Names Are Hard mini mafia

On June 07 2016 06:10 sicklucker wrote:
but really I want to kill shape for that. Reasons being hes the kind of guy who would acualy do something cute like that, where i just do it to fuck with people.

Example how many of you guys remember pyp where I was third party and shapelog was mafia? He rolecoped me and made jokes / notions that he knew I was an alien all game as a cute thing to show off postgame with. Ya murder this man

On June 07 2016 06:28 LightningStrike wrote:

NAI items so far from sicklucker and Shape seems to just be trolling to me. Kinda amused sicklucker and Shape are voting each other but neverless it just NAI items.

On June 07 2016 06:55 wherebugsgo wrote:
yeah we should kill Palmar

On June 07 2016 07:20 KelsierSC wrote:


that is an excellent report of what happened in the game, thank you.

I just found it weird that palmar called you and Damdred mafia, and you were more concerned with damdred than being like "palmar wtf get off me".

On June 07 2016 07:37 Damdred wrote:


This is a smart post, kel can go in the town pile for now as well.

On June 07 2016 11:33 nnn_thekushmountains wrote:
how the fuck did this start already... i cant play right now im super busy. REPLACE PLZ

On June 07 2016 13:17 sicklucker wrote:


what do you think of chezina?

On June 08 2016 07:06 Rels wrote:

##Vote Kwahamot
Prepared first post shows a difficulty to enter the thread.
The "newbie" excuse is typical of newbie scum.
Random reads are random and are looking like he wanted to fill up his post with "serious" stuff.

On June 08 2016 08:26 sicklucker wrote:


bugs seems to think palmar is this tryhard player and is suspicous of his lack of posts. But that was in the 80's. We all know the corrent palmar but I can see why he would focus on palmer since hes probably the only one here hes ever played with (you know in the 80's?) so he does not look that bad for focusing on him imo.

On June 08 2016 10:18 Shapelog wrote:
Idk,
Tumble did you actually get your wish, and replaced in as scum, and now will be able to have a scum meta after what? 8-9 games?

On June 08 2016 10:34 Shapelog wrote:


Only thing you meation about Damdred in your list.

me

Palmar is not even on your catch up post.

You can go ahead and explain the reads on those 3 btw. The fact you got something other than Null for Palmar interests me

On June 08 2016 11:09 Shapelog wrote:

Was the bold the reason why I am scum? Did you actually read the response I gave?

alright on damdred

But how the fuck is Palmar leading anyone onto anything? even if you think Damdred is scum, Palmar hasn't been fucking here leading anyone.

On June 08 2016 12:09 wherebugsgo wrote:


you know, I actually thought I had a pretty good read on you until this post. The observation is fine, and it's actually a pretty townie thing to say, but the manner has me confused.

What bothers me about this post is that the callout isn't direct. I would expect that if you're town you'd just call me out directly and even vote me if that's what you actually think, but in this case it was completely indirect, something I think mafia would be more likely to do because they don't take the attention of making such a strong statement. I like Kelsier's later clarification that the person who said this was me, because that was more direct, but he doesn't get as much credit for it because he wasn't actually the first to point it out.

On June 08 2016 12:18 wherebugsgo wrote:


what do you think of Mr. Log?

On June 08 2016 16:43 VisceraEyes wrote:

Like how has Palmar done any more than me? Seriously though, I've given reads on people, explained them to the best of my ability AND been able to answer questions (mostly, I hear ya Bugs)

That fact alone makes me suspect that ALL of these reads are fabricated and meaningless.

##Vote: Tumblewood

On June 08 2016 17:52 KelsierSC wrote:


I've got a couple of questions for you tumble.

First one is about palmar and your read list. You have made it clear that you agree with palmar and that your scum reads are like his. I'm curious why you needed to qualify that palmar agrees with you when he didn't give any explanation for his reads. To me your shapelog and damdred reads don't have any weight because your damdred read looks like it is just copied from palmar and shapelog is based on something he already answered ,"high volume low contribution" and because palmar agreed. I guess the question im getting at is a chicken or the egg style. is palmar town because he agrees with your reads, or are you making your reads based on town reading palmar.


The second question which ties into the first one is about your scum read of wbg, I don't really understand where this comes from, if you could put specifically what he did that you found scummy that would be great.

I will look over the rest of your list at some point but as VE pointed out some of it looks strange.

On June 08 2016 18:13 Koshi wrote:

also unlikely. TW is lock town because his reads are based on reading the thread and he he had to read the thread after replacing in.

On June 08 2016 23:09 Koshi wrote:

sand in vagina problems today?

On June 09 2016 02:13 Shapelog wrote:


Never a scum tatic, tho top scum.
Not to mention your read on me is so fucking wrong it hurts my eyes. It makes butterflies fly out of the town.

On June 09 2016 02:09 Shapelog wrote:

I did ask for me, and fair i guess. Am working out content tho.

I am predicting that Palmar hasn't posted, so tumble, do you actually know his reasoning behind the votes/reads of his? Because up to this post at least, he hasn't explain any of them, so it is kinda hard to agree with a read that looks like:

"Damdred scum, shape mostly scum"

I just refuse to believe that you, out of all people, who I know can play smart and usually do, is sheeping a person who hasn't even explained their reads, and agreeing with said none explained reads.

On June 09 2016 03:24 Chezinu wrote:
Facts:

##unvote
##vote Tumblewood

Analysis:

Note 13: Maybe this will give Tumblewood a motive to convince us how he is different from a Shapelog.

Purpose of Post:

1. To demonstrate my panic induced scumhunting.

On June 09 2016 03:08 Rels wrote:

He's scumreading me for reasons that are not believable.
He doesn't have this aura of "fuck you I do what I want" that he has as town, especially on D1.
He claims to be good at reading new player but misses the obvious scumtells in the two posts of the new player playing this game.
He didn't spew himself town. If he's town he will at some point.

On June 09 2016 03:42 Damdred wrote:
@sl, rels and koshi

Who am I lynching today so I an hit scum

On June 09 2016 03:48 Damdred wrote:
##unvote
##vote Tumblewood

This is fine my buddy rels wants him dead

On June 09 2016 03:51 Damdred wrote:
Sure let me just sheep Palmar unto myself

On June 09 2016 05:41 sicklucker wrote:


a doctor would not claim a doctor... he would claim a tracker...

On June 10 2016 03:07 wherebugsgo wrote:
I am like...98% sure VE is scum. Kill him.
95% sure Kelsier is also scum after a couple rereads. Kill him too.

The last one is the most difficult but there's a good chance it's Palmar. If it's not Palmar then probably Tumble. From there down the list who knows, very far down probably LS or Chezinu but I doubt it.

On June 11 2016 03:13 Chezinu wrote:

I've been in games where he was mafia and deceived the majority of town to thinking he was town. That's why I'm cautious about him. Especially, when his votes don't look good.

On June 11 2016 10:22 wherebugsgo wrote:
this game is so weird

On June 14 2016 00:02 Artanis[Xp] wrote:

Wait, you're scum?

On June 11 2016 06:54 Chezinu wrote:

it's okk. I just don't want to believe that the host messed up on a vote count against a mafia. It that was true.. I don't know what type of game this is. You should have trolled that you were town pretending to be a tracker to save yourself despite not caring about getting lynch day 1. yet you came back. then left and came back. one instant apathetic to dying and another fighting back til the end. The inconsistency has caused your demise.

On June 08 2016 16:43 VisceraEyes wrote:

Like how has Palmar done any more than me? Seriously though, I've given reads on people, explained them to the best of my ability AND been able to answer questions (mostly, I hear ya Bugs)

That fact alone makes me suspect that ALL of these reads are fabricated and meaningless.

##Vote: Tumblewood

On June 09 2016 18:36 VisceraEyes wrote:
I'm actually fine with Palmar all of a sudden. It's the strangest thing. XD I would have killed him yesterday, but now I think he's town. Maybe it's because I still don't believe Damdred's claim and he was still on Damdred with me. AFK maybe, but probably not. He despises D1 claims.+ Show Spoiler +
Like I said - I've seen Palmar play awfully on D1 before, even recently. Honestly I'm gonna have to see what he does between now and tomorrow, if he dies, etc.

I'm not sure about Tumble. I'm having a hard time getting motivated, to be honest. I don't even want to read his super short filter because I know the whole thing just says "Lynch VE" over and over. Same thing with Koshi - I don't even want to try and read Koshi right now.

On June 14 2016 05:44 VisceraEyes wrote:
TW Will you look at my post on LS and tell me what you think? Humor me plz.

On June 15 2016 00:56 sicklucker wrote:
4,337 km icelan to toronto
5,754 km port to toronto na not even close



im bored

On June 15 2016 07:13 LightningStrike wrote:

If flipped town we would of lost so yep he was mafia.

On June 16 2016 07:26 VisceraEyes wrote:
I don't know about Rels. He could be mafia, but Palmar pushing on him is strange. Like if they're partners why? And if they're not I certainly would rather lynch Palmar than Rels.

On June 16 2016 07:46 Rels wrote:
Wow it looks like it's palmar tumble after all. Tumble being so convinced of no lynching then changing his mind because a town said so is pretty scummy

On June 16 2016 07:49 Rels wrote:
Tumble your take on palmar case on me pretty please ?

On June 16 2016 07:50 Rels wrote:

Why did you change your mind then ?

On June 16 2016 07:57 Rels wrote:

Scum naturally wants to lynch today and not have to lie during more and more days. So you being OK to no lynch because it's the right thing to do then not doing it looks like you're scum posting the right thing to do at first but going with the natural inclination at the first occasion

On June 16 2016 08:03 Rels wrote:

I just explained the fucking scum motivation just because you scumread me doesn't give you the fucking right to not read what I've daif

On June 16 2016 08:16 Rels wrote:

Motherfucker just because your brain can't comprehend others doesn't mean you're right

On June 16 2016 21:10 LightningStrike wrote:

Ugh did you not read recent posts about VE? I townreading him now it just both of us were tunneling each other but now we not tunneling each other.

On June 16 2016 17:20 Rels wrote:

Yes it does. There is no confirmed town in this game. If there was fucking chez wouldn't have been killed last night

Rels said that one time:
Tumble why is Palmar scum

On June 17 2016 02:23 Rels wrote:
Tumble the way you're playing makes me think you' re scum a lot. You're sucking your townreads' dicks; SL can't be wrong about his assertion of the situation, LS can't be scum ... but more than that you are so sure Palmar is scum than you don't want to no-lynch because you think LS and VE will fight when you / SL / me are dead, but you still want to lynch me and your only reason to do so is a case your other scumread made.
The way you just assimilates the things that interests you and adds nothing from your perspective is different from the JAT game where you had your beliefs and they were weird and your own.

On June 17 2016 05:22 Palmar wrote:
SL you're bad if you think not only that I'm right on Rels but in addition that I'm his scummate

On June 11 2016 04:45 VisceraEyes wrote:
WAIT HOLY SHIT

On June 11 2016 04:46 VisceraEyes wrote:
Okay nevermind. I thought I remembered something huge from earlier, but it was nothing.

On June 12 2016 06:31 VisceraEyes wrote:
Jesus Fuckery we had 3 towns up for lynch on D1. Worst game ever.

On June 17 2016 22:40 VisceraEyes wrote:
There is literally no evidence I'm mafia. You are just describing thread sentiment. Everyone seems to THINK there is evidence against me, but no one thinks any of it is actually good. Just know I'm town and win with me. Vote Palmar.

On June 18 2016 00:09 LightningStrike wrote:
Palmar is mafia because he didn't vote scum at all Day 1 or Day 2 which is normally a huge indicator that he's town. Plus he wasn't NK'd Night 2 which he would normally be NK'd by if he's town especially with this player list.

On June 18 2016 00:29 Rels wrote:
Tumble I have a hard time picturing you as scum because all of your posts look so natural.

On June 18 2016 00:31 LightningStrike wrote:
Why can't we lynch palmar instead of sleeping?

On June 17 2016 22:40 VisceraEyes wrote:
There is literally no evidence I'm mafia. You are just describing thread sentiment. Everyone seems to THINK there is evidence against me, but no one thinks any of it is actually good. Just know I'm town and win with me. Vote Palmar.

On June 18 2016 00:45 LightningStrike wrote:

If he scum he will spew WIFOM until his lynch. If he's town we lose anyways.

On June 18 2016 00:54 LightningStrike wrote:

If we going to lynch him next day phase why not do it now?

On June 18 2016 02:01 LightningStrike wrote:
Fuck it i don't care anyone wants to follow I want to just lynch palmar now.
##vote: Palmar

On June 18 2016 03:07 sicklucker wrote:
yes infact if one more person votes palmar scum wins if hes town. so please dont do it yet

On June 18 2016 05:32 LightningStrike wrote:
Man my attempt at a bait on the scum team failed hard I was bating the team to vote Palmar with me to see if he was scum or town and with them not voting him with me it means he likely mafia. I guess we going to no lynch then.
##Unvote
##Vote: No-Lynch

On June 19 2016 19:27 VisceraEyes wrote:
He'll just get on and scream about Rels some more right? I mean, that's all he can do.

##Vote: Palmar

For the record, I'm not voting to get him to type more things, I'm voting him to lynch him because I think he's mafia and we've let him skate by long enough. I don't know why you guys vote someone and then say "Now, this is just to make you do things"...like if they're mafia and they do things what then guys? What then?

On June 19 2016 23:15 Rels wrote:
No I'm thinking sl is scum with palmar. No one else is scummy and there are things that point at him like him not being killed, chez being killed, him not playing the trap sl did when he's the one doing stuff like that usually, him not rereading the game when that's what he does at lylo

On June 20 2016 01:51 sicklucker wrote:
so tumble while your hear can you explain why you missed the last 5-10 minutes of the deadline and almost caused a power role to be lynched?

On June 20 2016 01:59 sicklucker wrote:
I had no idea i had the biggest filter when I did that tho. I can garanteed you I have never had the biggest filter in the game ever as mafia. Theres a big drop off for me meta wise

On June 20 2016 02:15 sicklucker wrote:
Chez was kind of also keeping his reads close to his vest. (he did leave a last will but mafia would have had no time to react to those reads)

So whoever killed him was afraid of the unknown since everyone else had posted reads except for chez. Now im not sure who that would be but thats how I explain his nk in my head

On June 20 2016 05:56 Rels wrote:

Whoever killed him didn't need him as a back up mislynch

On June 20 2016 05:58 Rels wrote:

I disagree. This kill makes ve town

On June 20 2016 05:57 Rels wrote:

This post says nothing :p

On June 20 2016 06:00 Rels wrote:
Like, if ve/palmar is the solution. The plan is to get a mislynch to win the game. So on me or on chez or on ls. In that position it makes 0 sense to kill both chez and ls.

On June 20 2016 06:11 Rels wrote:

It makes 0 sense when sl and you were considered town by everybody. Chez was a lynch target. I am not an easy target to get a mislynch on. I think it will lose scum the game actually

On June 20 2016 07:51 sicklucker wrote:
but what tumble was saying makes alot of sense. if your town in the palmar/ve scum world they would leave me and tumble alive (as they have fucking done) because we both want to kill you. so fuck I hope your not town here because I want to lynch you so bad

On June 20 2016 07:56 Palmar wrote:
I'm back from country

I'll answer any questions tomorrow. Please do not throw the game because you're afraid I might be scum for not posting too much (which is NOT something that makes me mafia, I generally post more as the game progresses as mafia).

On June 21 2016 00:23 Rels wrote:
Posting a case that doesn't make me scum 10 times don't make me scum more

On June 21 2016 00:28 Palmar wrote:

this guy gets it

On June 21 2016 00:41 Rels wrote:

Bad bad bad

On June 21 2016 01:16 sicklucker wrote:
tumble how are you leaning. does the rels/ve world scare you that much

On June 21 2016 02:46 Rels wrote:
Yep Tumble let's fight. I'm decided.

VE, SL: I'm asking for a DUEL with Tumble. Leave your vote on Palmar, so it's 3-2 Palmar-Rels. That's a risk you have to take. I'm taking it too.
If Palmar is not scum, the game is lost. That's part of the risk. He's very very likely scum though: town!Palmar appears decisive but he's actually always doubting and thinking about the game. He wouldn't 100% scumread me for all these days over something I'm known to do, IE tunneling someone because of only one post. But never once did he showed doubts about me.

Now if VE and SL are scum with palmar, the scum in there will switch to me and we lose the game right there. That is the risk I'm taking.
If no switch happens AND Palmar is scum, then VE and SL are confirmed town. And Tumble will be confirmed scum, and from his POV I will be the only one left to be pushed. 1V1 fight

On June 21 2016 03:06 Rels wrote:
First this:

What posts are you talking about here ?

On June 21 2016 03:09 Rels wrote:
Now my answer:

1. cause town are almost never 100% right this early in the game. The last post that called all the mafia in D2 in a game was by rsoul in Himalayas, and it was so impressive she got a 2015 reward from that.
2. cause scum has an harder time changing reads than town because they need to fabricate the reasons for this change.

On June 21 2016 03:13 Rels wrote:

But this was posted after a set of posts by VE that I did not felt were "too scummy to be scum" ?

On June 21 2016 03:19 Rels wrote:

So what did you think of VE's last batch of posts ?

On June 21 2016 03:23 sicklucker wrote:
yes. and holy shit if mafia decides to kill ve over me were gonna have another rels/tumble/sl final 3. no thank you

On June 21 2016 03:22 Rels wrote:

That's nonsense. Do you feel like making a game-turning decision with this little time ?

On June 21 2016 03:34 Rels wrote:

Did you already explain this ?

On June 21 2016 03:46 Rels wrote:
This doesn't make sense. VE / Palmar doesn't make sense because I am so scum ?

On June 21 2016 03:45 Rels wrote:

Then why are you not OK killing Palmar ? You said all these things about Palmar being scum and VE being town.

On June 21 2016 03:51 Rels wrote:

Which is why you're scum. Town do not have this kind of certainty

On June 21 2016 03:54 Rels wrote:

And what happened before the end of the game ?

On June 21 2016 03:58 Rels wrote:
Tumble you have so many "XXX what do you think of YYY"' in your filter I don't know how I didn't catch this earlier. It looks like you said to yourself "OK I'm gonna be really questionning people this game" when the game started. And you usually do nothing with the answer.

On June 21 2016 04:02 Rels wrote:
Seriously. D4 you townread VE and scumread Palmar. Since that post:

It's been 50/50 Palmar / VE never commiting to a read.

On June 21 2016 04:50 sicklucker wrote:
Like I think individually rels has been more scummy but your inactivity has just made your more likely to be with more people in my mind. Maybe im wrong on you like im still not decided but im certainly not lynching tumble today

On June 21 2016 04:43 VisceraEyes wrote:
Stay the course boys. In also waiting for GoT until after deadline.

On June 21 2016 05:02 Rels wrote:

Not that you're not right but this is ironic coming from you

On June 21 2016 05:05 Rels wrote:

Your case is palmar s case :p

On June 21 2016 05:06 VisceraEyes wrote:
Also from the guy who was 100%on ME being mafia for the first 2 game days lol. TW reads mean nothing.

On June 21 2016 05:08 Rels wrote:

No it isn't. I'm known for tunneling on little as town. It doesn't make me scum or town

On June 21 2016 05:11 Rels wrote:
And even if you scumread me me being scummier than palmar is pretty hilarious

On June 21 2016 05:22 Rels wrote:

I think he said it already

On June 21 2016 05:45 sicklucker wrote:
well that was shitty timing is tumble here. i like having the hammer you have 15 minutes to convince me. palmar bleed town out of ur arse if ur town

On June 21 2016 06:01 Rels wrote:
GG bros
Couldn't see clearly with Tumble tunneling all game
Tumble you played this one super badly. Each time I came to the thread trying to solve the game you shut me down. Too bad

On June 21 2016 06:15 LightningStrike wrote:
BTW why kill me when I was only right on palmar?

On June 21 2016 06:24 VisceraEyes wrote:
How did Tumble not switch to Palmar after he saw SL switch? That's what I want to know

On June 21 2016 06:44 sicklucker wrote:
If koshis doesint die its interesting . I think were still big favorites we just kill koshi and have to get chez or tumble lynched. I would like to think palmar would have tried more. I think palmar is a huge fan of trying as little as possible to win like me