I don't think those are *that* different from usual setups? I guess it's a bit unusual to choose the frame target for the rest of the game at the start, but.... Maybe it should at least be 48 hours or something? 24 hours seems a bit short; the team might not have even had the opportunity to effectively communicate yet and it's a pretty big choice. In any case, the game should be harder than usual for Mafia considering the player pool..

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

January 12 2016 11:13 GMT

#70

Oh... Are you informed if your jail target was hit? What if you were hit while in jail? I guess not since you're not informed of anything "not required"?

I don't really see a problem with limiting consecutive jailings.. I guess it could become a problem if the Jailer misses that rule (ouch), but otherwise it should be *at least* as good as a hard limit (you can still just switch if you want)..

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

January 12 2016 11:48 GMT

#72

On January 12 2016 20:29 marvellosity wrote:

Show nested quote +

24h is better.

Really? Usually you can switch it around freely though, isn't 24h from the start a bit limiting?

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

January 12 2016 11:49 GMT

#73

I guess Mafia already has a Roleblocker, but... It still seems OK for town, especially with no "free mislynches" etc.

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

January 12 2016 12:23 GMT

#75

Haha

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

January 14 2016 08:10 GMT

#158

DYH seems town so far... Basically it just feels like he's analyzing the game objectively. Not pushing any specific thought(s) or avoiding attention. Early credit grab

Insufficient data to use my new heuristic on rayn, and marv hasn't even posted yet :/

Some mixed feelings about ritoky. Could be town though with that level of confident posting style and activity...

I'll refrain from mentioning who disturbed me the most for a little bit.

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

January 14 2016 08:13 GMT

#159

Meh, Ace feels like he just really doesn't want to say anything meaningful. Slight scumlean.

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

January 14 2016 08:15 GMT

#160

(just to be clear, Ace isn't the one I mentioned earlier)

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

January 14 2016 08:20 GMT

#161

No, I changed my mind. It's null for now.

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

January 14 2016 08:21 GMT

#162

(the one I talked about)

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

January 14 2016 08:26 GMT

#165

On January 14 2016 17:23 raynpelikoneet wrote:

Show nested quote +

If i made the posts DYH did would you consider me town?

Not really... I use a different heuristic for you now anyway

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

January 14 2016 08:31 GMT

#169

On January 14 2016 17:28 raynpelikoneet wrote:

Show nested quote +

Do you realize DYH is a really good scumplayer?

I don't really remember him at all...... If that's the case, I guess he can't be given a free pass for now. His posts still seemed fine enough to me. You also pretty much said that it's in the "range of his scumplay", not scummy. Does he just appear really town as scum?

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

January 14 2016 08:36 GMT

#171

On January 14 2016 17:30 raynpelikoneet wrote:
Xatalos what do you think about Damdred so far?

He's actually the player I didn't immediately want to talk about earlier. I guess it's fine.

It's just that I was reading his post in the player read diagram thread where he was sad that his play was so easy to read (basically "emotive at all? YES -> town, NO -> mafia" haha). When I looked at how he played this game, I didn't really see any significant emotion, but there were some really weak signs of emotion such as the "(XD)" at one point. It got me thinking that he could be mindful of his read diagram and try to include some sort of emotion forcefully. But then again, I realized that it was too early to judge him just based on a couple of posts.

Now the usefulness of this thought process is probably more limited, since I already said it, but what do you think?

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

January 14 2016 08:38 GMT

#172

My personal history of reading Damdred isn't so good, so that's why I focused on the "emotion aspect" :D

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

January 14 2016 08:40 GMT

#173

On January 14 2016 17:32 raynpelikoneet wrote:
I am saying he could definitely make those posts as mafia aswell as town.
I don't have a read on one way or another on him, if that wasn't clear.

Maybe... My gut feeling was just that he was observing what actually happened in the thread rather than pushing some pre-set agenda... We'll see.

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

January 14 2016 08:45 GMT

#175

Well, I'm pretty much null on him too at this point. I've historically been bad at reading him and it's especially hard when there's so little content yet.

Xatalos

Finland9675 Posts

January 14 2016 08:48 GMT

#176

On January 14 2016 10:19 Damdred wrote:
You should just town me and try to pocket me here.

As for ace, hello ace i'm pretty new player (XD). I'm not very good depending on who you ask, it takes a bit of prodding to get me to explain what I think and why but don't worry I don't tunnel.

I've heard a lot about you and expect a lot

Oh yeah, this post just felt a bit bad to me overall. Both the weak (XD) like it was inserted as an afterthought to have some emotion (if that makes any sense hahaha.... maybe not) and the buddying with Ace? All conjecture at this point though.