|
On April 20 2016 04:36 Rels wrote:
The simplest explanation is "Palmar is good player, he got shot". Simple and more likely. The only thing that makes me think you might have a point is the Superbia's claim before end of night. It must have a purpose.
of course, to set up a vig claim XD
this argument has kind of meandered because I have had to go into how scum mishandled super if he was town, which requires me to argue the opposite side of things in order to prove why scum knew he was... well scum... which is pointless cause were going to know what he is soon enough.
Whereas if hes scum, it's pretty clear he called palmer out, then had the team shoot him, so that he could try and contest vig claim.
the fuck up there was that scum didn't know how to handle the fazzers flip, which clearly came from the actual vig. My assertion that scum is derp stems from how they could not have anticipated the fazzers flip ruining supers vig setup.
superbia realized his initial plan wouldn't work, so he switched over to doc, not with the intent of living anymore, but of getting the doc to cc and get some bang for his buck.
the end.
|
So my argument kinda has two halves.
1: if super is town, the night kill is really wierd and seems to simultaneusly bother and not bother with his claim
The logic of "hey, super might shoot his number 1 scum read, lets shoot him too and rb super just in case" seems kinda odd as opposed to "hey, super may very well shoot palmer, lets rb and kill someone else, while potentially getting him to do our work for us, could be worth the risk"
2: if super is scum, the nk makes sense (allows him to contest vig) but is still derpy as it does not consider several key factors (like what the actual vig shot would be)
one makes little to no sense, the other makes sense if scum are derps. Therefore scum derped / :
|
Unrelated to this an argument could be made that this points towards superbia being mafia because he just said he would shoot the guy he called scum all the way
jat this is what im saying happened, im just also saying that the opposite case of him bieng town and them rbing him then shooting palmer makes less sense / :
therefore the first case is more likely.
|
On April 20 2016 04:54 justanothertownie wrote:Show nested quote +On April 20 2016 04:51 gumshoe wrote:
So my argument kinda has two halves.
1: if super is town, the night kill is really wierd and seems to simultaneusly bother and not bother with his claim
The logic of "hey, super might shoot his number 1 scum read, lets shoot him too and rb super just in case" seems kinda odd as opposed to "hey, super may very well shoot palmer, lets rb and kill someone else, while potentially getting him to do our work for us, could be worth the risk"
2: if super is scum, the nk makes sense (allows him to contest vig) but is still derpy as it does not consider several key factors (like what the actual vig shot would be)
one makes little to no sense, the other makes sense if scum are derps. Therefore scum derped / :
Let's just agree to disagree here. At the very least until super flips. The thing you should take away from our discussion is that both me and Rels disagree with you. So you probably shouldn't townread us just because Palmar died.
opposite : P people disagreeing with me is what town do. Scum are the ones who encourage my madness XD(the lack of encouragement is actually rather encouraging)
also if ether of you are scum, why are you fighting so hard to be town read 0_0
|
Sigh, had to be the fucking rb, am disappoint T-T
|
On April 20 2016 07:05 rsoultin wrote:Show nested quote +On April 20 2016 07:04 gumshoe wrote:
Sigh, had to be the fucking rb, am disappoint T-T
RB is great. RB means scum has to kill doc -flicks- don't be so attached to your theories lol ><
Theories are why I play this game XD
Also this doesn't ruin the, just throws a shoe. Tumble is still likely town in my op as I still think in this setup claiming is a last resort and should never be used to buss.
|
Speaking of theories, this proves super wanted to claim vig (or at least left that route open for himself) now, question, does anyone know why that makes sick likely to be scum?
|
On April 20 2016 07:09 JustAnotherScummer wrote:Show nested quote +On April 20 2016 06:18 Superbia wrote:On April 20 2016 06:16 JustAnotherScummer wrote:
Since you are here super, can you like spitball ideas about the game? Just like things that you think off the top of your head etc. You're in my PoE scum list. Together with TW and SL. Maybe RSO scum. Maybe Obi bc TMI. Gut feeling is that there is a scum here.
That would be sl
|
On April 20 2016 07:16 JustAnotherScummer wrote:Show nested quote +On April 20 2016 07:10 gumshoe wrote:
Speaking of theories, this proves super wanted to claim vig (or at least left that route open for himself) now, question, does anyone know why that makes sick likely to be scum? Does this have anything to do with how their posts Align?
nop, this is new : D
|
but yeah people should really look at that as well
1: sl and obi never adressed each other till I brought it up
2: super never attacked obi and sl for staying on his wagon till I brought it up
3: they both bussed him round the same time / :
and I get that the post time thing isnt THAT big a deal but no amount of shrugs can change the fact that it was definitely odd.
|
jat, now that supers flipped no rush but def let me know where your at on reads sometime before e.o.n
|
On April 20 2016 07:27 justanothertownie wrote:
Everything superbia did or said day2 is completely WIFOM and should never be the basis of someones reads. Considering his defeatist approach scum also knew they would sacc him today really early. Noone gets any credit for attacking him today.
is his turning of a total blind eye towards obi and sl for all of night 1 and half of day 2 just wifom? Cause I understand accusing your scum partners as your going down is shitty, but not saying anything? That just seems like wishful thinking on his part.
|
On April 20 2016 07:32 justanothertownie wrote:Show nested quote +On April 20 2016 07:29 gumshoe wrote:On April 20 2016 07:27 justanothertownie wrote:
Everything superbia did or said day2 is completely WIFOM and should never be the basis of someones reads. Considering his defeatist approach scum also knew they would sacc him today really early. Noone gets any credit for attacking him today. is his turning of a total blind eye towards obi and sl for all of night 1 and half of day 2 just wifom? Cause I understand accusing your scum partners as your going down is shitty, but not saying anything? That just seems like wishful thinking on his part. He wasn't particularly invested in the game so I think he just casually opened the thread and posted the little he did in reaction to what he saw there. I mean he was the fucking rb and if he tried they could have at least outed the medic today. But he didn't.
sigh, sometimes I feel like your just arguing for the sake of arguing T_T but I cant quite accuse anyone of that so whateves, gn.
|
On April 20 2016 07:32 justanothertownie wrote:Show nested quote +On April 20 2016 07:29 gumshoe wrote:On April 20 2016 07:27 justanothertownie wrote:
Everything superbia did or said day2 is completely WIFOM and should never be the basis of someones reads. Considering his defeatist approach scum also knew they would sacc him today really early. Noone gets any credit for attacking him today. is his turning of a total blind eye towards obi and sl for all of night 1 and half of day 2 just wifom? Cause I understand accusing your scum partners as your going down is shitty, but not saying anything? That just seems like wishful thinking on his part. He wasn't particularly invested in the game so I think he just casually opened the thread and posted the little he did in reaction to what he saw there. I mean he was the fucking rb and if he tried they could have at least outed the medic today. But he didn't.
also if he wasn't so invested, dont you think its pretty likely he had his team bus him day 1? Or at least more likely than say rels leading a big counter push on tws to save him?
|
I am starting to understand your thought process though. I disagree with your conclusion but it makes sense.
I think this is the closest jat has come this game to agreeing with anyone this game and hes still telling me im wrong XD
still, i'll take it as a good sign. I am an optimist.
|
On April 20 2016 07:54 justanothertownie wrote:Show nested quote +On April 20 2016 07:44 gumshoe wrote:On April 20 2016 07:32 justanothertownie wrote:On April 20 2016 07:29 gumshoe wrote:On April 20 2016 07:27 justanothertownie wrote:
Everything superbia did or said day2 is completely WIFOM and should never be the basis of someones reads. Considering his defeatist approach scum also knew they would sacc him today really early. Noone gets any credit for attacking him today. is his turning of a total blind eye towards obi and sl for all of night 1 and half of day 2 just wifom? Cause I understand accusing your scum partners as your going down is shitty, but not saying anything? That just seems like wishful thinking on his part. He wasn't particularly invested in the game so I think he just casually opened the thread and posted the little he did in reaction to what he saw there. I mean he was the fucking rb and if he tried they could have at least outed the medic today. But he didn't. also if he wasn't so invested, dont you think its pretty likely he had his team bus him day 1? Or at least more likely than say rels leading a big counter push on tws to save him? It is possible but we already know that the biggest part of his wagon day1 was town since they are dead. And yes, there probably is mafia somewhere on the tumble wagon regardless of that guys alignment.
fair enough : D as long as that person is sick or obi I am content.
|
On April 20 2016 08:12 sicklucker wrote:Show nested quote +On April 20 2016 07:55 gumshoe wrote:I am starting to understand your thought process though. I disagree with your conclusion but it makes sense. I think this is the closest jat has come this game to agreeing with anyone this game and hes still telling me im wrong XD still, i'll take it as a good sign. I am an optimist. no this is probably why hes scum. hes trying to pocket you. the jat I know would never agree with your crazy theorys and probably bring you to tears for making the posts you made. ![[image loading]](http://i.imgur.com/AKQVTun.gif)
he didnt agree he still thinks im wrong probs XD
|
On April 20 2016 09:00 rsoultin wrote:Show nested quote +On April 20 2016 08:18 gumshoe wrote:On April 20 2016 08:12 sicklucker wrote:On April 20 2016 07:55 gumshoe wrote:I am starting to understand your thought process though. I disagree with your conclusion but it makes sense. I think this is the closest jat has come this game to agreeing with anyone this game and hes still telling me im wrong XD still, i'll take it as a good sign. I am an optimist. no this is probably why hes scum. hes trying to pocket you. the jat I know would never agree with your crazy theorys and probably bring you to tears for making the posts you made. he didnt agree he still thinks im wrong probs XD for what it's worth, so do i ^^ i really don't think that super's general lack of content should be read into overly much. he barely talked about anything. so him not talking about sl and ows isn't a reason to scumread them in my opinion
thanks : D I dont know what I would without your unwavering consistency XD
|
On April 20 2016 10:34 sicklucker wrote:Show nested quote +On April 20 2016 08:18 gumshoe wrote:On April 20 2016 08:12 sicklucker wrote:On April 20 2016 07:55 gumshoe wrote:I am starting to understand your thought process though. I disagree with your conclusion but it makes sense. I think this is the closest jat has come this game to agreeing with anyone this game and hes still telling me im wrong XD still, i'll take it as a good sign. I am an optimist. no this is probably why hes scum. hes trying to pocket you. the jat I know would never agree with your crazy theorys and probably bring you to tears for making the posts you made. he didnt agree he still thinks im wrong probs XD he would destroy you and eat your babies
you know Sick, just want you to know regardless of your alignment, I am rather enjoying you this game : D you is a good guy (even though your a bad guy XD)
|
On April 20 2016 10:45 rsoultin wrote:Show nested quote +On April 20 2016 10:44 gumshoe wrote:On April 20 2016 10:34 sicklucker wrote:On April 20 2016 08:18 gumshoe wrote:On April 20 2016 08:12 sicklucker wrote:On April 20 2016 07:55 gumshoe wrote:I am starting to understand your thought process though. I disagree with your conclusion but it makes sense. I think this is the closest jat has come this game to agreeing with anyone this game and hes still telling me im wrong XD still, i'll take it as a good sign. I am an optimist. no this is probably why hes scum. hes trying to pocket you. the jat I know would never agree with your crazy theorys and probably bring you to tears for making the posts you made. he didnt agree he still thinks im wrong probs XD he would destroy you and eat your babies you know Sick, just want you to know regardless of your alignment, I am rather enjoying you this game : D you is a good guy (even though your a bad guy XD) pssst ise got a secret for you >> sl is totes my town-bro this game
psshhhh there are no town bros, only slightly less suspicious players.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
