TL Mafia LXXIII: The Nutcracker - Page 4

On December 16 2015 04:09 GlowingBear wrote:


Mafia lurkers won the game without giving any kind of information. And doing nothing is kush's specialty. I prefer to get rid of the question mark

On December 16 2015 04:51 Tictock wrote:
Just got home, got out a little early kus it's Blizzarding here.

I'll do the filter dive of Gig I promised Rels and then catchup with what I've missed thus far.

While at work I was thinking about the whole Rit hardreading Shape. It's possible that what he said about "One moment defines a player" is just really how he's approaching this game (I don't recall him ever useing thinking like this before though, so it's weird) but I think it might be an indication that Rit is mafia.

So I know for sure we aren't looking at a Rit/Shape team here, kus I just don't believe Rit would hard defend a teammate like he is. I'm wondering now if the hard townread is a sign of TMI?

Like it dosn't make a ton of sense for Rit to have such a hard townread on Shape if he's town, he even made a post pointing out that Shape was doing some stuff that was stupid or looked bad, it also makes no sense for Rit to hard defend a scummate. However it makes perfect sense for a scum!Rit to hard defend a new-to-our-fourms town!Shape who people might have a hard time reading well. Would give him a nice platform to push from while seeming like he wants to prevent a mislynch.

The other thing that I was thinking about, is why am I the only person to have irked Rit for my read on Shape? I know he posted out his thoughts on why he thought I was scum for rethinking my read but he's given little to no reaction to anyone else scumreading Shape.

I realize my view on Rit is rather tainted with OMGUS kus he has a fordrawn conclusion to lynch me here, and my thinking here is more WIFOM than real evidence but I'm thinking Rit might be scum here. Only thing making me a bit unsure is that Rit is rather invested in his reads (pushing them etc) and cares about the lynch. So right now I'd put Rit as a OMGUS tainted scumlean.

On December 16 2015 05:31 Rels wrote:

Yep it's quite different from the two last games I played. I think he has a good chance at flipping scum.

On December 16 2015 05:49 Tictock wrote:


I see our tinfoil is set to the same frequency sir.

What do you make of the fact that Rit only cares about me rethinking my read on you, but doesn't really bother with anyone else who isn't sure about you, or even scumreads you?

On December 16 2015 06:21 ritoky wrote:
why rit is mafia and gig is mafia case before reading and analyzing thread?

On December 15 2015 19:24 ritoky wrote:
if you want me to write the why tt is potentially mafia book it would basically be: he tr shape for good reason (i thought) at proper time and when it was popular, then backed out of it for a bad/no reason when it was popular, was awkward, then has basically snap conceded/fucked off in the face of me wanting to lynch him.
.

On December 16 2015 07:03 GlowingBear wrote:

You're Mafia