Really Small Mafia II - Page 48

On December 18 2015 23:15 raynpelikoneet wrote:

Actually the best play for both me and Rels in case we are mafia is to no-kill.
But Rels or you not realizing this doesn't mean anything about anyone's alignment so we should just drop this discussion.

On December 18 2015 23:15 Rels wrote:
marv and DP are scum.

marv is the lynch. marv starts posting. I am the lynch. marv deflects and pushes on DP. DP sheeps rayn on me.

If marv is lynched: DP look very good and I look super suspicious.
If DP is lynched: the game is almost lost for scum since marv is not a good enough scum player to survive two more lynches. (or, he's a too good town player to fake it as scum)
If Rels is lynched: LYLO. DP looks null. marv looks OK.

So it's a gambit. If DP is lynched for whatever reason marv lose the game right there. But the other cases are OK.

On December 18 2015 23:19 Rels wrote:
How do you know scum can no-kill ?

On December 18 2015 23:20 DarthPunk wrote:


Why would we not just both lynch you as scum and go straight to lylo?

On December 18 2015 23:15 Rels wrote:
marv and DP are scum.

marv is the lynch. marv starts posting. I am the lynch. marv deflects and pushes on DP. DP sheeps rayn on me.

If marv is lynched: DP look very good and I look super suspicious.
If DP is lynched: the game is almost lost for scum since marv is not a good enough scum player to survive two more lynches. (or, he's a too good town player to fake it as scum)
If Rels is lynched: LYLO. DP looks null. marv looks OK.

So it's a gambit. If DP is lynched for whatever reason marv lose the game right there. But the other cases are OK.

On December 18 2015 23:21 raynpelikoneet wrote:

Your scenario here hinges around "if DP is lynched for whatever reason" which already assumes that DP was suspicious for people on D1, otherwise you should nowhere assume "if DP is lynched" is even likely.

Again we come to this, if you assume "if DP is lynched" is true, you assume DP was at least suspicious for people on D1 ---> in that case, if we mirror this to what I HAVE SAID, it makes sense for marv to NOT bus you, and try to lynch DP, no?

On December 18 2015 23:21 Rels wrote:

I'm not considering the motherfucking hypothetical scenarios. I'm considering what could possibly happen based on the actions of the players, and what outcome it would have.

On December 18 2015 23:21 raynpelikoneet wrote:

Your scenario here hinges around "if DP is lynched for whatever reason" which already assumes that DP was suspicious for people on D1, otherwise you should nowhere assume "if DP is lynched" is even likely.

Again we come to this, if you assume "if DP is lynched" is true, you assume DP was at least suspicious for people on D1 ---> in that case, if we mirror this to what I HAVE SAID, it makes sense for marv to NOT bus you, and try to lynch DP, no?

On December 18 2015 23:23 Rels wrote:

AND YOU ARE SUPER STUPID
"DP LYNCHED" IS THE ONLY SCENARIO THAT IS BAD FOR A MARV + DP TEAM
IF YOU SAY "BUT THE DP IS LYNCHED SCENARIO" IS EXTREMELY UNLIKELY, THEN THE OTHER TWO SCENARIOS ARE BOTH LIKELY, AND THESE TWO SCENARIOS ARE GOOD FOR A MARV + DP TEAM

On December 18 2015 23:19 Rels wrote:
How do you know scum can no-kill ?

On December 18 2015 23:30 raynpelikoneet wrote:

I am not going to answer your dumb shit...

On December 18 2015 23:33 Rels wrote:
OK I will resume one last time because you are all annoying me.

What happened at EOD1
marv is the lynch. marv starts posting. Rels is the lynch. marv deflects off Rels and pushes on DP. DP sheeps rayn on Rels. Rels deflects off marv and pushes on Arsoul.
Possible lynches: marv, DP, Rels.

1: marv + Rels is the team. How do the rest of the game looks like ?
If Rels is lynched => marv look bad. Game is lost because marv is not a good scum player + is being suspected. BAD
If DP is lynched => LYLO; marv and I, who were the two potential lynches, look super bad. A LITTLE BAD and UNLIKELY ANYWAY
If marv is lynched => It looks like both scum didn't want to vote for each other. I look bad. BAD

On December 18 2015 23:33 Rels wrote:
2: marv + DP is the team. How do the rest of the game looks like ?
If marv is lynched: DP look very good and I look super suspicious. GOOD
If DP is lynched: the game is almost lost for scum since marv is not a good enough scum player to survive two more lynches. (or, he's a too good town player to fake it as scum). BAD but UNLIKELY
If Rels is lynched: LYLO. DP looks null. marv looks OK. SUPER GOOD

On December 18 2015 23:39 Rels wrote:
Shut up fucking scum. It does not prove you're scum; anyone could be scum with marv but me with this analysis. It proves that I am town. I am town because marv was getting lynched and he hates giving information; but somehow we chose a way to play that ONLY LEAD TO BAD SCENARIOS.

On December 18 2015 23:42 DarthPunk wrote:


YOU COULD ONLY CHOOSE BAD SCENARIOS BECAUSE YOU HAD COLLECTIVELY PUT YOURSELF INTO A BAD SCENARIO BY PLAYING LIKE SHIT ON DAY ONE.