, most of the time you do that by posting reply bait comments, I really doubt mafia!ExO opened like he did here. You better go look for the prominent posters that are blending in doing completely nothing as town, or the afkers that are hiding their alignment. Kill those first.
Grack
Slam
Chez
TiTr
Disfo
TT
Superbia
darth
LS
GB
ExO
Slam and Chez are high on the lynchlist because both refuse to work with town. Easy lynches. Easy vig shots. Get rid of them.
Grack is mafia.
TiTr could already have pushed mafia agenda, has complained about things he shouldn't complain about, hasn't pushed the game further, has only 1 strong read which he adopted from thread sentiment.
@TiTr, try to do things other than pretending to be one of those complaining muppets from the muppet show. You do not participate at the game unless forced.
Koshi, I was usually the player that starts thread discussion, I know where you're coming from, but I don't think it looked like he was getting behind real suspicions. It actually looked like to me that he was just trying to look contributive without actually being committed to what he was pushing If we are not lynching him we should lynch disformation GB do you believe that load of bullshit you just spouted? You think I was trying to look contributive without being committed to who I was pushing. It's day 1, the thread was dead and I did everything in my power to get people talking and I think it largely worked. Did you want me to pick 1 player and tunnel them into oblivion? Do you not want me to consider the possibility that other players might be mafia? And where were you? You didn't do anything to get the thread going. Anything you are saying about me could be applied to you twice as hard. Really wanna vote GB now I did exactly the opposite of pushing everywhere, how come you can say that everything I say can be said against me twice as hard? Lol This kind of logic that makes me think you're mafia. You take a post, exaggerate it and use it to call anyone Mafia. You know, it's really easy to call anyone mafia. Sometimes I do that as Mafia because it's very easy and people will call me town for the same bullshit for why they are calling you town. Yes, I am considering other people being Mafia. I've already told the thread I would lynch Disformation. You're misrepresenting what I said (or are too stupid to comprehend it). I never said you were pushing everywhere, I implied the opposite. You accused me of trying to look contributive without contributing. I've contributed at least twice the amount you have. I got in and drove up a dead thread, while you sat around and did nothing. That's not the heart of the things I'm accusing you. You've pushed silly things, like, for example, forcing time traveler to reveal himself if he is a smurf. This is a thing that doesn't matter in any way. When he said he wasn't a smurf but a new player you kept pushing him saying you don't believe him lol. This kind of push is just apparently contributive, but it actually does nothing because him being s smurf or not being a smurf tells nothing about his alignment. And that's what I saw you doing. Most of ExO's posts were from the early game. It's not really a fair comparison. Then answer me: if he was someone really interested to get the game going, why having a burst of pressure early game but then not being pushy by the end of the day?
I think that's valid. But still not the best choice for today. I could get behind a disfo lynch.
|
On December 28 2016 03:37 Superbia wrote:
Actually I retract calling darth cool. His read progression on TT seems pretty weird.
This is a post where it looks like he is thinking critically about the game. It gave me pause when I've read his filter.
|
Disfo, expand on your read on me.
|
On December 28 2016 04:06 Superbia wrote:Show nested quote +On December 28 2016 04:04 Tictock wrote:On December 28 2016 03:38 Superbia wrote:More specifically this question seems kinda forced and is never answered/addressed. TT still goes to #1 town on darth's list though. + Show Spoiler +On December 27 2016 15:28 darthfoley wrote:Ticktock's entrance is definitely different than usual. However, motivated TT also makes me happy. Anyone feel like ExO is trying a little too hard to scum hunt? I know the D1 lynch thing is becoming a meme, but uber aggression is not what I associated with his town play (from what i've seen). I do find this post a bit odd, however. Show nested quote +On December 27 2016 15:10 Tictock wrote:On December 27 2016 13:12 darthfoley wrote:
Yup the votes on Koshi are silly.
Also don't understand why ExO wants a biography about everyone's history of mafia playing. Seems very irrelevant and feels more scummy than towny. I legit don't understand why he's asking people about it.
Yayyy people claiming VT in a game of only VTs! Great plays.
I prefer Grack so far to be most town This guy gets it. Darth you are gunna be my buddy this game I can feel it.Though tbh I don't think anyone has been terribly towny just yet. sentence one implies i'm towny, sentence two implies no one is towny? I think he and Grack discussed it and correctly concluded that the second line in my post was in reference to Darth early townread on Grack. I don't have a ton of time till later tonight so just gunna be doing some catching up and lite posts till then. I like GB he seems to be having similar thoughts as I did reading through the game. Koshi's return and semi list post feels pretty towny. Traveler also feels ok if a little, uh, formal? I guess. It's a bit early to tell on Super but the feels are good. Not sure what to make of Dis at all just yet, he feels like is is not invested in the game or something. Not sure if this is AI or related to him being in the other game. I need to reread Exo. I like his activity and his responses to pressure, but his reads feel pretty forced to me. Slam and LS have made little impact imo, actually a bit less sure on LS. Feels weird for LS to jump on board the Koshi vote so fast. Both because Koshi has def said he wants to post less as Town before and kus his view of the game feels oddly focused (kinda same on Exo) for this stage of the game. So I suppose I'm at Exo/Dis/LS right now. I dislike how you get to a team of 3 that quickly. =/ Especially since you mention slam but reach no conclusion.
This call-out is also good IMO, because it is actually pretty weird that TT is already making associations
|
I've been here non-stop and most of what Koshi says is crap. It should be a pretty easy tone read by now regardless of how much I feel like doing.
|
On December 29 2016 03:00 disformation wrote:
dunno gracks filter is a whole lot of nothing expressed in a lot of words. no reads / real hunting into defense against koshi.
|
On December 29 2016 05:31 GlowingBear wrote:Show nested quote +On December 28 2016 04:06 Superbia wrote:On December 28 2016 04:04 Tictock wrote:On December 28 2016 03:38 Superbia wrote:More specifically this question seems kinda forced and is never answered/addressed. TT still goes to #1 town on darth's list though. + Show Spoiler +On December 27 2016 15:28 darthfoley wrote:Ticktock's entrance is definitely different than usual. However, motivated TT also makes me happy. Anyone feel like ExO is trying a little too hard to scum hunt? I know the D1 lynch thing is becoming a meme, but uber aggression is not what I associated with his town play (from what i've seen). I do find this post a bit odd, however. Show nested quote +On December 27 2016 15:10 Tictock wrote:On December 27 2016 13:12 darthfoley wrote:
Yup the votes on Koshi are silly.
Also don't understand why ExO wants a biography about everyone's history of mafia playing. Seems very irrelevant and feels more scummy than towny. I legit don't understand why he's asking people about it.
Yayyy people claiming VT in a game of only VTs! Great plays.
I prefer Grack so far to be most town This guy gets it. Darth you are gunna be my buddy this game I can feel it.Though tbh I don't think anyone has been terribly towny just yet. sentence one implies i'm towny, sentence two implies no one is towny? I think he and Grack discussed it and correctly concluded that the second line in my post was in reference to Darth early townread on Grack. I don't have a ton of time till later tonight so just gunna be doing some catching up and lite posts till then. I like GB he seems to be having similar thoughts as I did reading through the game. Koshi's return and semi list post feels pretty towny. Traveler also feels ok if a little, uh, formal? I guess. It's a bit early to tell on Super but the feels are good. Not sure what to make of Dis at all just yet, he feels like is is not invested in the game or something. Not sure if this is AI or related to him being in the other game. I need to reread Exo. I like his activity and his responses to pressure, but his reads feel pretty forced to me. Slam and LS have made little impact imo, actually a bit less sure on LS. Feels weird for LS to jump on board the Koshi vote so fast. Both because Koshi has def said he wants to post less as Town before and kus his view of the game feels oddly focused (kinda same on Exo) for this stage of the game. So I suppose I'm at Exo/Dis/LS right now. I dislike how you get to a team of 3 that quickly. =/ Especially since you mention slam but reach no conclusion. This call-out is also good IMO, because it is actually pretty weird that TT is already making associations
Superbia had solid posts while he was here. He also had decent posts on Foley.
|
On December 29 2016 05:26 disformation wrote:
or to actually add something to my slam thing:
we have like 5 ??? players. And with him I 100% know he can play very town. So I want to pressure him into being more town. not too hard to understand right?
But if you call a pressure vote a "pressure vote", it stops being effective 
It also doesn't answer why aren't you pushing grack harder.
Can you tell me again why he is Mafia, please?
|
On December 29 2016 05:32 disformation wrote:Show nested quote +On December 29 2016 03:00 disformation wrote:
dunno gracks filter is a whole lot of nothing expressed in a lot of words. no reads / real hunting into defense against koshi.
Nonsense I've done more than most. More than you.
I just spend more time posting and there's a much smaller content to post ratio.
|
On December 29 2016 05:32 disformation wrote:Show nested quote +On December 29 2016 03:00 disformation wrote:
dunno gracks filter is a whole lot of nothing expressed in a lot of words. no reads / real hunting into defense against koshi.
Oh okay.
|
Vote Count
LightningStrike (0) : Grackaroni, disformation
Koshi (1) : ExO_, LightningStrike, Grackaroni
Tictock (0) : ExO_
disformation (1) : Tictock
ExO_ (1) : disformation, GlowingBear
Grackaroni (2) : Koshi, LightningStrike
Alakaslam (2) : ExO_, disformation
Superbia (1) : darthfoley
Not voting (5) : Alakaslam, beentheredonethat, Chezinu, Superbia, Time Traveler
Currently, Grackaroni is set to be lynched!
The day phase will end at Thursday, Dec 29 12:00am GMT (GMT+00:00), just under 3 1/2 hours from this post.
remain as you are reading this.
Remember, voting is mandatory! Place your votes in the voting thread.
If you see any vote out of place, let us know!
|
Grack, disfo, while you're here: what do you think about time traveler?
|
I must say I'm disliking LS. I remember Tina saying something about him being more "mechanical" when he is Mafia?
|
On December 29 2016 05:35 GlowingBear wrote:
Grack, disfo, while you're here: what do you think about time traveler?
He could be mafia but I don't really want to kill him today.
|
|
|
LS was scum in the game I just played. dont think he is scum here.
|
|
|
|
|
|
30323
632
504
146
94
74
EPT
