|
On August 30 2016 12:18 Trfel wrote:
Tictock, why are you more willing to lynch geript than Rels? Is it just the inconsistencies between his posts and the conclusion, or is there something else?
It is partially just feels, on the surface the both just did the same thing but Rels string of thoughts flowed better into his conclusions. Geript has the inconsistencies but also did little to focus on his scum reads or any reads infact, compare to Rels who put down a decent bit about each of his scum reads.
|
That reminds me. Tumblewood, in addition to Palmar, you also suspected Koshi of being Mafia. Why are they suddenly under "null/don't care yet"?
|
On August 30 2016 12:29 Tictock wrote:Show nested quote +On August 30 2016 12:18 Trfel wrote:
Tictock, why are you more willing to lynch geript than Rels? Is it just the inconsistencies between his posts and the conclusion, or is there something else? It is partially just feels, on the surface the both just did the same thing but Rels string of thoughts flowed better into his conclusions. Geript has the inconsistencies but also did little to focus on his scum reads or any reads infact, compare to Rels who put down a decent bit about each of his scum reads. I find this interesting because to me, Rels and geript were similar in some ways, but Rels was far more reactive in only addressing the thread sentiment, being open to lynch all the main suspects, and not having any original thought. On the contrary, geript felt more willing to share original thoughts, even if they didn't make as much sense.
I am having a bit of trouble believing that you can actually think this  . Help?
|
DanelerH, have you had a chance to look through the whole game yet, or are there still people you haven't looked at?
|
On August 30 2016 09:44 DanelerH wrote:Show nested quote +On August 30 2016 09:37 Tumblewood wrote:On August 30 2016 08:49 DanelerH wrote:Tumblewood, do you mind clarifying something for me? On August 29 2016 06:36 Tumblewood wrote:On August 29 2016 06:35 Trfel wrote:On August 29 2016 06:35 Tumblewood wrote:
maybe palmar's mafia Please explain? nah no thanks Why did you refuse to elaborate on Palmar being Mafia? that was all I had to say Isn't that odd, though? Normally, if you want someone to see your point of view, you need to give a reason. Why wouldn't you give one?
that's a good thought to have, but it was just an idea that popped into my head for no good reason. I think I saw Palmar trying to get cheeky but what does that even mean. I no longer think Palmar is mafia
On August 30 2016 12:07 Tictock wrote:
Tumblewood:
Here is another read I'm totally flipping on. Tumblewood's read progression doesn't make any sense to me. + Show Spoiler +On August 29 2016 11:45 Tumblewood wrote:Show nested quote +On August 29 2016 11:13 Tictock wrote:On August 29 2016 11:01 scott31337 wrote:On August 29 2016 10:59 Tumblewood wrote:
wow this is a bad game even by my low standards. can someone carry me Umm, I think the game has been going decently well. Every body has posted at least once, and I started my spreadsheet and have notes for everybody.  Could you tell me more? I hadn't noticed that everyone had posted. Points to you for paying attention. why is that a townlean ... OH SHIT tinfoil here, Scott is scum and intentionally dropping that he he's using a spreadsheet for town cred or not, maybe tinfoil's scott as scum + Show Spoiler +On August 29 2016 14:38 Tumblewood wrote:
meh I like scott now On August 29 2016 14:38 Tumblewood wrote:
new scott > afk scott
and is also probably town now likes scott for not being afk, also implies he wasn't joking about scott possibly being scum + Show Spoiler +On August 30 2016 03:08 Tumblewood wrote:
yes. compared to newbie xxi, in which he is much more attack-y. definitely seeing more similarity to his scum meta and his town meta.
got 'em boys
next target: palmar or holyflare Starts scum reading me though he got lazy in building his meta, suggests palmar or holyflare are his next suspects. + Show Spoiler +On August 30 2016 09:39 Tumblewood wrote:
town
vivax
daneler
also probably town
hf
scummy
tt
scott?
null/don't care yet
most people Suddenly Scott is scummy again, HF is town despite no new mentions, and apparently doesn't care about Palmar. I'm tempted to go off on a tinfoil here, but I'll try to hold off because it's fairly associative. There is definitely something weird going on with Tumble though, I thought maybe he was just being lazy town but it's looking worse. Definitely feels like a good lynch. ##Vote: Tumblewood ah tru I am known for being erratic as scum and clear as town
|
On August 30 2016 12:30 DanelerH wrote:
That reminds me. Tumblewood, in addition to Palmar, you also suspected Koshi of being Mafia. Why are they suddenly under "null/don't care yet"?
it's a weak suspicion. mostly my reaction when someone slips into the town category in my mind and then I think "oh, maybe they could be scum" or "why am I townreading them"
|
On August 30 2016 13:01 Tumblewood wrote:
ah tru I am known for being erratic as scum and clear as town
Actually I do think you are pretty clear as town, not an open book by any means but usually it's easy to see where your head is at and what you are bringing to the table.
This game you are hanging back despite calling yourself out for it, and the only thing noteworthy you have brought up is a couple of posts to possibly support the meta that I'm not friendly as town. Even then you trailed off without really showing it to be a solid meta, and the read was borrowed from something Trfel posted in the first place.
So yea throwing out a piss-poor reads list that doesn't even track with the reads you've been giving out so far is pretty scummy.
|
Hey, so if anyone has any questions or wants to talk about anything, let me know. Otherwise, Tictock, I asked you a question in post #583, if you're not going to answer it I'd at least appreciate it if you would just say that?
I'll be reading some stuff.
|
On August 30 2016 15:38 Trfel wrote:
Hey, so if anyone has any questions or wants to talk about anything, let me know. Otherwise, Tictock, I asked you a question in post #583, if you're not going to answer it I'd at least appreciate it if you would just say that?
I'll be reading some stuff.
I wasn't really aware that you asked a question, just said that you didn't believe I was more ok with Rels than Geript. I can't think of anything else to expand on since both of them are fairly low volume posters this game and both did the same kinda catchup into summary post without much else.
If you disagree that's fine, it's not like I have a strong read on either of them. Though I am curiuse who you are thinking should be the lynch today. Are you thinking Rels is scum for mostly focusing on hot topic people at the time?
|
Fair warning though, I'm unlikely to be very responsive for the next few hours.
|
On August 30 2016 15:53 Tictock wrote:
Fair warning though, I'm unlikely to be very responsive for the next few hours.
Wait!!! Can I get like five minutes to pester you with several more annoying questions?
First of which being, when you townread Tumblewood for the Koshi/Race Bannon/Tumblewood associative read thing (can link it if you need), what was it about Tumblewood's post that makes you say that it's more of a town mindset? Because I'm really not sure what you're getting at.
As to who I want to lynch... working on it. But for now I'm thinking not you, if that helps
|
On August 30 2016 08:43 Holyflare wrote:Show nested quote +On August 30 2016 08:31 Rels wrote:
Caught up. I want to lynch one of:
- scott: see Vivax case. Very disconnected to any pushes this game but posts random questions + have a very bad reason to vote me, since his "meta analysis" should indicate Palmar's "reason" to push me was not supported by meta, yet he acted like it did. As a counter to Koshi, scott has an habit of making spreadsheet so it's not impossible he's making one as town to replicate his meta.
- tumble: not involved in the game. Has random posts about different things / people but there is no continuous thought process to be seen. He's just posting whatever is in his head, which is scum indicative. In particular, his TT post was one I liked and agreed with, but like everything else he posted about he posted about something else afterwards.
- TT: I had the exact same impression Tumble posted about. He's reasonnable but, having played with him quite a few times, his "nice" tone matches his scum meta. As town he will not care for what people thinks about him and just post stuff about finding scum.
- geript: two big posts that are meh and contains two things that don't make sense. First, the thing above about Trfel. Second, the thing about RB being likely townie but being in his scumlist. His explanation makes little sense, he should use every information at his disposal to find scum. I know I find RB's posts about his PM to be borderline cheating but he didn't do it on purpose and he's confirmed town now. So you have absolutely 0 problem with the people saying there is no geript inconsistency?
No. I don't agree with it though.
|
@Tictock, might as well ask all of my questions now.
Early on, you said that you thought that both I and disformation were town. Why did you say this?
Why did you move Holyflare from "null" into "don't lynch"?
And I know that this question seems dumb, but if you wouldn't mind explaining a bit more of what it is about Vivax's passion over the scott31337 lynch that makes you townread him? Like, why can't he be mafia that is strongly pushing scott31337?
Thanks
|
On August 30 2016 09:19 Tictock wrote:Show nested quote +On August 30 2016 08:31 Rels wrote:
- TT: I had the exact same impression Tumble posted about. He's reasonnable but, having played with him quite a few times, his "nice" tone matches his scum meta. As town he will not care for what people thinks about him and just post stuff about finding scum.
Ok that's it. I have half a mind to be extremely nice and cordial to you all so that if/when I flip it will put an end to this terrible meta on me. That is if that's ok with everyone of course.
I can see how it is frustrating if you're town.
|
On August 30 2016 12:34 Trfel wrote:Show nested quote +On August 30 2016 12:29 Tictock wrote:On August 30 2016 12:18 Trfel wrote:
Tictock, why are you more willing to lynch geript than Rels? Is it just the inconsistencies between his posts and the conclusion, or is there something else? It is partially just feels, on the surface the both just did the same thing but Rels string of thoughts flowed better into his conclusions. Geript has the inconsistencies but also did little to focus on his scum reads or any reads infact, compare to Rels who put down a decent bit about each of his scum reads. I find this interesting because to me, Rels and geript were similar in some ways, but Rels was far more reactive in only addressing the thread sentiment, being open to lynch all the main suspects, and not having any original thought. On the contrary, geript felt more willing to share original thoughts, even if they didn't make as much sense. I am having a bit of trouble believing that you can actually think this . Help?
You think I'm scum ?
|
On August 30 2016 16:01 Rels wrote:Show nested quote +On August 30 2016 12:34 Trfel wrote:On August 30 2016 12:29 Tictock wrote:On August 30 2016 12:18 Trfel wrote:
Tictock, why are you more willing to lynch geript than Rels? Is it just the inconsistencies between his posts and the conclusion, or is there something else? It is partially just feels, on the surface the both just did the same thing but Rels string of thoughts flowed better into his conclusions. Geript has the inconsistencies but also did little to focus on his scum reads or any reads infact, compare to Rels who put down a decent bit about each of his scum reads. I find this interesting because to me, Rels and geript were similar in some ways, but Rels was far more reactive in only addressing the thread sentiment, being open to lynch all the main suspects, and not having any original thought. On the contrary, geript felt more willing to share original thoughts, even if they didn't make as much sense. I am having a bit of trouble believing that you can actually think this . Help? You think I'm scum ? The way I see it, the people you are suspicious of exactly match the thread sentiment, and you haven't provided any original thought.
Do you think that I am incorrectly perceiving things? And if not, why shouldn't I think that you are scum?
|
On August 30 2016 15:56 Trfel wrote:Show nested quote +On August 30 2016 15:53 Tictock wrote:
Fair warning though, I'm unlikely to be very responsive for the next few hours. Wait!!! Can I get like five minutes to pester you with several more annoying questions? First of which being, when you townread Tumblewood for the Koshi/Race Bannon/Tumblewood associative read thing (can link it if you need), what was it about Tumblewood's post that makes you say that it's more of a town mindset? Because I'm really not sure what you're getting at. As to who I want to lynch... working on it. But for now I'm thinking not you, if that helps
Only a minuet, but yet I remember that one.
It felt kinda towny to be tracking reads like that, in retrospect it's really not indicative since scum would be hyper aware of who is scum reading them so seeing his name next to koshi's in someone's scum list would stand out.
This kinda just makes me hate Tumble's last list post more since RB was one of the people totally left off, and I think that was their only interaction.
|
And Tictock, one more thing.....
In this post, where you vote for Tumblewood, when did you decide that you were going to vote for Tumblewood?
|
On August 30 2016 16:03 Trfel wrote:Show nested quote +On August 30 2016 16:01 Rels wrote:On August 30 2016 12:34 Trfel wrote:On August 30 2016 12:29 Tictock wrote:On August 30 2016 12:18 Trfel wrote:
Tictock, why are you more willing to lynch geript than Rels? Is it just the inconsistencies between his posts and the conclusion, or is there something else? It is partially just feels, on the surface the both just did the same thing but Rels string of thoughts flowed better into his conclusions. Geript has the inconsistencies but also did little to focus on his scum reads or any reads infact, compare to Rels who put down a decent bit about each of his scum reads. I find this interesting because to me, Rels and geript were similar in some ways, but Rels was far more reactive in only addressing the thread sentiment, being open to lynch all the main suspects, and not having any original thought. On the contrary, geript felt more willing to share original thoughts, even if they didn't make as much sense. I am having a bit of trouble believing that you can actually think this . Help? You think I'm scum ? The way I see it, the people you are suspicious of exactly match the thread sentiment, and you haven't provided any original thought. Do you think that I am incorrectly perceiving things? And if not, why shouldn't I think that you are scum?
No its true my scumreads ain't original. That doesn't make me scum thougy as i have 0 problem having polarizing thoughts as scum.
I think a lot of people are town: palmar vivax you disfo rb. Koshi might be, hf and the new guy I don't know. That's how I view the game atm.
|
Okay Rels, one more question. You said that you want to lynch one of four people, and then voted for scott31337. Why did you choose scott31337, and how much do you care about lynching him versus the other people on the list?
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
