[M][T] Haunted Mansion 3 - Page 43

On September 10 2016 06:45 NeverUnlucky wrote:




What's the difference between the two? Why is an argument scum indicative of one and NAI for the other?

On September 11 2016 02:35 Damdred wrote:
You forgot a option tbh, the third option is tt didn't want to play as scum and at least one team mate is light budding with the intent to jump on when the train looks like it,had no breaks,for cred.

COukd it be town tt just going down with the ship, yes it could. But there is no logical reasoning town should defend tt is there? For such a easy target the amount of push back,that has been received from the tt while no one town reads him is staggering tbh.

But really there is so much time left and so few people voting it coups,mean any number of things.

On September 11 2016 02:59 fuba wrote:
My current thoughts on TT are that no one could really defend him if he's not going to defend himself. It kind of eliminates that entire line of reasoning. On one hand, scum could more easily push a mislynch. On the other, scum couldn't defend him too much without associating themselves with him. I could see the scum waiting to drop onto his side until he started posting again, but being unable to because he never came back.

And he has been defended, in a way. Pushing another lynch defends the current lynch leader. I'm not at all saying that everyone iffy about a TT lynch is scum. I'm saying that if we're voting for someone else, then we're not voting for tt. Scum could push a counter lynch, or simply hop onto one, and not have to worry all that much about being associated with him because he's "just a lurker lynch".

I have to get back to work soon. Might be able to sneak a peak at the game before lynch time. Staying on TT because despite HF's overconfidence in the case, I remember finding it compelling at the time and nothing TT has done has convinced me otherwise. Also, the fact that he disappeared right after the votes popped up, and the fact that HF appeared to be (and still is) dead set on lynching him may have sapped his will to fight back. I know it's projecting, but I would be disheartened if HF declared me so strongly scum so early. Anyone know if this would apply to TT too?

Like, is he more likely to disappear when he's town being wrongly accused, or scum being correctly accused? Or maybe is neither more likely?

On September 10 2016 08:50 fuba wrote:
And before anyone mentions it, I am still voting for TT right now. If my post above didn't convince anyone, then I'm not going to have the impetus today and tomorrow to push it through. Scum NU doesn't eliminate scum TT as far as I can remember.

I work tomorrow from 8am-4pm, which is the deadline. I may be able to pop in about 3-4 hours before that for a few minutes, but will be otherwise unavailable.

On September 11 2016 02:58 Skynx wrote:
I still have to catchup but putting aside the reads, two main pointers in my mind:
1) Why is everyone except above ignoring Palmar being underwhelming?
2) Why is guys quoted bit more above sheep Holyflare and do nothing else?

On September 11 2016 03:07 Holyflare wrote:
Calix you're either mafia or you don't know when you're wifoming.

Mafia can do anything they want at any point in the game and you don't know our meta. If anyone was throwing suspicions away from tt for no valid reason it would be you.

Tt has three votes, tt has not come back to post, people ARE defending tt etc etc.

Stop talking around people's posts and what THEY have done and talking about wifom scenarios it's bad play regardless of your alignment.

You should pick a person to mafia read and post why they are mafia for reasons rhey have done.

On September 10 2016 09:58 Holyflare wrote:
No it's actually not at all. A certain scum read on someone at the start of the game generates a million times more discussion than crap discussions about mechanics, it also helps me make reads on people such as Grack being mafia now and it let's me see who is keen on just skating by and ignoring it.

It's a very strong opening.

But in this case I actually do think that Ticktock is mafia because:

On September 11 2016 03:13 Skynx wrote:

I mean nearly all these stuff are applicable to Palmar as well. However you are ready to ignore him cuz of meta.
You say not defending when pressure doesn't fit town!TT meta but in meantime TT is totally entirely afk from this game while Palmar is pretty much here but refuses to post any content. Why are you not considering him?

On September 11 2016 03:09 Vivax wrote:


A bit of Palmar meta.

Palmar can be an ass. He's unpredictable. Some games he tries, some games he openly doesn't give a fuck.

He absolutely hates being vigged, and thinks that not getting lynched is one of towns first tasks.

IE in the case he's playing his not give a fuck style, you get a wagon on him going and he's going to be forced to play. If he still doesn't care, you keep lynching. Not on weekends though cause he does stuff with his family (for example playing mafia with kids, he's already breeding the next generation of tl mafia players).

Btw fuba nice ninja.

On September 11 2016 03:13 Damdred wrote:
Why would scum defend scum when that scum isn't trying? Why would scum not hop onto,the tt wagon and solidify it when he's a easy lynch and no,real reprocussions?
Both questions are wifom but both have to be answered for your position calix

On September 11 2016 03:18 Damdred wrote:
Everything in mafia is wifom, me knowing all theories at this point is wifom doesn't negate the question.

And no that's not the easiest answer,because three votes isn't a lynch by any means