[M][N] Murder on the Cruise Trip Mafia

On September 28 2016 11:21 scott31337 wrote:


So does this mean there could be two of the same town power roles?

On September 28 2016 19:00 beentheredonethat wrote:

No. Good catch, thank you. Once a power role has been rolled, it will not be rolled again. I have added the information to the OP.

+ Show Spoiler +
As said above, no double roles will be included. Any combination of roles is possible but no duplicate roles.

medic/cop
medic/vet
medic/vigi
cop/vet
cop/vigi
vet/vigi

On September 28 2016 17:52 justanothertownie wrote:

I agree with this guy. He is a balance expert after all.

On October 04 2016 07:16 NeverUnlucky wrote:


I do not. Hence why I ask. I would like specific examples to know whether the rules prohibit me from being mod confirmed.

On October 04 2016 15:40 Holyflare wrote:
nEVERuNLUCKY probably bs confirmed himself town and koshi is either abusing it and bsing or is also town. Calix bad or mafia for even voting that way.

More wishy washy statements on koshi to come.

On October 04 2016 22:18 NeverUnlucky wrote:
Quick shitpost to make sure I have more posts than Calix.

On October 04 2016 23:11 Oatsmaster wrote:

Intent over already.
I think koshi has been skating by on pithy little comments.
I seem to remember other people promising shit but not delivering. I think it's stutters so he's leaning scum. Pretty sure Marv and Palmar are town. They don't give enough of a shit.

On October 05 2016 00:31 Calix wrote:


Well duh.

You didn't name yourself Yoshi

Also you keep harping on about your RL stuff.

On October 05 2016 01:43 Palmar wrote:
Thing about HF is I've convinced myself I need to figure him out, which is why I'm interested in him.

Also someone kidnapped the real Koshi, but I'm not sure fake koshi is mafia. But he's not real koshi.

On October 05 2016 02:40 Superbia wrote:
As I've said before, the Calix/NU thing is the most interesting thing so far. You've danced around alignments like a ballerina. Your push on Palmar was decent and founded. Palmar has shown up and done somewhat okay shit.

What now Marv?

On October 05 2016 03:46 justanothertownie wrote:

I wonder where I have heard that before.

On October 05 2016 05:40 justanothertownie wrote:

You know what's the purest form of irony?

Koshi, the guy who has been pushing me as mafia for repeating what town leaders say for years and years repeating what I say this game. If you are mafia this is quite hilarious.

On October 05 2016 22:42 justanothertownie wrote:

Your whole scumread on me hinges on bats being scum. And now if someone asks you what you think of grack if bats flips scum you say: "he might be scum because he pushed JAT instead of bats"? Like what?

On October 06 2016 02:47 NeverUnlucky wrote:

NU agrees with Koshi. Though replace super with stutters.

On October 06 2016 02:49 Calix wrote:
Like how is it that I have to explain the incredibly simple logic of "X player who stops posting and claims that he'll only check the thread to see how he can survive and who gets a counterwagon to X going shortly afterwards is mafia" to people?

Christ.

On October 06 2016 02:48 Holyflare wrote:
I'm up for a superbia shenanigan

On October 06 2016 02:56 Holyflare wrote:


because I remembered that I always scum read jat for playing like shit and I didn't mind his responses and I weigh someone scum reading me when they agree with everything I pushed way more likely mafia than anything else and all I did was ask for her scum reads and what i got instead was a "if my two scum reads AREN'T mafia then there's mafia in this pool" post instead of actual list of scum reads and reasons and my name was in the list which is bs.

On October 06 2016 03:00 Holyflare wrote:


because then she also forgot her jat read and made some bull shit grack post

On October 06 2016 03:02 Holyflare wrote:


I literally do not care. It was terrible.

On October 06 2016 03:10 Calix wrote:


In case people missed this post as it was at the bottom of the page.

On October 05 2016 20:18 Palmar wrote:
I like Hf's rant post.

On October 06 2016 03:22 Calix wrote:
I think lynching among JAT/ HF/ batsnacks is way more likely to hit multiple scum. Better return.

You don't agree?

On October 05 2016 21:12 Palmar wrote:
Regarding JAT, I don't know what to think about his response to me.

a) he might be (or he might believe that he is) correct that pressuring him to take a stance isn't going to work.

b) he also knows that I believe I can pressure him into submission as town, whether or not that is true seems irrelevant.

c) despite b), it's not certain that he thought about what I believe

So in general, I'm still sort of meh on JAT, he is doing the jat thing where he sort of casually comments along in the thread, and I always think he's mafia for it and sometimes I tunnel it and sometimes I leave it. I have no real idea what he actually is.

On October 06 2016 03:35 marvellosity wrote:
i'm on page 51 and the lynch on calix seems fine, gonna chill my vote on bats though.

good chance maf maf i suppose

On October 06 2016 03:37 marvellosity wrote:
although now i'm preferring batsnacks more

i really think there's a much lower percentage of the time bats is town than calix

On October 06 2016 03:43 marvellosity wrote:

we never agree on anything koshi

palmar can be anything, sadly i don't know yet

On October 06 2016 03:45 Calix wrote:
Fuck Palmar, what about JAT? Has he even done anything townie this game aside from compare himself to his town games?

I looked at Palmar's filter and he actually has some okayish posts in there.

I'm not saying that they're amazing contributions - we're talking about the Town Tard here - but there is some effort there imo.

On October 06 2016 03:46 Grackaroni wrote:
If you can write a convincing case then I will vote Bats.

On October 06 2016 03:59 Holyflare wrote:
Koshi, why is it you town read grack? I'm curious.

On October 06 2016 04:02 Holyflare wrote:
koshi can i stop sheeping you now? I want to make calix paranoid

On October 06 2016 04:10 Calix wrote:
The only reason I feel sympathetic is because he's about to get a hurricane through his area.

On October 06 2016 03:46 marvellosity wrote:

the case is simple

he doesn't really commit to much and has had 'politician' posts as jat has put it. that's scummy on its own

then add meta on top that that's what he does as mafia and doesn't do as town

that's my case. irrefutable

On October 06 2016 04:29 Palmar wrote:
Batsnacks is probably not mafia but idk

On October 06 2016 04:35 batsnacks wrote:

I think this is a great lynch and not just for self preservation purposes! It is bad that as soon as I intercepted all the heat he was getting he left.

Or Damdred for real

On October 06 2016 04:39 batsnacks wrote:

I don't think palmar has been scummy

On October 06 2016 04:45 Palmar wrote:

If I say sorry stupid shit that sounds smart I'm mafia
If I say smart shit that sounds borderline retarded I'm town

On October 06 2016 04:52 batsnacks wrote:
I don't know what palmar needs to do to be scummy or what scum palmar is like that's sort of an unreasonable question. Post why palmar is scummy I'll tel you if I agree sorry if you already did and I missed it.

Superbia could be afk I have no way of knowing. i do know that he disappeared after I inherited his pressure.

On October 06 2016 04:56 Calix wrote:
Koshi, you'd do a lot better to just ask "what reasons do you have to town-read Palmar?"

Save the waffling.

On October 06 2016 04:58 Calix wrote:
I'm still not convinced on Palmar even though he just turned up and has done nothing.

He doesn't seem to give a shit that he's at risk of being lynched at all.

On October 06 2016 05:02 Calix wrote:
What do you mean by 'rolling the dice'?

I would have thought that mafia would at least TRY to defend themselves.

Instead he just turns up, says that Superbia is an 'optional lynch' (whatever the fuck that means) and sticks with his stupid scum-read on me.

On October 06 2016 05:06 Calix wrote:
By the way, I am also biased a little bit by meta because he tried to defend himself when I was in a game with him as scum and it was a really half-arsed defense against some incriminating evidence.

So the fact that he's not even bothering against a wagon this weak makes me inclined to think he's either town or is having a seriously bad case of scum fatigue.

Only two explanations imo and given my other points, I think town.

On October 06 2016 05:09 Calix wrote:
What isn't normal?

On October 06 2016 05:12 Holyflare wrote:


U lie i pressurez lots

On October 06 2016 05:13 Holyflare wrote:
I still wouldn't be surprised if marv was mafia. I am confused why koshi rolled over when he returned and said calox was mafia-y

On October 06 2016 05:15 NeverUnlucky wrote:
I did not like Bats' recent defense. What I read was a deflection on Calix and a JAS defense. The dude never even stated he was town.

On October 06 2016 05:15 Holyflare wrote:


You said my push on calix was bad and looked mafia orientated.

Marv comes back and agrees with push and you didn't say shit.

On October 06 2016 05:27 Superbia wrote:
Yo I played divinity w gf all day and gonna sleep now. Im town so plz no lyncherino etc. I have time tomo bc the gf will be home late

On October 06 2016 05:35 Calix wrote:
It still bothers me how many counterwagons to batsnacks we can get in a single day.

On October 06 2016 19:32 Palmar wrote:

I think you should generally assume that.

On October 06 2016 20:21 marvellosity wrote:

Palmar would never say this about me as town. ever.

On October 06 2016 20:34 Holyflare wrote:
Why would mafia palmar not vote to save himself?

On October 06 2016 20:47 marvellosity wrote:

You could have saved me a lot of typing by posting this earlier

On October 06 2016 21:13 Holyflare wrote:
Didn't someone say pre game we lose a mislynch if we shoot wrong?

On October 06 2016 23:28 Grackaroni wrote:

Peekaboo!

On October 07 2016 02:01 Holyflare wrote:
I'm also feeling completely the opposite to your koshi read. He was perhaps one of my only town reads yesterday but his super strong town reads disappeared for no reason and they've flipped when seemingly momentum is gaining on their pushes (on you, marv etc)

He could and probably is likely town but he's definitely completely fallen off tonight enough for me to think he could be mafia again (null/town specifically), yes, even if I said I'd sheep him because that turned out to be a lie.

On October 07 2016 02:44 Calix wrote:
As a side note Koshi, the word you are probably looking for is "luxury"

Has anything else about Marv stood out to you?

Why would Stutters being modkilled 'probably put us in trouble'?

On October 07 2016 03:05 Calix wrote:


One last question. Can you walk me through why your read flipped that much after batsnacks flipped town? If this is already explained elsewhere in your filter then just ignore this post.

Your Stutters comment stood out as you assumed he was flipping town but since you openly admit that with some reasoning (even if I find it weak and disagree), carry on.

On October 07 2016 03:27 NeverUnlucky wrote:


Who did she harddefend?

My posts are not toxic :c

The way I play mafia is by getting lynched. If I am not lynched I am not mafia.

On October 07 2016 06:15 marvellosity wrote:
why even vote palmar koshi?

you know you're going to end up scumreading me in about 24-36 hours and do something else anyway

On October 07 2016 06:23 marvellosity wrote:

i'm super obvious mafia to you in about 95% games i'm town when we play together, so yes, i am planning on being super obvious mafia to you.

On October 07 2016 06:40 NeverUnlucky wrote:
To add to marv's points on Plam - Plamar said that I should have been modkilled day 1 for trying to abuse the game mechanics. This would only favor mafia.

That's his one post that made me think he is mafia.

On October 07 2016 12:23 scott31337 wrote:
Koshi - Carefree Koshi, leaning town for now.
Calix - He hates it when I put him in the tinfoil town pile, so I'll do it again.
marvellosity - town, pretty confident of - if he got mafia again he'd be all mopey and shit
Palmar - Null/Leaning Scum - Trying to coast, doesn't give much for info. (Lynch Calix)
justanothertownie - leaning scum, he's doing the not getting info/shitposting JAT - which is a mafia trait for him.
Damdred-slight townlean/almost null - very little to go on.
NeverUnlucky - town, probably #2 - lots of info, somewhat helpful.
Oatsmaster - townlean - points out some inconstistencies in posts that I've seen
Superbia - Uggg - kind of like last game - not very helpful - null
Grackaroni - like last game too but nothing of help/doing/etc.

That's where I'm at now - Lynch Palmar/JAT preferred, Poke Super and Grack some more.

On October 07 2016 13:31 Grackaroni wrote:
Writing a case for Damdred is harder than I thought.

There's the point that Bats made of Damdred primarily making a reads dump and very little questioning, which seems uncharacteristic.

I think a case could also be made that he's only willing to scum read weaker players that won't give him too much trouble. He mentioned HF in his initial reads post and backed off that very quickly.

Primarily I'm going to go with, "I have a lot of town reads and the feels are reals." Can you disprove my feels, Damdred?

On October 07 2016 17:51 Oatsmaster wrote:

What do you mean by the last sentence?

On October 07 2016 18:46 Palmar wrote:
It jives rather well with what I've been thinking about this game.

Batsnacks sounded like a townie
Oats sounds like a townie
NU sounds like a special snowflake
Grack is not as funny as I would've thought he should be, but I do like him nonetheless, for now.

Superbia is being an ass, but he does that all the time as all alignments, don't think he's been overtly scummy. One of the big milestones today is going to be whether or not he realizes what is up. If he doesn't, he needs to be dropped very low on everyone's lists when I flip town. Superbia is smart, knows me well, and a good player in general. If he votes for me when I'm town, that's super concerning.

Damdred and Stutters are players I have completely ignored.

Marv is going to drop his vote on me. If he actually stays he's 100% mafia. He reads me better than any player in the history of TL mafia, he has basically a 100% rate on figuring my alignment by day 2 when he's town. If I ever flip town, and he is still calling me mafia, he is scum. there is NO WAY AROUND IT. Thing is, I also know that he knows exactly this. He CAN'T be wrong on me, so I know he's going to end up drop his vote on me today. Depending on whether I believe the reasoning there's a tiny chance I'm wrong. But the NK, his play, his lack of enthusiasm for some things and just some tonally weird things, all point to marv-mafia. Not to mention, both HF and I picked up a townie vibe from batsnacks, and marv completely failed to recognize it. He is better at town than both of us, and that is super concerning.

JAT/Koshi/Calix <--- Three strong players who have been atrociously wrong throughout the game. There is definitely town in this group, probably even two. Whichever ones of you are town need to pull head out of asses and start playing reasonably. It is very likely that one of the townies is Koshi, because him tunneling stupid things is kind of what he does as town, the other two are slightly better so who knows.

Regarding Calix specifically, my day 1 read of her is mostly tonal. She felt very analytical and willing to try to solve the game when she was town in the last game I was with her. This contrasts her more timid and reserved tone here. I am also slightly suspicious of how she could read me so well on day 1 (against all odds she was calling me town) and then dropped it with some complete bullshit reasoning on n1, that is worrying.

On October 07 2016 19:36 Palmar wrote:
We're lynching JAT koshi, get with the times.

On October 07 2016 19:16 Palmar wrote:
Btw, you can call me nostradamus later, but here's what's going to happen today:

I'm going to rally some people to my side. Some stragglers and tunnelers are going to remain on the other side.

Marv is going to rescind his scumread on me and scite my posting today, but he's going to look for another easy lynch

JAT is going to be the alternative wagon, it should be marv, but it's easier to convince people to lynch JAT

I'm not going to be around tomorrow to drive the wagon, so the thread will be taken over by mafia.

In some fit of confusion, we're going to end up lynching some low hanging afk fruit, like stutters, damdred, grack. That person is 100% going to flip town and everyone will be mad.

On October 07 2016 19:19 Palmar wrote:


The only way to avoid this, is if someone else, (Calix? Superbia?) takes the mantle of leadership and whips this town into shape. It's going to be really tough, but it's what needs to be done.

On October 07 2016 19:56 Oatsmaster wrote:

still not following.

On October 07 2016 12:48 Grackaroni wrote:
My thought going into the day was that HF would be the kill and town reads are solidifying themselves, so now you're seeing the "thinks he's super smart" variant of Grackaroni. This Grackaroni will probably disappear around the time Palmar flips scum but until then you're stuck with him.

On October 07 2016 20:04 Grackaroni wrote:

That was just the most likely thing to cause a Grackaroni variant change.

On October 07 2016 20:10 Grackaroni wrote:
What I was saying was that I was going to be smug until something happens that shows that I'm actually a retard.

On October 07 2016 20:08 Superbia wrote:
Who called me vs JAT SvS again? That person is mafia if JAT is mafia.

On October 07 2016 20:16 Superbia wrote:


Read his stuff and then call him mafia or town plox.

On October 06 2016 02:35 justanothertownie wrote:
So, those are the people I would not be willing to lynch today as of now:

Koshi: There is no point in wasting my time on him. When he comes back he is either normal town Koshi or you lynch him. Pretty straight forward.

Marv: Not 100 % town but he has done enough typical stuff that I won't even entertain lynching him.

nu: Not gonna lie - his play since the very active start has been less than subpar. But he has that gamey shit going for him which almost always comes from town.

These I wouldn't lynch without a good case (which has to come between now and like 30 minutes later because I will be gone):

Palmar: If you want to lynch him you need to get the wagon going way earlier. You can never know his alignment before he is forced to actually play the damn game. He is really underwhelming though and his aimless rambling earlier did not feel very palmarlike.

Holyflare: Always hard to tell with him and like I said his push on me was really opportunistic and bad. Shitflingy if you want. But I think a mafia HF wouldn't have stopped going after me this easily once he had already started to. Felt like he actively avoided an unnecessary shitfight which I do not think scum HF would do. If he suddenly turns against me again when I am gone he is probably mafia.

Damdred: His presence is severely lacking and batsnacks is right when he says that there was very little damdy questioning going on. But I really liked his perspective on the game when he arrived. It mirrored my own quite well.

Oats: Made an easy thowaway scumread against me and then didn't care about me at all anymore (I might be biased but that seems quite disinterested to me). Some really bad logic that I pointed out but I guess thats par for the course for him. Really really forgettable though.

I could lynch (roughly in order from worst to best lynch):


Stutters: If this was an open setup with a vig I would be against lynching him but we don't know that. Maybe it still would be optimal to wait for a night and see if he gets shot by a vigilante before getting rid of him by a lynch but if you for some reason need to shennany onto someone eod he is a good target.

Calix: At first I was really sold by the fearless and aggressive way she plays but I have to remember that she is only new to this site and apparently a decent scumplayer. If you have that in mind then there are several problems with her play. Starting from the way she treated nu in the beginning despite him apparently being the easiest read in the world up to the total brainfart she made when asked about her grack read.

batsnacks: This is not the batsnacks I know. I don't know if it is mafia batsnacks but he is very different. Incomprehensible defense of Superbia because "being afraid makes no sense as mafia". But he has really been digging himself a hole all game if he is mafia. Besides the superbia read there is also his accusation against me (mafia for encouraging anti-town behaviour) which is so poor and weak that it is almost comical. Why does mafia batsnacks try to attack me like that? It is so pointless. Really horrible politician posts though...

Superbia: Refuses to play the game. Agressive/hostile tone fit his scummeta perfectly. Nowhere to be seen all day today.

Grackaroni:
Made a case against me immediately when 1-2 people suddenly started suspecting me when I was gone yesterday. A really lazy and factual problematic case as I have explained lately. He also just harddefended Calix without even knowing what the problem was with her posting. Otherwise he is just existing in this game without doing much.

On October 07 2016 20:22 Grackaroni wrote:

I don't think I'm that heavy of a busser. The last game was just me hedging on Tumblewood and then jumping on the wagon once it looked like he was getting lynched.

It only ended up looking super silly like that because when we were one vote away a string of people refused to lynch Tumblewood.

On October 07 2016 20:18 marvellosity wrote:

You know the reason I have a great record reading / lynching Palmar is because I don't make premature calls on his alignment and actually take as much time as I need to figure him out?

how do you not get this?

On October 07 2016 20:28 Grackaroni wrote:

You called me obvious town around this point yesterday for doing exactly this. Jesus Koshi.

On October 07 2016 20:35 Calix wrote:


Agreed. Not enough melodrama, 3/10.

Probably TvT though.

On October 07 2016 20:47 Grackaroni wrote:

Yeah I just checked you're in pretty deep here Koshi.

First you were arguing that I was bussing JAT. Now you're citing JAT's reasoning as a reason to scum read me without a connection to JAT when it's basically a summary of all the reasons you town read me to begin with.

On October 07 2016 20:14 Koshi wrote:

That was Grack. Doubt they are mafia together.

On October 07 2016 20:47 Grackaroni wrote:

Yeah I just checked you're in pretty deep here Koshi.

First you were arguing that I was bussing JAT. Now you're citing JAT's reasoning as a reason to scum read me without a connection to JAT when it's basically a summary of all the reasons you town read me to begin with.

On October 07 2016 21:08 Grackaroni wrote:

Yes when you read JAT's "sheepable reasons" the complete opposite way only the day before. You were one of the people who targeted JAT while he wasn't there. You town read me for defending Calix.

On October 07 2016 21:09 Grackaroni wrote:


Lol yeah you never suggested that. Must be lies.

On October 07 2016 21:13 Grackaroni wrote:

It seems pretty self explanatory to me. Now that Palmar is off the lynch block you're looking for a backup and you're using some reasoning you couldn't possibly agree with to try to support killing me.

On October 07 2016 21:15 Grackaroni wrote:

Here's what you are saying:
"He's not mafia with JAT"
"Actually he's a massive busser"
Am I supposed to interpret this as, "hey i just had a thought! He could be bussing Oatsmaster!"

On October 07 2016 21:23 Grackaroni wrote:

I don't see how I am supposed to interpret this other you calling me scum.

On October 07 2016 21:59 NeverUnlucky wrote:


There's a long road ahead. You do not want to be alone at night. You must choose a faction to live on.

Besides, I have been supporting the Dutch football team since 2010 and am an EDM zealot. You will find yourself home in Gracktopia. NU promise.

On October 07 2016 23:05 Oatsmaster wrote:

hey dude are you ever gonna decide who you read as scum?

On October 07 2016 21:19 Koshi wrote:

I am not doing that at all. Not at fucking all. marv/JAT/Palmar and if a back up is needed I am thinking Damdred/Scott. Never did I want to go to you.

On October 08 2016 05:14 Palmar wrote:

it isn't dull, it's correct.

You lack confidence, that points to you being mafia, but fuck it let's pretend you're not for a little bit for the sake of moving the game forward.

By lack of confidence, I mean your ridiculous emphasis on getting me to answer some completely tangential questions you have no need for to determine my alignment.

But if you must, the explanation is very simple. I wasn't very much around, I didn't think bats was scum and I'm not mafia. I tried to push for a Calix lynch, which I've now decided was retarded. At the deadline I was mad and only barely paying attention to the thread. I did explain my reasoning for voting HF, but in hindsight I was just being a moron and failed to catch what is a fairly obvious joke. I got mad and voted him.

Essentially, I got trolled.

Of course he started posting like a townie and making sense again, so I came around, also realizing that I was just being stupid. Someone said during that time that HF was scummy for pulling the "it was just a joke" defense, but whatever.

On October 08 2016 05:18 Palmar wrote:
Like think of it from my point of view marv.

Let's assume you're town. From your point of view, you're afraid that I'm fooling all the peasants, but you and jat remain steadfast. I get it, you don't want to be one of the morons I just fooled.

But look at at it from my point of view. To me, I know I'm town, and I've just convinced a bunch of people I am town, to the point where some of them seem fairly convinced. Sure, some of them may be TMI, but all can't be. So do you not understand why it concerns me that the guy who is more often right on me than anyone else fails to do what people who know me far worse have done easily.

I am being completely reasonable here.

On October 08 2016 23:59 Palmar wrote:
Wow I go afk and the narrative changes... who would've thought??

On October 09 2016 05:46 Palmar wrote:

Probably mafia at this point. Koshi

On October 09 2016 20:04 NeverUnlucky wrote:

Unless Palmar is Godfather, he is town.

And my case for you will come later in the day, you need not worry.

On October 09 2016 20:39 Oatsmaster wrote:

deffo scott for now.
the jat thing is super cool but it rests on people flipping

On October 09 2016 21:00 Oatsmaster wrote:

hes idependantly scummy, also what a retarded vote on damdred then the super sheep onto super.

On October 09 2016 22:25 Oatsmaster wrote:

Girl plz.

Palmar is hardcore just popping in, posting some stuff about the game that makes some sense then peacing out. His behavior around the lynch was really weird with him here


I mean like what the fuck man.

there isnt much to say about scott cause its so obvious.

Jat shit is in here come on man, im just quoting your filter.
+ Show Spoiler +

On October 09 2016 22:43 NeverUnlucky wrote:


I agreed with koshi's points on Palmar just like I agreed with jat's points on Super. Despite agreeing with them, I did not scum-read either.

I pretty much voted Superbia because I agreed with jat's case even though I did not scum-read Super. I regret that.

Arbitrarily better because jat's got no town tone and never proposed that his lynch was a ML nor that he was town.

On October 09 2016 23:42 Koshi wrote:

No words...

On October 09 2016 23:55 Calix wrote:
brb, going to filter-dive for Grack's attitude about the lynches. Koshi can do Palmar since he loves him so much

On October 10 2016 00:00 Calix wrote:
Actually yeah, that approach is considerably more efficient.

So we're concluding that the town did the usual thing of eating each other?

On October 10 2016 01:46 Palmar wrote:
Fuck you koshi

On October 10 2016 04:04 Grackaroni wrote:

What do you dislike from Scott's filter?

On October 10 2016 04:08 Grackaroni wrote:

Not yet. I haven't misread anything. I'm just not sure whether trying to get people to lynch you tomorrow is a good idea when Palmar is so sure that Marv is mafia.

On October 10 2016 04:10 Grackaroni wrote:

How can you be so sure? Maybe I'm just pretending to be mafia.

On October 10 2016 04:12 Grackaroni wrote:

Me neither.

On October 10 2016 04:32 Grackaroni wrote:
Actually there seems to be quite a few Koshi contradictions right now. There's also the flailing from when I pushed him that I will go into later.

On October 10 2016 04:39 Grackaroni wrote:

Has Marv ever been caught as mafia for having a strange tone? Content has also been completely absent this game.

On October 10 2016 05:47 NeverUnlucky wrote:


I'm more disappointed that the game did not turn out the way I expected it to between me being retarded and shitposting, Palmar, Marv and Koshi not having the time to play, Superbia having the time to play but prefering to be a shitter, and two slots being empty. :/

On October 10 2016 06:24 Calix wrote:
Legit question. Where do we go from here?

I don't really know how to operate given that everyone seems to have whack reads right now.

On October 10 2016 02:06 Grackaroni wrote:

This is incredibly rich. You have hard pushed all 3 flipped town so far. Mafia don't even need to be involved in anything because you are doing everything for them.

At least 2 are mafia from the Marv/JAT/Koshi group because they are reading the game incredibly wrong. One of them is being clueless. The other mafia is between Damdred/Scott.