|
On December 29 2015 16:58 Irishbound wrote:
@Shape - I've explained my issue with Giygas post as much as I can really. What content specifically are you waiting for and what's stopping you from getting reads from what's been posted thus far?
I Generally like having more then 2 pages (which half of which is either me or opening jokes) to base reads off of. I usually start subtracting the trolololo and add actual useful crap later into the day and into the later days.
100% tryhard mode this game. I promise.
@Fidel Castro (I must tryhard)
I do not know about GB (only play with him in nutcracker for a bit tbh) or NM.
About Onegu, His VT claim is dumb, but from what i heard from other players, this is the norm for him? Idk, I can tell more about him once he starts posting atcual content (if he does.) Last game i played (which was my first) he was more ativce days 1 and 2, but fell off during the later days. This might be because Koshi died thou.
But i really shouldn't jump to conclusions yet based off another game. Especially as i was compared as a rsoul. Smurf (still trying to figure that out)
Also I am not that experience IMO. I played 20 mafia games back in college during freshman year (so like 4-5 years ago) And nutcracker was my 1st forum mafia game ^.^
Personally, this morning I am giving a town read towards Irish and maybe NM. Irish for his general posting and podding questions.
Mderg is another i could place as town. At first i felt his intro post felt a bit scummy and a bit after wards espially with this post:
On December 29 2015 18:32 mderg wrote:
Meh, reading this thread is difficult when you don't know most of those names.
People are quick to jump on GB, I like that because his opening was fishy but I also don't like it because it feels too easy. I'll have to see how that continues.
Don't like GiygaS so far... Has made like 7 posts but I didn't see anything of substance. The fist reads also don't really seem that strong.
I have a slight townread on NocturneMage, he's being out there and being open about his thoughts. He's also asking lots of questions which makes me think he's trying to solve the game. He is a dirty league player, though...
The Bold feels a bit like hes repeating a lot of what people are saying, which indicatives to me mafia trying to look present.
However, hes recent posts on me gives me a bit of a more town feel. I do admit, to me, it is a bit early for filtering, but the fact he is thinking and perhaps doing it makes me want to say he is leaning more to town. I just want to bring up the above fact (repeating).
|
On December 29 2015 22:38 mderg wrote:Show nested quote +On December 29 2015 21:33 Fidei86 wrote:On December 29 2015 20:41 mderg wrote:On December 29 2015 20:23 Fidei86 wrote:
Eh what I meant to say is your lack of a read on ShapeLog (you don't actually have a read on him). For me, I think SL's "loneliest man in New York" rant was kinda towny, but it's more surprising that you didn't hit on that but went to Gigya. I haven't really gone through his filter because it's annoying to read and didn't notice anything special from him in the thread (aside from spam). I guess that also doesn't make him look too good considering the filter size. I agree it's annoying, but what do you think about his alignment? Not sure, as you've already pointed out there's not much content and mostly useless posts. But from my experience useless spam comes more often from town than from scum. So I'm leaning in the direction of town on him.
Are u insulting my information tactics?
BAD SHAPELOG. STAY ON TRACK.
|
Also presently voting Scott, that vote can change, there are a few other scumreads that I need to continue resolving one way or another, GB, Shapelog, possibly Onegu/Fidei and at present noon and Cow would fall under the policy lynch category for me.
|
Shapelog, any opinion (given your last on Onegu) on his vote on Fidei?
And that crossed out statement, are you inferring that could be another reason for mderg to be scum from your perspective?
|
Ergh, I don't know about that read on mderg. Like agree with everyone else on GB, but saying the GB vote is too easy? I don't recall anyone else in thread actually saying that. So I don't think that part of the conclusion is reasonable.
|
|
|
On December 30 2015 00:27 Shapelog wrote:Show nested quote +On December 29 2015 16:58 Irishbound wrote:
@Shape - I've explained my issue with Giygas post as much as I can really. What content specifically are you waiting for and what's stopping you from getting reads from what's been posted thus far?
I Generally like having more then 2 pages (which half of which is either me or opening jokes) to base reads off of. I usually start subtracting the trolololo and add actual useful crap later into the day and into the later days. 100% tryhard mode this game. I promise. @Fidel Castro (I must tryhard) I do not know about GB (only play with him in nutcracker for a bit tbh) or NM. About Onegu, His VT claim is dumb, but from what i heard from other players, this is the norm for him? Idk, I can tell more about him once he starts posting atcual content (if he does.) Last game i played (which was my first) he was more ativce days 1 and 2, but fell off during the later days. This might be because Koshi died thou. But i really shouldn't jump to conclusions yet based off another game. Especially as i was compared as a rsoul. Smurf (still trying to figure that out) Also I am not that experience IMO. I played 20 mafia games back in college during freshman year (so like 4-5 years ago) And nutcracker was my 1st forum mafia game ^.^ Personally, this morning I am giving a town read towards Irish and maybe NM. Irish for his general posting and podding questions. Mderg is another i could place as town. At first i felt his intro post felt a bit scummy and a bit after wards espially with this post: Show nested quote +On December 29 2015 18:32 mderg wrote:
Meh, reading this thread is difficult when you don't know most of those names.
People are quick to jump on GB, I like that because his opening was fishy but I also don't like it because it feels too easy. I'll have to see how that continues.
Don't like GiygaS so far... Has made like 7 posts but I didn't see anything of substance. The fist reads also don't really seem that strong.
I have a slight townread on NocturneMage, he's being out there and being open about his thoughts. He's also asking lots of questions which makes me think he's trying to solve the game. He is a dirty league player, though... The Bold feels a bit like hes repeating a lot of what people are saying, which indicatives to me mafia trying to look present. However, hes recent posts on me gives me a bit of a more town feel. I do admit, to me, it is a bit early for filtering, but the fact he is thinking and perhaps doing it makes me want to say he is leaning more to town. I just want to bring up the above fact (repeating).
Koshi died? 
I'm pretty sure I've played with Onegu in the past but I don't remember him doing stupid stuff like that. That's why I have no idea what to make of his posts so far.
I can see how the part about GiygaS can be seen as repeating what others have said but I definitely can't see it with my stance on GlowingBear. Can you elaborate more on that?
|
On December 30 2015 00:36 NocturneMage wrote:
Shapelog, any opinion (given your last on Onegu) on his vote on Fidei?
And that crossed out statement, are you inferring that could be another reason for mderg to be scum from your perspective?
Onegu does whatever Onegu does. He expects everyone to follow him IMO like he is town jesus. Onegu could honestly mean to vote Fidei based off of no explanation or lack of explanation. When he was smurfing he was quite aggressive last game.
But if i was to take off the meta glasses of mislynchs, I see either a horrible pressure vote or a troll vote IMO. I mean im guessing the "how about this" was to draw out a reaction of sorts.
No the [S] was because i was being too trolololoing. Idc if he has problems with my playstyle (or hopefully my old play style). His opinion is his opinion
And no i wasn't Afk, i went to grab my grits and it takes me a bit of time to type due to me misspelling every word and having to go back and retype it.
|
On December 30 2015 00:41 NocturneMage wrote:
Ergh, I don't know about that read on mderg. Like agree with everyone else on GB, but saying the GB vote is too easy? I don't recall anyone else in thread actually saying that. So I don't think that part of the conclusion is reasonable.
NVM your right, My memory failed me about that part.
|
On December 30 2015 01:10 mderg wrote:Show nested quote +On December 30 2015 00:27 Shapelog wrote:On December 29 2015 16:58 Irishbound wrote:
@Shape - I've explained my issue with Giygas post as much as I can really. What content specifically are you waiting for and what's stopping you from getting reads from what's been posted thus far?
I Generally like having more then 2 pages (which half of which is either me or opening jokes) to base reads off of. I usually start subtracting the trolololo and add actual useful crap later into the day and into the later days. 100% tryhard mode this game. I promise. @Fidel Castro (I must tryhard) I do not know about GB (only play with him in nutcracker for a bit tbh) or NM. About Onegu, His VT claim is dumb, but from what i heard from other players, this is the norm for him? Idk, I can tell more about him once he starts posting atcual content (if he does.) Last game i played (which was my first) he was more ativce days 1 and 2, but fell off during the later days. This might be because Koshi died thou. But i really shouldn't jump to conclusions yet based off another game. Especially as i was compared as a rsoul. Smurf (still trying to figure that out) Also I am not that experience IMO. I played 20 mafia games back in college during freshman year (so like 4-5 years ago) And nutcracker was my 1st forum mafia game ^.^ Personally, this morning I am giving a town read towards Irish and maybe NM. Irish for his general posting and podding questions. Mderg is another i could place as town. At first i felt his intro post felt a bit scummy and a bit after wards espially with this post: On December 29 2015 18:32 mderg wrote:
Meh, reading this thread is difficult when you don't know most of those names.
People are quick to jump on GB, I like that because his opening was fishy but I also don't like it because it feels too easy. I'll have to see how that continues.
Don't like GiygaS so far... Has made like 7 posts but I didn't see anything of substance. The fist reads also don't really seem that strong.
I have a slight townread on NocturneMage, he's being out there and being open about his thoughts. He's also asking lots of questions which makes me think he's trying to solve the game. He is a dirty league player, though... The Bold feels a bit like hes repeating a lot of what people are saying, which indicatives to me mafia trying to look present. However, hes recent posts on me gives me a bit of a more town feel. I do admit, to me, it is a bit early for filtering, but the fact he is thinking and perhaps doing it makes me want to say he is leaning more to town. I just want to bring up the above fact (repeating). Koshi died? I'm pretty sure I've played with Onegu in the past but I don't remember him doing stupid stuff like that. That's why I have no idea what to make of his posts so far. I can see how the part about GiygaS can be seen as repeating what others have said but I definitely can't see it with my stance on GlowingBear. Can you elaborate more on that?
Yeah Koshi and Kush both died on the same night because mafia unboxed a gun.
Onegu called me, Koshi, and damdred scum all game and on day 3 and up keep saying we were scum and that was it. his only reads were posted on d1 and he tunneled.
Also see above post for Gb.
|
Vote Count - Day 1
scott31337 (2): Irishbound, NocturneMage
Not Voting (10): Kmatt, Shapelog, TheCow, GiygaS, Fidei86, mderg, GlowingBear, Onegu, nooniansoong, scott31337
At this time, scott31337 is slated to be lynched.
Day 1 ends in on Wednesday, Dec 30 10:00pm GMT (GMT+00:00).
The voting thread is here.
Only votes there will be counted.
|
In the process of slowly catching up. I read something about Outlaw. Please do not mention ongoing games.
|
On December 30 2015 01:22 Shapelog wrote:Show nested quote +On December 30 2015 01:10 mderg wrote:On December 30 2015 00:27 Shapelog wrote:On December 29 2015 16:58 Irishbound wrote:
@Shape - I've explained my issue with Giygas post as much as I can really. What content specifically are you waiting for and what's stopping you from getting reads from what's been posted thus far?
I Generally like having more then 2 pages (which half of which is either me or opening jokes) to base reads off of. I usually start subtracting the trolololo and add actual useful crap later into the day and into the later days. 100% tryhard mode this game. I promise. @Fidel Castro (I must tryhard) I do not know about GB (only play with him in nutcracker for a bit tbh) or NM. About Onegu, His VT claim is dumb, but from what i heard from other players, this is the norm for him? Idk, I can tell more about him once he starts posting atcual content (if he does.) Last game i played (which was my first) he was more ativce days 1 and 2, but fell off during the later days. This might be because Koshi died thou. But i really shouldn't jump to conclusions yet based off another game. Especially as i was compared as a rsoul. Smurf (still trying to figure that out) Also I am not that experience IMO. I played 20 mafia games back in college during freshman year (so like 4-5 years ago) And nutcracker was my 1st forum mafia game ^.^ Personally, this morning I am giving a town read towards Irish and maybe NM. Irish for his general posting and podding questions. Mderg is another i could place as town. At first i felt his intro post felt a bit scummy and a bit after wards espially with this post: On December 29 2015 18:32 mderg wrote:
Meh, reading this thread is difficult when you don't know most of those names.
People are quick to jump on GB, I like that because his opening was fishy but I also don't like it because it feels too easy. I'll have to see how that continues.
Don't like GiygaS so far... Has made like 7 posts but I didn't see anything of substance. The fist reads also don't really seem that strong.
I have a slight townread on NocturneMage, he's being out there and being open about his thoughts. He's also asking lots of questions which makes me think he's trying to solve the game. He is a dirty league player, though... The Bold feels a bit like hes repeating a lot of what people are saying, which indicatives to me mafia trying to look present. However, hes recent posts on me gives me a bit of a more town feel. I do admit, to me, it is a bit early for filtering, but the fact he is thinking and perhaps doing it makes me want to say he is leaning more to town. I just want to bring up the above fact (repeating). Koshi died? I'm pretty sure I've played with Onegu in the past but I don't remember him doing stupid stuff like that. That's why I have no idea what to make of his posts so far. I can see how the part about GiygaS can be seen as repeating what others have said but I definitely can't see it with my stance on GlowingBear. Can you elaborate more on that? Yeah Koshi and Kush both died on the same night because mafia unboxed a gun. Onegu called me, Koshi, and damdred scum all game and on day 3 and up keep saying we were scum and that was it. his only reads were posted on d1 and he tunneled. Also see above post for Gb.
Sounds like an interesting game, not like a game I'd want to play, though. Right now Onegu is just a huge questionmark for me.
I was hoping you'd pressure me a bit for kind of repeating what NocturneMage said here... would have made things a bit more interesting
|
On December 30 2015 01:27 nooniansoong wrote:
In the process of slowly catching up. I read something about Outlaw. Please do not mention ongoing games.
Oh fuck! Yeah im sorry.
Kita might be visting me soon.
|
On December 30 2015 01:30 mderg wrote:Show nested quote +On December 30 2015 01:22 Shapelog wrote:On December 30 2015 01:10 mderg wrote:On December 30 2015 00:27 Shapelog wrote:On December 29 2015 16:58 Irishbound wrote:
@Shape - I've explained my issue with Giygas post as much as I can really. What content specifically are you waiting for and what's stopping you from getting reads from what's been posted thus far?
I Generally like having more then 2 pages (which half of which is either me or opening jokes) to base reads off of. I usually start subtracting the trolololo and add actual useful crap later into the day and into the later days. 100% tryhard mode this game. I promise. @Fidel Castro (I must tryhard) I do not know about GB (only play with him in nutcracker for a bit tbh) or NM. About Onegu, His VT claim is dumb, but from what i heard from other players, this is the norm for him? Idk, I can tell more about him once he starts posting atcual content (if he does.) Last game i played (which was my first) he was more ativce days 1 and 2, but fell off during the later days. This might be because Koshi died thou. But i really shouldn't jump to conclusions yet based off another game. Especially as i was compared as a rsoul. Smurf (still trying to figure that out) Also I am not that experience IMO. I played 20 mafia games back in college during freshman year (so like 4-5 years ago) And nutcracker was my 1st forum mafia game ^.^ Personally, this morning I am giving a town read towards Irish and maybe NM. Irish for his general posting and podding questions. Mderg is another i could place as town. At first i felt his intro post felt a bit scummy and a bit after wards espially with this post: On December 29 2015 18:32 mderg wrote:
Meh, reading this thread is difficult when you don't know most of those names.
People are quick to jump on GB, I like that because his opening was fishy but I also don't like it because it feels too easy. I'll have to see how that continues.
Don't like GiygaS so far... Has made like 7 posts but I didn't see anything of substance. The fist reads also don't really seem that strong.
I have a slight townread on NocturneMage, he's being out there and being open about his thoughts. He's also asking lots of questions which makes me think he's trying to solve the game. He is a dirty league player, though... The Bold feels a bit like hes repeating a lot of what people are saying, which indicatives to me mafia trying to look present. However, hes recent posts on me gives me a bit of a more town feel. I do admit, to me, it is a bit early for filtering, but the fact he is thinking and perhaps doing it makes me want to say he is leaning more to town. I just want to bring up the above fact (repeating). Koshi died? I'm pretty sure I've played with Onegu in the past but I don't remember him doing stupid stuff like that. That's why I have no idea what to make of his posts so far. I can see how the part about GiygaS can be seen as repeating what others have said but I definitely can't see it with my stance on GlowingBear. Can you elaborate more on that? Yeah Koshi and Kush both died on the same night because mafia unboxed a gun. Onegu called me, Koshi, and damdred scum all game and on day 3 and up keep saying we were scum and that was it. his only reads were posted on d1 and he tunneled. Also see above post for Gb. Sounds like an interesting game, not like a game I'd want to play, though. Right now Onegu is just a huge questionmark for me. I was hoping you'd pressure me a bit for kind of repeating what NocturneMage said here... would have made things a bit more interesting
Blah Onegu is just weird.
Y? all i have on you is GiygaS Khan and how it is a repeat, 1/2 of my discussion is already false. Like honestly if i was going to push i should (at least in my mind) something reasonable (IKR!).
Im not going to dig my own grave over something small. I shall put it down and make a case and dig my own grave when everything gets picked apart and no one can understand its true meaning.
|
On December 30 2015 01:30 mderg wrote:Show nested quote +On December 30 2015 01:22 Shapelog wrote:On December 30 2015 01:10 mderg wrote:On December 30 2015 00:27 Shapelog wrote:On December 29 2015 16:58 Irishbound wrote:
@Shape - I've explained my issue with Giygas post as much as I can really. What content specifically are you waiting for and what's stopping you from getting reads from what's been posted thus far?
I Generally like having more then 2 pages (which half of which is either me or opening jokes) to base reads off of. I usually start subtracting the trolololo and add actual useful crap later into the day and into the later days. 100% tryhard mode this game. I promise. @Fidel Castro (I must tryhard) I do not know about GB (only play with him in nutcracker for a bit tbh) or NM. About Onegu, His VT claim is dumb, but from what i heard from other players, this is the norm for him? Idk, I can tell more about him once he starts posting atcual content (if he does.) Last game i played (which was my first) he was more ativce days 1 and 2, but fell off during the later days. This might be because Koshi died thou. But i really shouldn't jump to conclusions yet based off another game. Especially as i was compared as a rsoul. Smurf (still trying to figure that out) Also I am not that experience IMO. I played 20 mafia games back in college during freshman year (so like 4-5 years ago) And nutcracker was my 1st forum mafia game ^.^ Personally, this morning I am giving a town read towards Irish and maybe NM. Irish for his general posting and podding questions. Mderg is another i could place as town. At first i felt his intro post felt a bit scummy and a bit after wards espially with this post: On December 29 2015 18:32 mderg wrote:
Meh, reading this thread is difficult when you don't know most of those names.
People are quick to jump on GB, I like that because his opening was fishy but I also don't like it because it feels too easy. I'll have to see how that continues.
Don't like GiygaS so far... Has made like 7 posts but I didn't see anything of substance. The fist reads also don't really seem that strong.
I have a slight townread on NocturneMage, he's being out there and being open about his thoughts. He's also asking lots of questions which makes me think he's trying to solve the game. He is a dirty league player, though... The Bold feels a bit like hes repeating a lot of what people are saying, which indicatives to me mafia trying to look present. However, hes recent posts on me gives me a bit of a more town feel. I do admit, to me, it is a bit early for filtering, but the fact he is thinking and perhaps doing it makes me want to say he is leaning more to town. I just want to bring up the above fact (repeating). Koshi died? I'm pretty sure I've played with Onegu in the past but I don't remember him doing stupid stuff like that. That's why I have no idea what to make of his posts so far. I can see how the part about GiygaS can be seen as repeating what others have said but I definitely can't see it with my stance on GlowingBear. Can you elaborate more on that? Yeah Koshi and Kush both died on the same night because mafia unboxed a gun. Onegu called me, Koshi, and damdred scum all game and on day 3 and up keep saying we were scum and that was it. his only reads were posted on d1 and he tunneled. Also see above post for Gb. Right now Onegu is just a huge questionmark for me.
Was just about to say the same. Looks like he waited almost whole IRL day before exposing himself to the thread. Is that a meta thing for him? Not to jump to conclusions, but it seems like he was waiting for a few other people (like Scott, GB, and ShapeLog) to come under a bit of fire before he would garner any attention himself. Not saying I have a lean on him but I'd feel much better if he would share with the class a little.
|
Also people reaction times are already interesting enough. Like it took NM 5 mins to respond to it (although he was on before so idk)
|
On December 30 2015 01:35 Shapelog wrote:
Also people reaction times are already interesting enough. Like it took NM 5 mins to respond to it (although he was on before so idk)
Might be my scrub showing, but I wouldn't think on that too much. Since we're on the internet, I would imagine people are bouncing between a couple of tabs before they come back to refresh this page. I know I often go back and review my own posts because I feel picky about sentence structure and grammar, etc. That really bothers me in this setup because I can't edit so if I post and see something I don't like, I'm forced to accept my repetitive structure or run-on sentence, etc.
|
On December 30 2015 01:35 Kmatt wrote:Show nested quote +On December 30 2015 01:30 mderg wrote:On December 30 2015 01:22 Shapelog wrote:On December 30 2015 01:10 mderg wrote:On December 30 2015 00:27 Shapelog wrote:On December 29 2015 16:58 Irishbound wrote:
@Shape - I've explained my issue with Giygas post as much as I can really. What content specifically are you waiting for and what's stopping you from getting reads from what's been posted thus far?
I Generally like having more then 2 pages (which half of which is either me or opening jokes) to base reads off of. I usually start subtracting the trolololo and add actual useful crap later into the day and into the later days. 100% tryhard mode this game. I promise. @Fidel Castro (I must tryhard) I do not know about GB (only play with him in nutcracker for a bit tbh) or NM. About Onegu, His VT claim is dumb, but from what i heard from other players, this is the norm for him? Idk, I can tell more about him once he starts posting atcual content (if he does.) Last game i played (which was my first) he was more ativce days 1 and 2, but fell off during the later days. This might be because Koshi died thou. But i really shouldn't jump to conclusions yet based off another game. Especially as i was compared as a rsoul. Smurf (still trying to figure that out) Also I am not that experience IMO. I played 20 mafia games back in college during freshman year (so like 4-5 years ago) And nutcracker was my 1st forum mafia game ^.^ Personally, this morning I am giving a town read towards Irish and maybe NM. Irish for his general posting and podding questions. Mderg is another i could place as town. At first i felt his intro post felt a bit scummy and a bit after wards espially with this post: On December 29 2015 18:32 mderg wrote:
Meh, reading this thread is difficult when you don't know most of those names.
People are quick to jump on GB, I like that because his opening was fishy but I also don't like it because it feels too easy. I'll have to see how that continues.
Don't like GiygaS so far... Has made like 7 posts but I didn't see anything of substance. The fist reads also don't really seem that strong.
I have a slight townread on NocturneMage, he's being out there and being open about his thoughts. He's also asking lots of questions which makes me think he's trying to solve the game. He is a dirty league player, though... The Bold feels a bit like hes repeating a lot of what people are saying, which indicatives to me mafia trying to look present. However, hes recent posts on me gives me a bit of a more town feel. I do admit, to me, it is a bit early for filtering, but the fact he is thinking and perhaps doing it makes me want to say he is leaning more to town. I just want to bring up the above fact (repeating). Koshi died? I'm pretty sure I've played with Onegu in the past but I don't remember him doing stupid stuff like that. That's why I have no idea what to make of his posts so far. I can see how the part about GiygaS can be seen as repeating what others have said but I definitely can't see it with my stance on GlowingBear. Can you elaborate more on that? Yeah Koshi and Kush both died on the same night because mafia unboxed a gun. Onegu called me, Koshi, and damdred scum all game and on day 3 and up keep saying we were scum and that was it. his only reads were posted on d1 and he tunneled. Also see above post for Gb. Right now Onegu is just a huge questionmark for me. Was just about to say the same. Looks like he waited almost whole IRL day before exposing himself to the thread. Is that a meta thing for him? Not to jump to conclusions, but it seems like he was waiting for a few other people (like Scott, GB, and ShapeLog) to come under a bit of fire before he would garner any attention himself. Not saying I have a lean on him but I'd feel much better if he would share with the class a little.
Onegu questions!
Onegu, what do you think about the game so far?
Onegu, why do you think that?
Onegu, any scum leans?
Onegu, are u going to notice me senpai?
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
